Andrew Devenish-Meares, who has written this week’s Angry Cripple guest column, has been slowly losing his sight for the past 14 years, and has been described as “pretty bloody blind”. He works as IT Coordinator for a peak not-for-profit body.

And this is off-peak time at Redfern Station. Pic: Brad Hunter

Last week my morning train pulled into Redfern station as normal. There was the usual struggle to get off the train, dodging and weaving around the people who just stand there and won’t move. I got out and followed the noise to somewhere near the bottom of the stairs, which I managed to miss. When my cane hit the side of the lower stairs, I realised my mistake and doubled back.

I trudge up the stairs with the throngs and enter the concourse. I reach the stairs to platforms four and five, which are set back. While listening for people coming up the stairs, the background noise makes it impossible to work out if the path is clear, if people are standing in the way, or if there’s actually traffic there.  Slowing down, I pass the entrance to the platform as the cane finds only empty space. I take two steps forward before I’m hit first on my left side and, as I bounce off him, spin slightly and try to move forward, I’m hit from the right. Double whammy.

People just keep walking, and I try to get out of the way. I’ve lost contact with the side of the concourse. Someone kicks the tip of the cane, making it bounce off the ground. I can’t see anything beyond a lot of movement in the dark. I swerve right and the cane touches the ground and the barrier as I crash into yet another body.

At this point, it’s become one of those “get the $%^& out of there” moments, so I push forward, and follow the turn in the concourse.

I’ve only taken three full steps across the next landing entrance before not one, not two, but a bunch of people hit me from the right (how many people is that now?). Stumbling and half tripping while the people move around and keep going, I take another step and something feels wrong.

Badly wrong.

The cane isn’t running over the ground properly. The now useless thing is in two pieces held together by the elastic inside. I throw the rubbish on the ground and shout. I don’t remember exactly what I shouted. At this point I’m totally stuck, I can’t see anything meaningful, I have nothing to track the ground with. I am close to tears and in shock. I’ve lost my independence and my mobility. Completely.

I’m one of 300,000 people in Australia who are blind or have low vision.  I can see something, but I’m blind.  This causes some people confusion, thinking that blind refers only to people who can’t see anything.  The World Health Organisation defines low vision as corrected visual acuity less than 6/18 (some people like to say less than 30 per cent) and greater than 6/60, and blind as visual acuity less than 6/60 (or less than 10 per cent). 

Of all the people who are blind, only about 10 per cent have no light perception at all.

Vision is the shortcut around almost every single thing we do, and sighted people, of course, take it for granted.  Say you’ve misplaced your keys, you look up, turn your head around and spot them on the table on the opposite side of the room.  If you can’t see, you need to get up, walk across the room, run your hand over the table and locate your keys, hoping the kids haven’t moved them. 

Blindness doesn’t stop you from finding your keys, but it makes it a more complicated exercise.

Personally, I’m a dedicated white cane user.  I’ve never had a guide dog, and I’m not planning on getting one in the future.  Contrary to the ideas of some, this is not a disadvantage for me. 

A guide dog, like a cane, is a tool for orientation and mobility, while they’re trained to do some fairly special things, they are just dogs and they certainly can’t press lift buttons.

Standing at a traffic light one day, a child asked “How does that stick make you see?”. I replied “It doesn’t. It just means I can feel the ground without needing to crawl”. Which is true; the cane lets me use my sense of touch to find obstacles and move around them, totally magic free.

Equally it lets me walk in a straight line, which no one can do without sight , by ‘shorelining’.  Shorelining is using the cane to tap along a wall, or the edge of a footpath and know I’m not wandering all over the place. 

This is one of the reasons many councils require the two metres adjacent to buildings to be kept clear, though often this isn’t well enforced.  Overhanging branches can also be a big problem too .

Redfern station is part of my daily commute. The 100m of that station that I walk through everyday is a minefield of humanity (a term I use loosely) with careless people destroying many white canes.  In this one location I’ve had more canes broken than any other.

In fact every cane bar one in the past 18 months has been broken here. Why? Because people don’t pay attention. You walk around with earphones blaring, or Facebooking on your mobile, or talking on the phone or just off in your own lala world.

If you’re in a crowded space, can you please just pay some attention? Take the earphones out, the text can wait or step out of the way if you’re on the phone.  And to those who wander in dreamland: wake up! You might just avoid stranding me.

Most commented

61 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • So sorry says:

      06:17am | 20/04/11

      So sorry. We’re stupid. Thank you for pointing this out to us. I will try to do better. We need to be better educated about this.

    • Gladys says:

      10:54am | 20/04/11

      I try very hard to be considerate of everyone on train stations. They’re crowded, desperate places at peak hour. I’d hate to have to be on one of them if I was blind.

      Tell me, do you want me to offer to help you in future? I’m happy to. Because sometimes when I drop groceries, or I might be carrying something heavy, people offer to help me.

      I’m a woman with a child BTW. I don’t see these offers as anything but thoughtful gestures of kind people. But if I offer you help to get to the right exit and street (Town Hall and Central are so confusing!) is that patronising?

    • Jay says:

      11:50am | 20/04/11

      I with Gladys, please let me know if it is ok to offer assistance. I can only imagin how intimidating it would be for a stranger to walk up and ask if they could help, especially with many people looking to take advantage.
      I saw an older lady fall one day, when I offered her help her anxiety went through the roof - she thought I was going to mug her.

    • Andrew Devenish-Meares says:

      12:05pm | 20/04/11

      Hi Gladys,

      Firstly, let’s be clear that you can pretty much generalise what I’m saying about myself here to any other blind person.

      That’s a complex question, but the simple answer is just to ask.  The answer may well be no.  If it’s yes, then its worth knowing how:

      There’s one video on the Guide Dog’s NSW/ACT site under “Don’t Turn a Blind Eye” (http://guidedogs.com.au/education-and-resources/access/dont-turn-a-blind-eye), but I rather like these two from Guide Dogs UK http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEoY6NeISs4 and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_tvyxIfPJ0.  All three cover the best ways you can assist a visually impaired person.

      The worst thing that you can probably do is to just grab me, which happens scarily often.  Just think: do you normally come up behind a sighted person and grab them?

      In the case of this particular morning, someone did stop ask, and get me to an exit, where I met one of my colleagues.  If he happens to be reading this: thanks!  I was kind of messed up, and don’t think I thanked you properly.

    • Brian Taylor says:

      06:48am | 20/04/11

      I’m legally blind and when I first came out of hospital I was give a white cane, my wife took me shopping at the local mall and I couldn’t believe just how many people either tripped over my cane or walked straight into me and I thought I was the blind one lol.
      After I’d said “sorry” everytime someone bumped into me, my wife reall went off the deep end at the next person who managed not to see my cane.
      she told me to stop saying sorry as it wasn’t my fault. of course shes right.
      But why couldn’t they see my cane?

    • missy says:

      03:22pm | 30/08/11

      because there ate none so blind then those that will not see

    • Brian Taylor says:

      06:48am | 20/04/11

      I’m legally blind and when I first came out of hospital I was give a white cane, my wife took me shopping at the local mall and I couldn’t believe just how many people either tripped over my cane or walked straight into me and I thought I was the blind one lol.
      After I’d said “sorry” everytime someone bumped into me, my wife reall went off the deep end at the next person who managed not to see my cane.
      she told me to stop saying sorry as it wasn’t my fault. of course shes right.
      But why couldn’t they see my cane?

    • Huey says:

      07:09am | 20/04/11

      coz they looking in the shops man.

    • Brian Taylor says:

      11:22am | 20/04/11

      malohi….people don’t have to look for the cane, it’s long and white, not damn hard to see
      Huey, they are looking in the shops as they walk right into me…Aren’t they damn lucky I’m not a brick wall then

    • missy says:

      03:24pm | 30/08/11

      sorry i am a first timer put my answer in wrong reply

    • malohi says:

      07:13am | 20/04/11

      People are not looking for the cane. Many people do not look others up and down when walking and simply mind their own buisness,  I know if I was frequenting Redfern station I certainly wouldn’t be staring at people I did not know. People are busy on their way too and from work, some are just waking up.
      I cannot imagine how frutrated and helpless you must have felt at that point and I would be pissed off too, but having people take music away from their dreary commute on the off chance they may bump into a blind man attempting to negotiate a busy crowd may be a bit of a stretch.
      Great Hyperlinks btw.

    • Chris L says:

      09:22am | 20/04/11

      I disagree malohi. It’s no great hardship to ditch the music and texting while you walk and wait until you are seated (or standing out of the way) before indulging.

      I’m not blind but I too am often frustrated at how people barge around without looking ahead. It isn’t difficult to maintain an awareness of one’s surroundings and just move a little if your current trajectory will lead to a collision but so few bother to do that.

    • deb says:

      07:13am | 20/04/11

      scary! I naturally thought that people had more manners.Of course living in a small country town we do tend to look at the person in the street.Keep your nasty cities and dont care attitudes. Angry has a right to be pissed off.Blind ,he is brave in my book to even keep going back out there!
      My husband related an incident with a teenage schoolboy who saw him laden down with groceries tried to force him off the sidewalk recently. he stood his ground and the child? 50 years younger was forced to step around him instead.No manners at that age,in a small town?spreads like some sort of disease doesnt it?

    • TChong says:

      07:35am | 20/04/11

      The öriginal “Angry Cripple “article was all about how the AC thought it was unfair how a sight impaired person could even consider themselves a “cripple” , and unfair that such a person should recieve any type of support.
      Todays article shows just how varied “disabilities “can be, and probaly just how unwittingly biggoted the original article was.
      IF the condition compromises someones ability to live a “normal “life, then there is a disability, whether the person is in a wheelchair , or uses a cane.
      One thing though Andrew- while sharing your POV that some people simply dont look (  broken canes) dont go dissing their “humanity”.
      Most people try to do the right thing to help etc. Clumbsyness by the “abled” doesnt equate to deliberate malevolance to the “disabled”

    • Angry Cripple Editor says:

      09:01am | 20/04/11

      lol OK, I’ll bite TC.
      The original article pointed out the inequities in the system. A blind person earning six figures still gets a pension, but anyone with any other disability loses 50c in the dollar after $70 is earned in a fortnight.
      Personally, I think all DSP should be means tested, and those with severe disabilities should be compensated for their disability related costs to enable them to work.
      It can cost a lot to be disabled - medications, therapies, equipment, home and car modifications etc etc. If a blind person can retain their pension (effectively covering their disability related needs) while working, so should many others (but I don’t think that should be in the form of the pension), and all pensions per say should be means tested. No-one earning $150K should be also receiving a government pension (assistance with disability related expenses? quite possibly - pension? no)
      I am, of course, open to learning more and changing this concept, and I’m not sure I’ve explained it very well, but this is where I stand now, with the knowledge I have today.
      Essentially - people with disabilities should not be prevented from working, if they’re able, by lack of supports and major financial disincentive. Hence - disability related supports (those that enable someone to work and participate in community) should be funded for those who need them, and pensions should be paid to those who, despite adequate support, are unable to work.

    • TChong says:

      09:10am | 20/04/11

      Original AC- no need to bite, but with hindsight, dont you concede yur original article could have been a little less ‘us and them’ ?
      United we stand, but divided….? . More united voices may win more support .

    • Phil says:

      10:02am | 20/04/11

      You say, “Clumbsyness by the “abled” doesnt equate to deliberate malevolance to the “disabled”
      Its more about ignorance by the abled for all those not self aware of whats going on around them, the same goes for people who get stuck behind older or slow moving people and crack it? why i often wonder you can see them and the speed they were moving why not get out of the way?
      The problem is people nothing thinking or paying attention, like roaches when the lights turn on they just scatter any way they can!
      This shows in many peoples driving, but how dare i ask people to become more aware of WTF they are doing when that could stop you from checking you FB or email while in a crowd of people.

    • Angry Cripple Editor says:

      10:24am | 20/04/11

      Hey TC, I admit, I employed a little of the “shock jock” in the first column to get people up and listening. And it may happen again again.
      I do think though, that it wasn’t the article so much as the comments that perpetrated us v them.

    • TChong says:

      10:45am | 20/04/11

      Dont get me wrong Original AC, I fully support those with ‘disabilities"etc recieving the treatment and help they need.
      But , as a long time “health"worker in ‘neuro ‘trauma/ medical and rehab, I see and work with many clients who may be cosidered
      “disabled”,( congenitally , or traumatically) Paras and quads, CHI, or hydrocephalus, and everything in between, hence my genuine belief that divisions are death, and a united voice may be more productive.
      Agree AC, fight the good fight, but make sure the target is legit.
      “Power to the people, Right On !!! ”

    • Mark says:

      08:08am | 20/04/11

      Not much can be said about this type of situation.  Plain wrong.  Make’s a bloke’s taser finger itch.

    • Over the cripple thing says:

      09:00am | 20/04/11

      Why don’t you get a device that beeps, like the ones on forklifts or trucks that work when they are put into reverse.
      That way people would know you were coming and you’d have one less thing to bitch about?

    • Rosie says:

      09:18am | 20/04/11

      If this article hadn’t been written you would have one less thing to bitch about!  I hope you’re never stricken with a disability.

    • Angry Cripple Editor says:

      09:20am | 20/04/11

      What a card you are.
      I better take those handcuffs and that headbrace off you so you’re not forced to read this anymore.

    • fairsfair says:

      09:26am | 20/04/11

      You are an ass. Bitch about? Could you imagine for a second how scary it would be to walk into a train station without being able to see where the tracks are, where you buy a ticket, where the doors are? It is stressful enough sighted.

      Wouldn’t it be easier for you to not be such an ass and leave for work in the morning with the action and movements of others on your mind? I think it is called common courtesy. Not just blind people - every kind of people. That is the purpose of this article - awareness - that is all Andrew is asking for, not to be stigmatised further by bloody beeping everywhere he goes. I am sure he is really sorry sharing his diability annoyed you this morning.

      Wow, I can’t believe your comment. Perhaps I have taken it the wrong way? I am furious.

    • HappyCynic says:

      09:35am | 20/04/11

      You’re not blind you know, you could just notice the guy with the cane.  Also since a lot of blind people rely on sound as well as touch to navigate wouldn’t one of those beepers just be disorienting?

      Besides the selfish and oblivious morons would just ignore the beeping anyway.

    • Brian Taylor says:

      11:29am | 20/04/11

      how would they hear the “beep” as you so kindly put it because they have ear plugs in for their ipad?
      As for bitching, I really wonder how you’d react if you were in our postion you wanker.

    • Biff says:

      01:32pm | 20/04/11

      Oh how wrong to not be sorry for someone else’s disability!!!

      What is with this pandering to the lowest common denominator by society all the time? In any other species it’s survival of the fittest and if you’re not right then you’re left behind to fend for yourself. We all have our problems, just live with them.

    • Carl Thompson says:

      01:49pm | 20/04/11

      Isn’t Biff that really stupid character in Back to the Future? Make sense I suppose.

    • Biff says:

      02:49pm | 20/04/11

      Yes, you said it. Please make sense.

    • Over the cripple thing says:

      06:18pm | 20/04/11

      Brian Wanker .
      How about the beeping noise and a hard hat with a revolving red light on top?

    • Parent who watches their child struggle with a dis says:

      11:30pm | 20/04/11

      Why don’t you spend a day in the life of someone with a disability and see if you had anything to bitch about.

    • Matt says:

      09:20am | 21/04/11

      Holy shit Biff, are you really calling disabled people “the lowest common denominator”?  And as a mutant braying donkey-man with such a skewed perception of the world, you should probably be thankful you aren’t living amongst a species where only the strongest survive.

    • Bec says:

      09:01am | 20/04/11

      I had a similar experience, Deb. Struggling to the post office with 10kg’s worth of express post bags, I was playing a game of chicken with a 12 year old boy who was walking right at me (I was right against the gutter as it was), in the end I had to step to the side because with only 2 steps to go, I would have bumped into him and I would have been the one that would have done damage to him if he’d fallen back and hit his head etc

    • shenanigans says:

      09:17am | 20/04/11

      this is the part where you give up the chains of society and become a monk trained in the art of blind fighting, you can beat the crap out people and hear even the most tiny of noises, this will teach people not to run into you as if they do, they will recieve a prompt arse kicking.

      i can’t sympathise with all you guys and girls for having people walk into you or being forced to move because of rude and/or ignorant teens and adults, my height and figure make people move, or if they run into me they generally end up as shocked as if they hit a brick wall, but countless times have i seen mums with their bubs or elderly being forced to stop or swerve out of the way because of ignorant or abnoxious people walking in their own little world. specially this one ‘emo’ kid who ran into a blind dude, the blind guy dropped his cane and his glasses flew off, the teen just told him to watch where he was going and walked off and no one stopped to help this blind man, made me want to throttle the teen and the people standing there gawking.

    • Limpy says:

      09:24am | 20/04/11

      I am using a cane at the moment due to a back injury.  I have found there are a few who don’t see, or don’t want to see me and bump me.  However, I have noticed a surprising number of people who offer me a seat on very packed trains.  I am a fit looking 40’s bloke, so they are obviously doing it in light of the cane.  I appreciate it, and alway acknowledge it.  Frankly, it amazes me how good so many people are.  Well, that is my Central Coast experience anyway.

    • Kate says:

      10:06am | 20/04/11

      I’d like a cane. I have a vision based disability and lack depth perception. If you look at my eyes you can tell that I’m almost totally blind. I’m sure you’ve all stood up on a moving train. Ever imagined what it would be like if you can’t adequately compensate and sway with the movements? I’m on Central Coast trains and I can count the number of people who have offered me their seat on no hands. Even when I’m stumbling around. I’m thinking about getting some sort of sign to hang around my neck. Going to stand in front of able bodied people in the disabled seats doesn’t seem to work, and asking them when you look able-bodied at first glance? Don’t even try it.

    • Limpy says:

      12:07pm | 20/04/11

      @Kate, that is one reason I have the cane.  I can’t stand for more than a short time without severe pain, and to stand all the way to Woy woy would be unthinkable.  The cane supports me.  It also does help in that, being very able bodied looking, people know I have some sort of problem and are more likely to offer a seat.  Kate, they only cost a few bucks at a pharmacy.  I would suggest given your problem you get one.  When not used just fold up and put in your bag.  See ya on the trains!!

    • fairsfair says:

      09:40am | 20/04/11

      My brother was born with an eye condition that was identified at age 6. When he was diagnosed my parents were told to take him home and prepare their lives and home for a blind child. They were devastated. Thankfully, various trips to opthamologists in Sydney and Melbourne were able to save his sight by simply telling him he had to wear sunglasses when outside. Back then, sunnies were not cool, and being 7 and wearing ray ban aviators and a flap hat, he quite frankly looked like the unibomber. These days though, it is not an issue.

      I am thankful everyday, that he does not have to endure what you do Andrew. I cannot for a moment even begin to contemplate how it must feel to be so removed from what the rest of us take for granted. I am petrified by the thought of being out in public visionless. I feel like I could handle deafness, maybe I could handle paraplegia, but I don’t think I could handle blindness.

      I think my fear and my brothers experience makes me aware of blind people. When I lived in Brisbane I was caught up in a platform crush at central and there was a blind girl beside me with a cane. All I could do was link arms with her, ask her to trust me and made sure she got out of harms way and on the train to Ipswich. I can’t imagine how hard it would have been for her to trust me.

      I admire you bigtime for getting out there, in the world and not letting this affect you Andew. You are stronger than I am and I don’t think it too much to ask eveyone to be a bit more considerate of others when out in the streets.

    • Bilby says:

      09:59am | 20/04/11

      “I’ve never had a guide dog, and I’m not planning on getting one in the future.  Contrary to the ideas of some, this is not a disadvantage for me.”

      This is obviously untrue, as the events as described would not have happened with a dog, so what is your objection? The phrase “just a dog” suggests a resentment (I can do this on my own, I don’t *need* a dog) which while understandable, is not doing you any favours.

    • What is it with you? says:

      10:46am | 20/04/11

      What is it with you that you must criticise instead of emphatise?

    • shenanigans says:

      11:46am | 20/04/11

      no empathy gland?

    • Bilby says:

      11:47am | 20/04/11

      I can empathise with person in a shitty situation, but I can’t empathise with someone that discards a better solution in favor of complaining that the one they chose doesn’t work. How many times does one have to have the same thing happen before taking steps to avoid it? That’s not smart, that’s just pig headed.

    • Garry says:

      01:49pm | 20/04/11

      Who says a dog is an advantage for every visually impaired person? More visible certainly, but what of the other issues, like care for the dog, the physical stature of the person to subdue an occasionally unruly dog, support, and what the person feels comfotable with etc. Plus there is the disadvantage of people patting or otherwise interfering with the dogs.

      It’s all down to the individual circumstances.

    • Edward says:

      02:21pm | 20/04/11

      With all due respect Bilby your comment highlights the your ignorance about mobility aids, guide dogs included.  From what Andrew described a guide dog would have just as much trouble in that sort of situation.  The hardest obstacles to avoid for any mobility aid is people simply because they are unpredictable.  Having a guide dog is a very big commitment and can be expensive - I’m sure you’ll happily come up with the $30K to help Andrew out.

      It sounds like Andrew would be better off with a steel cane - a few sore ankles and the morons will soon learn.  I always used to worry about hurting someone by walking into them. It seems that nowadays such concerns are unwarranted.

    • Bilby says:

      02:39pm | 20/04/11

      No doubt Garry, but AC doesn’t say that there is any particular issue preventing him from getting a dog, just that he doesn’t want one. There are plenty of reasons not to get a dog, but there are also plenty of reason to do so, and in this particular case (navigating a crowded open space) a dog would be a far better solution than a cane.

    • Bilby says:

      03:06pm | 20/04/11

      Edward - That 30k (for breeding and training) is born by the Guide Dog association and is funded by donations. There is no cost, other than the normal costs of owning a dog, to the recipient.

    • Slick says:

      10:37am | 20/04/11

      Andrew,
      hearing your story makes me sad. I really thought better of my fellow man. Please tell me the end of your story is that someone grabbed your hand and led you to the train you required?
      I cannot understand how anyone could just “bump” into you and not notice you and apologise and offer to help you? I mean I know you guys have busy lives down there, but really?

    • Kurt #1 says:

      10:57am | 20/04/11

      Kurt Fearnly is disabled (probably more than most that are recognised as disabled - my man was born without half his spine!!!) and I reckon he is a straight up and down legend, one of my all time heros.

      http://kurtfearnley.com

      Your life is what YOU make it, disabled or not.

    • Pudel says:

      11:49am | 20/04/11

      I have been visually impaired (was legally blind at one time) in the past, had surgery, got my sight back, and now heading to visually impaired again.  At some stage in the future I will be “Legally Blind”,
      I can say in the writers defence, that one of the scariest feelings is being in a crowd or unfamiliar place, and not being able to see well enough to get yourself to safety.
      I have been in tears in a Coles store whilst it was being renovated, because I needed to buy Saladas for my sons lunch box, and they had moved the biscuits.  There were seemingly no staff, and I spent 30 minutes looking for the biscuits.  As they were renovating they had no aisle directories at the end of the aisles (as I can get those close enough to my nose to read them) the ones hanging from the ceiling I could not make out.
      Eventually I stumbled across the biscuits, but by then my confidence was shattered.  With the sight I have, and I am not considered visually impaired at the moment, I hate being in an unfamialiar space and needing to find something.

    • Amy says:

      12:58pm | 20/04/11

      This is so distressing. Is this part of Sydney’s notorious rudeness? There’s a vision-impaired woman who regularly catches my tram, and fellow passengers herd her on-board, the tram driver waits extra long for her to get on and get seated, and she’s always offered a seat if none are available near the door. I can’t imagine being so rude as to bump into anyone without apologising, let alone someone with a cane or stick!

    • TQS says:

      01:48pm | 20/04/11

      You should get a dog. Not so much to guide you, but to intimdate/attack the people who rudley bump into you and break your cane.

      Requesting compassion won’t do your cause much good, most people will not hear it, and even those receptive to it will soon forget about it. But a nasty growl and a few barks will always inspire manners and respect for your personal space.

    • TracyH says:

      03:13pm | 20/04/11

      Human nature in many cases I suppose, sadly. I once had to go to a city train station and was nearly barreled over buy groups of teens. I also found the younger uni students were just as bad…an older friend was literally knocked over several times trying to get out of the lecture theater. And we both are sighted! I have less than 50% hearing, but can communicate well most of the time. I sometimes get the total shits when people ask me something, and if I politely ask for it to be repeated they roll their eyes and sigh, as if having to repeat something is sooooooooooo much of a hassle! I don’t think things will ever change…they are just getting worse. If I were blind at a train station, I would wear flashing lights and have one of those airhorns, walk along proudly blasting away, and enjoy the ensuing outrage smile

    • Will Kemp says:

      05:24pm | 20/04/11

      My first thought, on reading this, is “why the hell would you live in Sydney?” I mean, it’s a shit fight if you can see and it must be a nightmare if you can’t. There are so many other places in Australia that would be so much easier to get around in - because there are less people and because the people actually care about you.

    • mike j says:

      06:47pm | 20/04/11

      Harness that self-indulgent whinging, AC, and get about with sonar like a bat.

    • City girl says:

      08:02pm | 20/04/11

      This article is enormously self-centred.  You’re asking eryone else in the world to make way for you.  You’ve not considered whether one or more of the folk bumping into you was themselves hindered by a permanent or temporary disability, no they are just making your life difficult.  Choose a route that doesn’t require a change at Redfern.  Like the rest of us.

    • Louisa says:

      09:07pm | 20/04/11

      I do hope that you retain your eye sight CIty girl.

      I guess that you are quite young

    • It's Not All About You says:

      10:12pm | 20/04/11

      Nice suggestion, CityGirl. A shame if Redfern is the closest train station to your place of employ. Like it is for Andrew. Who I understand does not live in Sydney, incidentally, but travels there by train. To work in a full-time job and pay his own way in the world.
      I can see your point though about a crowd of thousands being full of people with the kind of permanent or temporary disability that would make you hit someone else hard enough to break a cane, and not stop to even see if you’d done any damage. I hear that disability is called selfishness. Are you a sufferer, too?

    • Richary says:

      09:51pm | 20/04/11

      My mother in her 70s has been legally blind since about 15, with retinitis pigmentosa that stabilises for a while, then worsens and so on. She is down to about 5% vision these days. While she has relied on a cane for many years she now has a dog as well, but she also lives in a country town where the peak hour crush is not a problem and she does quite well. But get her out of her normal environment and you can see just how bad her sight is.

      To go back to the earlier comments, if you offer assistance in a kind and respectful manner you are likely to get a good response. If you come in all patronising then you may not if the disabled person feels you are treating them as a lesser person.

      And Andrew, it must be horrible, I guess a spare cane in the backpack is one answer, but doesn’t solve people’s rudeness and incosideration. I am glad someone offered assistance.

    • Adrian says:

      06:22am | 21/04/11

      There is a partially sighted man who is frequently on my morning run into work on the London Underground. The underground staff make sure that he gets onto the tube and then call ahead to make sure that a staff member is waiting to guide him out of the station and across a busy road on his way to work. Couldn’t they do the same in Sydney?

    • Dave Carter says:

      08:43am | 21/04/11

      The story’s sad, the reactions from certain cowardly commenters more so.

      I think many people here have sympathy, and there’s a clear need for better CityRail service (good point from Adrian above), as well as greater awareness and understanding from the general public.

      Regarding “Over the Cripple thing” and “Bilby” I think we’re best served by ignoring the hideous trolls - their views are as irrelevant as any bigot’s.  However a comment system where we can vote down these disgraceful sentiments so they disappear would be a good idea.

    • Jane.b says:

      11:11am | 21/04/11

      Hi Andrew
      It is a terrible shame that the last few generations of Australians have not been taught common courtesy ie to stand in a bus to allow someone less able than youself to sit , to offer assistance to someone in need, to give someone like yourself some space to navigate your way.Unfortunately parenting is a lost art and we will continue to raise people who lack consideration and thought for others whilst the dollar is more important than raising fine children to adulthood. There is one thing all of the able bodied need to remember and that is that at some point in your life you will be frail and aged or perhaps disabled.
      Good on you Andrew you a courageous man to battle the crowds everyday may god bless you and keep you well

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

ToryShepherd

@Bogans_Heroes @1fatbogan Ha! So Adelaide, so creepy. Gilles St, then Unley, then Pembroke.

Paul Colgan

@joekiely just beat the crus. No sweat eh?

Paul Colgan

@bolgo101 Stick ROG in front of the posts and you still have white knuckles

Paul Colgan

@joekiely how far out was he?

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter