It seems absurd that the lesser football codes - the imported football codes - persist in starting each season by arguing their supremacy on the national sporting stage.

The great uniter: Geelong Captain Tom Harley with the premiership cup

As John Howard memorably stated on the day the CFMEU pulled down all the bollards outside Parliament House and smashed up the souvenir shop, it is both ugly, and un-Australian.

The origins of our one true national code, the great game of Australian Rules Football, remain the subject of conjecture. Some argue that it was invented by a couple of black guys kicking the shit out of a possum. Others argue it evolved naturally when the Aborigines rejected rugby on the grounds that none of them were stockbrokers, rejected league on the basis that they already had enough mindlessly violent initiation rites in their culture, rejected soccer because they didn’t want to spend another 40,000 years dreaming that someone might actually score a goal.

Its origins matter not. All that matters is that Aussie Rules is the one game that transcends class, race and ethnicity. As such it is the true national game - an egalitarian game for all Australians.

Rugby is essentially a form of corporate networking conducted in a sporting stadium. It’s for this that nobody knows the rules, or cares, because they’re too busy necking Stellas and commenting that the sushi is particularly good, and chatting about Ian Verrender’s column about the restructure of Telstra’s broadband division. There is no outer at the union, and no actual fans, just a series of boxes the occupants of which look like a Henry Bucks fashion shoot. It might not be much of a game, but it serves a vital role in giving grown men who first met in the showers at Kings or Joeys a chance to catch up and exchange business cards in a more clothed setting. I know that it is a working man’s sport in other countries but here it’s a toffs’ pursuit and the very antithesis of Australian values.

And what to say about league? Sure, the AFL has had one or two off-field dramas, but it’s Rugby League which week in week out conducts itself like the sporting wing of the Department of Community Services. In another of his trademark sprays Wyong intellectual Luke McIlveen has burst into print celebrating the sheer joy of seeing one man who is the size of a sherman tank run at speed into another man who likes like a Cocos-Keeling Islander crossed with a two-door Westinghouse refrigerator. If this is a sport surely it could be simplified by getting rid of the ball and holding it a more linear setting, like the back alleyway behind an Elizabeth St pub, where its true charm of bone-crushing violence could best be displayed without the taxing distraction of keeping score.

It might sound less than inclusive, it might even sound arrogant, but there is only one code in Australia which unites the dandy and the prole, the dinki-di and the recient emigre, the spooner and the bogan. There is only one code, to quote that great Fosters ad from the Olympics, which unites the Wongs, the Smiths and the Da Costis, and its name is Aussie Rules.

Finally, can I say that I’m becoming tired of the cheap jibes from the league-loving likes of Mcilveen that loving AFL is a form of homoeroticism. Although I will concede that if I was forced at gunpoint to choose between a night of manly romance with Willy Mason, or dinner for two with James Hird, I know which choice I would make. It’s for this reason that the ladies like Aussie Rules too. Truly a game for all of us.

34 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • iansand says:

      07:20am | 22/03/10

      In summary:  I like AFL because the others are crap.  Says it all, really.

    • Adam Diver says:

      07:27am | 22/03/10

      I agree but I think his attacks on rugby league were poorly disguised complements smile.

    • acker says:

      09:16am | 22/03/10

      I agree and AFL will be even stronger when Brad Johnson holds aloft the Premeirship Cup late September this year much like Frodo held that confounded ring in the air.

    • Thugs are weak says:

      03:23am | 23/03/10

      AFL has true athleticism. Rugby league has meatheads. Rugby has toffs but it has a thuggery element. AFL anyday ...

    • backing Colgo says:

      07:43am | 22/03/10

      “one code to rule them all…”??

      Wasn’t the whole point of the book to take the evil world ruining ‘one ring to rule them all” and cast it into a volcano?? Perhaps its just me, but thats not a bad idea for what to do with AFL as well.

      So what you’re saying Penbo is that you are quietly a Union fan as well? (It has to be Union, there is hardly be a league fan out there who has read a book, let alone Tolkien!!)

    • Pete the footy fan...almost all codes says:

      07:42am | 22/03/10

      too right Penbo

    • Rover says:

      08:40am | 22/03/10

      As a league girl, I tried very hard to get into AFL but failed. I don’t mind the game and enjoy watching it live, but discovered that the fans were unlikeable, mono-codal idiots.

    • Greg Dell says:

      08:40am | 22/03/10

      League and union ar’nt even sports, they are a place where those with 3 teeth go to meet!

    • PG says:

      10:26am | 22/03/10

      If your built like a tomato stake and are facinated by fumbling a teeny weeny ball across a paddock and slap yourself on the back when you catch—- sorry mark the teeny ball and punt kicking on and on and on and on so repetitivly that by the end its like cats scratching down a blackboard (over 2 hours for gawd sake) without anything much happening then Irish—- sorry Aussie Rules is for you.

    • Nick S says:

      10:17am | 22/03/10

      Well said Penbo. Aussie rules, rules Australia

    • John says:

      10:19am | 22/03/10

      Australian Football is a game for all Australians. Bring on the GWS team and go Sheedy!

    • BULMKT says:

      10:27am | 22/03/10

      AFL:
      On a crowded tram going to the football game the fan resplendent in black and white colours had a large magpie tucked under his arm.
      Sitting directly opposite, at face level with the magpie, was an old codger flaunting a scarf in the opposing team’s colours. “They won’t let you take a pig into the ground ya know,” he said loudly
      “It’s not a pig, it’s a magpie ya doofhead,” said the fan in the black and white scarf.
      “I was talking to the Magpie,” said the old codger.

    • aussie Jack says:

      11:24am | 22/03/10

      The Rugby codes are inherently stupid. Players deliberatly running into one another. It does’nt get much more stupid than that.

    • PDaddy says:

      12:11pm | 22/03/10

      In summary:

      Rugby Union – represents elite classes/lots of cash/slow, boring & struggles to identify as an actual sport

      AFL – in amateur comps it is tough as but progressively metrosexual the more professional it gets/reminds you of women fighting over the last pair of panties at a lingerie sale

      League - meatheads/the strongest team sport there is on the face of the planet and epitomises masculinity in team sports/constantly evolving to suit increase in skill and ability….

    • Sour Ron says:

      12:15pm | 22/03/10

      AFL - for all it’s sporting qualities - remains a local (Australian) oddity. It’s also a really poor spectacle on a bog track because it relies more on blunt, upper body force than it does on skill. (60/40 weighting) Typically the debate ignores so called “soccer”. Globally it dwarfs every other code. It is the Sauron to all other codes which are mere Gollums.

    • Footy Fan says:

      01:07pm | 22/03/10

      Sour Ron, soccer sucks and some of the fans suck. Why the game sucks. It is not engaged in competitively, most soccer games end in ties. Both teams lose. Soccer is not a sport. It is an activity. Why the fans suck. They always rant about the McDonald’s Soccer World Cup. Even though most of the time it’s decided by penalty shoot-outs and dubious referee decisions from diving. Over many years there have been various claims of match fixing, some proven. There have also been many allegations of corruption against FIFA which puts the whole the results of the Soccer World Cup in doubt.  I used to play it as a kid but I grew up.

    • Sam Chowder says:

      01:46pm | 22/03/10

      AFL is as quaint as cheese rolling but without the international interest

    • SLF says:

      01:46pm | 22/03/10

      Most soccer games do not end in ties.

      Here you go, the current EPL breakdown….
      302 games played, 226 ending in a victory for one team with only 25% resulting in a draw. But hey don’t let facts get in the way of misconceptions.

      Plus more games will end in a draw because it is harder to score points. You do not have a line the width of the pitch to meathead across nor do you have multiple ways of scoring points. Oh and you don’t get anything for missing.

      This all adds to the excitement as a near miss can be crucially as important as a goal.

      Still soccer is for the discerning punter, one who does not need score multiples of 2,3,4,5,6 and see tens of points scored per game to feel like they have value for money.  And yes, a 0-0 game can be as dramatic, exciting and incident filled as a 5-5 game. And a punter who can understand a game can be a tie and doesnt need golden point to give them ‘closure’.

      Dubious refs are in everysport. Guess you didn’t watch Bryce Lawrence’s performance this weekend or the fiasco that is NRL touch Judging?

    • Michael C says:

      03:53pm | 22/03/10

      SLF——- soccer is binary,

      1s and 0s….....

      my children out grow it’s mathematical challenge around age 3.

      And master it’s feet only restriction around age 4….......

    • a little part of me dies inside when you say backs says:

      12:43am | 19/04/10

      there are 10 types of people in this world, those who understand binary and those who dont, and i dont think your three year old would.

    • Axolotl Pluvius says:

      12:17pm | 22/03/10

      Ok, you had me until you mentioned Howard. Now that is un Australian.
      Rugby - the truly international game for the pointy ball.

    • cityboy @ Sydney says:

      01:32pm | 22/03/10

      Having moved to Sydney from Adelaide many years ago I have never got the hang of Rugby League played here.  It seems that you get the ball by whatever means, tuck it under your arm, run like hell to a predetermined end of the field, and hurl yourself onto the ground over some line, all the while dodging the opposition beefcakes or mowing them down! Or if you feel like it, you can boot it through some goalposts.
      Do I have the hang of it?

    • John Ryan says:

      05:22pm | 22/03/10

      Your opening remarks say it all I come from Adelaide,that about covers it really,.

    • Kate says:

      02:02pm | 22/03/10

      “...rejected soccer because they didn’t want to spend another 40,000 years dreaming that someone might actually score a goal.”

      I just snorted with laughter, now the boss wants to know what’s so amusing. He’s not impressed because I said that as a Carlton supporter he’ll probably spend just as long dreaming of another premiership.
      Great article though.

    • Michael says:

      03:56pm | 22/03/10

      Love me Australian football,

      however - I could suggest that behinds might only be used on count back should goals be level after a game.

      At any rate though - Australian Football is the ONLY code of football in which you can ONLY score a ‘primary score’ (aka ‘goal’) via KICKING it yourself.

      The Rugby codes found it too hard and started awarding points for trys and then elevated trys to be worth more and then way more than kicking a goal (now known as a ‘conversion’).

      Soccer find it so hard they give a single point for anything and everything (including a balloon or plastic bag??) that might find itself in the onion bag….....

      at any rate - I’m no fan of 19th century military style formation schoolboy field games with 2 armys at either end of a paddock….....the modern era is far, far more represented by Australian football.  The ‘street fighter’ of the football codes…...

    • Bob H says:

      05:13pm | 22/03/10

      Only 22 comments says it all really

    • Matt says:

      09:09pm | 22/03/10

      AFL is the BEST! It wont be long until it is played worldwide!

    • Ben says:

      12:45am | 23/03/10

      The fact that you contemplated dinner for 2 with Hird says it all. Back to the beauty saloon for a back wax with ya!

    • Bearbrass says:

      10:35am | 23/03/10

      How could anyone call the AFL homoerotic when all you can see for 90% of an NRL game are arses and thighs?

      It drives me mad when the ABC give us the Rugby League results here on Melbourne TV - and even take up valuable minutes showing “highlights” from the games - no one here cares!

      Thanks Penbo for your measured and helpful contribution to national debate.

    • Michael C says:

      03:42pm | 23/03/10

      The greatest thing of Aust Footy is true 50/50 contests.

      The centre bounce is pivotal to this, but, so too around the ground and boundary throw-ins.  The AFL has to be careful not to declare war on ‘packs’ and boundary throw-ins - - as they accentuate the need for talls and smalls (body type diversity) and allow rare chances for set plays (strategic variety).

    • Mr Subramanian says:

      04:51pm | 23/03/10

      *sigh* It’s precisely the tone of this article - and of many of the commenters - that is why AFL is labelled “arrogant”.

    • Michael C says:

      03:41pm | 24/03/10

      Arrogance….

      let’s see -

      RL - ‘The Greatest Game’
      RU - ‘The game they play in heaven’
      Soccer - ‘The beautiful game’......

      allow us our rhetoric too,

      btw - arrogance is the FFA expecting other codes to step aside to let it host a FIFA WC…......without proper consultation, compensation and consideration.

    • is he having a laugh? says:

      01:48pm | 30/03/10

      ALF a ‘national’ game. Sorry BOB, but when 75% of the teams come form the one state (11 form mel) ,Around 95%+ of the player come from anywhere BUT the two most populated states in NSW and QLD and still refers to those states as foreign markets. .........you ain’t a national sport. Indigenous yes, national? NOT NOW NOT EVER.

      “transcends class, race and ethnicity.” ETHNICITY? Again is this guy for real their is ONLY ONE Football code that describes,..........and it aint played with an oval ball.

    • tell em' their dreaming says:

      02:59pm | 30/03/10

      Take it from me. The day victorian eggball is the national sport of Australia is the day ice-hockey os the national sport of Brazil

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

@IanHanke That was indeed him.

Lucy Kippist

New post: Gina Rinehart earns $50m a day - but she's not the most interesting thing on BRW's List: http://t.co/ftrlKepj

Lucy Kippist

RT @BreakfastNews: Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook being sued for not sharing enough - http://t.co/gF8nSnLr

Anthony Sharwood

RT @gregprichard: The Victorian Sports Minister has just sent the New Zealand Prime Minister a commiserative email. #stateoforigin

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Animal experiments won’t cure me from cancer

Animal experiments won’t cure me from cancer

Lying on a cold table in an unfamiliar place and undergoing a core biopsy was probably one of the most…

If you want to get promoted, laugh at the boss’s jokes

If you want to get promoted, laugh at the boss’s jokes

Red alert, ladies. Making jokes about your ability at work is not funny particularly at board level.…

Need someone to do your dirty work? Try God.

Need someone to do your dirty work? Try God.

Punishing the baddies is only fun in the movies. In real life it’s messy, expensive, and fraught…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

242 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter