As all the cool kids got themselves in a lather over last night’s budget I noticed a distinct void in the chatter.  Where were the mums and dads? Turns out that lots of them were watching Masterchef (possibly the people’s new opium) - studiously avoiding the budget telecast.

A welcome return to a surplus of calories

Political apathy seemed to be the flavour of the day, plated up and served with a side of Couldn’t Give a Shit.

Was it the fault of the no-frills budget? Or have we lost faith in a government which once seemed to promise so much?

Or was an ‘unsexy’, boring budget simply a clever way of getting us to tune out from a government in all sorts of trouble.

Probably closer to the truth is the fact that families - all kinds of families - are actually too busy working, wrangling kids, balancing their own budgets, paying the bills, worrying over interest rates, childcare, rising costs of living to be worried about the budget telecast. Most of us only have time to read the headlines the next day and ask, “So what’s in it for me?”

Turns out this year, not so much. Naturally the health initiatives are of interest. Sickness and injury are a mainstay of family life. Something all too apparent for me as I picked my sick daughter up from her nan’s so that I could rush home and prepare for the budget speech. Significantly, she threw up all over the loungeroom floor during Joe Hockey’s ABC interview.

I wondered aloud if any of the new super clinics were open yet.

After cleaning her up and I looked back over what else was on offer. They were slim pickings.

Proposed simplified tax returns: Yep, most of us hate the annual tussle with the Tax Pack so this holds definite appeal. But I found the introduction of this initiative with a spiel about how the average person’s desire is to spend more time with their ‘loved ones’ particularly annoying.

At first I thought Wayne Swan was about to offer us all a free week on the Gold Coast. But no. A few hours annual relief from sorting through work receipts is all that this offers, because if your tax obligations are more complicated than that chances are you can’t use the new ‘click and flick’ option anyway.

Budget sweetener lite if you ask me.

Childcare is the other thing which is usually wheeled out to catch the eye of the mum and dad voter. But blink and you would have missed this years offering - which, actually is no offering at all. Capping of rebates to the 2008-2009 level is a cut many of us didn’t expect. Although the announcement of the National Quality Framework for early childhood education and child care is what we can expect to see as a result of this capping.

After that it was all a bit yada yada - the Resources Super Profits Tax (RSPT) and its link to superannuation is all a bit tenuous for many of us to take seriously right now.

Granted, the Renewable Energy Fund sounds like just the thing to keep the government in the green parenting good books after the ETS backdown. They know that parents are passionate about the future of the planet because their kids are going to be walking it. But is it going to be any good? We’ve already seen an ill-conceived green initiative go bad this year.

There is no denying that this was, as promised, a no-frills budget. Perhaps the kind of budget that, in other years that would have mums and dads jumping up and down shouting, “I got nothing!’

I’m going to bet that is year they won’t. And here’s why. Despite its lack of sweeteners, the spin on this years budget, with it’s heavy emphasis on caution and fiscal responsibility, is perfectly suited to families. The spectre of the scary GFC and our ‘lucky escape’ from it plays right into the heart of most parents. Yes, we watched the world go into financial meltdown, and for many of us we were terrified that we were going to go down too. The government knows our fears only too well and has played them perfectly.

What they also know is that most families have had to have the ‘hard money talk’ themselves at various times. “Time to tighten the belt if we want to give the kids Christmas this year!” Swan has aligned himself with all of us who are trying to be responsible and ‘do the right thing’ financially. How can we argue with what seems like good sense?

Just don’t mention the insulation scheme, or the school building program or the fact that the RSPT hasn’t actually been passed yet.

Otherwise you might find that tonight’s budget is even unsexier than you think. 

In that light it might sound a little like this: “Um… honey –I kinda just maxed out all our credit cards on Davo’s snake oil scheme and possibly sold our firstborn so, you know, it’s time we tightened our belts, wait for that money we’re getting when Uncle Harold dies, and have ourselves a little quality no-frills time together. Hey, at least we didn’t lose the house like our neighbours, eh? ”

Er, yeah, thanks for that, sweetheart. Isn’t it time for Masterchef?

Don’t miss: Get The Punch in your inbox every day

Get The Punch on Facebook

Most commented

45 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • George says:

      07:53am | 12/05/10

      @Jayne

      I was one of those you referred to as “studiously avoiding the budget telecast” and YES I have lost faith in a government which once seemed to promise so much.  So much for KRudd’s ‘working families’ mantra.

    • J.W says:

      02:08pm | 12/05/10

      How would you know George you didn’t watch and God forbid the government spending money on us or fixing the roof insulation problem they should just let us fix it and look after big business hay. wouldn’t want to tax big business would we ?
      You people knock the government but take no notice in what’s going on and will cry poor and hard done by when the Lib’s return to power

    • JA says:

      03:56pm | 12/05/10

      J.W.

      I do not believe anybody will “cry poor and hard done by” if the coalition are returned to power, however, I do think plenty of people are currently thinking what idiots they were for voting ALP in 2007.

      Just a few things for you to remember J.W.
      -  The Government does not have any money, it is all ours – we entrust it to them to spend wisely (guess what – the ALP hasn’t)
      -  Big Business is already taxed fairly, ripping a further 12Bn out will only send business offshore – just as smokers tax reduces smoking, business taxes reduce business – meaning we are all poorer and have less opportunity thanks to Wayne Swan.  The share market losses alone exceed any future gains from this impost.
      -  The roof insulation “problem” only came about because of poor government controls over a get rich quick scheme that the ALP invented after 30 seconds of planning.  Jayne’s description of “Snake oil scheme is praising it up. Remember, the ALP actually caused deaths through it’s mismanagement and yet you reckon we owe them government a good turn for “fixing it”.

      Before the Rudd Government we were all comfortable and stable, people took that for granted and voted for social (not economic) change.  How sorry they now are now that it is a struggle to survive and worse to come.

    • iansand says:

      08:12am | 12/05/10

      But what happened on Masterchef?  Absolutely no mention of that in this article.  Talk about promises and no delivery.

    • Adam MacLeod says:

      12:44pm | 12/05/10

      G’day Ian,

      I was hoping for some mystery boxes and invention tests.

      All I got was a predictable celebrity cook off.

    • Anne71 says:

      12:55pm | 12/05/10

      Sod Masterchef, I was watching Top Gear! smile Would rather watch Clarkson, Captain Slow and the Hamster any day over that overhyped cooking contest, and I’m not even particularly interested in cars. As for the budget, I normally watch it but this time? Care factor was in negative figures and falling.

    • Voter says:

      08:59am | 12/05/10

      Most people are morons that choose to remain wilfully ignorant of the important issues affecting them. They then spout ignorant drivel based on whatever twaddle they read in The Daily Smelegraph.

      and they are allowed to vote…...

    • Eric says:

      09:21am | 12/05/10

      How dare those common folk have opinions! Let them eat cake.

    • An Idle Dad says:

      10:47am | 12/05/10

      If you think watching a speech by the treasurer on budget night gives you any detail on the actual budget, you’re a bit of an idiot yourself. Any speech that includes the words “so they can spend more time with loved ones” when discussing a simplified tax return is a wank, frankly.

      I’m a big fan of the bumper sticker “Is that the truth, or did you read it in the Daily Telegraph?” but even that paper would provide better analysis and a clearer explanation of budget changes and impacts than Mr Swan’s speech ever would.

      If you think Mr Swan’s words are less crafted or sensationalised than the Daily Telegraph, you are wilfully ignorant of an important aspect of the political world.

      And yes, you’re allowed to vote.

    • blissfully ignorant says:

      10:53am | 12/05/10

      Did you see the Black Forest cakes the other night? They looked great, although I am not sure about whether I would use the hazelnut praline.

      I am not short or long in the tooth, but I can never remember a time when people have ever got engaged by politics (except during elections). Unless you are an accountant, listening to people contineously spout numbers is dead boring. But good luck to those who got a bowl of popcorn and snuggled up on the couch for it.

    • boom says:

      11:04am | 12/05/10

      I tried to watch the budget, and was finding it very interesting, until Wayne Swan came on, and treated it like a political debate and the actual content of the show vanished in political spin and rudd’esque talk. Lasted 2 minutes after that.

    • JenK says:

      11:10am | 12/05/10

      There were numerous budget updates and headliners in the ad breaks on 7 & 9.  So much so, they encouraged to sit up and watch Survivor!

    • Matthew says:

      12:08pm | 12/05/10

      “and they are allowed to vote…... “

      *forced to vote.  Honestly, next election I’d rather not vote, both sides have nothing to offer me except stuff I don’t want.

    • Voter says:

      01:09pm | 12/05/10

      Idle Dad
      I have done more than watch the budget speech. I like to keep informed about important matters and use a wide variety of sources to do so. I also have a long career in economics, finance and tax with the necessary qualifications to draw on in order to understand what is really going on behind the scenes.

      Matthew
      The budget isn’t aimed at you. Or anyone. It is designed to build a nation and give it direction. This was one of the better budgets in a long time as it focused less on desperate handouts to the middle classes and more on what can be done to build the nation.

      People that look at it and think “what’s in it for me?” should be gaoled where they can’t vote.

    • An Idle Dad says:

      02:33pm | 12/05/10

      But you link watching the budget live with the right to vote? My comment is completely fair in that light.

      “People who look at it and think what’s in it for me should be goaled”? You’ve obviously just winding up people.

    • nonoodle says:

      09:59am | 12/05/10

      What difference does it make if I watch it or not, why spend an evening that your never going to get back when you will find out about it in the papers the next day! Seriously give me Masterchef any day….....

    • Kath says:

      10:01am | 12/05/10

      If Channel 10 actually thought people wanted to watch the Budget rather than Masterchef, they’d show the Budget.

      Then again, most people I know don’t watch the budget speech unless they really really have to.  It has nothing to do with disillusion or ignorance.  Anyway, you get better coverage from the press the following day because it covers everything - not just the highlights in the 20 minute (or so) speech.

      I’m sure if you compare Budget viewing figures over the past decade, I don’t think they would have changed all that much.

    • bella starkey says:

      10:32am | 12/05/10

      I knew a kid, he was 16 or 17, and he had budget parties. He also had red hair and dreamed of being an accountant. he was a rather unfortunate kid,

    • Paul Horn says:

      12:15pm | 12/05/10

      Yeah Bella better that kid be either a sporting hero or become a hardened crim throwing acid in womens faces and shooting a couple of non descript punters during the Christmas shopping period. Or even better planting a nail bomb in a major mall. Now that would main and kill hundreds. 
      Just think he’d become an instant celebrity, do a book deal and go on the lecture circuit talking about all those other low life underworld figures that the average dropkick sems to be mesmerised by. Now that’s unfortunate! 
      By the way where do you shop Bella?

    • Alison says:

      12:49pm | 12/05/10

      Paul, those are our options? Accountant sitting on the couch with popcorn watching the budget, or a spree shooter? Bleak.

    • mintxx says:

      12:55pm | 12/05/10

      post of the day. Thanks Paul! =)

    • Joan says:

      10:03am | 12/05/10

      The 2010 budget so boring and unsexy that Laurie Oakes on Channel 9 this morning had to drag out a Joe Hockey comment from past historical notes to spice it up. In the ordinary days of our ordinary lives this budget will be forgotten in next 24 hours. if noticed at all. Smart people those that watched Masterchef instead of budget. The only passion and fury to be felt by voters will come from the smokers with each pack of cigs they buy.

    • Elphaba says:

      10:24am | 12/05/10

      I don’t usually watch the budget because as a single, full-time worker who doesn’t own a house, I figured there wasn’t going to be anything in it for me anyway.

      I watched South Park (Comedy Channel) and filled out a job application. I must be the only person in Australia who didn’t watch Masterchef last year and I haven’t this year either. grin

    • Likewise says:

      12:46pm | 12/05/10

      Nope I’m in the same ship as you, I can’t stand Masterchef either so I spent the time that the Budget was on playing a couple of videogames.  I then got a 5 minute catchup of what’s in it for me (nothing) this morning.

      In the past I’ve tried to watch the Budget address, but honestly not even Megan Fox presenting the budget completely naked while Katy Perry and Miranda Kerr pash on the table in front of her, with male strippers in the background (for the female voters) would make the Budget any more interesting smile

    • Anon says:

      01:26pm | 12/05/10

      In our house, we didn’t watch a single episode of Masterchef in 2009 either (and we don’t intend to start this year!). 

      My husband is a fully qualified chef with 20 years experience and figures if you want to become a chef that badly, try enrolling in a TAFE course and slogging it out working nights and weekends as an Apprentice Chef!

    • Lindy says:

      02:00pm | 12/05/10

      I watched a DVD instead. Masterchef is drop dead boring as is motor sports & seeing grown men try to be hoons…......*tragic*  Anyhow we already know that the budget will blow up in labors face, just like everything else they do so why waste my time on listening to Swan drone on in his oversized suit & looking like a terrified animal caught in the headlights of a speeding road train!

    • Elphaba says:

      02:01pm | 12/05/10

      Hahaha, Likewise, nicely said.

      I might be forced to watch the budget if the Top Gear boys were presenting it… it would have to be screamingly funny though, and I think it’s a tall order, even for them.

      True, Anon.  It’s a TV show,  and not the search for the next greatest chef.  Besides, I already think I am a Masterchef… wink

    • Jenni says:

      10:34am | 12/05/10

      “Um… honey –I kinda just maxed out all our credit cards on Davo’s snake oil scheme and possibly sold our firstborn so, you know, it’s time we tightened our belts, wait for that money we’re getting when Uncle Harold dies, and have ourselves a little quality no-frills time together. Hey, at least we didn’t lose the house like our neighbours, eh? ”

      wow - I think that’s about the best description I’ve heard yet regarding Australia’s country financial situation LOL

      I must admit, I’m one of the apathetic many who pay very little attention to things like the budget. I don’t see how there’s a lot I can do about what’s in it, besides vote for a different bas***d next time who will offend me no less than this one, just perhaps in a different way. Labour/Liberal - is there even a difference any more in terms of idealogy and governing policy?

    • Spot On says:

      02:18pm | 12/05/10

      Jenni, I complete agree with you - I detest any government that gains power these days. So much for a democracy when they never listen to the public.

    • Lulu says:

      02:47pm | 12/05/10

      Yeah Jenni….I agree wholeheartedly.  The thing tha pisses me off is uncontrolled immigration. I just spent over two hours waiting to see a specialist at RMH. The waiting room was packed with immigrants, many of whom needed interpreters (paid for by tax payers!) I am 62 & have worked & paid taxes all my life. My Mum & Dad both worked & paid taxes as did their fathers. It was our hard work & taxes that built this country & we are now forced to wait in line while so-called refugees get all the freebies. If we couldn’t afford things we went without. There was no credit cards & only people with solid businesses were given housing loans….as long as they were male of course. A series of blinkered federal governments have let too many immigrants into the country without investing in infra-structure such as the schools & hospitals.  Rudd is doing nothing to stop the boat people who will to continue arrive here with no money & put further pressure on this crumbling infra-structure…...& yet they can afford to pay a people smuggler??  We have to make our government listen to us & put some controls on immigration until they can catch up on the infra-structure back-log. We working Australians & our parents paid for Australia to be built & are now being treated as if we deserve nothing.

    • An Idle Dad says:

      11:21am | 12/05/10

      I’m not worried about the budget - parties are pretty much aligned. Had the Coalition retained government last election their response to the GFC would have been almost identical to Labor’s. Don’t fool yourself that it wouldn’t have been.

      What Swan is doing now is exactly what both parties would be doing too - getting things back to normal as our economy heats up again.

      What matters to me is other policies, budget night has very little relevance to me. It is always, ALWAYS, crafted to appeal to voters, always focuses on handouts and spending more.

      What would get me to watch would be pre-budget leaks that a party was willing to actually fix the system: means-test benefits, sweeping changes to the tax code, a government actually asking us to DO something for our country. That would rock my socks. However that would involve a party willing to stand up for its values and fight a opposition with little more in the arsenal that sound-bites. But Labor isn’t that party.

      So I vote according to other policies. Labor will be last on my ballot paper. ETS, childcare, tax reform, education - they’ve failed to deliver on their promises and fought tooth and nail for the ones I’ve been against. In fact, the opposition simply needs to say something catchy and Rudd folds.

      Watch budget night? Pfffttt…  Bring on the election. And some good candidates (please?)

    • Comedian says:

      11:33am | 12/05/10

      I was playing Counter Strike online..

    • Alison says:

      12:50pm | 12/05/10

      I was taking Mr Swan’s advice and spending a few hours quality time with my family instead of watching either the budget or Masterchef!

    • Brett says:

      01:06pm | 12/05/10

      Is anybody really surprised at this revelation?  You only have to refer to the “most popular/read” stories at this on-line paper each day to get an idea of the intellect and interests and values of the average “aussie” these days.  Pathetic doesn’t even come close.

    • Miles says:

      01:51pm | 12/05/10

      And this is exactly why we end up with the pathetic governments that we do.  Sure, everybody will whinge and moan until the cows come home but when it comes for time for change (which involves actually being informed on what you’re voting on), Australians are SO apathetic.  For the most part, people wouldn’t have a clue what the implications of any given parties policies are.  All they see is $900 and away they go….  Sometimes I think we need an IQ test to be able to vote.

    • An Idle Dad says:

      03:05pm | 12/05/10

      I disagree. Sure, I’ve met Aussies who couldn’t give two .... for politics, but most people I know, either here on the Central Coast or back when I lived in the Eastern Suburbs care and talk about politics non-stop.

      As for being informed, the $900 was part of the stimulus package that everyone, except Liberal mouthpieces, believe saved Australia from going into negative growth last year. The Liberals would have done the same thing if they’d been in power (the same public servants would have developed the plan).

      I’m no Ruddbott fan, but just saying. And I support your right to vote.

    • Megan says:

      01:59pm | 12/05/10

      Not really a comment on the theme, but more on Jayne’s use of English…. I’m not sure I would describe sickness and injury as ‘a mainstay’ of family life. I thought mainstay was used to describe something that is supportive? Sorry, I’m being a bit picky, I know….

    • Jayne Kearney says:

      09:18pm | 12/05/10

      lol - it was late. My child was vomiting on my slippers, but good call. grin
      Jayne

    • Luke says:

      02:24pm | 12/05/10

      Well this shows that Cooking is more important then Watching How the Government is stuffing up your hardearned money and taking more out of your pockets. If you are more interested in watching cooking Then you have no right to complain when you have less pay

    • hs says:

      03:00pm | 12/05/10

      I spent the evening updating the firmware and reflashing my modem; I’d rather pull my intestines out and strangle myself with them than watch the odious boring smug Wayne Swan, purlease, all most politicians do is spin platitudes and acknowledge the sycophantic nods from the carefully placed stooges behind them. I did however watch Kerry interviewing him and the equally annoying Hockey afterwards, in the hope that he would ask both idiots a particularly hairy question…take your time, hehe. Oh Peter, Peter, why don’t you please please come back? All is forgiven.

    • Fred Bloggs says:

      07:44pm | 12/05/10

      I’d prefer to watch something constructive and interesting, rather than a wannabe treasurer spruiking horsefeathers

    • Barry says:

      09:09pm | 12/05/10

      Yes Jayne. The Chaser used to have a segment that profiled people like you - “This Person Votes.”

    • jim says:

      01:31am | 13/05/10

      We all watched Master Chef because of one reason.

      1. Whats the point of watching the HAS BEENs?

      They’ll lose the next election, why waste time listening to them. Not going to put a cent more on that stupid Conroy filter

    • Neil Prasad says:

      08:24am | 13/05/10

      I am surprised at the tunnel vision some of us Australians have when it comes to things like budgets and are only supporting it if we’re getting tax cuts or cash in hand. We often tend to miss the big picture. For example, investing in apprenticeship programs for our locals is million times better than having to get them from overseas, some of whom don’t understand basic English. How about training more nurses so that the wait time at the public hospitals is shortened? I’d rather support these two things than get a meagre $500 in tax cuts.

      Budget is about how the government allocates money for the forthcoming financial years and any responsible government should at least consider health, education and infrastructure development as its key priority. Health sector reforms were severely ignored for the past 15 years. Education standards are lagging – thus the need for mass skilled migration (something we often complain about). Take a close hard look at the budget to see how it can address problems, not only in the coming year, but in many years to come.

      I am not a supporter of most things this government has done, but given the financial ruins the whole world is coming out of, I feel they have acted very well – for a new government from a party which has been sitting in the Opposition for 12 years.

      National budget is not a soap opera, its a reality!

    • Fed Up says:

      09:00am | 13/05/10

      The devil is in the detail. Forget the spin show of a budget presentation and wait for the chance to read all the other bits!
      What you all need to watch are reruns of “Yes Prime Minister”. It may be over 30 years old and billed as comedy but its still very close to the truth!!!
      No I did not watch it nor did I watch masterchef!

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @newscomauHQ: Hazel Hawke, the former wife of Bob Hawke, has died surrounded by her family | http://t.co/wSl6QrnOtU

Daniel Piotrowski

@_Tors @pollietracker you tell your newspaper to behave Tors

Daniel Piotrowski

"@newscomauHQ: Hazel Hawke, the former wife of Bob Hawke, has died surrounded by her family | http://t.co/JdRfQUB1lZ"

Daniel Piotrowski

@ClaireRPorter get out

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter