If Ricky Ponting scores a double century in the Boxing Day Test and announces his retirement from cricket, there would be nothing preventing the Prime Minister making Australia’s greatest run scorer the next governor-general.

Is it really that bad an idea? Pic: Getty Images

How about Kylie Minogue? She would bring international experience and contacts to the vice-regal post and is a recipient of France’s highest cultural honour, the Order of Arts and Letters. She’s talking about retiring to a “big house” with a garden. Would Government House be suitable?

While either scenario might seem absurd, it could in fact be a reality. There are no rules, no selection criteria, no formal list of qualifications, no formal vetting procedure and no restrictions for appointing a person to the highest office in the land. It is the personal gift of the prime minister, who alone makes a recommendation, which the Queen is obliged to accept.

It is not a decision of Cabinet, the government or the Parliament and the people certainly have no say. Tony Abbott could give the job to John Howard. Julia Gillard could select Paul Keating. Yet the whole process is now out of step with most other major government appointments.

The Reserve Bank governor is chosen by Cabinet.

To become a member of the ABC board you must first be nominated by the public (after the government advertises the vacancy). An independent panel assesses applicants against an official criteria and provides a written shortlist. For the position of ABC chair, the prime minister is also required to “consult” the Opposition leader. And if the person chosen was not on the shortlist the government must table a statement in Parliament.

The chairman of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission is nominated by federal Cabinet but must be approved by a majority of state and territory governments. It was difficult when some Labor states played hardball against Peter Costello’s choice to put Graeme Samuel in the job but it was open and transparent.

And there was extensive consultation before Nicola Roxon named Stephen Gageler as the latest High Court judge.

The Attorney-General spoke to her state and territory counterparts, her shadow George Brandis, the Chief Justice and other High Court justices, the chief justices of the Federal Court, Family Court and Supreme Courts as well as bar associations, law societies and deans of law schools who submitted up to five names for her to consider.

But the appointment process for the GG has been frozen in time along with the republic debate. The failed 1999 referendum proposed a president with similar powers as a governor-general but they would be chosen by a two-thirds majority of the Parliament.

At the time this was criticised as being the “politicians’ republic” that denied the people a direct say. But at least the Parliament is elected by all the people. What we have now is one person’s GG.

The vice-regal office became mired in scandal when Peter Hollingworth was chosen by Howard and then quit in 2003 after controversy about his handling of child sex abuse complaints years earlier when he was Brisbane’s Anglican archbishop.

Howard said he made sure there were “background checks” on his replacement, former SAS commander Michael Jeffery who had been “road-tested” as WA governor.

Quentin Bryce, the first woman to hold the office, had also been a state governor. Bryce has been terrific in the job and won bipartisan praise. This week Gillard said the Queen had agreed to a request to extend her term by six months to March 2014 to make sure there would be no change in the vice-regal post during the 2013 election year.

Speculation is now running about who might be the 26th GG.

If Abbott becomes PM and lives at Kirribilli House overlooking Sydney Harbour, he could seek to have his mentor, Howard, living next door in Admiralty House. The nation was reminded of Howard’s capacity to play the role of statesman during the Bali bombing anniversary.

Perhaps Abbott might choose Malcolm Turnbull, following the lead of Bob Hawke, who gave it to Bill Hayden, who he’d vanquished as leader.

There’s been speculation in the past that Turnbull could become president but this would be a twist for the monarchist Abbott, who helped beat the republic campaign led by Turnbull.

Abbott could decide to appoint the first indigenous Australian to the highest office. Noel Pearson’s name leaps to mind.

Maybe Gillard will try the tactic used by John Gorton in 1969 to get rid of his rival, Paul Hasluck. Would Kevin Rudd accept the job?

These examples may seem silly but it’s been done in the past to fix political dilemmas or reward mates.

There’s strong speculation Gillard will consider respected former Defence chief Angus Houston.

Some believe there should be formal qualifications to carry out the vital legal aspects of the job, particularly the reserve powers made famous by Sir John Kerr when he sacked Gough Whitlam on Remembrance Day 1975.

A wildcard could be Adam Gilchrist, the former wicketkeeper who is chair of the National Australia Day Council.

He has displayed great civic duty and would be non-threatening to politicians but a youthful face for the office.

There’s no shortage of interesting and worthy candidates. There should be a formal process for nominations and consultation. The final choice can still rest with the PM but if it’s good enough for the High Court, the ACCC and the ABC, then surely we deserve something more substantial than the gut feeling of one person to select the next governor-general.

Phillip Hudson is Herald Sun national political editor.

Comments on this post will close at 8pm AEST.

Most commented


Show oldest | newest first

    • acotrel says:

      05:46am | 26/10/12

      When we become a republic perhaps we could have a system whereby the Presidential position is always filled by direct promotion of the Commonwealth Ombudsman ?  That way we would always know who the heir apparent is,before the politicking starts.

    • Fiddler says:

      06:59am | 26/10/12

      When? Is there a referendum coming up? Last I saw, support for a republic has gown down, you know since the last referendum when it was soundly beaten.

    • Eskimo says:

      07:20am | 26/10/12

      If we adopt the North Korean republic model, we would also have certainty about who the next president would be.

    • Fiddler says:

      08:09am | 26/10/12

      yes, I heard that 14 Generals were just recently executed, one for “consuming alcohol during the mourning period for Kim Jong-Il”

      Wacky, wacky people

    • inamnit says:

      08:53am | 26/10/12

      I heard Abbott was going to tell us how much direct action was going to cost taxpayers today.

    • paul` says:

      12:19pm | 26/10/12

      @Fiddler The worst one was that army general. He was forced to stand in a certain position while they shot and blew him up with a mortar. It sounds like one of those comedies making fun of a dictator. Insane.

    • iansand says:

      06:01am | 26/10/12

      Sir David Flint.  You know it makes sense.

    • Tubesteak says:

      06:51am | 26/10/12

      There is one criteria in being selected to be G-G = be friends with the government that is making the choice.

      What’s that about democracy?

    • Rosie says:

      07:25am | 26/10/12

      While our first female PM is flying high on the sexist thing I suggest another female the calibre of our first female GG to be our next GG. Quentin Bryce, is nothing but a delight to watch do her duties and always heartfelt when listening to her. I love her dress sense, the woman epitomizes all the traits required for someone as the Queen’s representative. While the Queen is still there Australia should have a female like Quentin Bryce and a male when Prince Charles takes over.

    • Mother of the Rose says:

      09:16am | 26/10/12

      And here we have a woman who picks her politicians on their looks and whether they buy their clothes up the Paris end of the street.
      Why am I not surprised she is a conservative straight out of the 50’s.
      To understand how the PM gave voice to the thoughts of women all over the world would be to admit her life as a kept woman was wasted.

    • Joel M-J says:

      11:31am | 26/10/12

      @Rosie -

      I really don’t think it’s a good idea to start appointing people to positions based on their gender.

      If another woman is appointed as the next GG, then it is my sincere hope she is done so because she was the best candidate for the job, and not because she is a woman.

      Bad precedent to set Rosie. Very bad.

    • stephen says:

      07:40am | 26/10/12

      The one we have now has been in retirement since the first day she was awarded her first overseas trip.
      She’s not made one announcement that is any more sensible than has Prince Charlie.

      ps anyone would think that she was a retiring Olympic swimmer.

    • Tel says:

      08:22am | 26/10/12

      Am I the only one that gets a whiff of the stench surrounding the current appointment and extension? Think of the connections.

    • Christine says:

      08:56am | 26/10/12

      I read this article looking for the story.  I couldn’t find it.

    • Sir Osis says:

      10:47am | 26/10/12

      Considering the constitutional reserve powers that they can wield, would not someone highly experienced in constitutional law be appropriate? Like a former High Court judge? A currently or former High Court judge, with a minimum of 10 years in said position, who is elected by a 2/3s majority of a joint sitting of both houses of Parliament, with a 5 year extendable term?

    • Joel M-J says:

      11:35am | 26/10/12

      Leave the judiciary out of the legislature thanks. We separate the powers for a reason.

    • Sean says:

      12:21pm | 26/10/12

      @ Sir Osis - I think former High Court justices (and I’m thinking here specifically of either Kirby or Gummow) would make an excellent choice for a G-G. I think that mandating a High Court judge unnecessarily narrows the field of candidates. It is only in the rarest of cases that the reserve powers would need ot be wielded and you can bet your bottom dollar that there will be no shortage of legal advice justifying one position or another. In such a case, you want somebody who can make the right choice for the nation. Ex-Lawyers aren’t the only people vested with such judgment.

      @Joel M-J - 1) The G-G is the Executive, not the Legislature. 2) Obviously, appointing a sitting judge would be unconstitutional, hence why Sir Osis referred to *former* judges

    • iansand says:

      01:46pm | 26/10/12

      Gummow is an alien.  He will not serve as G-G as he will have returned to his home planet.

    • Joel M-J says:

      01:06pm | 26/10/12

      @Sean - yeah agreed, FORMER high court judges in the pool of candidates, absolutely, but let’s not limit it to that.

      I suppose you are right about the G-G as Executive as well, although there is very little about the role that is actually Executive (in the practical sense).

    • Captain Col says:

      03:47pm | 26/10/12

      Journalists and lefties love to fiddle with things that are working well already.  For goodness sake, find something important to not just change, but improve.

      Here we have a system that has produced excellent GGs for decades and the meddlers want to change it for no good reason.  No PM wants to appoint a dud.  PMs of all political persuasions want someone who will represent all Australians.  Add an imposed process to the current system and all that’s good about our present system goes out the window.

      Leave it alone!

      P.S. “Speculation is now running about who might be the 26th GG.”  Really?  Where? When?  WHY?  Someone has a fevered imagination.


Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more



Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter