If India was hoping to strike gold by hosting the 2010 Commonwealth Games, it now looks more like it landed a lead balloon.

Geoff Huegill might be all smiles but we're worried. Picture: Damian Shaw.

A week before the opening ceremony and there has been more controversy off the field than in any of the scheduled competition events at the Games.

As athletes start to arrive in Delhi this week, the loudest chatter on online news sites in recent days has been not on our gold medal hopes, but on the poor standard of accommodation, health risks and terrorism fears.

While cancelling the Games at this late stage would be unprecedented, many Australians have been suggesting we should pull out of the Games.

Pathetic of Adelaide echoed what many online readers were saying in a comment to Adelaide Now: “As a country I would not be sending my sportspeople to the Games. Not only is the work going on a joke, but the chances of terrorism etc is extremely high. A Commonwealth Games medal is not worth any person’s life.”

Another reader, Jules, added: “It is stupid to expect the athletes to make a balanced decision. They have been training for these Games for years. They are looking at things through rose-coloured glasses. I sense trouble in the next few weeks. I just hope I’m wrong and it’s not a repeat of Munich.”

Many commenters were also critical of the decision to choose Delhi to host the Games considering the poverty in which millions of its people live.

This was not helped by revelations of Delhi’s Underbelly and that it sealed the hosting rights after its delegates offered all nations in the Commonwealth Games family about $140,000 for training schemes if the city was chosen.

Stellar wrote to The Courier-Mail: “It’s morally irresponsible to allow a country plagued with such poverty to bid for the Games. The money they have spent in the attempt to host the Games could have been much better spent on their community needs - which are desperate.”

Rebecca Ryan of Brisbane, posting on news.com.au, thought Games organisers had failed to provide the most basic of accommodation standards for athletes: “I’m all for diversity and I accept that when you are in another country we should somewhat adapt to the lifestyle. However, when they cannot meet basic hygiene standards (third world or not), it is unacceptable to expect athletes to compete let alone live in conditions that even a dog shouldn’t have to endure. The officials should be ashamed of themselves if they let this go ahead.”

Andrew S of Sydney was one of the few who defended India’s hosting of the Games, writing on news.com.au: “India is a magnificent country but it is desperately poor. It is unfair for rich Western countries to now criticise their efforts. For anyone who has travelled through India, this situation should come as no surprise. Get on with the Games and get over the dirty toilets.”

But Lara was not convinced the problems could be overlooked so easily, commenting to The Canberra Times: “Well with crumbling structures, filthy unfinished accommodation, lack of proper sanitation, monsoonal rains, 100 per cent humidity, dengue fever running amok and an 80 per cent threat of a terrorist strike/s, good luck. I have been there, and take it from me, it won’t get any better any time soon.”

With such a damaged reputation even before the first event has been run, Delhi has a long way to go to prove its critics wrong and avoid hosting the worst Commonwealth Games in history.

6 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Walker Waters says:

      05:59am | 27/09/10

      Fair suck of the saveloy brother,all olympic and commonwealth games should go to third world or underdeveloped countries. This is one way to stimulate their economies,build some infrastructure,showcase their best and worst attributes.Sure the cost is a problem,maybe the funding has to come from the I.O.C. or competing countries,but why London, L.A. or Sydney,already established cities, with huge developments. I,d like to see the Cairo olympics,or a South American city host some world events.This reflects the core value of the Games,uniting the people of the planet.

    • Charlie says:

      11:25am | 27/09/10

      Rio 2016 - Your prayers have been answered

    • Condomonium says:

      08:01am | 27/09/10

      I’d rather the IOC spend their money on a Condom Championship expecially in Third World countries

    • Bethany says:

      12:18pm | 27/09/10

      The question is, how’s your appetite for risk?
      If you go to the games, you are crossing your fingers and hoping you don’t:
      a) get blown up by a terrorist
      b) get buried under the rubble of a collapsed stadium
      c) catch some god-awful disease
      The government has rightly left this decision to the individuals involved.

    • Jugger says:

      03:32pm | 27/09/10

      There’s a name for all this hype, and its called a moral panic.  Delhi will be the safest city in the Commonwealth for the period of The Games, because the Indian Government will want to show the world that India is a safe place to visit, therefore security will be at an extremely high.

      To say the city is unsafe is an insult to all the people that live there.  These pampered athletes only have to spend two weeks there, then they can fly back to their own luxury homes.  Spare a thought for the millions of people that live in Delhi, who have to put up with the conditions there every day of their lives.  If they can do it, day in, day out, then our pamered athletes can do it for two weeks.

    • marley says:

      09:43pm | 27/09/10

      Oh for heavens’ sakes.  I lived in Delhi for a couple of years, back in the 90s.  Sure there were problems - don’t drink the water, be careful with the food, be prepared to deal with insanitary conditions and infrastructure that isn’t all that it should be.  And there were the occasional terrorist attacks, even then.

      Mind you, I could say many of the same things about New York or London or Madrid. 

      Sure, India isn’t the first world.  Sure, there are problems there.  But it’s a fascinating country, and it’s a pity our athletes won’t get to see any more of it than the athletes’ village. 

      As for cobras, pahhh.  No Aussie worth the name should be concerned, given the nasty critters on offer here.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Lucy Kippist

New post: Gina Rinehart earns $50m a day - but she's not the most interesting thing on BRW's List: http://t.co/ftrlKepj

Lucy Kippist

RT @BreakfastNews: Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook being sued for not sharing enough - http://t.co/gF8nSnLr

Anthony Sharwood

RT @gregprichard: The Victorian Sports Minister has just sent the New Zealand Prime Minister a commiserative email. #stateoforigin

Anthony Sharwood

@VanillathunderV fair comeback. But seriously, if that was a try then I'll book my skiing in Queensland this year

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Animal experiments won’t cure me from cancer

Animal experiments won’t cure me from cancer

Lying on a cold table in an unfamiliar place and undergoing a core biopsy was probably one of the most…

If you want to get promoted, laugh at the boss’s jokes

If you want to get promoted, laugh at the boss’s jokes

Red alert, ladies. Making jokes about your ability at work is not funny particularly at board level.…

Need someone to do your dirty work? Try God.

Need someone to do your dirty work? Try God.

Punishing the baddies is only fun in the movies. In real life it’s messy, expensive, and fraught…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

242 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter