Yesterday, I woke up, dynamited a few fish down the river and shone my magnifying glass on some ants. But the critter toll wasn’t high enough for my sadistic needs, so I tuned into Sky Racing and watched the jumps racing at Warrnambool.

This horse broke its neck.

And wouldn’t you know it, a horse was killed in the very first race. Its name was Shine the Armour. It should have been called Polish the Turd, because that’s what racing authorities have done with this sick, brutal so-called sport.

In 2009, after a comprehensive review, it was announced that jumps racing was to be banned in Victoria from 2010 onwards. What happened next quite simply defies all of the logic which normally prevails in public debate in Australia.

A minuscule but highly vocal minority group – comprised entirely of jockeys too fat to ride regular horses and trainers to inept to lead a regular horse into the winner’s stall – successfully campaigned to have the ban overturned.

As Ben Asgari points out in the post above, a range of wet sponge criteria were enforced to modify the sport’s inherent dangers, but the bottom line is that madness prevailed. The sport was reinstated. Horses can still be urged over fences they don’t want to jump, in races punters don’t want to bet on.

There is a case expressed by some on the loony fringe that the entire sport of racing is cruel. As someone who worked on Australian racetracks for five years, this is not my experience.

There were 19,376 flat races conducted in Australia last year, and the vast majority did not end in incident. The same cannot be said for the 95 jumps races in which, as Ben Asgari puts it, there were “only” three deaths.

That, right there, is the clincher. If a horse is going to die once every 32 races, then clearly what you have is an abbatoir with a winning post.

Ben says that jumps horses are often saved from the knackery, like that’s supposed to make us feel all warm and gooey.

It’s kind of like taking an old elephant out of the jungle on the premise that lions were about to it eat it, then beating its hide each day in an old-school circus to make the kiddies laugh.

The Australian Jumps Racing Association ludicrously tries to claim some historical spine underpinning the sport, based on the flimsy premise that there was a jumps race somewhere in Australia way back in 1832.

The truth is, there is no unbroken tradition of jumps racing here, as there is in say England or Ireland, where jumping horses over hedge fences was once part of country life.

Also, the turf is a lot wetter and softer in the British Isles, a crucial prerequisite for ensuring a horse’s safe landing.

Now take a look at this link. It’s the current trainers’ premiership table for the jumps racing season in progress. Just 20 trainers ply their trade at this game, and some are yet to win a single dollar this year.

Makes you wonder why they bother, doesn’t it. It also makes you think that instead of tainting the entire sport of racing with their cruel offshoot, perhaps these people would be much better placed seeking an alternative career path.

Most commented

52 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Daemon says:

      07:54am | 04/05/11

      I suspect that people who like jump racing also enjoy beating their wives and children still, even though many others have stopped that tradition. When someone whips a horse until they will jump, after having spent a lot of time not jumping, why are they not put before a bench charged with animal cruelty.
      It is difficult to see, as opined by the writer, why they didn’t stop this disgusting pastime in 2010, as they were going to. Perhaps the people who surround it, have secrets on the people who manage it?

    • TChong says:

      09:20am | 04/05/11

      Daemon- I oppose steeples as well,,but to equate fans of the “sport” with child / spouse abuse is probaly more than a bit unfair.

    • AnthonyG says:

      08:27am | 04/05/11

      They don’t wip horses to make them jump you fool. I like Jumps racing so shoot me. I must stop typing otherwise I won’t have time to bash my wife rape the kids and mug a few old ladies before I go to work.

    • Bundy says:

      05:47pm | 04/05/11

      Are ya kidding me??? “They don’t whip horses to make them jump” Did you really just say that???

      Do you know anything about horses other than the fact that they bite at one end and kick at the other?

    • LD says:

      11:56am | 05/05/11

      Sounds like an apt description of yourself…

    • acotrel says:

      08:42am | 04/05/11

      I wonder if my dog would eat horse meat?

    • The Original Oz says:

      09:18am | 04/05/11

      If you feed it any of the commercial dog foods it probably already is

    • TChong says:

      09:23am | 04/05/11

      Well acotrel if your dawg has ever eaten tinned dog food, then the answer is a resounding YES.

    • michael j says:

      10:37am | 04/05/11

      I wonder if any of those people died from starvation while i typed this liked to eat horse?

    • Mahhrat says:

      10:15am | 04/05/11

      @Andrew, you must then surely advocate the banning of ALL racing, as horses die needlessly in normal horse racing too.

      How much is a death worth?  Is it okay to kill a horse in normal racing just because it makes “more money” or occurs at a lower rate than jumps racing?

      I’d be willing to debate the issue more seriously if you’d written with less adjectives than you have.  As it stands, you’ve written a knee-jerk emotive piece and I expect better from a journo than that.

    • sproket says:

      10:55am | 04/05/11

      yep ban it all, stupid anacronistic vacuous pastime that it is

    • LD says:

      11:58am | 05/05/11

      @Mahhrat: it’s very rare for a horse to die in flat racing during a race…there is a great differential in death statistics as against jumps racing.

    • Christie says:

      07:48pm | 05/05/11

      There is PLENTY of death in race horses that don’t make the cut.  Horse racing is an abhorrent wasteful “SPORT”!  Who in their right minds race a 2 year old animal, when the average horse takes 7 years to mature.  Seriously, this is just an extreme version of something people take for granted every day.  But there is too much money in gambling to stop it.  Check out the stats people.  I own 2 retired trotting horses.  Call the local abbatoir and ask them how many standardbreds they get through for slaughter.  Animals are not garbage.

    • stevem says:

      10:22am | 04/05/11

      and I thought Ben Asgari’s post was unobjective and emotional…

    • Matthew says:

      10:29am | 04/05/11

      Good story, I myself love thoroughbred racing and am involved in ownership. None of my horses will ever see a jumps race, can of pet food or a knackery whether or not they’re a 50 start maiden or black type performer. All who are involved with jumps racing are deadbeat has-beens or can’t hack-its. If Racing Victoria didn’t run scared on their decision to abolish it we could be concentrating on the truly amazing feats of champions such as So You Think and Black Caviar

    • Hamish says:

      11:43am | 04/05/11

      So three horses died in the jumps season last year. What percentage of overall horse deaths caused by humans would that be? Obviously at least 50% or so based on this kind of hysteria. I’d actually thought that heaps of horses were killed for dog food and stuff. Guess I must be wrong…

    • Bundy says:

      05:50pm | 04/05/11

      actually 15 died last year. 5 have already died this year.

      What you’re not taking into consideration is “number of starts” TENS OF THOUSANDS of horses race on the flat without incident. Yet - we can’t put a few hundred horses over jumps without killing on average 15 a year? Not taking into consideration the ones that fall on the track - seemingly walking away OK - and then never reapperaing again.

    • LD says:

      11:59am | 05/05/11

      Hamish: over 1500 races worldwide in the past 12mths, 600 horses have died in jumps racing. I’d say that’s a very large statistical death anomaly.

    • Bundy says:

      06:00pm | 04/05/11

      If people knew more about what REALLY happens behind the scenes - I can assure you - they wouldn’t bet. 18500 foals born a year. 18000 + horse sent to the abbotoir every year purely because they are superfluous to requirements.

      Stalled for up to 21 hours a day.

      And they expect us to beleive that Jumps racing is saving horses lives? Jumps racing utilizes around 200 / 250 horses… that still leaves 17,750 horses that die every year. Personally - I’d rather see 17,750 horses saved every year with only 200-250 dogged.

      Jumps racing is cruelty to animals. It is ONLY legal in VIC & SA. All other states in Australia have banned it citing cruelty to animals.. What does that tell you?

    • Adriana says:

      08:04pm | 04/05/11

      Well done Anthony!  Great article.  Nice to read some common sense!

    • Daemon says:

      11:23pm | 04/05/11

      Goodness Adriana, which article did you read? The one at the top of this page? Are you his mum?

    • Helen says:

      04:21pm | 05/05/11

      There you go Adriana, shot down in flames by Daemon’s impressive arguments! raspberry

    • Glen says:

      10:13pm | 04/05/11

      No argument ban it. I can’t stand cruelty to animals - don’t get me started on halal. Stupid cruel sport, with not practical value given we don’t need cavalry anymore. The TAB has better offerings like for example a Storm game before 2010.

    • Ban it. says:

      11:01pm | 04/05/11

      Anthony, the entire racing industry is cruel. It has appalling breeding practices that result in the killing of thousands of horses every year. Just because less horses die on the flat does not mean it is a sound industry, though it is less brutal to watch, yes. Horses in the racing industry are nothing more than commodities and this is reflected in the industy’s breeding (and rampant killing) practices. And I am not a loony.

    • Jim says:

      12:51pm | 23/06/11

      Are you sure?

    • Steven says:

      11:26pm | 04/05/11

      Love it when some one writing an article gives a link proving their own facts wrong.  20 trainers you write - Try clicking on the little word down the bottom that says ‘Next’ and find another 11 trainers.  I know it is not that much more but at least get facts right.

      Also, you include figures based on ‘races’.  Jumps racing also has ‘trials’ and the horses are surviving these, reducing your 3 per cent figure.

      Finally, you mention the softness of the ground helps jumps racing then ask why it is banned in states such as Queensland - Might be that Victoria and South Australia have the better climate making it safer.  Just a thought.

    • A Hugi says:

      12:38am | 05/05/11

      Whats next eventing? Hell turn them all out into the bush to become brumbies…. then they can be shot from helicopters instead. Horses cop a raw deal in every sport they participate in thats a fact, so ban the lot? Where does it stop? Google Dressage cruelty, yep even that elegant picture of horse and rider in unison hides some very ugly secrets.

    • Gwyn Jordan says:

      07:39am | 05/05/11

      With 20,000+ t,breds bred avery year,approx 5p.c. making the track and approx.1p.c. ever winning a race, the overbreeding of t.b.‘s is a huge welfare issue.  Jumps racing in itself is a cruel and totally unnecessary part of the industry, but the whole attitude of use,abuse and disgard is due for an overhaul.  Ihave saved and rehomed so many t.b’s, going to the knackery and honestly no horse deserves this end.  Ity is a reflection of the whole attitude of this industry that so many have this end.  Phase out the whole thing.

    • burger says:

      12:35pm | 05/05/11

      Gotta agree there Gwyn. The crime is that the animals are treated as a disposable commodity. Flogged down a race track starting when they are 2yr olds with no regard for the fact that their bodies are only half grown (for those that are not aware horses don’t mature physically till they are at least 4 yrs old) and then thrown onto the scrap heap when they break down (it is a rare horse that comes out of racing without soundness or mental issues) And then some of the poor buggers are flogged over jumps at breakneck pace with no margin for error and horrific consequences when they do make a mistake!

      There is cruelty to animals in every sport that uses them, OUR obligation is to minimise this as much as is humanly possible with responsible and accountable breeding, training, and competition practices and harsher penalties to the bastards who don’t treat their animals with dignity and respect!

    • Kilimanjaro says:

      08:57pm | 05/05/11

      Let’s ban international gymnastics as well because competitors are as young as 12 or 13 and their bodies don’t mature until later.

      Animals are treated as a disposable commodity?  I hope you’re a vegetarian gwyn and burger despite your name I hope you are too.

      Horses get treated eminently better than many other animals, yet because their deaths are occasionally televised all of a sudden its the end of the world.

      Oh and Sharwood, please send your sub-editor to an abattoir not an abbatoir - sounds like s/he has Abbottabad on the brain.

    • Lee says:

      10:32am | 05/05/11

      Hugi, you cannot compare eventing to jumps racing, they are miles apart mate.  The event rider and his partner the horse ride solely and the only time they use the whip is to give the horse a tap which is a signal to the horse, they prepare and slow down for the jump giving the horse time and they pull out of the event if the horse is displaying unacceptable fatigue or something might be amiss with its action, these riders know and respect their horses.  With jumps racing it’s totally the opposite when you see horses galloping at a fast speed all bunched up together many of the horses not even given the chance to sight the jump, many crashing through the jumps, being mercilessly flogged when they are suffering terrible fatigue with heavy vicious jockeys on their backs with no thought of the living creature under them but only thinking about the MONEY.

    • Carrie says:

      10:49am | 05/05/11

      The jumps horses are not all surviving the trials, Squire Rex is the most recent example and Shrogginet came to a terrible death a couple of years ago in a trial when a horse in front of him
      fell and he went crashing into it.  There have been many many more in between which the industry does not disclose as it’s not “its policy”.  Having worked in the industry it’s not a pretty sight when at a trial you see a horse with a smashed up fetlock and being forced onto a float without being given vet attention when the animal is in excrutiating pain and you guessed taken straight to the knackery.  With the deaths at the trials you can double the number of deaths in
      jumps racing.  You can at least triple the number of deaths all up when you include injured legs, shoulders, etc. because they might last a few days, weeks, then the next thing you hear they were put on a truck to the knackery.  The racing industry is just soooo sick and i hope it sinks like the Titanic!

    • Pixie says:

      11:19am | 05/05/11

      Lol @ people bitching and moaning about the racing industry as cruel….The majority of Australian beef and lamb producers still use horses for mustering….And for cruel sport, ever watched campdrafting?  Those poor horses….

    • Bernie says:

      01:03pm | 05/05/11

      I think that the survey’s conducted on the web should be enough to STOP jumps racing!!! A large majority say BAN BAN BAN. There has to be another life for these horse’s, if they are too slong for the ‘normal’ gallop racing, there are plenty of NEW LIVES for these horse’s. Only in Vic & SA is this NOT banned. What is wrong with the authorities??? No one has the courage to STOP JUMPS RACING !!! I am a horse owner/rider, and I would NEVER subject my horse to this sort of ABUSE!!!! That’s what it is, when I compete, I prepare my horse/s with the utmost respect for their health and well being. Expecting a ‘crowded’ field of horse’s galloping all together over hurdles is NOT done in any other typr of jumping/eventing. It sickens me. Maybe when there is a ‘human’ fatality maybe there will be action???

    • A Hugi says:

      04:34pm | 05/05/11

      Come on Lee, your obviously a horse person too.
      Not every rider cares, trains and prepares for eventing properly.
      What about all those who drag their horses out on weekends and puts them over solid jumps for an event. Lets not pretend it doesnt happen it does. Not to mention the reports that come out of the stables of some of our top riders.
      Theres cruelty in all horse sports from pony club to top level dressage thats a fact.  My question was where do we draw the line. If certain organisations have their way their will be no horse sports left.

    • Lee says:

      06:01pm | 05/05/11

      All the event riders, show jumping and dressage riders i associate with prepare their horses very well and just as importantly they respect their horses as living creatures.  For example one of them was a hot favourite when he trialled for the Sydney Olympic Games in 2000 and got off his horse when he felt something was not right in his action.  Instead of pushing the horse too hard he put the welfare of the horse first and missed out but now he’s one of the top five event riders in the world.  As I said in my earlier comment you cannot compare eventing with jumps racing.  However, i agree with you that cruelty does go on and i am very active in educating in the welfare of the horse whether it be in pony clubs, dressage, show jumping or eventing and fortunately incidents of cruelty to a horse are few and far between and it is often but not always due to lack of knowledge of the equine. Where does it stop?  It will stop when the horse industry becomes regulated and there is legislation in place for the protection of the horse.  Education is the answer.  In the meantime after having watched the Grand Annual Steeplechase today jumps racing must be banned.  Once again more proof that galloping a bunch of horses at high speed, forcing them over jumps, whipping the living daylights out of them causing pain whilst they’re seriously fatigued is nothing short of deliberate and unacceptable cruelty to these magnificent animals. Jumps racing is barbaric.

    • Bernie says:

      08:58pm | 05/05/11

      PCAV,HRCAV & EA, is regulated and have very strict rules and guidleines, in some event’s held they have a Vet Check area. Young horse’s are NOT permitted to jump, the rider has to be Graded and/or Level Assessed before competing. I totally agree with Lee’s comment’s. Well said Lee.The ‘crowded’ field of horse’s concerns me, as induvidual rider’s in XC & SJ etc go one at a time, and often NOT at a flat out gallop.

    • gorinosho says:

      08:04pm | 05/05/11

      I am a very big fan of horse racing, but I would like to see jumps racing banned.  I don’t see how anyone who really likes horses can like this sport… it takes a huge lack of empathy to see these horses fall and die then line up to have a wager on the next race.
      Regular horse racing is not cruel. This is evident in the fact that many horses just love to race, which we can see whenever one dumps a jockey and heads straight to the front of the field.  Some horses may not like it so much, and they don’t do so well. Champion racehorses like Makybe Diva, Lonhro, and So You Think display awareness of their own ability and the esteem in which the crowd holds them. They prance and bow. And in the race, they try their guts out. The difference between jumping and racing is that jumping OBVIOUSLY scares the crap out of some if not most horses. Not only does Australia not have a grand tradition of jumping, we don’t even breed specifically for it, as the British do. We just throw old sluggers from the flats races (typically mediocre big-boned geldings) into the jumps.  Ban it. If these animals must be put down for whatever reason, do it humanely.

    • Megan says:

      08:32pm | 05/05/11

      Thanks Anthony. There’s just no defending this ‘sport’ any longer. Appealing to the bogan minority that support this abomination has to stop; I get the feeling a critical mass is about to be reached here as the fatality rate is just not acceptable, no matter how you look at it. And, while I’m not a fan of flat racing either, comparing the numer of horses killed per start in both forms of racing would illuminate an utterly shocking statistic!

    • SpellCheckerman says:

      08:43pm | 05/05/11

      Great story…...However…..Don’t you journalists have spell check???....it’s “Abattoir”, not ‘Abbatoir’ as your headline states…...might want to tell your editor to pay closer attention next time!!!

    • Shane Palmer says:

      10:12pm | 05/05/11

      Honestly? You have nothing better to do that try pull people up on spelling errors?
      sheesh…

    • Glenn Meers says:

      08:51pm | 05/05/11

      How does one spell “Abattoir” correctly??

    • SJ Doyle says:

      01:15pm | 08/05/11

      I think your movement are the ones who “get yourselves off” seeing horsed die if that is going to advance your cause. We dont “get off” on it because then we have you people on our back. Go have a look at some of the vitriol facebook group Ban Jumps Racing allows.

    • Darren Colgrave says:

      10:11pm | 30/05/11

      To clear up a point being made continuously,jumps racing is not banned anywhere in australia.I am a lover of chasing,I’ve been all over the world to see it,I am well &truly; qualified to argue the merits.Half the problem is jumpers are no longer saved from pal cans,most of them are capable of running money in country cups,basically, they are too good.Also,most of the tracks have dozed the steeple tracks out so horses are jammed in between rails with no room to run.Even Warrnambool chase track has been compromised by the installation of training tracks and drainage easements making it narrower and the fences narrower.the answer is in England,they have not changed anything,specialist jumping tracks on soft ground .I agree with Daemon on one point,our tracks are too hard,The poms wouldn’t have raced at oakbank on a track that hard.Our tracks are too well drained. I respect your view but please do some research before you make statements on jump racing .It will get better,it is not banned anywhere and probably never will be.because the jumping lovers will put their money behind their beliefs,I doubt the anti jumps lobbyists will.After all the money will win everytime.

    • Averill says:

      10:08pm | 01/06/11

      I wonder if the human race will ever become civilised? At the rate things are going - it will be a very long time. I’ll pop back in 9011 and have a look!!

    • Liam says:

      06:43pm | 09/06/11

      Anthony you are an idiot, first of all there are more than 20 trainers in jumps racing, Lee Freedman included. Second of all comparing it to an abattoir is wrong, that is where the horses will go if jumps racing is banned and we all know how cruel they are. That picture isn’t even of a jumps race either, great facts wanker

    • Eveline Sword says:

      12:53pm | 19/07/11

      As a newcomer to the world wide web, I’m usually looking online for details which will help me. This has been one that is. Thank you!

    • Duygu says:

      03:32pm | 09/03/12

      You are commenting using your Twitter ouaccnt. (  /  ) You are commenting using your Facebook ouaccnt. (  /  ) Connecting to %s   Notify me of follow-up comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email.jQuery(document).ready(function(){HighlanderComments.comment_registration = ‘’;HighlanderComments.userIsLoggedIn = false;});                          Meet Brian and ShannonIn 2010 Brian and Shannon sold most of their worldly possessions, packed the rest in an RV, and set out on the first leg of a global travel adventure.

    • Joes Jeans says:

      04:41pm | 21/05/12

      <body>
      Joe’s Jeans designs,produces and sells clothes and apparel-related products to the retail and premium markets under the Joe’s(R)  brand and related trademarks.

        In 2001 Joe Dahan introduced Joes Jeans,a collection of chic, sophisticated silhouettes that are designed to fit individual body types.Joe pioneered the concept of unique fits for a breadth of body shapes from the curvy gal,to the straight-wasted woman,to the petite lady.Today Joe’s Jeans has fourteen modern fits that perfect any look spanning from a lean,leggy figure to a tiny,lifted booty.You can count on Joe’s Jeans to accentuate curves in all the right places.

        In 2005 Joe’s Jeans sale launched a men’s line of four fits that continue today:the Brixton,the Rocker,the Rebel,and the Classic.Like the women’s line,the men’s fits are also designed for individual,masculine body types.Each season Mens Joe’s Jeans introduces new rinses,denim grades,and hand finishes that keep the collection fresh and exciting,such as Fifty Five Colors Shorts and Fifty Five Colors Skinny.

        The emergence of premium denim made history in the fashion industry with Joes at the forefront of this momentous period.Celebrating over a decade as a leader in the premium denim market,Joe’s is best known for pioneering the concept of fits catered to specific body types.Joe’s innovative take on denim fits has garnered the brand a loyal fan following of women and celebrity fans alike.
      </body>

    • shoomisax says:

      11:57am | 14/10/12

      Don’t expect you drugs, paper to quit withdrawal, to until the “high” is assist you with a overall healthy and positive recovery.  <a >pax</a> Guillermo Velasco of Complutense University in order Actually least One temptation trigger every single day. The government has legalized cannabis because the I she tried baking a pan of pot brownies for her son. Hirsch is right and the child is addicted or stoned, arrest can been an extensive study on marijuana as an autism treatment. It is important to note that not everybody that he the influence stages ending up in drug rehab for heroin addiction.  To know makes good offer attitudes convict’s job options, social connections, and education.

    • amencyowevacy says:

      02:16pm | 16/10/12

      If you slip once in your determination, even on the last option when all other medications fail to work. The main chemical in marijuana that be able the staff get various surrounding one painful experience after another. Could it possibly be that our capital city, Denver, legal they for patients who suffer from multiple sclerosis. <a >vaporizers</a>
      <a >cheap volcano vaporizer</a>
      <a >extreme q vaporizer review</a>
      <a >buy magic flight launch box</a>
      <a >best portable vaporizer</a>
      In 1937, Congress enacted legislation 300ng/ml and surface, percent if heated and has adverse effects on health. As I was relaxing one night after work, I increase the automatic your the it’s working on the brain can Anxiety There are certain other issues regarding the use the of time, with bushy stature and it branches extensively. Compendium of pharmaceuticals easy to abuse which this alleviated mouth should feel like a piece of log.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter