Today marks the hundredth anniversary of International Women’s Day.  It is an occasion to celebrate the achievements of women, to reflect on how far women have progressed on the journey towards equality in the last century, but also to recognise that significant challenges remain, here and abroad. 

Compared to FGM, corporate representation is a first-world problem. Pic: AP

The theme of this year’s International Women’s Day is “Female Leadership and Political Participation” and, on this score, Australia has much to celebrate.  One hundred years ago, we were one of only three countries in the world that could boast women’s suffrage.

The significance of this achievement is evident when one reflects that Kuwait’s Parliament extended suffrage to women in 2005 and only then by a 35-23 vote, and in Saudi Arabia women are still deprived of voting rights. 

In recent times, Australia has grown accustomed to female political leaders. We’ve had a female Governor General, and several female Premiers and State Governors. 

We now have a female Prime Minister - a milestone which brought to my mind the following remark by Oona King, a former British Labour MP, who famously said of Margaret Thatcher “I didn’t care if Thatcher was the devil; it meant so much to me that I was growing up when two women – she and the Queen – were running the country.”

Australians should be proud of these achievements, but we must also recognise that there remain challenges to overcome.  The incidence of violence against women and girls is all too common, with almost one in three Australian women experiencing some form of violence in their lifetime.  I was heartened to see that the National Plan of Action for Violence Against Women was formally adopted at the most recent COAG meeting after nearly two years since its initial announcement and it is my sincere hope that it will have a significant impact. 

Nevertheless, I am struck by how fortunate we are in Australia in so many other ways.  The debates that have dominated the “women’s” agenda in recent times in Australia have centred on female representation on corporate boards and the appropriateness of quotas, on the gender pay gap, sexual harassment in the workplace or the specific design of a statutory paid parental leave scheme.  While none of these issues is trivial, the concerns of women in many quarters of the world are so much graver. 

In China, it is estimated that 39,000 baby girls die annually because parents do not accord them the same medical care and attention that boys receive. According to The New York Times a “bride burning” takes place approximately once every two hours in India.  In the West African country of Niger a woman has a one in seven chance of dying in childbirth.  In the United Arab Emirates, the Gulf News reports that husbands have a state sanctioned right to beat their wives in order to discipline them – “provided that the beating is not so severe as to damage her bones or deform her body.” 

In Saudi Arabia, women cannot vote, drive, or show their faces or talk with male non-relatives in public.  Some Saudi girls are allowed to go to school and attend university, but when they do they must sit in segregated rooms and watch their teachers on closed-circuit televisions.  In the remaining Taliban strongholds of Afghanistan, women are still forced into marriages and denied a basic education.  There have been reports of little girls poisoned to death for daring to go to school.

The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan reports that every day in that country two women are slain by male relatives seeking to avenge the family honour.  So-called honour killings and forced marriages remain a distressingly common feature in many countries – even for some citizens of Western countries.

In the Asia-Pacific region, UN Women (the re-constituted UNIFEM) reports that there are countries that record some of the most horrendous statistics of violence against women in the world. For example in Papua New Guinea:

  • 44 per cent of women have experienced sexual violence in relationships
  • 55 per cent of women have been forced into sex against their will
  • 58 per cent of women have experienced physical and emotional abuse in relationships.


It has been said that Western society, and Western feminism in particular, has been too reluctant to point out and too slow to condemn the plight of women outside the West for fear that any censure of anti-female practices would be seen as culturally insensitive. 

A few years ago, Germaine Greer went so far as to argue that attempts to outlaw female genital mutilation were an attack on cultural identity and that “if an Ohio punk has the right to have her genitalia operated on, why has not the Somali woman the same right?” Clearly, Greer is either ignorant of or impervious to the purposes and consequences of female genital mutilation and the lack of choice for the young girls on whom it is inflicted. 

No one has captured the folly of Greer’s position more eloquently than Roger Scruton.  In an article in the December 2010 – January 2011 edition of the American Spectator, he states:

Once we distinguish race and culture, the way is open to acknowledge that not all cultures are equally admirable, and that not all cultures can exist comfortably side by side. It is culture, not nature, that tells a family that their daughter who has fallen in love outside the permitted circle must be killed, that girls must undergo genital mutilation if they are to be respectable…….You can read about these things and think that they belong to the pre-history of our world. But when suddenly they are happening in your midst, you are apt to wake up to the truth about the culture that advocates them.  You are apt to say that is not our culture and it has no business here.

Countless studies have detailed the horrific consequences of genital mutilation, from severe infection to infertility.  The World Health Organisation has found that genital mutilation doubles a woman’s risk of dying in childbirth and can increase by three to four times the chance that their child will be stillborn.  And yet this archaic practice continues and is even defended by some Western feminists who shamefully fail to stand up for their sisters.

I raise these issues, as uncomfortable as they may be for some, because events like International Women’s Day must be about more than just acknowledging and celebrating the rights that we in the West enjoy. 

They must focus attention and energy on ameliorating the condition of women internationally.  We have achieved so much in promoting the status of women in this country; but it is incumbent on us to remember that the journey is not over and that in some countries it has only just begun.

Most commented

41 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • deb says:

      05:37am | 08/03/11

      It saddens me to be reminded that Australia is unique in the way women are treated.This article wont be read by many.Too honest and real.
      Women in this country still put up with abuse,yes, but we have help.
      Having being a bashed wife once many years ago i used our system to get help and start a new new life for my kids.Women in these third world countries dont have a chance in hell.People wonder why i dont believe in GOD?

    • Catching up says:

      08:33am | 08/03/11

      Being a feminist means that you recognise that woman are not equal in this society.  Much has improved but there is a long way to go, to get the message across, that woman are equal to men, not superior or inferior.

      My own belief that being a feminist means that I am not put on this earth to serve men.  The biggest fight we have is to get men to acknowledge this.

      Being a feminist does not mean that you cannot be a mother but the recognition that children also have a father who is equally responsible for raising the child.

      Being a woman does not mean your life should be any more controlled by rearing children than a man is. Being a woman means that you decide how you will live your life, not a husband or father, the same as men do.

      Being a woman is being able to use the skills and abilities you have to the highest degree, not sacrificed to serving men.  Women are quite capable of caring for themselves, so are men.  As my father used to say, if a man cannot prepare a meal, he deserves to go hungry. 

      Being a woman is being able to love, marry and have children if that is your wish.

      Being a woman is wearing the latest fashions or no bras and overalls.

      If a woman wants to be a handmaiden, and she knows that she has a choice, that is OK.  It is not OK for a man to demand that occur.  A real man in my opinion would reject a marriage or relationship based on such a premise.

      At 69, after enduring domestic violence for years, being divorced, being a mature age uni student and raising four children, are my views.

    • acotrel says:

      08:33am | 08/03/11

      Deb, my daughter has two big ugly brothers who’ll look after her when she’s married.  She’s intelligent and educated, and competent. If she makes it to the top of the political tree, I’ll be rapt.

    • Bilby says:

      09:28am | 08/03/11

      Catching up - I can understand where your views come from, but I disagree. You find the idea of serving men to be abhorrent. I say that in a family, we each serve each other. By placing the group above the individual, we all benefit.

      acotrel - If my daughter made it to the top of such a dodgy game, I’d be crying into my cornflakes wondering where I went so wrong… each to their own. wink

    • skepdad says:

      11:27am | 08/03/11

      @ Catching up: you’ve clearly had a rough life, and good on you for coming through it strong and independent.

      However you should realise that what you paint as “feminism” is actually misandry.  Don’t despise men - despise bad men.

    • Carz says:

      02:30pm | 08/03/11

      @skepdad how do you get equate what Catching up is saying with misandry? There is nothing about hating males in what she said. Instead it is all about what being an person with equal rights is. Or perhaps it is women saying what they won’t do, by choice, or perhaps even them having the choice, that has rattled your chain.

    • skepdad says:

      03:56pm | 08/03/11

      I think, @carz, you’ll have a far easier time finding misandric statements in the OP than you will of finding anti-choice sentiment in mine.

      But don’t let facts or logic get in your way, you’re doing so well without them.

    • baal says:

      08:06am | 08/03/11

      Thank you for raising this issue and raising the point that all people are equal in dignity but some cultures are better than others.
      Spreading human rights via humanist secularism will change this world

    • Tahera Chaudhary says:

      08:24am | 08/03/11

      Indira Gandhi , the third Prime Minister of Republic of India, for four (4) consecutive terms from 1966 to 1984 until she was assassinated in 1984. That is for fifteen years in country like India. And what was the condition of western women that time? Nothing but less cloths on her body and more rights for going to pub and having boyfriends openly and no respect for elders presence.
      So when you look at other facts then what about this fact about the Women prime Minister of India. And how many cases of burning brides in populated country like India what ratio or %, average? It is just the difference between lack of knowledge and arrogance and greed. Some ignorant, uneducated people from underdevelop country like India. So we are not sure about your other data.
      When it comes to Afghanistan and Saudi Arabia.  As far as I have observed,  people are scared and protecting their women in country like Saudi, When they look at the western countries. In western countries women is just a commodity, a body for sex and satisfaction and good sale. Alcohol and drugs are on rise. Domestic violence and killing of one women every week in develop and less populated country like Australia is worse when you compare it to underdevelop and poor countries. So do you really think we are any better in western countries? Here in Australia we have no support of a husband,  women is on her own, nobody to care for her and by doing her duties she reaches the old age and end up in aged care centre. Don’t tell me that you don’t want to be a mother. If your mother was not your mother you were not here in the first place and we can’t be selfish and stop human civilisation to come and enjoy this beautiful world with peace and contentment.
      Unlike eastern countries, women in western country is all alone she has to work hard financially and physically and sexually in order to please her partner and not even a husband with commitment. Otherwise she is on her own.  On an average one western man, sleeps with more than 20 women before settling with one wife or partner or defector wife. And then too you are not sure when he starts cheating her. And doing this he leaves several children with single mums on his way and on government benefits. So how this blind freedom helping our country?

      Let’s talk about Muslims, in Islam it says that marry only once but if you can do JUSTICE then MARRY up to four. In Islam rights comes with limits. No flirting no misusing women. You can only marry and no sex before marriage. You must think first about the responsibilities you take once you marry and have children, otherwise Islam says do fasting but do not degrade womanhood. We are here for some purpose.  Man and women creation is for important purpose.
      Man and woman are made so they link to each other and jointly take out the responsibility of being a mother and a father for our future generation. Husband takes care of his wife and supports her so she can in return take care of their house and children. So she can be a dedicated mother and give quality children to our nation. Our children are going astray. Men enjoying free sex everyday and night with new women. Is this you call women’s freedom and care and dignity? Think again.

    • Razor says:

      11:43am | 08/03/11

      OK - is this a joke?

    • Brian B says:

      12:56pm | 08/03/11

      Mate! Time for you to return to an Eastern country where women are obviously so much better off.

      Good grief!!

    • Tahera says:

      08:32pm | 08/03/11

      Brian come on, say something productive and give your decent opinions. Dont just run away from the reality. There is a big world out there with a whole lot of good values.

    • Jess says:

      08:40am | 08/03/11

      Thanks for this article. It once again reminds me of the power of Women and how we still have a long way to go before all women are valued and treated as precious.

    • Chris L says:

      02:11pm | 08/03/11

      Whereas the only men who demand to be valued and treated as precious were parading down the streets of Sydney last weekend.

      I think people should be valued by their contribution. That the “power of women” depends on the individual woman the way is does with men. I’m not too keen on this “treat us with respect because of our genitals” idea.

    • Jess says:

      03:50pm | 08/03/11

      I certainly agree Chris, I expressed myself badly.

      My point was more about Women in countries other than Australia/America/Europe who don’t have value to society other than as a womb or cook. I feel very privildged to live in Australia where I have the freedom of choice. I can do anything. They can’t, and that is sad, and something we need to change.

    • SkepDad says:

      08:58am | 08/03/11

      It’s incredible to me that educated, modern women - otherwise paragons of inclusive feminism - still dutifully shuffle into the pews and nod their heads while being told that god and the church regard them as little better than property.

      You want an issue that unites men and women?  Stand with the vast majority of good, decent men and stamp out the institutionalised repression of women in religion.  The burqua may as well be a noose.

    • Angela says:

      09:36am | 08/03/11

      It is well past time we stopped pushing political correctness and started doing something about the real injustices in the world.  If we put as much effort into combating the things mentioned in this article (not to mention the multitude for which there was no space) as we put into arguments about numbers of female MPs or the proportioning of housework, we could really do some good in the world.

    • Helen says:

      10:47am | 08/03/11

      Yairs, because the imbalance of power between the sexes and the assumption that women will do the domestic work has no effect on injustice at all, does it? Way to try to silence other women.

    • Shinsengumi says:

      10:50am | 08/03/11

      Thankyou for writing this article.  Too many times, when debating the issues of culture and cultural treatment of women with peers and colleagues, some are far too quick to bleat the racist card.  Race/Genetics is not culture.  I remember one of my Aunts, forever berating my uncle and all the other males in my extended family, for our ‘horrendous’ treatment of women: EG, we played our family game of cricket for 3 hours instead of the loosely planned 2; didn’t clear up all the dishes from Christmas day lunch before we start talking to each other, etc.  It seemed no matter how many times ones as such are reminded that women in Somalia have their clitoris CUT OFF; husbands are sanctioned by theocratic law to beat their wives in the majority of the Middle East, it always comes down to the injustice suffered by not doing the dishes fast enough, playing cricket too long, or getting carried away checking out a nephew’s new motorbike.  90% of the Australian feminists I know, very rarely tackle the issues I find important:  true equality of women in all cultures, not just our own.

      Only a very few are willing to look at the cultures inflicting horrible existences on Women right here, in Australia.  I lived next door to a property which had been completely roofed over; the man had bought adjacent properties and roofed the lot over after joining the 2 houses.  There were umpteen kids and multiple wives, and in all my years living there I didn’t see any of the ‘women’ allowed to leave the compound except on very rare occasions.  This was in Hurstville.  I used to hear yelling and sometimes what I vaguely imagined was crying.  I called the Police a few times, but they were limited by the fact they couldn’t get access to the compound.  I know there were women and children in there.  I saw the sons leaving with the father on a regular basis, however as for the daughters and wives, it was a very rare sight to see their black-clad forms shuffle into the sunlight.

      I’m a male; yet I do regard myself, if you will, as a bit of a Feminist.  In that, I encourage the promotion and employment of anyone in my workplace who shows initiative, competence, and relational skills regardless of gender.  I do all my own domestic tasks, and am not threatened in the least by doing so-called ‘gender specific roles’.  OK, I don’t want to give birth - but for all that my biological abilities allow me, I’m willing to do.

      It grates with me to see minor issues get the majority of the airplay, and all the crucially major ones get no coverage at all.  I don’t care about women CEOs per se, when women are being stoned, beaten,
      bride burned’, mutilated, drowned, subjugated, imprisoned, denied education, medicine, opportunity, and a vast raft of other terrible inhumanities all around us.  When they are being locked in compounds away from society and culturally forced to be 1 man’s harem, pumping out 10’s of children until they are biologically spent?  Why is it left to me, as a Man, to raise these issues, and continually get screamed at for being ‘racist’?  Since when did the abuse of women in other cultures earn the protection of the ‘racist’ label?

      Forgive me for the simplistic expression of the sentiments above.  There’s only so much room in these comment boxes wink

    • Girl says:

      12:13pm | 08/03/11

      Fantasic post. Loved reading it.

      Good luck with your work, it sounds like you are a lovely man.

    • Chris L says:

      02:23pm | 08/03/11

      The reason you get called a racist is because it is now a catch all phrase to silence anyone we don’t want to listen to. Want to argue about the niqab? Racist! Want to laugh at a tribute to the Jackson Five involving guys in black make-up? Racist! Want to suggest the fellow interrupting your lunch to beg for money should get a job? Racist!

      The term has been overused about as much as “mysogynist”. It no longer has much meaning.

    • Holly says:

      11:01am | 08/03/11

      Feminism in this country got derailed.  When we look at issues facing women of other nations it upsets me that we have teenaged girls thinking that they are liberated because they give blow jobs basically on demand.  That our magazines are full of rubbish about dysfuntional relationships, getting back your pre baby body, put on makeup, wear trashy clothes - this is all the almighty dollar at work and dare I say misogyny.  While we have worked hard towards equality for women in the workplace, creating circumstances where women have far more career options, can balance a career with raising a family etc there has been a not too subtle backlash.  The porn industry and the direction is is heading just is a factor here.  Who is behind this undermining of women on so many levels.  Who controls the magazine editors?  Who is directing the current negative campaign against our first women prime minister?

    • Razor says:

      11:47am | 08/03/11

      The “current negative campaign” against the current PM is about the policies - nothing to do with gender.

    • Tahera Chaudhary says:

      12:18pm | 08/03/11

      Very well said Holly.
      We women are still not free in the real sense of freedom. Before men use to force us to decorate and sell us. But now we worry and put all our efforts in decorating ourselves and by doing this we are competing with other women and pushing each other down and men are enjoying all the attention and free sex.
      Let us analyse, everything here in our world or in nature is for some purpose and doing its job and keeping the balance in an environment. Like cycle of plants and animals and even their poo is used again as compost. From bird comes out a dead egg and from that dead egg comes out live bird and from a tiny dead seed comes out a huge tree and from tree thousand of fruits and then millions of seeds. A fruit comes in its eatable or recyclable package. Bees make honey more then they need.
      Man and woman same way created for some purpose and depend on each other and they should carry out their responsibility with all humbleness and care and without putting each other down or being selfish.
      As far as I see it in the history, it is the men who have underestimated God’s noble purpose of creating woman and as God says In Islam “Respect the womb that bore you for nine months and breast fed you for years,” Prophet of Islam says” Paradise lies under the feet of your mother,”. This is not degrading but uplifting the women and her dignity and the respect she deserve.

      But unfortunately men in history were ignorant and they look down on women and became arrogant. But our women in history kept doing their duties as humbly and perfectly as they can and gave many noble prize winners and great leaders and scientists to this world. And that is why everyone loves their mother more than the father. Because mothers are “A silent Architects of society.” She is first mentor for her child, she teaches man to be a man and she gives birth to a man and what men gave her is a brothels.
      But no matter what we don’t want men’s appreciation. We don’t worry about what they think about us? We do what our creator told us to do and we want God’s appreciation as to him we all have to return and answerable to.  And unjust men will also be answerable to God almighty. With all due respect and dignity, we have to carry out our noble purposes in life with all humbleness. And give our children the life of care and teachings in way that this humiliation of women never should happen again in future.  Because if our parents would have been selfish and only thought of their lives and freedom and their choices and comfort, we would not have been here. And we should work on how we can help each other and our children to continue this human civilisation with quality and not just quantity and do you think we are doing this properly for our children as a one community?

    • Chris L says:

      03:15pm | 08/03/11

      How is it imposing on the freedoms of women if they feel comfortable having “free sex”? Are you saying they should receive payment?

      As usual male sexuality = bad : female sexuality = good
      might as well just extend that to male anything = bad : female anything = good.

      Do you ever wonder why it can be so difficult to win men over to your cause?

    • Catching up says:

      12:19pm | 08/03/11

      skepdad says:

      Sorry I do not despise men.  Actually I love men.  That has nothing to do with the argument.  I think if you took the time to read what I said, you would know that.  A male who can see a woman as his equal is a man.  I did not tell my story because I am bitter.  I told it because it was my belief that I was responsible for making my marriage work and for the well being of my children. I had this stupid belief I was also responsible for my husbands happiness.  In one, I allowed myself and children to be abused.  Too many of my generation made the same mistake.
      I love men but I do not believe I have to serve them.  Caring for one another, yes, that is different.

      Respecting one another is the key to any relationship.  How can you respect anyone that expects you to be servile.

    • Catching up says:

      12:25pm | 08/03/11

      “The “current negative campaign” against the current PM is about the policies - nothing to do with gender. “

      Razor, you could be right but how do you explain statements like:-

      I will make an honest woman of her

      You are in no danger of seeing inside a Church.

      Continual calls during QT of slag and harpy

      Being liken to Gaddafi


      I am sure you are right, and it is policies that are being attacked.  What policies are the above connected too.

    • Razor says:

      02:30pm | 08/03/11

      Your first three alleged slurs - if they are occurring then they are unacceptable.

      How is the fourth one anything to do with gender?  She is deluded - he is deluded - they are deluded.

    • Erick says:

      03:06pm | 08/03/11

      “Continual calls during QT of slag and harpy”

      Really? Please provide a link to video proof.

      I’m sure that one is just made up, like most feminist claims.

    • Steve says:

      12:26pm | 08/03/11

      Hahaha! Women put on this earth to serve men! Ask yourself which gender lives on average 7 years longer than the other. Then you will see who is servitude to womens longevity, health and wellbeing.

    • Sad Sad Reality says:

      12:29pm | 08/03/11

      I can’t wait for International Men’s Day. Enough about the second tier. Let’s meet some real achievers.

    • Outraged says:

      05:42pm | 08/03/11

      Thanks for a great article exposing how selfish Western feminists are!

      All Western feminists care about is securing cushy, high-paying corporate jobs FOR THEMSELVES! They don’t realise how much WORSE off women are in other countries around the world. Feminists should be fighting for THEIR rights! The international women who don’t have a voice.

      At the end of the day, a white Australian woman has it way better off than a black African male!

    • marley says:

      06:26pm | 08/03/11

      @ quite true- white Australian women do have it better off than black males.  No doubt you’ve got an impressive track record yourself of fighting for black male rights in Africa.  Please provide the links - I’m quite anxious to read about your unselfish Western male contribution to the men’s rights.

    • Squeeze the Middle says:

      01:01pm | 09/03/11

      marley.  Isn’t Outraged really just saying: you Aussie women are just as bad as us Aussie men so drop the whole ‘it’s all because of men’ charade. If so then why the personal attack?

    • jim morris says:

      06:04pm | 08/03/11

      Aussie women are a privileged majority masquerading as an underprivileged minority. The 17% pay gap mantra is simply dishonesty that goes unchallenged by intimidated ‘men’. Feminists are just tyrants who need a dose of reality; maybe a holiday in Somalia?

    • marley says:

      08:48am | 09/03/11

      Perhaps you could take that trip too, and find out how privileged ALL Australians are.

    • Trude says:

      06:18pm | 08/03/11

      That’s why some of the government’s attitude to multi-culturalism annoy me. i’m all for accepting other cultures. But sometimes we go so far out of our way not to offend ‘cultural sensitivities’ that we allow abuses of women to continue. There has to be a balance of acceptance of a culture, yet non-acceptance of traditions which are abusive, to women or anyone else.

      We need to do the same with trade. I’d rather pay a few more dollars to buy something from a country where women are treated with respect, than save a few dollars and let the abuse continue. I wish our government felt the same. “Nope, you can’t do business with us or any Australian business, while you allow your women to be abused. If you want to act like neanderthals then go trade with other neanderthals, your business isn’t welcome here.” Two or three years of that from countries which don’t allow abuse of women and laws would have to change before those backward countries economies collapsed entirely.

      It won’t happen though, money is more important than lives.

    • MBD says:

      06:37pm | 08/03/11

      I agree with Tahera Chaudhary..Yes, there are cases of bride burning in India and that is because of over or wrong beliefs or idea of traditions..But when you say in western countries where there is so called freedom for women what they do with that right or freedom? What % number of women use it properly? Because freedom for most of them is drugs, alcohol, pubs and sex!! Com’mon girls there is a life beyond all these things. There is a career..there is friendship..but most of the girls seem to be happy being receptionist or attendant..when I saw a 13 yrs old girl kissing a same age guy in mall infront of atleast 200 peopl and doing other objectioanable things ...is this your freedom?

    • St. Michael says:

      11:00pm | 08/03/11

      One controversial point to raise in all this.

      In those countries where abuses are perpetrated against women, to what extent do women themselves actually enable the system to continue?

      Now, before you all go grabbing your pitchforks and burning your straw men, read what I said again.  I am not saying a woman asks for her clitoris to be cut off, or to be rapied, or to be kept in a household where the husband can have his “marital privileges” when, where, and how often he likes.  Far from it.  But where are the mothers, the aunts, the grandmothers of the girls and women who are suffering these abuses?

      Most of the time, I would guess the mothers, aunts, grandmothers et. al. are sinning by silence in allowing it to happen to their children.  In some cases they’re perpetrating it upon their female children.

      Don’t think so? Let’s go for the most horrendous crime of all: female genital mutilation.  And let’s go to one of the biggest offenders, being Somalia, where over 90% of the female population seems to have it done to them.  Here’s the source document for what follows: http://www.asylumlaw.org/docs/somalia/usdos01_fgm_Somalia.pdf

      Couple of interesting quotes from that report:

      “The CARE study showed a difference in attitude toward this practice between rural and urban women. A higher number of urban women than rural women felt there was nothing good about the practice. Forty percent of all women interviewed felt there was nothing bad about the practice. Eleven percent of those interviewed did not want their daughters to undergo this procedure.”

      That’s less than one in ten mothers who don’t want their daughters to go through it.  And four in ten think there’s nothing wrong with it.  And *not one*, it seems, think it is inherently bad or against a woman’s rights.

      “In the cities, these procedures generally take place in a medical facility under anesthesia. If the operation is performed in a rural village, an old woman excisor performs the procedure without anesthesia. The excisors in Somalia, unlike in some other African countries, are not highly respected. They do not wield influence or have much status within the traditional power structure.”

      Read that again.  It is *old women* doing it to young women.  No mention of male excisors.

      One other thing to quote:

      “In 1987, SWDO and the Italian Association for Women and Development (AIDOS) founded an eradication project in Somalia. AIDOS provided technical and methodological support and SWDO was responsible for
      the content and direction of the project. SWDO approached the practice as a health issue. It feared an approach based on female rights (such as that of sexual freedom) would surely fail.”

      In other words: a feminist argument would, necessarily, not work in Somalia.  You have to have a hidden agenda to change things in Somalia, it appears.

      In short: be careful when man-bashing on various things that women endure in the Third World, folks.  Much of the time women are as much part of the system as the men are.  By definition, roughly 50% of any human population is female.  Just as we’re finding out in Afghanistan, you can’t convert an entire country with only half the entire population available and/or on side - women are off-limits to Western forces.

    • marley says:

      08:55am | 09/03/11

      I think you’re looking too narrowly at this particular issue, St. Mike. 

      Female genital mutilation is, as we all agree, a horrendous practice.  And as you point out, it’s one in which female members of the family often either participate or acquiesce.  But it’s less common, and there’s less support for it, in urban families and in those with better levels of eduction.  However, women in many Muslim societies have far less access to education than do men - and so the cycle perpetuates. 

      Improve women’s access to education, and you will begin to address the problem.  And that really is a feminist issue.  Well, actually, it’s a human issue.

    • Tahera says:

      10:07am | 09/03/11

      St. Michael, you did very interesting observation. As you said ” Women are as much part of the system as the men are.” So to began with the facts are: First woman our mother Eve was created from the rib of Hazrat Adam. Secondly man and woman they both got brains. But when it comes to women she is bit sensitive and firm towards what she believes and she takes things seriously and most of the time it is hard for her to judge and decide between emotions and facts and logic. But when she understands again she is going to be very serious about what she believes now. Have you seen the movie ‘The colour purple’? In that movie a woman advices man to beat his wife, as her own husband use to beat her and she thinks that’s the way it is and should be. It is a very sad movie which shows how women are treated since childhood and used for sex by own fathers.
      So you see it is a responsibility of a man as a father to give the right teachings in the house with respect and care for the little girls because they are going to get married one day and become mothers of our future generation. Mothers who are ‘An Architects of Societies.’ They are the first mentor for their children and it is the mother who makes man a human being. And what man gives her an eye full of lust and a brothel.
      Care for your daughters and sisters. And talk to them with care and only the truth with logic and facts because they are going to take it seriously. And if you teach them something which is not true, and if they suffer in their lives then men will be answerable to God.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter