It took a couple of calls to get through to Sister Mary Ellen O’Donoghue, but when I listened to her phone message I knew it was going to be worth it.

Sister Mary Ellen O'Donoghue. Picture: Lindsay Moller.

“Sorry to be so late getting back to you Lucy,” she said, “But I can’t be in two places at once.”

A sister of St Josephs, the order of nuns established by Mary MacKillop in 1866 Sister Mary Ellen is also the CEO of not-for-profit organisation Good Grief and a terrific conversationalist.

Driven to religious life by a “calling for education”, Mary Ellen says she joined the order to “make a difference” and “be around like-minded people”. 

Three decades on she says while things are a little different it’s her relationship with God and her belief in “his compassion to help all people” that continues to inspire her work. 

As one of the 6, 400 nuns in Australia today Mary Ellen is part of a community threatened with extinction. It’s hard to imagine that only thirty years ago 13, 000 women fulfilled these kinds of roles; but in the past twelve years the Sisters of St Joseph have taken a total of just three new recruits into their noviciate (nun school). 

But the reasons for the drop are fairly obvious to Mary Ellen. 

“For many people we are irrelevant,” she said. “And I think that’s because they don’t understand what we do or why we do it.” 

Nuns or “sisters” as they are more appropriately called were a normal part of life when I was growing up. My Catholic primary school backed onto a Dominican convent where it was more common than not to see a nun or two, head to toe in black and white, walking through the playground. My first piano teacher was also a nun of considerable age who wore a habit and a pair of rosary beads that would swing distractingly from the belt of her dress during lessons. 

Closer to home, my great aunt was sent to a convent at the tender age of seventeen and remained a “sister” until she passed away two years ago, at ninety years of age. And as my Grandmother tells it, back in the 1940’s, when my aunt was packed away to the convent, it was considered “normal” for at least one child among families of my great grand-parents social standing (working class, Irish Catholic immigrants) to send at least one child “off to serve God”. 

It’s a tradition that I can’t help thinking must have been like drawing the short straw because in those days a lifetime of serving God wasn’t for the faint-hearted. As a “novice” my aunt not only had to swear a life of poverty, chastity and obedience; in her first few years of service she was also forbidden to leave the convent or visit her family; a period of time that included the death of both her parents.

When I share this story with Sister Mary Ellen she assures me things have changed. And while the sisters still take vows of chastity, poverty and obedience she is quick to remind me that a literal definition of some of those values “just sounds ridiculous”.

“What it really means is that we go where we are needed. We work for good and all our “goods” (possessions) are held in common. And poverty doesn’t mean destitute,” she said. 

But what it does mean is that sisters share their income and those earning little or no money at all through their work are supported by those that do. The Sisters of St Joseph also regularly send money to colleagues working overseas in places like East Timor and Peru. 

When it comes to the vow of chastity I find myself treading cautiously. After all, it’s pretty self-explanatory right? So instead I ask Mary Ellen what she considers “the advantages” of being a “sister” in her extensive field of work. 

“I guess that comes down to the fact that as sisters we don’t have a mortgage in Sydney to worry about. Or if we are needed to work off in a rural community we don’t have the needs of a husband or children to worry about. I guess it’s a freedom to go anywhere, with no considerations,” she said. 

But it’s the vow of obedience or, “to go where the need arises” that seems to have given the most shape to Mary Ellen’s working life. 

Following through on her love for education she started working as a teacher, first in Sydney and then several years in a remote outback community in Western Australia. Four years ago she became the CEO of Good Grief, a company established by the sisters of St Joseph that runs education programs for people affected by change and loss.

It’s a position she admits twenty years ago would have been an anomaly, but now that’s no longer the case. 

“Each person comes to us with skills and talents that we can use, depending on need. We have all kinds of professionals in the order now, lawyers, social workers, nurses, doctors and teachers. But the difference is that we work in organisations that meet pressing needs,” she said. 

It had been almost a week since the announcement of Mary MacKillop’s canonisation when we spoke and I was keen to talk about some of the negativity and cynism that had arisen from sceptics, Anglican ministers and MX readers (February 22, page 20) alike. 

I found their opinions offensive and my first response was to shout “don’t people realise that it is nearly impossible to be a saint?” at the radio. In a calmer moment a bit later on, when I realised I didn’t actually know how hard it was either, I wondered what impact this negativity would have on people with faith, who believed their prayers to Mary MacKillop had in some way steered their recovery. 

As we started the interview I secretly hoped that Mary Ellen would agree with me and cajole these kinds of people for their disrespect (not particularly holy behaviour I’ll admit), but instead her response was compassionate, forthright and fair.

“I think it’s because people don’t understand sainthood, so their first response is well, what about the other good people in the world?

“Then of course there are people who question the church and this didn’t happen so much twenty or thirty years ago. Since then we’ve had all the revelations of abuse within the church, and the wars and the conflict. So will all those things in mind, rightly so,” she said. 

“But when you turn on the television every night and see violence and greed, I guess what the “saint thing” does is show there is another way to live life and that instead of treading on everyone, we can give a hand up.”

And what does she think Mary Mackillop would have made of all this “saint stuff”. 

“She would have been gobsmacked,” said Mary Ellen. “There is no way she would have expected this because she would have been just trying to help the people around her.

“At the end of the day, Mary MacKillop is a role model and we all need role models.”

Most commented

27 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • bec says:

      07:26am | 26/02/10

      What a champ. It’s a shame that the number of sisters working in the community will fall over the years, because they do a fairly A+ job making up the shortfall in education and social services.

    • Tropsmurf says:

      08:31am | 26/02/10

      A positive article about Catholicism in the media…a miracle in itself, I almost dropped dead from shock.
      Thank you Lucy and a big thanks to Sister Mary and her fellow sisters for all their hard work.

    • Patricia says:

      09:11am | 26/02/10

      What an interesting article you have written here Lucy.  It really shows the hard work of Mary McKillop being continued through the Sisters of St Joseph. A great reminder to all of us that there are people within our community who really care about the disadvantaged in this world.

    • nic says:

      10:44am | 26/02/10

      A positive article. I probably would have liked to have read more about the sacrifice and compassion that are part of a nun’s daily duties/ life.

    • noncatholic says:

      11:00am | 26/02/10

      fascinating.. and refreshing to see a positive article about this faith.

    • Harquebus says:

      11:42am | 26/02/10

      Does being a role model include the zombie worship too.

    • Julie Coker-Godson says:

      01:52pm | 26/02/10

      You really try very hard to be obnoxious don’t you Harquebus.  This is a lovely article.  If you can’t be relevant to the discussion in hand, find another blog on a subject you can be relevant to.

    • Tropsmurf says:

      02:28pm | 26/02/10

      I was just going to ignore him but nice comment Julie

    • Michael says:

      04:08pm | 26/02/10

      Harquebus, exactly what do you contribute to society champ? And to what beliefs (religious or secular) do you subscribe? So I can make a clever wise crack.

    • Pope on a Rope says:

      04:37pm | 26/02/10

      Yeah! that’s really terrible, Harquebus… they don’t worship ‘zombies’... they worship deceased Jews & then ‘miraculously’,  go on to propagate religious anti-semitism… that one REALLY got out of hand there in Eastern Europe a while back. I find this ‘gentle fatih’ quite fascinating too. I recommend reading anything you can find on; Eugencio Pacelli, Albino Luciani and Ignatious of Loyola, in particular. Did you know that Hitler (a Catholic) regarded Himmler (another Cathoilc) as ‘my Ignatius of Loyola’ and that Himmler based the SS on the Jesuits? It’s funny; the priests and nuns live as communists, while the church activley engages in fascism. There’s no ‘margin’ for the Vatican in enlightened atheism, I guess… best keep people fearful and ignorant… for 1500 years. I find people that maintain imaginary relationships with dead people and ritualistically engage in cannibalism and vampirism ‘strange’ to put it mildly.

    • Michael says:

      04:55pm | 26/02/10

      Dope on a Rope, what the hell does that primary school diatribe have anything to do with what this woman does in her life. If she devotes her life to charity and goodwill causes and really gets her hyands dirty with the margins of society, who cares if she believes she is doing it for God…or a dead Jew. The point is she is doing something for no financial gain and chooses a life of simplicity - if she was an atheist she would be a shoe-in for Australian of the Year.

      I ask you as well, Ropey, what have you ever contributed to society comparable to what this woman has, to entitle you to scorn her and her motivations? Loser.

    • Pope on the Ropes says:

      06:59pm | 26/02/10

      @Michael;
      the catholic church had centre-stage in the western world for 1500 years. As we speak they are busily ‘evangalising’ the developing world (as the developed world turns away from them) consigning poor, un-educated women to generational poverty or premature death by denying them access to birth control. The score sheet on the ‘universal’ church was returned years ago; historically one of (if not the) most corrosive, corrupt, brutal and brutalising self-interested organisations in the history of western civilsation. As an atheist I believe we need less (or no) religion, not more religious tolerance. I haven’t attacked (or even mentioned) the woman; just he outfit she works for. You might need a few glasses of ‘blood’, a couple of ‘hail Marys’ a bit of self-flagellation and a long hard think about how you speak to people who don’t share your deluded, childish fantasies and peculiar practises. What’s that shtick about ‘turning the other cheek’ the late JC used to crap on about?

    • Pope on a Rope says:

      01:38am | 27/02/10

      @Michael;

      If you found offence at the ‘primary school diatribe’, you’re really going to freak if I bother to bring out the Master’s Degree or PhD ‘big guns’ then, Mickey the Mick. The fact that the article was written about what this woman does ‘in the name of god’ and for the ‘universal’ church makes her and her church fair game, winner. I commend her activities, I just question this sort of warm’n’fuzzy PR exercise for what is, essentially, a criminal organisation. If she did her ‘good works’ for the Mafia, would they still be so ‘good’? Are ‘good works’ for ‘bad organisations’ good works at all? If the woman were an atheist, would we be hearing about her at all? No, probably not, winner. You need to ask yourself what religion in general and the ‘catholic’ church in particular, actually contributed to the human condition, since the fall of the Roman Empire? Do smatterings of individuals doing ‘good works’ at a local level in any way ameliorate the awful carnage inflicted on humanity for centuries by these sexually repressed, barbaric, superstitious, egomaniacal, dictatorial and cynically corrupted predatory perverts? No. I don’t think so either, winner.

      What do I do? I donate via direct debit to a human rights organisation, I give cash I can’t really afford directly to homeless people on the street and people collecting for various secular charities. I buy ‘The Big Issue’ when I can afford it. I’ve done volunteer work for people with substance abuse problems and I’m about to start working with disadvantaged kids. Oh and by the way, winner, not that it’s any of your business, but my early life circumstances placed me personally very squarely on the margins of society; the resultant clinical depression and substance abuse kept me there for a couple of decades. So get down off your patronising high horse and accept that increasingly people see the ‘catholic’ church and all those historically associated with it objectively and it’s not a pretty picture, winner. You don’t have to believe in fairy stories or work for corrupt self-seeking organisations to do good in this world, winner.

    • Kim says:

      01:09pm | 26/02/10

      Loved the article Lucy.  I must admit I haven’t really given much thought to sisters of the faith, but would love to learn a bit more on how they live etc.

    • Grreat artlcle says:

      02:07pm | 26/02/10

      Great article.

      I can’t help be to think , “what would St. Mary MacKillop be thinking about the religionist Middle-Eastern man.  How would she have done to the men that treat their wife, more to the pint their many wives?  The cruelty those poor woman endure.  Those men that treat her with cruelty brutality, savagery, inhumanity, barbarity of callous indifference just for their pleasure in the causing of pain and suffering.  I think you get my point. 
      It is a fairly tall order to you to answer my question, I know.  But how would she handle the argument of religion.  Their type of “holiness” is very different to our type of “holiness’.

    • Gavin says:

      04:46pm | 26/02/10

      You answered you own question. Her idea of religion is an institution of peace the way she believes God intended. The example you used earlier is in direct contrast to what she obviously believes religion to be about. You can’t tar them both with the same “religion-ist” brush just because she subscribes to her religion.

    • formersnag says:

      03:13pm | 26/02/10

      As recently as 2002 i witnessed a young catholic woman with intellectual disability being abused by an ex prostitute, who was introducing her to new boyfriends and deliberately infected her with herpes. The young woman was living in a refuge of sorts run by catholic church charitable organisations. None of the loony, left, feman-nazi social workers, or priests & nuns, wanted to know. Apparently i was lying and did not see, what i saw.

    • 6clegs says:

      03:51pm | 26/02/10

      And will the good sister advocate for those Forgotten Australians that had the misfortune to be brought up in catholic homes   ? (the st joeys sisters/brothers didn’t just get their hands on the rich kids)
      So they don’t have to go up against the traumatic in-house style of “Redress” that the church has set up. (where if they’re “really lucky” will get a paltry 2 or 3 grand ‘settlement’)

      And will she advocate for her church to make a significant Apology?

      With so much bad press ‘the good sister’s” church has had nationally this past fortnight, it was just a matter of time before pel trotted out a ‘friendly face’ for a soft n fuzzy story.

      If the Catholic Church was serious about caring about what happened to those they were suposed to be caring for, it, wouldn’t hide behind that disgusting (& slightly suss) court ruling that decided the institution wasn’t to blame for all the pedos it hired !

      IMO the CC is too stupid to realise that if it genuinely owned what happened that its profile would actually gain. But greedy church princes will never let that happen. (*waves-to-georgy*)

      How, in the 21st century, any woman of ethics- & that would make it in the real world - can work for that patronising & male dominated institution?

      It just leaves me gobsmacked.

    • Gavin says:

      05:00pm | 26/02/10

      She does it for God, not the institution itself. There is a difference if you think hard about it. Really, the institution just provides her with the means to live. God is her motivation and if that is the case, congratulate her for the practical humanistic things she does. She doesn’t deserve your scorn.

    • 6clegs says:

      11:44am | 27/02/10

      “Gavin” - the thousands of abused innocent children didn’t deserve the catholic churches “scorn”, either. The Sister is at least an adult, one that has chosen to be there. wink

      You carry on sticking ya head in the sand if that’s what works for you. It won’t change the documented (modern) history, or make the lives of those Abused (when) Innocent children better, but you go for it.

    • Sad part of it all says:

      04:35pm | 26/02/10

      Thanks 6clegs, 
      Speculation has it: that they (nuns) to the point of starvation due to the Priest rulings, even to the handing out of food.

      Still I can’t comprehend any order helping out help to countries that silently practice somody, women must cover up as a sign of holy obedience, and all the rest of what we would look at evil.  This I do not understand.

    • SK says:

      04:58pm | 26/02/10

      A family friend was given a 10% chance of surviving brain surgery and pulled through. We live in a small rural town where the church community she is involved with really pulled through donating food and coming to sit with her as she cannot be left alone due to her propensity to have seisures.

      Every so often a nun will drop by to catch up and allow our friend to maintain a tangible link to the church which is a high priority in her life but not always a physical one depending on whether she’s having a good week or a bad week while recovering.

      We view her survival at all as nothing short of miraculous, but the truly enlightening thing about the whole experience to a Gen Y observer has been the selfless, gentle role the Catholic Church has played in alleviating her suffering. I had no idea that nuns performed this kind of service: my vision of a nun was someone who stuck to their ivory tower (or seminary) or taught in Catholic schools. It certainly updated my vision of the Church and was a great reminder that while the hierarchy in the church can be somewhat obfuscating (whether ‘dwelling crankily on old wounds’ or harming those in their care) a church is comprised of its people, who are predominantly good and try to be better.

      This was a really lovely article. Thank you for it.

    • Mum of lots says:

      06:54pm | 26/02/10

      Thank you, all we hear are is how terrible the Catholic Church is. How stupid and gullible it’s followers are. Or if not, they are sexual predators.  As Sk said, the church is comprised of people, humans with a desire to good and be better to others.The Church is based on Christ’s teachings. As with all institutions you get the blood suckers, the perverts and the money makers. Show me an insitution without any of those.

    • simon says:

      09:50pm | 26/02/10

      Probably the best article i have ever read on The Punch. Personal, entertaining and a wonderfull insight into what appears to be a dissapearing world.

    • Nick Carroll says:

      09:53pm | 26/02/10

      I really enjoyed reading that. Very personal!

    • Peolpe want more proof. says:

      10:41am | 27/02/10

      SK Yes indeed,  I do believe in the power of unexplained miracle that could only be considered to be the work of a divine agency. Only just recently the media have covers a story about ‘the weeping walls’.  I believe that if such god liked events happen they should be investigated by the full force and scientific/medial and legal forces.  This would satisfy the non-believers.  Thank-you

    • rkay says:

      11:00pm | 17/10/10

      Sr Mary Ellen was my high school principal, and her answers in this article is exactly how i remember her. She is a wonderful person and a truly inspiration person to the ones in need and our community. Thank you for sharing this piece of work.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

ToryShepherd

@KateEllisMP I believe you! Kid does naplan tests at home for fun. Geez.

Paul Colgan

Wow... Vines embedded here show the incredible scale of the destruction in Oklahoma City http://t.co/EWoXgE03A2

Anthony Sharwood

An Oklahoma radio station called "The Twister", complete with tornado logo, urges residents to pray http://t.co/U2Cj8vIgdz

ToryShepherd

@KateEllisMP asks kids at prospect what their fave thing is. NAPLAN, says one. Surely a plant!!!

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter