That there are still unexplained and magical elements every day in this deep and complex world is mostly wonderful.

Paddling hope. Pic: Jocelyn Milbank

It is wonderful, for example, that doctors still cannot tell precisely when a woman will go into labour.

The world held its breath early this week, wondering when our own Princess Mary would give birth to twins.

The timing of their arrival was roughly predicted but, as with all natural births, no doctor could say precisely when it would happen.

There are so many unexplained wonders that still have no plausible explanation, are outside the realms of real predictability and tease us with their mystery. 

The placebo effect still has scientists stumped.

A patient, dependent on pain-relieving medication, can be given a sugar pill in the drug’s place and the pain is still relieved.

No one really knows why it works. But it seems that sometimes, nothing can be very powerful.

It is wonderful that no one knows why we blush, laugh or dream.

It is extraordinary that US Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords, who was shot point-blank in the head in Arizona this week, can not only live, but appear to hear and respond. Her survival so far is remarkable and hopeful.

It is wonderful that the act of altruism has no rational explanation.

There is no explanation for why music moves us, or why we feel the urge to create art.

It is wonderful that we do not know why we kiss.

But other unexplained and unpredictable elements of life are, at times, not so wonderful.

While information from the weather bureau has this week become the stuff of sustenance and survival for the everyday person, there is so much about the weather that is unknown.

In fine weather times, the predictions of the weather presenter on TV can be a kind of light-hearted joke.

Seeing how many times the temperature is overshot or underdone makes for light conversation.

Meteorologists use weather prediction devices and equipment to assess the likelihood (or not) of rain, sun, wind and flood. But, despite technological advances, it remains an inexact science.

So while meteorologists and other specialists knew we were in for a rough ride, they could not have foreseen 21 days ago, when the first wave of the flood crisis struck, how wild the weather was to become on so many fronts.

The unpredictable ferocity, the underestimation of the power of the weather and the drastic effects it would have on people, animals, land and sea blindsided everyone from layman to expert.

And it is important to remember they, as the interpreters of the signs and carriers of the resulting messages, are not to blame for the havoc unleashed.

When the floods subside and the storms finally vacate the skies, it is important to look forward with hope, rather than scout around for something or someone to blame for what happened.

The flood rebuilding and recovery taskforce chief Major-General Mick Slater this week warned against a culture of blame. It is corrosive and divisive, he said.

We must remember those hit hardest by the floods are beaten but not bowed; they are survivors, not victims.

There is a huge difference. Victims look back; survivors look forward with hope. 

And hope is a powerful motivator. Former long-time editor of the Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology and renowned clinical psychologist Rick Snyder proved hope, applied and clung to, was empowering enough to overcome differences in physical ability, intelligence and socio-economic conditions in all manner of circumstances.

Snyder found that hope works when a plan is made to overcome a problem and a person is motivated to put the plan in action.

Those ingredients for success will soon be in place in Queensland.

But we all must commit and cling to hope in the long haul ahead as so many rebuild landscapes, lives, homes and careers.

In ancient Rome more than 2000 years ago, an ordinary boy named Marcus Tullius Cicero became a mover and shaker in politics, a game-changer and, for a time, a republic-builder.

But the things he is most remembered for today are his words and philosophies.

Among those he selected for utterance were ``dum spiro spero’‘.

Roughly translated from Latin, it means ``While I breathe, I hope’‘.

It could be hope for something better, something more, or just something else.

Like most powerful phenomena, the mystery of which words and phrases will stand through the ages is unforeseen.

Cicero could not have known how important to inundated and grieving Queenslanders his words would be this week, centuries after they were first spoken.

Even during floods, hope floats.

Jane Fynes-Clinton is a Courier Mail columnist.

84 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • nosthow says:

      05:32am | 13/01/11

      Hope indeed Jane and our brave people here in QLD have been subjected to Mother Natures worst ! The Gillard and Bligh Labor governments are to be commended for their constant and timely support for the ver increasing flood victims. They could not have responded better in fact. Contrast that with the pitiful comments of Abbott and his dilly sidekick Barnaby “Joke’ re we need more dams they said to stop the flooding. Now you would only need a brain the size of a pea to rrealise that 50 new dams would not have stopped this monstrous flooding . And their lies the cause of the Liberl/Nationals stupid statements, I note also roundly condemed in the media - there is no-one in the Liberal/Nationls who possesses a ounce of sense or brainpower - as a matter of fact I am beginning to realise that to qualify to be a Liberal in this country the 1st requrement is to have no brains !  hahahahahahhh Shame on you Tony Abbott and your sad little band of misfits who once again during this flood crisis have clearly shown all Australians why you are not fit to govern !

    • Frances says:

      07:59am | 13/01/11

      You’d do anything to take a swipe at the Lib/Nats. Pretty long bow this time. Even by your language though you are obviously a victim and not a survivor and probably in dire need of a good dose of ‘hope’. Perhaps wash it done with a little less cynicism next time.

    • James says:

      08:14am | 13/01/11

      Sorry to disagree nosthow, but I think Mr. Abbot was right. Dams would not only hold back some of the flood waters, but, if designed properly, could also provide some electrical power generation you Aussies seem to so dearly need. The difference between a liberal and laborite is, a liberal thinks with his brain and a laborite thinks with his heart.

    • ZSRenn says:

      08:41am | 13/01/11

      You have just proved to me you are the troll you are Big Nose.

      This is a time of pain and suffering and you want to use it to promote your own political agenda. This is a piece asking us not to blame and look to the future and in you come with the blame game.

      Shame on you!

    • Jack says:

      08:50am | 13/01/11

      Nosthow, you need to do some deeper reading instead of skimming the headlines and also some research before making your obviously biased, uniformed comment, but expected.

    • Peter says:

      09:03am | 13/01/11

      Nosthow..I love reading your childish rants and raves directed at Tony Abbott at every opportunity.It reminds me of why I vote Liberal and how the left of politics are filled with hate and vile blinded by their hopeless socialist mentality.Please keep it up as I am sure there are many readers whom you will help decide which side of politics they belong to.

    • RT says:

      09:08am | 13/01/11

      I agree, let’s leave out the partisan attacks for just a little while. Using tragedies for political point scoring is one of the most distasteful things about online discussion. Give it a rest, nosthow.

      I hope that a thorough enquiry is held after this about flood prevention. It seems that dams can be used for flood mitigation in some situations -like the Wyvenhoe, which, it seems, may be the main reason that the Brisbane flood peak is lower than ‘74. It seems to me though that dams as flood mitigators are not for the long rivers of the Murray-Darling system.

    • fairsfair says:

      09:23am | 13/01/11

      Re QLD Govt - I totally agree with you Nostow. Anna Bligh and all of her ministers have handled this amazingly. As have the regional councils. I have so much more respect for her as a politician and will never again place a ‘t’ on the end of her name.

      Re the dams though Nostow - Why do you have to always take comments out of context, elaborate upon them and then turn them in to something that they are not? I am certainly not blaming anyone, as like I said yesterday perhaps the Goss govt thought they made the right decision - but if Wolfdene damn had been constructed Wivenhoe would be left to do what it was planned to do - rest half empty to catch flood waters. However, the drought that QLD has just come off people are keen to conserve water, so I do believe that it would have been almost at capacity anyway.

      This was a freak event. We can’t blame anyone for what has happened or mock anyone’s attempts at rectifying the issue. We will need to something in the long run, as this can’t happen again. I am sure when Wivenhoe was finished in the 80s people saw it as a guarantee - and effectively managed with connections to other dams would make it one.

      Wivenhoe saved Brisbane, but at the same time it has also been the reason for the water reaching the city. 

      Anyway, this article was about life’s little amazing mysteries and the spirit of the people affected is humbling. Still thinking of you all!

    • Jim says:

      09:31am | 13/01/11

      Nosthow…I’m certain that in one thread that was up between the time of the Mary River flood and Toowoomba you pulled out your childish and ever so droll “BLOCK WRECK” mantra, accusing the Lib/Nats of blocking every essential dam that has been proposed in the last 30 years.

      A number of replies to that highlighting it was actually the greens who blocked the dams and you’ve conveniently forgotten your rant and turned it around, now saying the dams would have done nothing…

      I know we shouldn’t expect truth and logic from a die hard Labor mule like yourself, but it also appears consistency and memory has been lost!

    • Ben81 says:

      12:32pm | 13/01/11

      Why does the bar seem to be continually lowered around here for just for this absolute twit to troll and make an idiot of himself?

    • Fran says:

      02:38pm | 13/01/11

      I agree this should give Bligh some hope at the next election.

    • Simon Wetherall says:

      03:12pm | 13/01/11

      Bligh is a legend.
      A woman who has demonstrated her competence and compassion.

    • Sick if it says:

      07:52pm | 13/01/11

      What the hell is with people and this BRISVEGAS crap?  Its Brisbane for Gods sake, isnt there enough Americanism in this country without creating more.  Seriously, get a life and start being loyal to our own culture, not someone elses.

    • Matthew says:

      09:09am | 14/01/11

      Sick if it, calling Brisbane BrisVegas is a sign that you are a local, think your city as good as Las Vegas (if not better) and have some pride of your city unlike Sydney.

      As for nosthow, Wivenhoe stopped 2.5 million litres of water coming into Brisbane.  Without it, this flood would have been twice as bad as 74.  I’m not sure how you can say that more flood mitigation dams wouldn’t have worked.  They wouldn’t have stopped it but still would’ve helped.

    • Gold Coaster says:

      09:53am | 14/01/11

      Gee, what job in the labor party do you hold??? On the payroll for sure!

    • Kika says:

      02:03pm | 14/01/11

      Sick of it - I don’t like it particularly either, but it’s called BrisVegas I believe thanks to our stack of illegal casinos hiding in the valley back in the 70’s and 80’s when gambling was banned.

      It’s not the case that we’re trying an Americanism on, it’s actually relevant to the history of our city.

    • Retired Soldier says:

      07:56am | 13/01/11

      nosthow says:05:32am | 13/01/11: i am wondering if this comment could be mistaken for an unpaid Labor Party promotion advertisement. It isn’t the time for political attacks and while the author may talk about ‘stupid statements and a lack of brains” this comment would indicate a similar condition exists in the mind of the writer. If a sensible comment is required then perhaps your beloved ALP could cancel the National Broadband fiasco and transfer the wasted 43 Billion dollars to fixing the current mess in Qld.

    • DH says:

      08:27am | 13/01/11

      Simply beautiful.

    • RT says:

      08:30am | 13/01/11

      Why the name Bris-vegas? Is the implication that Brisbane is supposed to be like Las Vegas? Have those who use that name actually been to both places? I have, and can’t see the slightest resemblence. Might as well call it Bris-jing, Bris-kok or Mumbane. It would be as meaningful.

    • ZSRenn says:

      12:00pm | 13/01/11

      When it was announced that Brisbane was going to get a Casino. I was standing outside the restaurant at which I worked. I turned to my buddies and said.

      “We are going to have to call the place Bris-vegus now”

      From that moment on all of us called it Bris-vegus and soon it spread like wildfire all over the town the media and then Australia.

      So you see I started it!

    • SM says:

      01:03pm | 13/01/11

      It’s a tongue in cheek reference RT, suggesting that the big old country town that Brisbane used to be (before it became the busy metropolis it is now, not before the floods)  was nothing like Las Vegas

    • matt says:

      03:35pm | 14/01/11

      agree… I have always hated that phrase, you notice anyone who hasn’t been to Vegas will call it BrisVegas… haha

    • UglyStick says:

      08:44am | 13/01/11

      BrisVegas has to be the stupidest nickname I have ever heard.

      You’re not in the desert, your lively-hood doesn’t depend on casinos and you restaurants are third world. What marketing guru came up with that and where is he currently digging through trash bins?

    • Fred says:

      10:36am | 13/01/11

      Was it Sir Richard Branson or one of his PR people with a sense of irony? Anyway it is about marketing and expresses as much individual identity as ‘Brisneyland’!

    • dave says:

      02:36pm | 13/01/11

      more like BrisVenice lately

    • someone has to say it says:

      10:48pm | 13/01/11

      It’s called ironic, self-deprecating humour; something enjoyed amongst people who could politely be described as “your betters”.

    • LJ says:

      08:56am | 14/01/11

      Probably someone who lives in your neck of the woods

    • P. Darvio says:

      09:16am | 13/01/11

      I wish Kevin Rudd would stop thanking GOD for the rain stopping unless he also wants to blame GOD for the flooding rains and the death of innocent people.

    • Amanda says:

      03:58pm | 15/01/11

      Of course God was to blame! God takes the lives of innocent people every day! Haven’t you noticed? This is no reason to be skeptical that there actually is a God. Rather, it is the opposite. Finding hope that there is meaning in what otherwise seems meaningless. Wondering if God has a plan for these innocents to be in a better place than here. Hope is what this story is about and hope is what God is about. The saying, “The Lord moves in mysterious ways” has been around for a long time before Rudd. The belief in God and Christianity has survived through centuries of catastrophes, slavery and persecution. It is not naive to wonder whether there is a God and a purpose behind all of the bad and the good in life. Life is a mystery, as the author of this article has pointed out. Only the unreasonably cynical and seriously stupid are dead to that fact.

    • Jess says:

      09:28am | 13/01/11

      People from smaller towns jokingly refer to Brisbane as BrisVegas because it emphasises the fact it’s a bigger city/place to party and because ironically it is nothing like Las Vegas. Surely @RT @UglyStick you guys know what jokes and irony are?

    • AFR says:

      09:38am | 13/01/11

      I actually thought it was the opposite. It’s something we call it in Sydney to make fun of the place.

    • Matt says:

      09:53am | 13/01/11

      Jokes are funny… but I leave irony for the misses…

    • RT says:

      10:19am | 13/01/11

      I guess the irony was lost on me, Jess. It seems more aptly applied to some of Qld’s other cities. Las Vegas is an interesting but place - slick and sleazy - but I don’t know why anyone would expect an Australian city to aspire to be anything like it.

    • Bruce says:

      08:42am | 14/01/11

      In the early 90s it was referred to as BrisVegas because the pubs would shut early, and it was nothing like Los Vegas.

    • Margaret says:

      09:44am | 13/01/11

      my heart goes out to all the brave fellow Aussies in Queensland..it is heart breaking to hear the stories ...the lovely thirteen year old boy Jordan, who is braver than i could ever hope to be..my step daughter , who continued to go to work in the Brisbane cbd right until they had to be evacuated, the mums and dads, the old people…the bravery and humanity will make me try to be a better person.. at the moment..and the humour too…the photo of the house with a bathtub on the front lawn with “plan B” written on it…and i think all of our political leaders…all of them..are acquitting themselves very well…we should remember that they are having terrible floods in Brasil at the moment, with loss of life

    • Zeta says:

      09:57am | 13/01/11

      “The placebo effect still has scientists stumped.” - Actually no, since the 1970s we’ve known that the placebo effect is caused by endogeneous opiods in the brain, which is why placebo painkillers show a higher rate of effectiveness than placebo antibiotics. Doctors found that the placebo effect could be stopped by administering opiod antagonists, like the kind used to bring people off heroin. I’m only an armchair neuroscientist, so you can find the real research here - http://www.jneurosci.org/cgi/content/short/25/45/10390

      ‘It is wonderful that no one knows why we blush, laugh or dream.’ I’m sure it’s wonderful that you don’t know these things, but you could have found them with a Google search. Blushing is a vestigal fight-or-flight reflex, we know this because inside the Blush zone on your face and chest vasodilates in concert with adrenaline reception.

      Neurophysiology indicates that laughter is linked with the activation of the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, that produces endorphins. There are two main theories for why we laugh, one by Freud, which is bat shit stupid, and the other, which is backed by the neuroscience - laughter is a response to endorphines released by suprise, but the specific receptors for that suprise are activated by solving of ‘cognitive riddles’.

      Although we don’t categorically know the purpose of the content of dreams, we do know why we dream in general - the consolidation of semantic memories. Although there are different theories as to how, almost all somnologists agree the protection, strengthening and consolidation of memory is the reason why we dream.

      “It is extraordinary that US Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords, who was shot point-blank in the head in Arizona this week, can not only live, but appear to hear and respond.” - Although it’s a myth that we use only 10 per cent of our grey matter (we use all of it), we only use a small percentage of the sum total neurons at a time. When the brain undergoes serious trauma, there remain many billions of neurons to carry information around the source of the trauma. Gifford’s survival has more to do with the type of bullet used than some ‘miracle’ - people in the buisness of killing other people use hollow point bullets that fragment and maximise damage to the brain by fracturing the skull and piercing the brain with skull fragments.

      “It is wonderful that the act of altruism has no rational explanation” - there is a perfectly rational explanation for altruism to be found in both theoretical mathematics and neuroscience. In the first instance, there are Nash equilibriums to be found in the payoff matrix of giving, so game theory is one explanation. Otherwise, the posterior superior temporal cortex activates during altruistic behaviour that suggests reward pathways might be involved.

      “There is no explanation for why music moves us, or why we feel the urge to create art.” - Music and Art were forms of pre-language centre development communication. There’s plenty of evidence to suggest we made musical instruments and drew pictures before we could speak.

      “It is wonderful that we do not know why we kiss.” - It’s kind of half right - we know why we kiss, simple pleasure, dopamine response. We figured out it feels good because proto-humans would have used their lips and tongue to sense their environment, and the act of kissing would have been important in that regard. What we don’t know is why some cultures don’t kiss, such as some African tribes and Indigenous Australians who were unfamiliar with it upon first contact with Europeans.

    • Dan says:

      10:59am | 13/01/11

      Well, I’m glad we got that straight! Now, can I add my voice to all those who are calling for politics to be kept out of all this discussion? It is neither the time nor place.

    • notSue says:

      11:53am | 13/01/11

      There’s also the philosphical standpoint, Zeta, that there is in fact no such thing as “pure altruism” because all acts considered such have a payoff for the actor, even if fleeting.
      It’s still one of the most wonderful things about being human though, no matter the neurochemistry behind it.

    • David says:

      02:56am | 14/01/11

      Thanks Zeta, that saved me the effort! Well they do say ignorance is bliss .... grin

    • Mark says:

      07:59am | 14/01/11

      Thanks Zeta for taking the trouble to set this so called Journalist straight. It really was a silly article.

      And I thought the term BrisVegas was just used by kids trying to look cool…

    • Maverick says:

      10:44am | 14/01/11

      Thanks Zeta. You saved me the trouble. I hate it when people who can’t be bothered to do adequate research just assume that there are things that cannot and will not be explained
      Just to put my two cents worth in on altruism in humans. Richard Dawkins has written extensively on this subject in his many books on evolution to suggest an evolutional explanation for this phenomenon.

    • Bob says:

      10:11am | 13/01/11

      I have never voted Labor but I am prepared to give credit where credit is due. I think Anna Bligh’s handling of this situation is terrific. She conducts the press conferences in a no-nonsense, factual and open manner which must provide reassurance for those affected by the floods. Onya Anna, lots of Brownie points!

    • Matthew says:

      09:19am | 14/01/11

      She’ll win the next election easily because of it.  But she was going to win anyway, the opposition in Qld has been a joke for the last 15 years.

      Unfortunately people will forget the privatisation of QR and all the other things she (and Beattie before her) did wrong.  She’s just cleaned her slate and got +10 brownie points in under a week.

    • Julia Thornton says:

      10:13am | 13/01/11

      I HATE the term Bris Vegas. It’s elitist and misinformed.

      Why you would want to be insulting now, I’ve got no idea.

      Wise up, Punch Team.

    • Bitten says:

      10:33am | 13/01/11

      BrisVegas - the term applied by the uninformed non-Queenslanders, or the ill-considered Queenslanders with an inferiority complex who want non-Queenslanders to think they’re cool.

      The rest of us know where we live: it’s called BrisBANE.

    • RT says:

      12:34pm | 13/01/11

      The bane of every Bris’s existence.

    • TheRealDave says:

      04:28pm | 13/01/11

      Its ‘Brisben’ and always has been…..BrisBANE my arse you seppo wannabe…..whats next MelBOURNE (as in the not so bad movie the BOURNE Indentity)

    • Bitten says:

      08:58am | 14/01/11

      Dave - Eh? I’m spelling the word, not suggesting how it should be pronounced.  Brisvegas in this example has been used in a WRITTEN article, not a speech. Wind back your douche-o-meter.

    • Born and Bred Brisbanite says:

      01:04pm | 14/01/11

      The Term Brisvegas is as one reader put it. For people who live in the outer Burbs of Brisbane, Where the nightlife of their small towns is a pub with 80s music playing. So When a group of partygoers get together to organise a big night out on the town we have to travel up to an hour into the city of Brisvegas where there is much more nightlife to thrust ourselves into. But all you southerners wouldn’t be able to understand this, And the deep rooted loyalness that Brisbane residents have and why we are so passionate and true to our City and state. By the way i have noticed most posts here have major spelling mistakes which are no doubt from southerners, So clean up your act and get some perspective.

    • Noely says:

      10:40am | 13/01/11

      I have no problem with the term BrisVegas and I am born & bred there, it is just an ironic joke, a lot of locals still say they will go into ‘town’ for something, not ‘the city’, hence the irony.  On point though…  I can’t stand Anna Bligh, though have to admit, she has been handling this crisis very well.  ‘Can Do’ is the one I have an issue with, he obviously when to the same school of politics as John Howard, all he can ever say is “I will”, “I have informed” etc…  “I” is his favourite word.  Considering the state of emergency and his power is basically zip, and he would not be making any real decisions at all, it would be very funny if the situation was not so serious.  Queenslanders are tough, and all the ‘new’ Queenslanders that had never been through 74 will learn to be tough!

    • Matthew says:

      09:27am | 14/01/11

      Campbell Newman’s not getting extra money from the federal government like Bligh is.  Disasters aren’t a councils job to handle, they simply don’t have the money.

      Don’t forget, Campbell Newman only handles the BCC, not Ipswich, Toowoomba, Grantham or Rockhampton.  He’s hamstrung by so many things so don’t jump on his back.

    • majid says:

      10:45am | 13/01/11

      The only similarity with Las Vegas is that everything is fake and lacks soul… Sorry, it’s better I stop writing as Brisbane has been already hammered for the last few days…

    • theArchitect says:

      11:27am | 15/01/11

      ... mmm, another well balanced commentator, with a chip on each shoulder! You’re right in the sense that Brisbane, along with the most of Queensland, has been hammered for the last few days but watch it grow out of the experience with some very creative and unique solutions to some big challenges ahead.

      Why use that acknowledgement to apologize for writing more intellectually challenged, self serving drivel? Please carry on. It’s quite entertaining.

    • thetrureal says:

      02:19pm | 13/01/11

      Floods and droughts are common in Australia, no matter how your build and prepare it effects us all, you can have all the evacuation planed and rehearsed but when it hits it strikes without mercy. No matter who you blame and so on, it won’t make a difference. When it hits, hopefully we all act with logic and compassion and not anger!

    • TheRealDave says:

      04:28pm | 13/01/11

      it could be worse…we could be Sydernee .......

    • SouthOfTheBorder says:

      12:51pm | 14/01/11

      yeah champ….. you bloody wish!

    • RADMAN says:

      04:32pm | 13/01/11

      All the best to those in BRISVEGAS from everyone in RADELAIDE **Cringe***

    • kerrie o'rourke says:

      06:05pm | 13/01/11

      Your comment:
      Bris Vagas is where you gamble on real estate and risk floods every few years.
      Brisbane is a roulette wheel for real estate.
      Yet everyone wants to move to Queensland as its perfect one day and beautiful the next.

    • Matthew says:

      09:29am | 14/01/11

      No, it’s Beautiful one day and perfect the next.  It’s also the Smart State.

    • Jimmy says:

      06:21pm | 13/01/11

      You say no one knows Jane Fynes-Clinton?

      Well you are wrong God knows and all unanswered questions on this earth will be somehow revealed to us by him one day.

    • Rick says:

      08:15am | 14/01/11

      Jimmy,  How do you know this? Did a bloke down the pub tell you? The basis of religion and Gods is that people cry out for answers to the unexplained so having a God conveniently gives them comfort and the answer. “God works in mysterious ways” “It’s all part of God’s plan” It appears that it doesn’t matter to the followers of these religions that science continues to give explanations to the point that there is only a small percentage of our natural world that we don’t understand now compared to when some of our current religions started. Some things will never be explained but it is an ignorant and pathetic cop out to say “God knows” or “God did it”.

    • Matthew says:

      09:36am | 14/01/11

      “science continues to give explanations to the point that there is only a small percentage of our natural world that we don’t understand now”, you’re a bad scientist if you believe that.  Science has provided answers to an unlimited number of questions.  Religion has answered all of them.  Unfortunately the answer is always the same and is something you would expect from stupid people.

    • Bananabender says:

      09:21pm | 13/01/11

      The floods are due to stupidity not Mother Nature. Brisbane was known to be flood-prone even before European settlement. Despite this the city was built in areas that would regularly flood.

      During 1863-4 Brisbane flooded almost 20 times.

      In 1893 Brisbane was almost destroyed by floods. This happened again in 1973.

      Yet no attempt has ever been made to limit construction in flood-affected areas.

      If proper planning laws were in place not a single building would have been affected.

    • Kika says:

      02:06pm | 14/01/11

      I agree. The flood prone suburbs have always been attractive to people. The Queenslander also went out of fashion, and those people living in those suburbs saw the benefit of lifting and building under these houses. Maybe now people will think twice about living in these areas.

      Then again, same thing happened in 74. Property prices and land value around the river plummeted, people bought up and made a lot of money from it years later thanks to the human inability to remember these things!

    • Andrew says:

      10:44pm | 13/01/11

      Good work, Jane. Many love to put their pain onto a convenenient scapegoat. I hope it doesn’t happen this time: humans are capable of better.

    • Alison says:

      02:34am | 14/01/11

      Dear Jane, I would have thought and sincerely hope that everyone looks back, its the only way we learn enough to move forward.  Looking back is only a problem if you don’t learn from your mistakes, and then move on. Would it be a stretch to say that you personally lost nil and grieve for no one and nothing, you are simply looking in from the outside, thinking and “hoping” your words will some how uplift people “them”, even though you personally have no real experience to draw upon this time. I find this story filled with excuses and propaganda “oh, dont blame the gubment,”  Dont look back or ask questions. You are half right, its not about placing blame, its about learning and moving forward, and there are things to be learnt, without a doubt we need to look back as well as forward.  The real victim is a person who chooses to only think of and act for only themselves and their own agenda being right, the “me, me, me’s” they make themselves the victims, like the looters, who’ll end up in jail and lose even their freedom.  Everybody dreams and everybody hopes, even those who seem hopeless.  Sometimes there is just a very big gap between what one hopes for and reality.  I have no political motivation.  I just read your story, and cannot believe you are labelling people who are suffering shock and grief as “victims” in a derogatory way, people who have lost hope need our help, not labels.  Its too soon to start with this sort of politics. Hold the salt, the wounds are still too fresh.  I do however like your sweet references to the awe inspiring beauty, mystery and massive power of nature though, that we can do with more of, healing and inspiration is what is needed, however separating from people, and adding fear of being labelled, this is not motivation.  first you must take the thorn out before the wound can heal, the thorn in this case is separation between them and us. We are all in this together.  Dont forget it could have been you, your children or parents. Without judging, think of and treat “them” how you would wish to be treated, they are us, they are QLDer’s and each deserve that respect in their time of need, loss or grief.  If there is responsibility to be owned up to, down the track, I doubt people will be looking to blame, its natural to have that reactive response initially, but really people just need to look to find ways to improve on what we have and can do, more than anything some will need to reveal the guilt they now face and make amends to prevent a repeat of those same mistakes, or even get off thier chest the obvious improvements they can see which are needed. Darling get down out of your high house and get dirty, get to helping for real with cleaning up, write about the real stuff, the real heros, be one, all you have to do is think of others, sacrafice for and give to others in need.

    • Faith Hope and Charity in the Great Flood says:

      09:04am | 14/01/11

      To Rick of 8:15; people need ‘faith’ in something, faith in other people for example. if you have no faith you end up like Richard Dawkins who wrote ‘The God Myth’ - most of that book is well-written and common-sense but makes assumptions on logic rather than faith. Dawkins comes across as a sad and arrogant individual when interviewed.

    • Kika says:

      02:10pm | 14/01/11

      I disagree. Richard Dawkins is a very straight forward and his books are good reads. You have to remember that Richard was abused by a priest at his Anglican boarding school as a child. He has come out against the Pope and wanted him arrested for crimes against humanity for failing to respond to the Catholic church sexual abuse saga, however when asked whether he would like his abuser arrested he comes out in vehement opposition to any action being taken against his abuser. Very strange. Stockholm syndrome?

      These situations are fantastic for reminding us in our own strength, faith and charity for each other in times of need. And if that doesn’t stir something in Dawkins (who would say that is just a misdirected evolutionarty need to protect yourself and your genes) then that’s pretty sad.

      As they say, there’s no Atheists in a Fox hole.

    • Anna says:

      03:36pm | 14/01/11

      At least get the title right - it’s “The God Delusion”.

    • Sam says:

      01:45pm | 14/01/11

      Welcome to Geo-engineering Australia! enjoy!!

    • Ellie says:

      03:54pm | 14/01/11

      As tragic and horrific as the current flooding situation is all over Queensland, parts of NSW, and now Victoria and Tasmania, there’s one thing no one seems to want to mention…

      There’s still a good 2 months left in the wet season. This could all happen again before its over.

    • DMG says:

      09:31pm | 14/01/11

      “victims look back, survivors look forward” What rubbish, sounds like something someone with a philosophy degree from McDonalds would say. Human emotion isn’t that simplisitc. People will both look forward and back, depending on the day, the hour, their mood, a photo, a song, a cloud….

      Let us gain some perspective. This wasn’t world war 3. It was a natural disaster in which under 20 people so far have died, contrasted with the same type of event in Brazil the last few days where hundreds have died. We have become a nation of whingers and drama queens. Anna Bligh in press conferences has invoked the “us against them” QLD’er mentality, and yet expects those from the south of the country to treat it like a national disaster and despair.

      Let’s all get over ourselves shall we. Bligh, as with all Australian politicians is a hypocrite. We have an ongoing national disaster in inland Australia where people live in 3rd world conditions, i don’t see her crying over that.

    • Tania says:

      02:25am | 15/01/11

      where’s your mentality?????? while the floods in Brazil certainly are a tragedy and yes conditions for our fellow Aussies are not perfect every where; BUT how can the loss of ANY life whether 20 or 300 be compared???? A nation of whingers because we had less loss of life???

      ’ “victims look back, survivors look forward”...Human emotion isn’t that simplisitc…’

      I find this a sad comment because yes, it really is that simple.  Every single one of us has the ability to achieve anything if we choose to move forward.  that’s not to say it’s not going to be a long, tough and heartbeaking road.  Its called the power of humanity and spirit.
      As you wrote your comments i assume you were fortunate enough to be at home somewhere obviously NOT in Qld; not trying to salvage the fragments of your whole life.
      What a shame for you as if you had been up here you may have felt the love, spirit and sense of community that all Qld’s have shown by the way we have all pulled together.
      Perhaps a volunteering stint to Grantham (go to Brazil if you like) might provide you with the experience of simplistic and basic emotions called compassion and kindness.

    • js says:

      09:57pm | 14/01/11

      Jane says “And it is important to remember they, as the interpreters of the signs and carriers of the resulting messages, are not to blame for the havoc unleashed.  When the floods subside and the storms finally vacate the skies, it is important to look forward with hope, rather than scout around for something or someone to blame for what happened”

      So why jane, do you bring up the subject of blame?  Are you a struggling journalist?  How pathetic.

    • Snoopy says:

      09:49am | 15/01/11

      I’m not so sure most people would agree with your suggestion that this situation was not predictable. Visit this weather forum http://forum.weatherzone.com.au/ubbthreads.php/topics/928166/SE_QLD_Flood_Crisis_05_01_2011#Post928166 and tell me you still excuse the actions of the Bureau of Meteorology. Sure, this event was unavoidable, but there are lives lost that could have been warned hours beforehand. I watched the toowoomba event unfold on the weatherzone forum, and I can tell you, the absolute panic in some of the posts that the Bureau were not issuing warnings was heart-breaking. Sure, we can’t blame any individual, but it is wrong to say everything was done that could have been done. Our weather warning systems need upgrading NOW!!!

    • youdy beaudy says:

      01:39pm | 15/01/11

      They need to build levees along the brisbane river in the hollows that allow water into the city. As brisbane is very hilly with a lot of hollows then doing this could stop floods in the future. Levees between the hills, it’s a no brainer really, but the Government and the Council have been very slack in this area. They will have to spend the money now to do this and it should have been done many years ago and if it had been done then this flood would not have had the impact on the city that has happened this time.

      The sad thing is that many people can’t afford or cannot get flood insurance and then there is the damage to the structure of the houses themselves. It must be very sad for all those people who lost their families and their properties. We wonder why these horrible things happen to us from time to time but it gives us more respect for the powers of nature and puts us in the basket with all the other animals that live here. I wonder how much of our wildlife were decimated as well.

      So the federal Government should be injecting a lot of money into flood mitigation. Levees would definately help to solve the problem of flooding, let us not worry about the cosmetic value of the foreshore of the river but fix the problem so it doesn’t happen again. This will require a large injection of money and then give it to the engineers to build what is necessary to stop the problem. Best wishes to all who suffered and lost loved ones and pets and we all hope for a better future for Brizzie people.

    • Ryan says:

      05:56am | 16/01/11

      Please. For the love of god. Stop calling it BrisVegas.

    • Simon says:

      07:54am | 16/01/11

      sometimes we need to look back just to see what a bunch of assholes we have been !!

    • Sick of being called that! says:

      11:58am | 16/01/11

      Jane, stop calling us BrisVegas…IT’S INSULTING!

    • Michelle says:

      02:50pm | 16/01/11

      It’s all fine and well to say build dams, but where should the dams be built? Would the residents of the Lockyer Vally be happy to give their homes up for a dam? X may look good, but it’s useless if it can only hold X before the water spills back into another area. Build the dams, they may work, they may not. Hopefully they will. But face it, Australia is a pretty flat continent, when we build a dam we also inundate huge tracts of land. Dams just move the problem from highly populated areas to our food producing areas.

    • Chris T says:

      08:37am | 17/01/11

      Here we have a Federal and State Labour party in power completley stuffing up left right and centre. We have a disaster and they shed a few tears and we think they have done a great job and re elect them. I was watching the GG on TV last night lost for words and nearly in crocodile tears. Call me strange but I prefer leaders that shed less tears and get on with the task at hand. Yes, its a tragedy, yes we need to feel sad and help out anyway we can but we need leaders to be strong and lead not turn in to emotional sap albeit it would only have been for the camera.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Paul Colgan

Greece makes the final and Ireland gets in on a golden ticket. How awkward and embarrassing. Love it. #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Every single #eurovision band is roxette #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

The weird thing about #eurovision is you've got this massive collection of dorks in a room and no one is wearing Spock ears #sbseurovision

Anthony Sharwood

Europe has the large hadron collider which is light years ahead of its time and #eurovision, where the eighties never die

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Eurovision can’t drown out the human rights abuses

Eurovision can’t drown out the human rights abuses

Last year, thousands of Azerbaijanis spontaneously took to the streets of Baku shouting and chanting.…

Revenge. It doesn’t get a whole lot better than this

Revenge. It doesn’t get a whole lot better than this

Last month, Katy McCaffrey boarded the Disney Wonder cruiseliner. At some point during the trip, a sneaky…

Friday dilemma: can school bullies grow out of it?

Friday dilemma: can school bullies grow out of it?

ClubsNSW is set to introduce a fresh new effort to combat schoolyard intimidation, insisting on a principal’s…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

243 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter