On school visits, Benji Marshall has a fun and disarming way of introducing himself. He says “my name is Benjamin Quentin Marshall” as the kids look on with bemusement. Marshall will no doubt introduce himself with similar formality, minus the cheeky grin, when he fronts court on assault charges on April 20. But regardless of what happens that day, I’d still invite him to my kids’ school.

Benjamin Quentin Marshall. Pic: Getty Images

Marshall, who launched the 2011 NRL season last week, was allegedly racially taunted in the most vulgar possible way on Saturday night. This, after he’d MC’d a charity function for the Children’s Cancer Institute which raised $244,000, then stayed out in town for a few drinks, and a fateful 3am burger, which all made sense as he had a room booked in town.

Obviously, The Punch wasn’t there. But let me say this: in five years at Australia’s biggest sporting magazine Alpha, I met numerous topline footballers in all codes. And Benji Marshall was right at the top of the list of the players who struck me as intelligent, wholesome, and thoroughly unlikely to turn feral without the severest provocation.

A disclosure: I am a fan of Marshall’s NRL club, the Wests Tigers. But it wouldn’t matter if I hated the Tigers as much as I hate cowards who taunt people with racial epithets. Because in my opinion, Marshall is not just officially the world’s best rugby league player, he’s the game’s best bloke too.

Rugby league, plagued as it is by serial idiots, needs figures like Benji. His life story is the classic rise from Struggletown to fame which rugby league prides itself on. That, as much as his success, is why the NRL picked him for the season launch.

Brought up by his mother Lydia, who was 15 when she had Benji, the young kid would play football in Whakatane, NZ, with a large group of uncles and cousins who served jointly as father figures but showed him absolutely no mercy whatsoever on the football field. In this tough school, he learned toughness and resolve. He also learned to dance around big dudes with the trademark snappy footwork that would go on to revolutionise the NRL.

If you’re an AFL follower who’s never watched league, or entertained the thought it might be entertaining, click this link from 2005. Or this supremely famous and decisive moment from the 2005 Grand final. Now try this cracker from 2009. Or this, to the Penbo/Ant corner of Leichhardt. Yes, even the editor-in-chief of this website David Penberthy, an avowed Adelaide Crows fan, has travelled to worship at the altar of Benji.

None of which, I say again, is to prejudge Marshall for what happened on Saturday night. But it’s to paint a picture of man who plays the game of football as cleanly and exuberantly as I believe he plays the game of life. A man whom I believe would only lash out under extreme circumstances.

Twice before, in 2006 and then in 2008, Marshall was involved in incidents in Sydney nightclubs. Both times, the strong suggestion is that he was “baited”. Again, details are lacking from the nights in question, but in general, the formula can be simple enough.

Deliberately spill a footy player’s drink, or spill your own and accuse the player of having done it, shove a little, push a little, and see what happens. Who knows? The player may bite, and whammo! You’ve got incriminating camera phone footage you can sell.

On those occasions, Marshall did his best to get out of harm’s way. But whatever happened on Saturday night seemingly pushed him to do the opposite

Like all people, Marshall has a breaking point. Funnily enough, I saw it early last year at the media conference when he announced his long term deal to stay with the Tigers until 2015.

A young female reporter asked Benji if he thought he a five year deal was a risk for the club given his recurring injury problems. Marshall had indeed had numerous shoulder operations back in 2006 and ’07. But he’d been on the paddock for almost the entirety of the previous two seasons (and would go on to play every match in 2010), and the question visibly angered him. He didn’t lash out verbally, but clearly, he’d reached the end of his patience.

People who live almost their entire lives in the spotlight have a right to reach the point where they switch off the charm. Whether they have the right to start swinging is, as mentioned several times, a matter for the judicial system.

As this story goes to print, the Tigers are submitting a report to the NRL on this weekend’s incident. At the very least, you’d hope the game’s ruling body clears him to play his club’s first game this Monday night. After all, the bloke who’s just recorded his 3rd DUI has got the green light.

91 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Sam says:

      12:43pm | 07/03/11

      I don’t follow the NRL and have no idea who Benji is, but seriously you can’t punch someone for calling you a name.
      The racial taunt maybe be the reason he hit someone, but it is no excuse.

    • Super D says:

      01:36pm | 07/03/11

      I just reckon Benji Marshall is incredibly unlucky to be famous.  In the early hours of the morning on George St in Sydney you can normally biff someone with absolutely no fear of ever being charged or called to account for your action in any way.

    • charlie says:

      01:51pm | 07/03/11

      Easy solution…. Make Alan Tongue the face of rugby league

    • cleaver says:

      02:05pm | 07/03/11

      I second that Super D

    • frilly says:

      02:21pm | 07/03/11

      totally fully agree

    • SM says:

      12:44pm | 07/03/11

      The racial slur part (as originally spruiked by Benji’s manager) has been denied

      Regarding Benji’s 2 previous incidents involving late night pubs and violent encounters with members of the public, Anthony, as a Tigers fan, paints Benji as the victim

      On this occasion, Benji will really want to hope they can make the racial slur claim stick

    • Mark says:

      03:25pm | 07/03/11

      Do you really think Benji would have punched someone for saying Lockyer is better than him!? Benji has publicly stated he is in awe of Lockyer himself that before the All-Stars and Test matches.

      Both of those other ‘late night’ incidents Benji didn’t throw punches and it was proven he was setup.

      There is only 1 party that instigated all this and it’s not the bloke who raised 1/4mil for Kids with Cancer earlier in the evening.

    • Matt B says:

      03:48pm | 07/03/11

      “The racial slur part has been denied,”

      Has it SM? who would have thought?  If I was a faux-hawk sporting, Ed Hardy wearing box head destined to give evidence in court, I would confess my sins to the media and police in short order.

      “Sure officer. I called him a black c…., only because he flicked a pickle at me while I was playing chess on my IPhone,”

      What else would you expect? Besides, making false claims about racial slurs is almost as bad as making the slurs yourself. I doubt Benji would be crying wolf.

      I have no doubt some sports people are targeted by morons. It’s fair to say the sports stars are well aware of this and should limit any possible exposure to such people. Though surely they cannot be expected to stay home every night and play X-Box/ read Dickens

      The only reason a bloke getting a “scratch/cut on his face(didums)” after getting punched is in the public domain is due to the involvement of an NRL player.

      I’m not excusing any bad behaviour, just pointing out we view these incidents in isolation. If we had figures on how many drunks got belted for gobbing off over any given weekend across this country, we could likely publish a decent coffee table book (the pics would be great). Fair to say many of these events would have worse results, and milder penalties.

      When it comes down to it anyone can lose a bit of control on occasion, give the lad a break. It’s not like he threw his own poo or felt up a dog.

    • SM says:

      03:48pm | 07/03/11

      @Mark

      “Both of those other ‘late night’ incidents Benji didn’t throw punches and it was proven he was setup.”

      that’s incorrect

    • undertow says:

      04:37pm | 07/03/11

      “that’s incorrect”.

      Wow. A scathing, unassailable retort.

    • hot tub political machine says:

      12:49pm | 07/03/11

      “the formula can be simple enough.

      Deliberately spill a footy player’s drink, or spill your own and accuse the player of having done it, shove a little, push a little, and see what happens. Who knows? The player may bite, and whammo! You’ve got incriminating camera phone footage you can sell.”

      Ant, I have no doubt what your talking about happens, which leads me to following line of thinking. What the hell is a player doing in a bar/club late at night anyway? Yes its the drunken yobbo’s fault not the players, but sadly, you can guarantee the drunk trouble maker will be there. So why go?

      Also just to add some balance here is the opposite side of formula (first hand account from a friend of mine):

      Former Adelaide Crows player (now working in medialand) pushes in front of my friend at the bar. The dialouge then goes like this:

      My Friend: “Mate, what are you doing?”

      Crows player: “Do you know who I am?”

      Friend (doesn’t watch AFL): “No. Who are you?”

      Crows player: “I’m (says players name)”

      Friend: “So?”

      Situation got resolved non-violently but I would take any players advice that it was “unprovoked” with a pinch of salt, one side of the story right?

      FYI I’m not casting aspersions on Benji - I wouldn’t have a clue if he is a good guy or not - just saying you oughta recognise many players are responsible for their own troubles.

    • Wagga Magpie says:

      01:36pm | 07/03/11

      @ hot tub political machine says: 12:49pm | 07/03/11

      “What the hell is a player doing in a bar/club late at night anyway?”

      I’m so glad someone mentioned this. The moment that they apply Dencorub we know that rugby league players have distanced themselves from the rest of society. They have absolutely no right to be out after 12am; furthermore they shouldn’t be allowed to ride on public transport, visit the zoo, swim in the beach (I can’t stand being next to an athlete with my 75 kg frame) or be in a pub/club/bar unless they are in a designated VIP area.

      “you oughta recognise many players are responsible for their own troubles.”

      We do. We vilify them all the time. I can’t think of one person who has tried to defend Todd Carney recently. What about Anthony Watmough doing 30km+ speed limit recently? Who has defended that? Fortunately most of us have the ability to differentiate between being a tool on the grog (repeatedly), speeding excessively over the limit (and without your P-plates on) and being baited so often that you finally snap and give a drunken yobbo a “small facial laceration”.

    • Gregg says:

      01:44pm | 07/03/11

      @htpm,
      I think he was getting something to eat it has been reported.
      As to what Benji was doing out, did you read the article for Ant says he had been to some function, and in being booked into a city hotel has had some after function drinks and then felt a bit hungry.

      Haven’t you ever been out and had some hunger pangs in the wee hours!, the very reason the burger, pizza, cart de wheels and all the other joints will do a roaring trade in the early hours.

      Benji ain’t the biggest bloke and do you reckon there is no chance some yobbo may have been wanting a piece of him!

    • hot tub political machine says:

      01:53pm | 07/03/11

      Wagga Magpie,

      I don’t say they don’t have a right to be there, just that they can hardly be suprised if a yob decides they are the sport for the night.

      Arguably they have a right to more privacy too but (right or wrong) it just ain’t gonna happen. Its kinda like crossing the road on foot, you have right of way and people are suppossed to stop for you. But you take a risk someone will plow into you. So it is walking into a bar late at night if you are a recognisable sportsperson.

      Its a short career so why bet it on the reasonableness of drunks? Heck with their kinda money they could start a nice bar in their house.

    • Tim says:

      01:54pm | 07/03/11

      Wagga Magpie ,
      you also forgot that athletes are not under any circumstances allowed to have sex with willing women.
      Even if it is completely consensual, you must be virtue of who you are be an abuser/user/rapist/misogynist.

    • hot tub political machine says:

      01:55pm | 07/03/11

      Gregg,

      I wasn’t talking about Benji specifically. More about Ant’s general point that players get tapped up in bars. I could have been more clear about this though.

    • PTom says:

      02:13pm | 07/03/11

      @htpm. You might note that this occured after charitiy event that is claimed benji did not drink at, then had a few drinks and on his way home at Macdonalds is where the assault occured.

      I don’t care if sportsstar in a bar at 5am. It is not the time it is the amount.  Why do we have more volicene is simple when you have 3 blokes down a bottle of vodka on a train while planing to go out to drink buckets of beer in the city that was the 6pm train.

    • fairsfair says:

      12:49pm | 07/03/11

      Wow Ant. I think this is the first time I have ever not liked (not mostly agreed with) one of your articles. I see Benji as the new Andrew Johns - he is to be protected at all costs and not criticised. There is explanation for all his actions. 

      I don’t deny, these guys must have to deal with bozos a fair bit, but it is their job to not react. He should not have reacted, full stop.

      There is no denying - he is a good player, but it shouldn’t be all that matters. How is this matter less severe than Todd Carney’s minor DD? Both of these overpaid, over egoed clowns have done bad here. I am hanging for the NRLs decision following receipt of this report today. It will be interesting what they decide.

      Meanwhile… Brent Stewart, Benji Marshall - if the NRL approached you to “launch” the season you’d politely decline me thinks. Almost a jinx on your career.

    • Elphaba says:

      12:59pm | 07/03/11

      Hi5!

      No tolerance, as far as I’m concerned.  Stop fining and stop coddling them and just start firing them.

    • fairsfair says:

      01:39pm | 07/03/11

      I dunno if they should be fired, but they should be taken down a peg or two. We all make mistakes in life (though these are pretty big mistakes), my issue is the people that constantly run in to defend. I was in support of Todd Carney last week because the issue was his “response” to the issue. My issue this week is this response to the issue. It can’t be glossed over (Todd’s is not going to be) and it has to be dealt with.

      Apologies for the over use of the word issue!

      A poster below mentioned Jonathan Thurston. He is a tool of the highest order - constantly reported drunk in public and doing stoopid stuff around Townsville. The Cowboys have taken him down a couple of pegs. Last issue (a while ago now) he was threatened with losing his captaincy and when he does his next wrong (which I am sure is only a matter of time) I hope they follow through with it.

      I recognise that these people are here to play a game. Less god worshiping, lets realise they are people and that means that when they do bad things, they should be punished like normal people would be. Face it, if I got into a scrag fight on the weekend I wouldn’t think it right that I got fired for it, but I should be chatted. Time for real world consequences for real world actions.

      However this fails to address the fact that they are all repeat offenders - so clearly things are just not getting through to them. I do see that Nate is more in control of his bowels lately though, which can only be seen as a positive thing.

      Who knows WTF the answer is. Carney was fired, but some idiot hired him back again.

    • Ted says:

      01:47pm | 07/03/11

      Get your facts right, Andrew Johns, by his own admission had a drug problem, which in retrospect was known in league circles.
      Todd Carney a drinking problem, barred from the town he lived in, was over the limit, and the list goes on…. Brett Stewart, again was so drunk, he did not know where he was heading.
      Benji Marshall with his girlfriend and mates, had left a function to raise money for cancer sufferers, and by all accounts, was sober, and signing autographs for whoever approached him.
      Your comparisons are a joke, and stupid

    • Elphaba says:

      01:53pm | 07/03/11

      Maybe a one chance deal.

      “You f*cked up, we’re officially warning you, you’ll be fired if it happens again.”

      Then if they get hired by another team and f*ck up again, fire and deregister them.

      I don’t know what the answer is.  All I know is, my workplace wouldn’t put up with the kind of crap like what Thurston and Fevola do.  I definitely think the boards are too soft on them though.

    • Gregg says:

      01:54pm | 07/03/11

      Wow fairsfair, like all’s fair in love and war and you’re on the war path more than a bit
      ” I see Benji as the new Andrew Johns - he is to be protected at all costs and not criticised. “
      ” Both of these overpaid, over egoed clowns have done bad here. “

      And you get something right at least
      ” I don’t deny, these guys must have to deal with bozos a fair bit “

      As for not reacting, you’d reckon you’d have to be there to really know for like as in not reacting there’s push, push and more push even if all verbally and then Bam, it’s natural.

      All sporting organisations will look to use great players as representatives and even the likes of a Darren Lockyer can drop clangers like his Johnny Raper comment at a press conference when he may have even been the Oz Captain.
      Benji is going to get his criticism over this as he already is ain’t he!

      There’re always going to be some alike and those less alike.

    • TheRealDave says:

      02:05pm | 07/03/11

      @Elphaba

      So your workplace will fire anyone who gets involved in a dust-up outside a club at 3am on a Sunday morning?

      Yeah, I think you’re full of crap as well.

    • fairsfair says:

      02:21pm | 07/03/11

      I take that on board Ted and Gregg, but they are overpaid and they need to realise that with that they are required to be the “bigger man” in any and all situations. It is part and parcel of their chosen career, otherwise they are required to face music to the tune of this fallout.

      Ted, Johns did exactly what the “alleged victim” did to Greg Inglis last year and he was required to “apologise”. Carry on as normal. The man is the golden child, he always will be. Now he is not playing, someone else has to take his place. Articles like this one (and Ant is not alone in this - if I had a stomach of steel/head injury I would watch the Footy Show on Thursday -  they will be saying the same thing) just reitterate that he can’t be touched.

      My comparisons are not a joke and/or stupid. There is NO EXCUSE for violence and I think punching someone (and this is not the first time he has done it) is far worse than crapping in a hallway, doing something non-violent with a Labrador or a group of consenting adults having sex while on tour in NZ.

    • Ryan says:

      12:51pm | 07/03/11

      “allegedly racially taunted” but unfortunately no one can verify this racist claim that is usually spewed forth when caught doing something they shouldn’t.

      The man assaulted someone, there is no justification for this regardless, unless he was defending himself from attack which appears not to be the case.

      Just another football thug, no more, no less.

    • Bill says:

      01:16pm | 07/03/11

      The only people who have come foward with any information on the slur is Marshall and the guy he hit. How many people are going to admit to the police that they racial vilified someone? The fact is this guy got in Marshalls face and got what he deserved, then went crying to the police. Has it really come to a point when players aren’t even able to go out and have a drink without being harrassed?

      I think there is too much emphasis on the players personal lives these days. Look at other sports like the NBA, if you do something wrong you lose sponsorships and face the judicial system, if necessary, you don’t get stood down for games and it doesn’t have anything to do with your club unless it was directly related to a club event or something to do with the club. Footballers are people too, they have the right to live their lives.

    • Ryan says:

      01:30pm | 07/03/11

      @Bill: Assaulting someone is a crime in Australia, it is not justified under any circumstance unless you are defending yourself from physical attack.
      I am sure had there been racial vilification that the witnesses to the attack would have quickly offered up this as a reason. There were witnesses Bill.

      If Benji was being harassed then he should have taken the same course of action any responsible law abiding citizen should have taken which is to call the police.

      What we see here is the usual thuggish behavior we have become accustomed to from football players who usually get away with this sort of thing because they are treated like they are above the law.

    • Tony of Poorakistan says:

      01:30pm | 07/03/11

      Bill

      ‘‘Has it really come to a point when players aren’t even able to go out and have a drink without being harrassed?’’ 
       
      Yes. And what’s more the clubs should be telling them that. Most elite players are around for 5 to 7 years in AFL, for example, and they get paid big bikkies. Enough in fact to make it worthwhile to have a quiet beer at home instead. Or pay for minders.

    • Markus says:

      01:33pm | 07/03/11

      “The fact is…” so how come you haven’t come forward with this fact?

      And come on, you are seriously holding up professional sport in the USA as an example of how we should treat professional sportsmen?

    • Ted says:

      01:38pm | 07/03/11

      The overall incident report is that Benji and his girl friend and party, who had come from a fund raiser, for cancer sufferers, were sober, and well behaved.
      Don’t compare him to Brett Stewart, who by his own admission, did not know where he was staggering around, and urinating in public. You sound like another misinformed fool, Ryan!

    • Ryan says:

      02:12pm | 07/03/11

      @Ted: so Benji didn’t assault someone then? What am I misinformed about?

    • Ando says:

      03:15pm | 07/03/11

      Ryan,
      You say
      ‘What we see here is the usual thuggish behavior we have become accustomed to from football players who usually get away with this sort of thing because they are treated like they are above the law. ”

      In what universe do you live? Footballers pay a heavier price for these types of incicents than any other profession. If he is guilty he will be charged. However , the gutless cry baby only complained to the police because it was Benji Marshall and he knew there would be consequences. Why ?because hes a footballer.

    • Ryan says:

      03:59pm | 07/03/11

      @Ando: if this were indeed the case then there should be even less of a reason for this to happen in the first place.
      The person who was assaulted exercised his rights to report a crime, being accused of being “gutless” for doing so is in my opinion not correct, reporting a crime takes real guts.

    • rufus says:

      11:44am | 08/03/11

      @Ryan - guilty until proved innocent, it seems, is the way you think the law works.

      Have you ever heard of the saying ‘reserve judgement until enough facts are known’? Something you might like to contemplate.

    • Yokahontas says:

      01:27pm | 08/03/11

      Ted: you might want to get your facts straight and leave Brett Stewart out of it. Bandying around the ‘by his own admission’ cr@p doesn’t make it true - there was no such ‘admission’ and even in court the prosecution were told (by the judge) to drop the spurious claim that Brett Stewart was drunk - as there was not a shred of evidence that was the case. In fact CCTV footage indicated the opposite.

      I believe Benji Marshall is as entitled to the presumption of innocence as anyone else, but so is Brett Stewart and I sincerely hope he and Manly sue the pants off David Gallop for his continuing slander.

    • Hamish says:

      12:53pm | 07/03/11

      Peter Costello would have a field day with this article. Are you a journo or a groupie? I’m an AFL fan but follow league a little and Benji Marshall is the only player in the NRL who has really any skill whatsoever, but seriously mate, how many drunken stouches don’t involve provocation?

      We don’t know exactly what happened, but he gets paid enough to be above some drunk bogan hurling racial abuse. Maybe next time some a-hole says something I don’t like I’ll just punch him in the face. It would be interesting to see how many journos jump to my defence.

    • Tiger in Twba says:

      01:48pm | 07/03/11

      “but he gets paid enough to be above some drunk bogan hurling racial abuse”
      The fact he is well compensated for his commensurate skill on the park has little to do with having to put up with racial or non-racial taunts from the general public. Yes he lives in the public eye more than most of us do and I agree it comes with certain obligations however sometimes enough is enough.

    • Hamish says:

      02:16pm | 07/03/11

      Tiger, if it was okay to punch someone when they provoke you, then no one in Australia would be in jail for assault. If it’s good enough for me, it’s good enough for him. It’s not just sportsmen who get provoked when they’re out on the piss you know.

    • AdamC says:

      02:51pm | 07/03/11

      “...  sometimes enough is enough.”

      What does that mean, Tiger? That it’s OK to smack someone in the mouth becuase they say something you don’t like? That seems like a pretty ordinary attitude.

      Hamish, to me the point is not so much that Benji Marshall is paid lots or is a celebrity and therefore has special obligations. It is that we all have an obligation not to assault other people, even when they are being douchebags. That is why Marshall has been charged with a criminal offence and should be tried and (if convicted) punished.

      Having said that, it is a pity when fawning sports ‘journalists’ like our author (and Sharwood is a serial offender in this respect) set their keyboards to gush, giving startstruck character references for their idols and excusing away their behaviour.

    • Greggo says:

      04:27pm | 07/03/11

      AdamC - Spot on mate!

    • RT says:

      12:54pm | 07/03/11

      I believe most players are unable to handle excessive consumption of alcohol yet they still go ahead and think it is how to enjoy yourself. I think his racial slur story was cooked up. He was drunk and was not in his senses because of excessive consumption and couldn’t bear the fact that some other player was regarded as better than him. He deserves a suspension but the NRL boss and Wests Tigers CEO do not have the courage to do that.

    • Andrew says:

      01:22pm | 07/03/11

      From the numerous accounts from the 40 or so eye witnesses, Marshal was not drunk. In fact he was walking back to his hotel with his girl friend and was signing autographs and taking photos with numerous fans, who all claimed that he was approachable and friendly. He had just spent the evening speaking at a gala, that raised over a quarter of a million dollars for cancer victims, a topic that is close to his heart after losing his father to cancer. There are plenty of boof heads, thugs and idiots that also happen to be professional athletes but Benji is not one of them. This was not a vicious attack, it was a one punch retort to numerous and vile slurs on an emotionally charged evening. I actually respect the bloke more now.

    • Gregg says:

      02:15pm | 07/03/11

      @Andrew,
      I could well understand that being the situation and hope it was less having cockheads about anyway.
      Perhaps there are times when sporting organisations do need to have a minder squad about and having had a top player at an event, having a minder in the background until he was back in his hotel for the night would seem to be a reasonable thing.
      Do hope all those witnesses can be rounded up and I agree that Benji has never come across as other than a good guy and should be more like him in sport.

    • Terry says:

      12:55pm | 07/03/11

      I think the word “allegedly” needs more emphasis. What’s the best way to excuse an episode of violence? Cry you’re a victim of racism.

    • rufus says:

      11:48am | 08/03/11

      The whole matter is the subject of allegations (a charge is only an allegation), Terry. Nothing is proven, yet.  It’s for the court to find the facts, and I don’t mean the court of public and media opinion.

    • DocBud says:

      12:55pm | 07/03/11

      Why not wait for the outcome of the court case?

    • Tim says:

      01:13pm | 07/03/11

      Pffft we’ll have none of that kind of behaviour here.
      It’s sensationalise and scandalise as much as possible as soon as there’s even a hint that someone high profile may have done something wrong.
      Then if it’s shown there’s no case to answer, we might print a retraction months later somewhere where no one will read it.

    • Gregg says:

      01:01pm | 07/03/11

      Yes Ant, with a second name of Quentin you would expect a guy to have dancing feet but even with confirmed AFL fans I’d reckon there’d not be too many that would not know of Benji and a fine sportsperson he has always been.
      I myself follow predominantly AFL but having lived sometime in NSW and now Queensland an interest in League and rugby of the Union type has also developed and I recall it was probably not long after Benji’s name came to notice that he suffered with his shoulders and I thought then, smaller bloke and bigger guys always willing to target weaker points, he is going to do it tough.

      Well just like the Jonathon Thurstons, Darren Lockyers, King Wally and many others, as the old saying goes, when the going gets tough, the tough keep going and Benji as you say is up there with the best of them.

      It is easy enough to appreciate what the situation could have been and hopefully there will be some witnesses to the taunting, goading or whatever and by the sounds of things it was not much more than a jab on the beak above the mouth.
      To Benji’s credit he has not shied away from the event and I think it may have even been reported he went to the police himself the following morning.

      So lets hope he does get a fair hearing and a jab on the beak of a mouth seems a fitting enough response.

    • Justin says:

      01:06pm | 07/03/11

      There’s that spin machine you mentioned last week in action.

      No doubt his manager would have been dying for a puff piece about all the charity good Benji does, and here it is.

      We don’t bring up previous offences during a trial for a reason - the person must be judged for their specific actions at the specific time. That should go both ways.

      Bold prediction: Danny Weidler will be spruiking a story on the alleged victim’s background by the end of the week.

    • Seano says:

      01:51pm | 07/03/11

      He was hosting a charity function that raised nearly a quarter of a million dollars. Where’s the spin?

    • Justin says:

      02:05pm | 07/03/11

      He wasn’t hosting a charity function at Maccas at 3 in the morning. Allegedly.

    • Seano says:

      03:44pm | 07/03/11

      He was staying at the hotel, he had a couple of drinks with friends nearby after the function and as many people after a night out do, stopped for a snack on the way back to his room. As I said where’s the spin?

    • Shane says:

      10:48am | 08/03/11

      Seano - the “spin” is that helping to raise 250K for cancer sufferers some how excuses Marshall’s behaviour of punching someone.

      I assume you’re trying to stir? If not, you’re rather dense.

    • Seano says:

      09:53am | 09/03/11

      Shane - the “fact” is Benji was in the area after hosting an event that raised a quarter of a million dollars. This was no spin.

      The bloke should be allowed to walk the streets without being racially abused. Whilst I accept that violence is usually not the answer eveyone has a breaking point and being told that you’re less because of your skin colour would be the breaking point for many people.

    • bigmuzz says:

      01:20pm | 07/03/11

      compared to recent AFL scandals, the NRL benji marshall incident is nothing. so he gave some absolute tosser a love tap, who cares? complete media blowup!

    • Ryan says:

      01:34pm | 07/03/11

      @bigmuzz: the law cares, the one that EVERYONE is behold unto. Go do that to a cop and see where you end up.

    • Surely says:

      03:34pm | 07/03/11

      Ryan,
      And the law will sort it out, but you want more becuase you dont like footballers.
      Regardless of the law that doesnt mean Bigmuzz is wrong when he suggests that some people deserve a punch in the head. If I was mouthing off and got puched I wouldnt go to the police.
      By the way, what did this imaginary cop do to Bigmuzz?

    • Ryan says:

      09:04am | 08/03/11

      @Surely: incorrect, I have a lot of time for footballers, I have no time for criminals who break the law.

    • bigmuzz says:

      02:14pm | 10/03/11

      well obviously you’ve not spent much time out on a friday or saturday night…. see this kinda thing every weekend at pubs and clubs. no-one gets arrested for it, its only cos he is famous that this guy went to the cops.

      and no, i have never been in a drunken punch up. but i have helped break a few of them. and who would be stupid enough to punch a cop?!?!

    • Horthy says:

      01:38pm | 07/03/11

      Forgive me, but I don’t get why you specified the age and gender of the reporter. Has something gone over my head, or are you just padding there?

    • Seano says:

      01:47pm | 07/03/11

      You know what, a guy like Benji doesn’t punch some idiot for the sake of it no matter what. What was said must have been pretty serious to provoke this sort of reaction.

      Even though I normally don’t support people solving their problems with their fists, in this cause I’ll make an exception. Because I for one am sick of beligerent racists getting away this shit because no one wants any trouble. Good on Benji, the bloke got what he deserved and then proved what a weak prick he is by running to the police afterwards. Someone has to stand up to these arseholes.

      BTW. I don’t support the Tigers at all.

    • Gregg says:

      01:59pm | 07/03/11

      Crikey Seano, I didn’t know Labor has him lined up for a seat in parliament either!
      But I’ll at least agree on giving Benji a chance as you can see from other posts.
      Then again, maybe our other ring dancer Tony might take a shine to him and vice versa.

    • Seano says:

      03:42pm | 07/03/11

      “Crikey Seano, I didn’t know Labor has him lined up for a seat in parliament either!”

      There are plenty of dumb right wing ranters posting dumb comments like this Gregg, surely the quota is full.

      “But I’ll at least agree on giving Benji a chance as you can see from other posts.”

      A clock is right twice a day.

      “Then again, maybe our other ring dancer Tony might take a shine to him and vice versa. “

      Oh please, I know you ranters like to fantasise about “action” Tony but he wouldn’t last two minutes with Benji.

    • Seano says:

      03:42pm | 07/03/11

      *stopped clock

    • Richard says:

      01:57pm | 07/03/11

      Toddy Carney getting busted for driving “drunk” the morning after a night of drinking is more indicative of how stupid the drink driving laws are in Australia rather than any faux pas on behalf of the player.

      As for Benji Marshall, a football player shouldn’t be tut-tutted for getting into a fight regardless of extenuating circumstances. Violence is not a great evil, it is a part of human nature. Famous sportsmen DO get provoked by idiot yobbos, all the time, and I don’t judge the player for punching the lights out of a boozed up clown who acted without respect and propriety.

      We can’t let our culture get too soft and namby pamby. Yes, one punch can kill. So can a tea spoon of water. So can a french kiss. But there are certain principles which everyone has the right to stand up for in themselves, and one of those is respect. If you drunkenly disrespect a football player just because he happens to be famous (and you happen to be a dickhead), you deserve to get a clobbering.

    • Pete #205 says:

      03:02pm | 07/03/11

      You are so right Richard.  I guess I’ll see you out on the road while I’m driving the last of the V8 interceptors….  Pull. Your. Head. In.

      And to suggest theres a problem with drink driving laws because a probable alcoholic was above the normal legal limit, let alone the zero limit on his licence, the morning after a night out…  Congrats Richard.  You win this week’s “one tough mofo” award.  Clap clap clap for you.

    • richo says:

      01:58pm | 07/03/11

      So three times he’s been ‘baited’ into assaulting people, that’s not a bad record, it almost sounds like he can’t control himself. I don’t know why Ant mentions how good he is at Rugby League, it has nothing to do with the story. Also it didn’t need to be mentioned that he goes to kids schools and acts great with the little ones, as we’ve seen with AFL players they’re contract states they have to visit a certain amount of schools and do a set amount of hours to do with ‘community work’, the fact he puts on a smile whilst he does it is probably more to do with the fact that he can’t tell the kids how he really feels.

      I’ve been abused, spat at and tormented and every time have walked away laughing at the jokers who have said it, if his ego can’t handle a bit of abuse then too bad, this is Australia getting abused is part of life. If he was such a great role model and so intelligent he would have done the right thing, walked away with his head held high, because he didn’t he now has to live with the consequences. We all know he won’t be fired, I can’t think of anyone in League who has been.

    • Ando says:

      03:40pm | 07/03/11

      Can you provide a list of people who have been fired for this type of behavior, anywhere? or is it just league you have an issue with.

    • richo says:

      04:19pm | 07/03/11

      Ando, I didn’t ask for him to be fired, there have been suggestions in the media about his punishment, some wondering would he be stood down. I am just stating that he won’t be fired, nor should he be in my opinion.

      Although some people involved in the game should have (over the years) been let go, I was trying to suggest that if they haven’t fired players for massive indiscretions in the past, Benji has nothing to worry about now.

      I don’t have an issue with league, but you clearly have a issue with people that you think have a issue with league. My main issue is with his record of assaulting people, nothing to do with league, everything to do with Benji.

    • Moiby says:

      01:58pm | 07/03/11

      There is not a doubt in my mind that he would have been goaded.  A dear friend has a famous brother who regularly puts up with all sorts of insults and crap from tough-talking dickheads whenever he goes to a pub or club.  He knows they are out to sue him if he responds with a punch so tries his best to ignore them.  Fortunately he is white so doesn’t have to face racism as part of it.  I can see that something like that could push even a patient fellow over the edge.

      As for all the other incidents in the NRL - I have commented elsewhere on the despicable way that some NRL players have treated women, and escaped punishment.  If Marshall is punished for an incident like this, it will underscore the mysogyny of the NRL administration.

      With regard to comparisons with drink driving - there is no comparison.  A drunk driver is handling a large machine capable of immense damage and death.  A punch in the face to a bigot is nowhere near the same.

    • DA says:

      02:08pm | 07/03/11

      so if the guy he punched had fallen backwards cracked his head on the concrete and died is it still ok because he says he was racially abused (yet to proven) to me he has admitted guilt and should get whatever sentence comes his way, as we are always told one punch can kill

    • Mark says:

      03:59pm | 07/03/11

      The can, but this was a split lip so there was obvious restraint. Could have even just slapped him?

      Usually fact is better than ‘what-if’s for an argument DA.

    • Michael Larkin says:

      02:47pm | 07/03/11

      I tend to agree with what Gerard Whateley said on ABCs Offsiders. That although it may not be Marshalls fault, when are these guys going to realise that nothing good really can come of being out that late.

    • Tall Poppy says:

      03:40pm | 07/03/11

      I reckon Benji Marshall is one of the nice guys of league, he’s never put a foot wrong and up until now has stayed away from controversy.
      The problem is that when guys get drunk, they think they are tough - so why not pick on a league star ?  Yes perhaps Benji should have walked away, but the dickhead must of really goaded him.  Benji star or not would have done what any other guy would have done…when faced with a smartarse.

      GO THE TIGES IN 2011

    • rufus says:

      11:40am | 08/03/11

      Yes, GO THE TIGES and go, Benji.

      That said, sometimes good people do stupid things. Maybe that’s what happened here, maybe not.

      None of us know what happened, so perhaps we should all leave it to the court and not comment.

    • Bondi Billy says:

      03:42pm | 07/03/11

      Woah (the game’s best bloke ) has been involved with 2 other violent altercations?

      I dont know about you but it sound like he has a drinking and anger management problem

      The occasion in which he was anger by the female reporter and he didnt react. I reckon that because he couldnt, last time I check quick witted isnt generally two words you put together with league players or leaguies. May dim witted and quick to anger.

      Regardless you cant go around punching people because they had a pop at you. If this guy who had a crack at Benji is an idiot Benji is even worse.

    • Jeg says:

      04:10pm | 07/03/11

      Please allow management control to take over sports and throw the first kick, that is if their “Patience” know right from left of course.

    • david says:

      03:55pm | 07/03/11

      Love is blind…

    • PabloD says:

      04:03pm | 07/03/11

      I suspect most of the “it is against the law to punch” people above would also rail against the nanny state, and lack of personal responsibility.

      Benji probably massively regrets loosing his cool, but equally Benji made this person accountable for his actions.

      If I aggressively taunted someone (racially or not) I would fully expect that person to retaliate physically. One flows from the other doesn’t it?  Ergo I don’t taunt people unless I want a fight.  Ergo.  I don’t taunt people.

      Anyway…Worst case: Benji gets a conviction for assault, so what?  He can tell his kids he regrets what he did but that that he defended his, or his girlfriends honour against a lesser man.  But if it does go to court, we will all also get to see the identity of this guy..

      The result will be Benji being known as someone who stood up for himself, if not a little rashly.  This dickhead will be forever known as the drunken racist tool that he is.

      Perhaps if you are so confident that most people would not react in the same way, go and tell some bouncers in the Cross of the inadequacies of their heritage and see if they go and to the police station to fill a form in, or if they just fill your face in…

    • anton says:

      04:38pm | 07/03/11

      how weak is the guy who’s gone to the police…seriously!  cop it sweet, you’re not hurt.  you mouth off, sometimes you cop one.  you say nothing you generally don’t.  i don’t think you were kicked while down or ganged up on.  just wanting your 5 mins in the press.  don’t be so weak, withdraw the charge and take it as a lesson learned.  Benji will be disciplined most likely so you’ve got what you wanted…..let it GO!

    • DocBud says:

      05:19pm | 07/03/11

      Just as you don’t know if the person was kicked while down or ganged up on, you equally don’t know who was mouthing off to whom or what the circumstances were. So let’s wait and see what evidence comes out in court and then we can all sit in judgement from a position of knowledge rather than of speculation and bias.

    • Daniel says:

      05:33pm | 07/03/11

      Asotasi was right you dont need to bash people about you have to be bigger and walk away or you will become a human headline like what has just happened.

    • Gary says:

      06:12pm | 07/03/11

      So a 26 yo man has a gutful of some yobbo allegedly mouthing off at him so he smacks him in the mouth.This is a serious story,like any assault ,and it seems to be happenning with more frequency,sadly for our society.It raises a lot of questions,such as how easy/difficult it is to walk away when you are being provoked or should an elite athlete be out at 3.00am one week before the start of a very tough football season.While this story has been front page news in all the nsw papers,lead story on tv, radio news and talkback,it raises one other issue.If you look through the news about Benji Marshall and that drug taking dingbat with the pornstar girlfriend in the US, you may find a couple of small articles about a 65 yo woman in Ashfield who was bashed while putting groceries in her car and a 5 month old baby being allegedly bashed by a 22 yo ‘‘man’’ in Ipswich.Its a shame we dont have the same passion about stories such as these,but theyre not famous so…......who cares?

    • society is to blame says:

      08:09pm | 07/03/11

      The News Rugby League spin machine is in action again I see. Poor guy, how could we so heartless and unsympathetic towards his thuggery? Shame on us.

    • rufus says:

      11:50am | 08/03/11

      Another one-man court system. You’ve heard all the evidence, then, and spoken to witnesses….? Didn’ty think so.

    • Jim says:

      08:19pm | 07/03/11

      Brett Stewart - great bloke. Did heaps to bring attention to diabetes, did heaps for the childrens hospitals, was the face of rugby league.

      He copped a 4-week ban for being drunk - this, despite the police saying he was NOT drunk, and him being a diabetic kind of limiting how much alcohol he can consume. He was dragged through the mud by a stupid young girl and her greedy, criminal father for 2 years. Ultimately proven innocent, but no apology from Gallop, no rescinding of the $100,000 fine imposed on the club either.

      September last year - Tigers halfback Robert Lui beats up his partner, no punishment.

      October last year, the Australian captain, Thurston, gets locked up for being drunk and disorderly - no punishment.

      February this year - the DallyM player of the year Todd Carney gets done DUI. Just a slap on the wrist.

      All three players are repeat offenders - and from my time in Townsville you can be assured that if Thurston wasn’t in a one-team town (and therefore protected) he’d be grabbing bad headlines every week!

      Now Benji does this…not only 4 days after the launch of the NRL season, but weeks also after Gallop proclaimed him as his favourite player. He, like the three above, will face little if any punishment.

      All the while Brett Stewart would be sitting there thinking WTF?!

      If Gallop is going to be so inconsistant, and so soft on certain players, then the very least he could do is to publicly apologise to Stewart and Manly.

    • bozos cement truck says:

      10:27am | 24/08/11

      Stewart is a grub pure and simple. Plays for Manly, a grub, doesnt deserve justice and his eyes are too close together as well. Deserved whatever he got and more.

    • Jay says:

      09:47pm | 07/03/11

      I think this article and others like it that have appeared in the media today illustrate one of the reasons why these men get into legal trouble time and time again. They’re never held accountable. It’s always someone elses fault and there’s always an army of mates in the media, the footy ‘boys club’ and amongst supporters that come running to back them up. These men are grown adults. They shouldn’t be treated like spoilt children whose parents think they can do no wrong. Maybe he’s a great guy. So what? He allegedly committed a violent crime which can result in serious injury or death. Backing up your mates means holding them to account when they stuff up. That’s what being a man is all about. Not smashing someone’s skull in because they called you a name. These men get paid large sums of money for the privilege of playing football. They must understand that occasional negative attention comes with the territory and be prepared for that? You’d think highly disciplined athletes would be able to exercise self control. You’d think they’d get it by now that as public figures who are role models to thousands of kids around the country, they should maintain a decent standard of behaviour. Apparently not. I think it’s time to stop making excuses for these men and let them face the consequences of their actions for once. They might learn something.

    • DJ says:

      01:27am | 08/03/11

      Look, this sort of stuff has been happening ever since I can remember. Footy players are targets for alcohol fuelled idiots wherever they go and unfortunately it goes with the job. What they (the players) must do is minimise their exposure by avoiding hot spots and remember that nothing good ever happens after 2 :00am at these places. The NRL must also show consistency in dealing with incidents and they simply havent.

    • Marc says:

      12:00pm | 11/03/11

      I was following this article pretty well, and it all seemed pretty straight forward up to the third last paragraph.
      I’m not sure why it’s relevant that the reporter you refer to in the article was a ‘young female’. But the question she put to Benji actually sounded pretty valid. And if that fairly innocuous question visibly angered him and made him lose patience, that is a worry to me. So maybe he didn’t lash out that time, big deal.
      And nicely said, Jay. I happen to agree.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

@christoforpaine @mcilveenl Queensland has 2000km of useless coastline with no beaches, plus no ski season. And a silly name. That is all.

tory_maguire

Because she's a prostitute? @dobellthommo: "To buy a story from a prostitute is chequebook journalism at its worst."

ToryShepherd

What about Weet-Bix? “@Slate: How to make pork-infused veggies: http://t.co/ZYOOxVVT

Lucy Kippist

@christoforpaine sorry! Actually thought I already was... Weird?

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Animal experiments won’t cure me from cancer

Animal experiments won’t cure me from cancer

Lying on a cold table in an unfamiliar place and undergoing a core biopsy was probably one of the most…

If you want to get promoted, laugh at the boss’s jokes

If you want to get promoted, laugh at the boss’s jokes

Red alert, ladies. Making jokes about your ability at work is not funny particularly at board level.…

Need someone to do your dirty work? Try God.

Need someone to do your dirty work? Try God.

Punishing the baddies is only fun in the movies. In real life it’s messy, expensive, and fraught…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

242 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter