Gibson: Is it time to take pity on the racist potty mouth?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

by Hannah Harborow

110
Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

by Sarrah Le Marquand

210
Defeating bullying one child at a time

by Peter James

310
Why can’t I be pope?

by Xavier Toby

410
My democratic dilemma after the death of a despot

by Gabriel Pizani

510
Punch on: Open thread 14/03/2013

by The Punch Team

610
Atheist church’s faithless flock proves value of religion

by Sam Clench

710
There’s no such thing as a free bus ticket

by Jessica Irvine

810
Politicians can’t control the economy

by Albert Alla

910
How far do the National Rifle Association’s sights focus?

by Scott Limbrick

1010

by Tory Shepherd

19 Apr 01:30pm

Must Reads

The Punch is moving house

385

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

122

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

251

Filed under: Celebrities, Entertainment, Film, Mel Gibson, Mental Health, Racism

112 comments

The sight of a famous person crumbling is irresistible. People love to see the mighty fallen, to gloat over leaked video of people falling over drunk, or falling over sober, for that matter.

We enjoyed watching time-lapse video of Lindsay Lohan degenerating, we sucked up the pictures of Michael Jackson’s face falling apart. Botched plastic surgeries, beauties without makeup, celebrities getting fat.

But there is a point at which you’ve gotta tuck your schadenfreude back in your shorts and that’s when mental illness seems to be the problem. Then it’s just pathetic, in the true sense of the word.

Mel Gibson’s unravelling has hit that point.

Over the past few years we’ve witnessed his downfall, his racism, his repulsive comments. Just last week it was revealed he called Jews ‘oven dodgers’, and indulged in a bit of Holocaust denial. He has form on the anti-Semitic front.

Gibson’s screenwriter Joe Eszterhas spilled the beans to the media on his latest rant – Gibson called Eszterhas a liar, and in retaliation Eszterhas has again gone to the media, this time with audio of a rampant rant which is mostly inchoate and incoherent, and just a little bit sweary. You can hear it here.

According to Eszterhas, Gibson said a bunch of other stuff to guests in his home, such as this after looking at a photo of himself with his daughter:

I look so fucking old! I look horrible! That fucking whore is destroying me! She’s taking my looks! I hate her! She’s destroying my life!

112 comments

Show oldest | newest first

- Tedd says:
  
  02:13pm | 19/04/12
  
  Mel Gibson was inculcated into anti-Semitism by his vehemently self-righteous father Hutton Gibson who said -
  
  “The greatest benefit anyone can have is to be a Catholic. You have the lifelong satisfaction of being right.”
  
  Reply
- 6 million subotics says:
  
  02:14pm | 19/04/12
  
  Just the 1st and 2nd Mad Max flicks, thanks. That is all.
  
  Free Mel Gibson.
  
  And Erick.
  
  Reply
Jason says:

03:25pm | 19/04/12

Think you forgot Gallipoli.
Peter Dellaplane says:

04:36pm | 19/04/12

“Payback” was great.
Edward T. Head says:

05:06pm | 19/04/12

Braveheart.

And neither of them have much to contribute.
Steve Putnam says:

07:26pm | 19/04/12

Gibson got the Mad Max role because Actors Equity stood firm on a local getting the lead despite Kennedy-Miller wanting a big name overseas star. Gibson then went to the US and paid out on Australia, saying it was 25 years behind Hollywood because of organisations like AE.
The sad thing is there are still people in this country willing to stick up for him.
Fingers says:

10:03pm | 19/04/12

Leathal Weapon. The first one only. That is all.
- Zeta says:
  
  02:14pm | 19/04/12
  
  You can get away with anything in Holywood, absolutely anything. You can wake up at 3pm, chase a quart of whiskey with an eightball of blow, bang three whores before sun down, beat your wife, crash your car, and then go to a BDSM orgy in a castle at dawn.
  
  But you can’t be anti-semitic. Even places without rules have to have rules. And you know what? That’s pretty much OK. I mean, you get to work around beautiful people all day, get paid millions of dollars, have even the most boorish and outright illegal behaviour glossed over by multi-million dollar PR execs and all Holywood asks in return, the social contract you sign with them next to the one with your agent, simply says, ‘Don’t be anti-semitic.’ It’s a pretty good deal on balance.
  
  I don’t buy into that whole, Elders of Zion, Ze-Jews-Kontrol-Ze-World bullshit, because they clearly don’t. White men with great teeth and bouncy hair control the world, fact.
  
  But they do control Holywood. Jews have most of the money that gets films made. Offending them needlessly in the place where they live, work, and marry beautiful Eastern European models their mothers don’t approve of is just stupid.
  
  So when Mel Gibson cries about not getting to make more movies in obscure languages, which I’m disappointed in as well, he should just remember he brought this all on himself, by pissing off the only people in Holywood you’re not allowed to piss off.
  
  (edit: it’s highly possible Holywood is actually controled by The Gays, but since we haven’t seen a rush on Elizabeth Taylor biopics yet the jury is still out.)
  
  Reply
Scotchfinger says:

02:28pm | 19/04/12

ha Zeta, great comment. I wish I had written it.
fml says:

02:43pm | 19/04/12

What are your thoughts on Cardinal Pell? Why are his words also glossed over?

And David Icke? Does his ostracisation mean that he is onto something?

He shouldve stayed in goal for coventry city.
Peter says:

03:06pm | 19/04/12

Great response Zeta, but the thing that REALLY annoys me is how so many self-righteous journalists love to write about the fall of any celebrity, because obviously no journalist has ever done anything wrong in their entire lives, have they? Or are the journo’s I’ve met who indulge in blow and various affairs etc just an aberration and not ‘real’ journo’s?
F&*%ing hypocrites!
Em says:

03:28pm | 19/04/12

Nah, Hollywood is run by black, gay Jews.

*rolls eyes*
gobsmack says:

03:48pm | 19/04/12

“But they do control Holywood.”

It would be the only thing that explains why Adam Sandler is able to star in so many so-called comedy movies (or even one for that matter).
Scotchfinger says:

04:07pm | 19/04/12

Em you look hot when you are sarcastic. Sort of like Phryne Fisher.
Rickster says:

04:11pm | 19/04/12

Seems to me it’s all gone bad for Mel since “The passion of Christ”
or what ever it was called , if the Jews controll Hollywood how do you get to make such a movie? Any how you said it he’s just a person it’s just that anything he says gets amplified by the media.
SimonFromLakemba says:

04:28pm | 19/04/12

Oh sh*t don’t let AdamC see this, he seems to think they have no real influence over Hollywood even after showing him all the exec’s, casting agents and the original owners of the studios are mainly Jewish.

Glad to see someone else point this out.
Moron Brando says:

04:41pm | 19/04/12

“Jews have most of the money that gets films made.”

Thats just plain racist.

“it’s highly possible Holywood is actually controled by The Gays”

Also racist.
AdamC says:

04:45pm | 19/04/12

Hollywood is probably the only place where Jews possess the sort of influence Arabs and anti-Semitic westerners seem to think they have across all aspects of life. Mind you, film producers, Jews or otherwise, didn’t seem to mind working with Mad Mel until his anti-Semitism and general freakishness became public. Surely it must have been an open secret in film-making circles for some time that the guy is a pretty ugly drunk, in the most literal sense.
Tory Shepherd says:

05:14pm | 19/04/12

Zeta, I love you, that is all.

Peter, the downfall of journalist would be the grimmest, greatest, most grotesque film ever made and I sort of hope one day some uber-rich producer with all the right contacts pulls it together.
ZSRenn says:

05:29pm | 19/04/12

I can see it now. The Tory Sheppard story

Tory played by Lindsay Lohan
The client played by Hugh Grant

The movie opens in the back seat of a car with the police knocking on the window.
AdamC says:

05:33pm | 19/04/12

Simon, I did see it and commented. Actually I am happy to concede that there are lots of very powerful Jews in Hollywood.

At the risk of bringing up a fairly tiresome topic, when you claimed several months ago that Jews ‘owned’ the media generally, I disagreed with you because it isn’t true.
willie says:

02:23pm | 20/04/12

@Zeta.

“You can get away with anything in Holywood, absolutely anything. You can wake up at 3pm, chase a quart of whiskey with an eightball of blow, bang three whores before sun down, beat your wife, crash your car, and then go to a BDSM orgy in a castle at dawn. “

There is nothing wrong with any of the things you list, unless beating your wife isnt part of the BDSM orgy.
Jack says:

12:51pm | 30/04/12

http://sixmillionmyth.blogspot.com.au/p/six-million-myth.html

I suppose all this is BS too.
- Chris says:
  
  02:15pm | 19/04/12
  
  Ah leave him alone…he s human like the rest of us
  
  Reply
HappyCynic says:

03:03pm | 19/04/12

Yeah a human with a foul mouth and no self-preservation skills whatsoever. Most humans may be idiots but they are at least smart enough to know you don’t p*ss in the water you’re about to drink from, so why doesn’t Gibson understand that you don’t p*ss Jews off in Hollywood if you want to continue working there?
- Sam Jensen says:
  
  02:19pm | 19/04/12
  
  What an awful, shallow, ugly, tabloid-style article written by a complete lay-person with no medical background, just a sad nobody who is jealous of peoples success and a perfect example of the “very” ugly tall-poppy (Australian) syndrome that continues to plagues this nation. Have you ever thought that this guy could just be full of anger or hatred. I’m not excusing his behaviour, but why do you make your stupid, pitiful assumptions.
  
  Tory Shepherd’s train-wreck obsession with other people’s problems, sadness, loss etc is just a further example of how Australian’s are changing - for the worse! I wonder how this village idiot would report her family in similar circumstances?
  
  Reply
Tory Shepherd says:

05:17pm | 19/04/12

Sam, please try not to make it personal - we’re about conversation here, not personal abuse.

Why do you think my arguments are stupid or pitiful? Look at the arguments.

There’s really no need to bring my family into it.
Ben says:

01:45am | 20/04/12

The best thing I find about how “Australian’s are changing” is the expectation and understanding that a bunch of abuse in a situation that is perceived to be antagonistic is going to produce a more productive result in the long run.

And I always love the way people complain about other peoples assumptions - in particular when they have just made a bunch of assumptions themselves.

But well done for your efforts. You get 8/10 for aggression, 3/10 for cleverness, and 1/10 for humour. Next time I would suggest adding some sarcasm just to ensure people realise you are aware that no one on the internet will ever take you seriously anyway, so you are just venting for the sake of letting out some personal frustration.
HeatherG says:

08:13am | 20/04/12

Anyone with any idea of Gibson’s history could see that there’s a mental illness going on. The man was an alcoholic for years. That doesn’t do much for the brain cells as you get older… it would certainly make it harder for him to *hide* his crappy attitudes.

Tory’s point is well-made though. WTF do we even care so much that the stories rate so well? “News” only reports this crap because we lap it up.

(As for Zeta’s comment above, so I’m not throwing in an extra comment: all I have to say to that is “Winning!”)
Barry from Adelaide. says:

08:39am | 20/04/12

Poor form, Sam Jensen.

Try getting drunk and shouting out your post as loudly as possible. You will sound just like Mel Gibson, I suspect.
- Stella says:
  
  02:30pm | 19/04/12
  
  more violent villification from the current media spokeswoman for the loony left. Let he/she who is without sin, etc etc, i actually feel sorry for you that writing this sort of meaningless trash is what you pass off as a job.
  
  Reply
barry from adelaide says:

08:44am | 20/04/12

Tory is the spokeswoman for the loony left? What planet are you from Stella?
- Anubis says:
  
  02:32pm | 19/04/12
  
  Really Tory - “he’s not just a potty-mouth racist anti-Semitic man”
  
  Was it reallt necessary to add the word man? Mel Gibson is a potty-mouth racist anti semite but wether he is a man or not is irrelevant to your article. And honestly he’s not much of a man when he publicly spouts drivel like that
  
  Reply
fml says:

03:27pm | 19/04/12

I think she was just using “man” as a descriptive, i do not think there were any connotations attached to it, nor do i think she was generalising to include all men.
Andrew says:

04:51pm | 19/04/12

Have I missed something, he is a man isnt he, if he isnt he does a bloody great job playing men in those films.
Tory Shepherd says:

05:19pm | 19/04/12

Oh Anubis! Do you want us to do some politically correct speak? Person, then, if it makes you happy.
subotic says:

08:03am | 20/04/12

Anubis is an anagram of Bi-anus.

Just saying….
egg says:

09:11am | 20/04/12

... oh god, not another one.
- imissmax says:
  
  02:34pm | 19/04/12
  
  I certainly don’t revel in seeing somebody fall apart or see their lives and the hard times they have in them as a spectacle but each to their own I guess. These people have every opportunity and so many just implode which I just find sad not interesting. Money and fame can’t make up for emotional instability, stupidity, lack of rational thinking or mental illness, celebrities demonstrate this over and over again. I never think of celebs as anything but regular people, they are just regular people with a longer way to fall and a crowd watching it happen.
  
  Reply
- john says:
  
  02:41pm | 19/04/12
  
  Well, lucky he is a caucasian male, otherwise we would not be allowed to judge him…...
  
  Reply
Philip says:

03:15pm | 19/04/12

Caucasians are very diverse group of people, I think you mean White.
fml says:

03:29pm | 19/04/12

I don’t get it,

Firstly he is not from the Caucus’s, secondly wouldn’t you be considered lucky if you were not judged?
gobsmack says:

03:52pm | 19/04/12

Oh give your paranoia a rest.

We were able to put the boot into Chris Brown when he transgressed.

There are no race barriers when it comes to bagging off the bad behaviour of celebrities.
Owen says:

04:09pm | 19/04/12

gobsmack, I assume you’ll be able to dig up Tory’s article about Chris Brown then…I’ll wait for you to get back to me on that.
gobsmack says:

04:23pm | 19/04/12

@Owen
john uses the word “we” which suggests that “we” in general are only allowed to judge “caucasian males”. No specific mention of Tory.
I don’t know about you, but I certainly feel free to judge whomever I like.
Brad says:

04:36pm | 19/04/12

careful, you’ll be called a racist!
- double standard? says:
  
  02:46pm | 19/04/12
  
  He’s entitled to his opinion. What he’s doing is not illegal, so he will reap the social consequences of what he sows.
  
  Remember though that he is part of an exclusive extremist Catholic sect and this is probably the reason for the way he is. Christianity, by definition, should hate the Jews for what they did to their god. Religion is still a freedom. I mean, just look at the Muslim extremists, they can worship their god without reprisal… oh, wait…
  
  Reply
HappyCynic says:

03:21pm | 19/04/12

Uh we didn’t do a damn thing to the Christian’s god. The jewish penalty for false prophets in those days was hanging we never ever crucified a single person. The last Pope knew this and worked bloody hard within the Church to ensure that history was set straight about this lie that’s been perpetrated for centuries.

There was 2 opinions in those days over who should deal with this trifling little Christ problem (largely between those who hated Roman rule and wanted autonomy to mete out justice as they saw fit and those who just wanted to practice their religion freely and so long as the Romans didn’t interfere in that they would agree to live peacefully under Pax Romana), in the end saner minds won out and Christ was given to the Romans to let them sort him out.
Paul says:

04:31pm | 19/04/12

@ HappyCynic: ‘in the end saner minds won out and Christ was given to the Romans to let them sort him out.’

I’m wondering, as a Jew would you say something similar about the prophet Mohammed.

I guess the Rolling Stones were correct, ‘Made damn sure the Pilot washed his hands and sealed his fate.’
Andrew says:

04:57pm | 19/04/12

To begin with it was gods son not god, secondly didnt Jesus say forgive them for they know not what they do. Therefore christians have no reason whatsoever to hate jews, jesus forgave them so christians are suppose to forgive them to.
- Kaz says:
  
  02:46pm | 19/04/12
  
  Agreed, very human. Human beings = a species capable of the most terrible words and actions imaginable. Let’s hope he gets some much needed therapy for being human.
  
  Reply
- Outraged says:
  
  02:48pm | 19/04/12
  
  YOU’RE the racist one, Tory!
  
  Jews aren’t a race! It is a religion! You can’t be racist against a religion…
  
  Reply
subotic Yom Ha'atzmaut says:

03:13pm | 19/04/12

So what do you call a Palestinian Jew, Outraged?
Philip says:

03:21pm | 19/04/12

Wrong that only works with Muslims and Christians etc. A non religious Jew is still a Jew.
marley says:

03:31pm | 19/04/12

@outraged - then why has the Federal Court ruled against a Holocaust denier under the Racial Discrimination Act? If it’s good enough for the Federal Court, it ought to be good enough for Tory and for you.
fml says:

03:38pm | 19/04/12

Outraged,

That’s why she used the term “Semite”, they are infact a race.

If you are an anti-Semite then you are racist.
HappyCynic says:

03:42pm | 19/04/12

@Outraged

Actually that’s not quite true, we are a religion that much is true, but a very large proportion of Ashkenazi Jews have genetic markers unique to them and no other ethnicity in Europe and the same applies to Sephardi Jews in Northern Africa and Spain. So technically Jews can be both a unique ethnicity and a part of a unique religion making us both a race and a religion. Also given that we generally have different cultural attire and customs etc to the bulk of the population we can also be a culture

The more you know…
PsychoHyena says:

04:08pm | 19/04/12

@Outraged, actually Judaism refers to the religion, Jewish refers to both the culture and religion. Judaism and the Jewish people is actually one of the few examples left in the world where culture and religion define the other and are inextricable from the other.
Tory Shepherd says:

05:21pm | 19/04/12

Wot they said
Scotchfinger says:

05:35pm | 19/04/12

Outraged feels very small, poor guy; it will teach him not to use exclamation marks indiscriminately!!! But at least he got a happy smile from Cynic.
- Pete says:
  
  02:48pm | 19/04/12
  
  Sooooo…....Gibson has issues so it stands to reason that he can’t tell a crap script when he reads one. Is that how it goes Joe?
  
  Bit of a tenous link there if you ask me (which of course no one did).
  
  Reply
- dexxter says:
  
  02:49pm | 19/04/12
  
  What is a star or so called celebrity? We give them that status because of something they may have done, or we perceive we would like to be like them. But many of these people are trashy human beings who cannot string two words together without a script and have no idea of reality. Just as we give so should we take away, and Gibson is a trashy human being. When he’s movies are on TV, I now switch channels, after seeing behind his public mask.
  Zeta’s comments3:14pm may be right in some areas but at least the people who have the money invest it to make more, possibly, pay their actors handsomely and probably too much, and entertain people. That is still no reason to rant the way Gibson has been doing.
  
  Reply
- Owen says:
  
  02:51pm | 19/04/12
  
  The worst thing about this story is that an individuals private rantings and ravings have been secretly recorded and then released to the media.
  As Tory points out, people eat this stuff up because it’s a celebrity…but why do we need to hear a recording of someone spitting the dummy over his broken marriage and declining appearance? There’s nothing anti-semitic about it…just pure anger. Surely this is stuff that should remain private. There are people having hissy fits in private residences all over the world all the time…the point is that they’re private and they aren’t hurting anyone, except the unlucky few who are in ear shot. Who hasn’t had a next door neighbour who yells and screams?
  The bottom line is that this writer has accused Gibson of rejecting his script on the basis of anti-Semitism but has produced no evidence to support that assertion. In place of evidence he has released a secret recording of Gibson at a very vulnerable moment (clearly distressed and angry). That’s a pretty low act if you ask me.
  This guy wrote a lousy script and it was rejected. And now he’s crying racist and doing anything he can to get back at Gibson. It’s all a bit sad really.
  
  Reply
Jason says:

03:40pm | 19/04/12

You actually have a good point Owen. I’m sure if somebody was recording me all the time, they could be some serious crap taken out of context. Your also correct about most of the assertions by this director. The anti-semitic stuff is all hearsay which everyone is willing to believe due to something Gibson said a couple of years ago when he was drunk.

That being said it’s possible Gibson does have some issues, but there’s plenty of people in that industry that could be describing.
- Nick says:
  
  02:59pm | 19/04/12
  
  He is white ,Catholic and straight..I guess it passes the lefts criteria and means we are allowed to make derogatory comments.
  
  Reply
Warren says:

03:30pm | 19/04/12

Yeah, nothing to do with being a wife beating anti-semite ...
egg says:

09:28am | 20/04/12

So true, I checked the “Is He White Enough to Hate?” webpage, and it turns out Mel’s all good, so let’s go! *fist pump*
- Andy says:
  
  03:11pm | 19/04/12
  
  Yeah, but how good was Apocalypto. And Payback. Let him make films. The rest is just voyeurism.
  
  Reply
- Nathan Explosion says:
  
  03:20pm | 19/04/12
  
  What gets me is why he’s dumb enough to get caught again and again saying vile things about other people (mainly Jews or his ex wife).
  
  You’re a public figure, mate. You know what Hollywood is like by now. Hold yourself in check until you can make sure you’re in private with no recording devices.
  
  Reply
- Wayne says:
  
  03:24pm | 19/04/12
  
  Tory Shepard you are holding on too tight like a lot of you Jorno’s you need to get over it and learn to let go. Everyone is a little racist even you and some of those that reckon they are not are even more racist. So learn to get over it
  
  Reply
Anna says:

11:30am | 20/04/12

This is such a bullshit claim that always gets thrown around. Can we stop now, please? No. Everyone is not “a little racist”. You either make assumptions and judgements (or worse) based on race, or you don’t. I would count myself, and most of the people whose opinions I respect, in the latter category. I am not in denial, I’m just not racist.

You sound like the kind of person that might begin sentences with “I’m not racist,but ...” Here’s a hint: whatever follows is always intrinsically racist.

Don’t drag us all down with you.
- wizard says:
  
  03:25pm | 19/04/12
  
  Read the Protocols. Mel did.
  
  Reply
Zeta says:

03:41pm | 19/04/12

The Protocols of the Elders of Zion are now widely known to be a hoax, even amongst avowed anti-semites.

They’re directly plagiarized from the Dialogue in Hell Between Machiavelli and Montesquieu by Maurice Joly.

The reveleation that it’s a hoax and a fraud actually date back to the 1920s, when the New York Times broken the story.
Andy Mack says:

04:14pm | 19/04/12

wizard, I’ve read some of the Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion like you recommend and I have come to the conclusion that they are definitely not fake. Here they are:

http://www.biblebelievers.org.au/przion1.htm
marley says:

04:29pm | 19/04/12

Well, there you go. Andy Mack believes in the Protocols of Zion. Based on his track record over the last few days, I would say that makes it an iron-clad, gold-plated certainty they’re a fake.
HappyCynic says:

04:48pm | 19/04/12

@Andy

Lol, too funny. I guess there’s always at least one person dumb enough to believe that sort of thing.

The problem with these sorts of consipracy theories is that it’s hard enough to keep a secret between 2 or even 3 people let alone millions.

The Protocols are full of sh*t because of this one rational and very reasonable fact.
John says:

10:44pm | 19/04/12

You are wrong Zeta, as the Protocols were reported as being a Czarist “forgery” in Russia in 1905, and even then they were claimed to date from the 1880s.

But whether they are a hoax, fake or forgery is all besides the point. In my opinion, they are more comparable to a theory that explains certain social behaviours, rather than a historically accurate report of past events.

People should read them and make up their own minds.
- JayJ says:
  
  03:30pm | 19/04/12
  
  No suprises here with Mel. I interviewed him in regional NSW in 1988 for a local Bicentenary event. His off camera comments about the then USSR supplying guns to aborigines and inciting an uprising were bizarre. He was worried about a “black” uprising…..and he was dead serious!
  
  Reply
- woppadingo says:
  
  03:33pm | 19/04/12
  
  Not the first actor to explode into foul mouthed racist expletives. But certainly some people have taken the opportunity to stick the knife in, including you, Tory.
  
  Reply
- Rebecca says:
  
  03:34pm | 19/04/12
  
  If his comments were about any race other than the Jews this man would be casted out of society. Our society is happy to let anyone say what they want about the Jewish community without any reprocussions. This is the truly sad part of the whole Mel Gibson fall.
  
  That said, everyone liked him when he was a succesful movie star. He was an anti-semitic then too
  
  Reply
fml says:

03:44pm | 19/04/12

r u 4 realz?

Taht being said, the media has been quite quiet on Cardinal Pell’s abominable recent remarks on Jews. He should really be sacked atleast reprimanded, i would ask where is the government backlash to his remarks.

He was totally out of order.
SimonFromLakemba says:

04:29pm | 19/04/12

“Our society is happy to let anyone say what they want about the Jewish community without any reprocussions”

LMAO
stephen says:

08:34pm | 19/04/12

When, on Q &A, Pell said that the Germans suffered more than the Jews in the 20th century ... well, he should have been pulled up for that by the moderator, because it is dead wrong.

And though I would not necessarily disagree with Rebecca, above, I think that sophisticated people of all religions and beliefs would discount comments of a racist nature.
Responding to abjectness offers it credibility.
- Humanity says:
  
  03:36pm | 19/04/12
  
  Most mental breakdowns barely raise a blip on anyones radar, its a sad and lonely place. To see someones breakdown polarized in this fashion is a pitiful reflection on the lack of understanding of all concerned.
  
  Reply
- Meph says:
  
  03:37pm | 19/04/12
  
  Put yourself in his shoes for a moment. You might also be kinda angry at the curve balls that life was throwing your way too.
  
  Some anger management may be an idea for the old guy, but lets be honest, he didn’t say anything in that transcript that Gordon Ramsay hasn’t said to pretty much all of the plebs on hells kitchen when they screw up.
  
  Reply
- Wayne Kerr says:
  
  03:39pm | 19/04/12
  
  Seems to me that we only have Joe Esterhauz’s word on Mel Gibson’s alleged anti-semtic ravings. As for the recording we don’t really know if it was taken when Mel Gibson was having a melt down over his split with his mistress or whomever she was/is. Believe me I’ve had conversations with my ex where I was swearing black and blue too. It’s an emotional time.
  
  This all seems to be trial by media where I don’t think we even know half the truth
  
  Reply
Warren says:

05:21pm | 19/04/12

There was nothing alleged about his anti-semtic ravings to the police. it was taped.
- James Shaw says:
  
  03:44pm | 19/04/12
  
  “Potty Mouth”??? - Did I accidentally log on to my 4 year old daughters website??? Do you think you could be anymore condescending to your readers? Come on you are no longer in kiddy school and are a big bad writer. You can get rid of all your kiddy widdy words now or otherwise you will get a big smack.
  
  Reply
- Tiredofit says:
  
  03:48pm | 19/04/12
  
  This is nothing compared to Tool McFadden from that silly show on TV…did anyone read the crap/‘filth that came out of this dogs mouth about the girl he is seeing and how he was going to F***ing bang all her friends on their hens night?????? Sheesh!!! Gimme me a break!!! The worst thing is Channel 7 put him up on a pedastal .........and this guys has kids….he should be deported back to the UK where he belongs…oppps that may be racist!!
  
  Reply
- Waz says:
  
  03:53pm | 19/04/12
  
  Harsh words and acts of violence are two different things, if Mel Gibson had have been an anybody then no one would bat an eye lid in regards to his rants, however in saying that just because he’s a somebody does not mean that he’s not entitled to an opinion. What I’ve come to learn in life is that if you follow the trend and listen to our Govt and media then racism is only so when it comes via a white person, that the segregation and violence toward the people of Palestine is acceptable because it’s happening in Israel, America did not violently enter Kosovo, Iraq and Afghanistan just to protect US oil pipeline interests. If all we’ve got to go buy is our Govt and our media then we’re all in trouble, we’re all adults here and we’re all entitled to an opinion whether its derogatory or not, as long as it’s not conveyed via acts of violence, acts of violence that occur daily against white people by the same people that our Govt and media protect. God placed all the different races on separate land masses and divided them by deep shark infested oceans knowing all too well that they couldn’t coexist, then man invented the canoe, end of story!
  
  Reply
fml says:

04:07pm | 19/04/12

“he’s not entitled to an opinion”

No one has said that.

“What I’ve come to learn in life is that if you follow the trend and listen to our Govt and media then racism is only so when it comes via a white person,” No, you are just playing the victim, the reverse is also true.

“God placed all the different races on separate land masses and divided them by deep shark infested oceans knowing all too well that they couldn’t coexist, then man invented the canoe, end of story! “

No, We all originated from Africa.
Waz says:

04:48pm | 19/04/12

two can play that game fml,
“has said that”
Has said what?
“No, you are just playing”
Actually no, I was simply commenting!
“We all originated from Africa”
That depends on whom you believe, I personally think that we we’re placed upon earth, rather than having evolved from the African apes.
fml says:

05:52pm | 19/04/12

difference being you are purposely being facetious, just in case you didnt actually understand,

No one has said he is not entitled to an opinion.

Yes, you are playing the victim, victims usually only see their victimisation, ergo you thinking that only white people are called racist, which is simply not true.

You are allowed to believe what ever you want, even if you are totally wrong, where in the bible does it say anything about dinosaurs, had they known about carbon dating i am sure the placement on earth by a higher being theory wouldve been included in the bible too.

p.s. nerny nerny ner ner.
- Ally says:
  
  04:10pm | 19/04/12
  
  Clearly, he has issues. I just don’t understand why we need to hear the secretly recorded audio.
  
  Wouldn’t it be nice if movie and tv stars just shut the hell up and did what they get paid to do? I don’t want to hear their opinion about politics, religion, society etc just because they think that being popular for acting suddenly means that the world’s waiting to hear what they think on every other subject.
  
  Reply
- DFB says:
  
  04:19pm | 19/04/12
  
  Sounds like a regular aussie bloke to me. I think a lot of the alleged ‘antisemitism’ read into terms like ‘ovendodger’ is a bit sensationalised.
  
  Lets not forget that the ‘scriptwriter’ who leaked all this rubbish has got the shits with Mel because he had the temerity to expect him to do his job. From all accounts he was supposed to have a first draft of this movie ready and turned up with nothing- zero, not a word. I know I’d be pretty cranky too.
  
  Reply
- Edward T. Head says:
  
  05:13pm | 19/04/12
  
  Gibson is a douche bag racist with anger issues. His ex-wife was a gold digger and this bloke is a a bludger who betrays his boss for getting upset at him for not doing his job. None of them have covered themselves in glory.
  
  But even though I despise racists I’m starting feel a smidge (a tiny, tiny smidge) sorry for Gibson as every man and his dog apparently tries to screw him over and then release the audio tapes.
  
  Although you’d think by now Gibson would have a) learnt some restraint and b) invested in some high tech security systems.
  
  Reply
John says:

01:04pm | 20/04/12

I despise people who use the term “racist” You commie Leon Trotsky lover!
- abolish welfare says:
  
  05:50pm | 19/04/12
  
  If Mel Gibson becomes the next Liberal National Party Treasurer in the next Liberal National Federal government then he would be a great improvement on Joseph Benedict Hockey who wants to abolish all government welfare in Australia !
  
  Reply
Pat says:

03:33am | 20/04/12

abolish welfare: I give you 1st prize for being the total idiot, How you are able to connect Mel Gibson , Joe Hockey ,The Liberal Party, the next election and political ideas or policy….is mind boggling. And , all done in 3 and 1/2 short lines. Did you take a leaf from a typical Mel Gibson rave to achieve that.?
- abolish welfare says:
  
  05:54pm | 19/04/12
  
  Who runs America and American foreign policy ? Hollywood or Washington ?
  
  Reply
marley says:

07:04pm | 19/04/12

From what I can see, no one is running it.
- Felicity says:
  
  06:50pm | 19/04/12
  
  To Owen: What you said. You just took it right out of my mouth.
  Gibson was in his own home expressing his own feelings which had nothing to do with any race issue.
  The only thing he did wrong was to let a little snake into his home.
  Clearly some people want to finish his career off for good.
  
  Reply
- stephen says:
  
  08:07pm | 19/04/12
  
  He’s a crook actor, though.
  A bit like a hopalong destry, but with a shrug.
  He wants the lens to like him so moves whilst he is thinking - which is never, unless he is standing on one foot, and then the other, then he talks at - and not to - his opposite on the screen.
  Notice how he never seems to really look at his actors ?
  He never breathes right when in dialogue, as if he just cannot get out his lines fast enough for another judgement. (Yeah, Mel judges when he should be listening. Have a look at his eyes.)
  
  There was an article on this site 5 or 6 weeks ago about Empathy.
  I think this bloke would fail miserably.
  
  Jews in Hollywood would probably ignore the rants personally, that is, (as they should) but would not be pleased at the box-office fallout from cinema customers - Jewish or otherwise.
  Movies function as a business, just like all other artforms.
  Anyway, Mel’s washed up.
  Seen his puppet movie ?
  I tried getting my money back.
  (I’d have better luck getting a loan from a Miner.)
  
  Reply
- BIGTONY says:
  
  10:11pm | 19/04/12
  
  The Protocols of the Elders of Rudd declare there will come a time when bespectacled blond know-alls walk the earth with impunity. And I think Tory is hot.
  
  Reply
- NESLIHAN KUROSAWA says:
  
  01:02am | 20/04/12
  
  Hi Tory,
  
  Mel Gibson has most definitely entertained millions of people around the world, in his own very charming way for a while now. And right now he just seems to be a little lost and out of control. Mostly because he might be feeling a little bit old and unwanted by his fan his own club, the good old Hollywood crowd and the paparazzi. And in a way he could have lost a little bit of the charm, youthful good looks and his manners as well.
  
  The story of fallen stars is absolutely nothing new at all. However, making very narrow minded, racist and anti Semitic remarks could actually be seen as being very unacceptable, indeed. And how about showing a bit of sympathy and compassion for your fellow country man? After all life is full of ups and downs for all of us? But our lives don’t make headlines almost everyday, well may be some people like you do manage to do just that.
  
  But can we say that about Hollywood actors with a lot of fame and fortune? Do we remember what has happened to the very famous Whitney Houston? You can call it mental illness, if you like. Somehow, I personally feel that the very famous live fast lives on the fast lanes. All this could be the actual cost and consequence of all those long hours of acting which can seem almost effortless for the likes of Mel Gibson.
  
  It is surely about time that we began to see all the stars with their names up in lights, just like every one else, if that is possible. Because getting older and wiser may prove to be so much harder for some people in our society. And eventually all that glamour, partying and getting used to the idea of being seen in the limelight constantly can actually take its toll on the famous.
  
  Maybe it is also about time that we have started to see the true personality and character behind the scenes. Instead of worshipping these stars constantly for the only reason being once upon a time they managed to make quite a few good Hollywood films and loads of money along the way. Most unfortunately these days, in our world money may make the world go around or stand still also? Kind regards to your editors.
  
  Reply
- Pat says:
  
  04:50am | 20/04/12
  
  Look at the clash of two egos here,,,,with more in common that it first appears. You know the history of Gibson, with his relentless film depictions of merciless violence….but what about Eszterhas? He wrote things like the tripe - Showgirls and Basic Instinct and then followed it up with an even more sex-violent movie Jade?
  The full uncut version of Jade is not available on DVD,,,,BUT the original R- rated tape video is noticeably far more extended, especially its sex and S/M perversion scenes. The porny plot .. driven by various recorded forms of blackmail. (How ironic, is it? ) THEN…...........Eszterhas made a public renounciation of his former sleazy script style of work , and that he had now FOUND GOD.
  
  So here, we now have two similarly twisted washed up creatures bitching, about who was the more genuine : in touting a religious themed script to a film studio. Moreover each also may have seen it as their likely ticket for renewed respectability . The studio, as we already know - looking at the script and its marketability did not buy the effort, as presented. For anyone looking on, to then build out of all this, a grand political -religious -racial conspiracy…is madness. in itself . Quite simply. it only takes an equally capable rat to finally destroy another such rat, once and for all.. And in those circles ,what you are seeing is : Show Business cannabalism at work, devouring some of its own. Get out the popcorn and take your seat,
  
  Reply
- Pat says:
  
  05:03am | 20/04/12
  
  HA! HA! , Unfortunately Gibson , just happens to be one of those people, silly Australians used to take to their bosums and possessively call “Our Mel ” Leaving aside the simple fact : he was not born in Australia, in the first place
  
  Reply
Edward T. Head says:

10:45am | 20/04/12

We were more than happy to consider him Australian when people didn’t know what he was really like.
- prosperity@adelaide.on.net says:
  
  08:54am | 20/04/12
  
  For his vicious homophobia over the years, may Mel rot in hell.
  
  Reply
- Robert S McCormick says:
  
  10:55am | 20/04/12
  
  Who is mel Gibson?
  Another Anti-Jew Australian Greens Senator?
  
  Reply
- Mark/Fox says:
  
  07:29pm | 20/04/12
  
  Do we we give pity to the druggo Greens because they hate Australia and its culture? No, so why should we pity Mel.
  
  Reply
- Yosef says:
  
  07:26am | 18/10/12
  
  Thanks for the link.Amazing… Charlie Gibson going all Laffer Curve on us.And even more amazing is the blntcaay of the President’s desire for empathy rather than really doing anything of substance to rally the economy.
  
  Reply

Sorry, comments are now closed for this article.

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

See all tweets

Light weight

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Gibson: Is it time to take pity on the racist potty mouth?

Must Reads

Most commented

112 comments

Tedd says:

6 million subotics says:

Jason says:

Peter Dellaplane says:

Edward T. Head says:

Steve Putnam says:

Fingers says:

Zeta says:

Scotchfinger says:

fml says:

Peter says:

Em says:

gobsmack says:

Scotchfinger says:

Rickster says:

SimonFromLakemba says:

Moron Brando says:

AdamC says:

Tory Shepherd says:

ZSRenn says:

AdamC says:

willie says:

Jack says:

Chris says:

HappyCynic says:

Sam Jensen says:

Tory Shepherd says:

Ben says:

HeatherG says:

Barry from Adelaide. says:

Stella says:

barry from adelaide says:

Anubis says:

fml says:

Andrew says:

Tory Shepherd says:

subotic says:

egg says:

imissmax says:

john says:

Philip says:

fml says:

gobsmack says:

Owen says:

gobsmack says:

Brad says:

double standard? says:

HappyCynic says:

Paul says:

Andrew says:

Kaz says:

Outraged says:

subotic Yom Ha'atzmaut says:

Philip says:

marley says:

fml says:

HappyCynic says:

PsychoHyena says:

Tory Shepherd says:

Scotchfinger says:

Pete says:

dexxter says:

Owen says:

Jason says:

Nick says:

Warren says:

egg says:

Andy says:

Nathan Explosion says:

Wayne says:

Anna says:

wizard says:

Zeta says:

Andy Mack says:

marley says:

HappyCynic says: