Collingwood are into a Grand Final.

Up yers! Photo: Craig Borrow

If you’re a Collingwood supporter, read that line again, and let it sink in. If you’re not a Collingwood supporter, read that line again, and suck it up. 

The lot of you have grown more obnoxious and annoying than anything our supporters could dish up. Nearly 40,000 people have joined some nonsense Facebook event: “The Day Collingwood Choke”. Their M.O.? “Collingwood are shit and we hate you.”

What a pack of sooks.

Growing up, I never “got” the world’s anti-Collingwood sentiment. Like every bright-eyed Australian kid, I chose a team and a team chose me.

I got smug eye-rolls every time I told people which team I went for. It was like a goddamn conspiracy. Grown men would explain to me how feral my fellow supporters were, and tried to shove some rubbish about “Colliwobbles” down my throat.

As a five-year-old, I didn’t understand why people were kicking us while we were down. After attending my first AFL match in 1995, Collingwood didn’t make the finals for seven years. Winning a game felt like Christmas. Why were they still hating on us?

My mother routinely blamed my father for putting me onto a “loser team”, but I always had a fond attraction for the underdog. The diamond in the rough.

I’ve lived through a lot of pain as a Collingwood supporter. I’ve seen two losing Grand Finals—one tantalisingly close, the other humiliatingly far—and spent the turn of the millennium watching our archrival pummel us into the 2000s.

I’ve grown into a cynical, biased and occasionally obnoxious AFL fan. Self-fulfilling prophecy and whatnot.

But I still vehemently argue that my club has come a long way: for all the jokes, few know that Collingwood’s most infamous supporter, Joffa Corfe, is a welfare worker who devotes much of his free time to working with indigenous and underprivileged communities, and has spent the better part of five years fundraising for the Epilepsy Foundation of Victoria.

The club has gone a long way to atoning for its shameful history with racial incidents—the most notable of which saw indigenous St Kilda player Nicky Winmar respond to overt crowd racism from Collingwood supporters by lifting his jumper and boldly pointing to his skin. Leon Davis became the first indigenous player to play 100, then 200 games for the club, whilst Collingwood were the only club to take a punt on Harry O’Brien by taking him in the 2004 rookie draft, O’Brien becoming the league’s first Brazilian player, and going All-Australian this year.

In 2010, everything is falling into place nicely—Collingwood finished 1st, disposed of each of the top teams during the regular season, and secured a place in the Grand Final via a preliminary final belting of one of the best teams of the past decade.

I’m still bloody nervous.

Collingwood play free-flowing, fast, attacking football, the antithesis of St Kilda’s infamously negative footy. When it comes to playing the best, the Saints know a sure way to win—ugly: they’ve averaged less than 10 goals against Top 4 sides this year, despite a 5-1 winning record. They know how to strangle a game to victory.

Contrary to the insistence of the bookies (who have installed the Pies as heavy favourites), this Grand Final is a genuine 50/50. The game plans of the two finalists are polar opposites, and the side that holds its nerve under duress and dictates the tempo of the game will win.

To all of you on the fence, there’s a lot to like about the Pies: an exhilarating game plan, a coach chasing glory in his twilight years, overwhelming youth (more than a quarter of Collingwood’s Grand Final team will enter with less than 50 games of experience), and new recruit Luke Ball, who will face-off against the club that benched him for the final quarter last year’s Grand Final, despite a near best-on-ground performance to half time.

But all of this reasonable talk is probably futile. Haters will hate, and what good is any story without an antagonist?

Go Pies, go Mick, go Eddie, and stuff the rest of you.

Don’t miss: Get The Punch in your inbox every day

Get The Punch on Facebook

91 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • T.Chong says:

      06:05am | 23/09/10

      The doubters , and sneerers can say what they like, it just makes the Chosen Few, ( ‘Pies supporters) more resolute to see this season to its preordained Collingwood victory.
      The gnashing of teeth, and tearing asunder of garments by St Kilda, and other supporters will be but music to our ears.

    • Dan says:

      09:15am | 23/09/10

      No victory is preordained. Geelong learned that in 2008.

    • Tom says:

      04:06pm | 23/09/10

      St Kilda fans “cry ice instead of tears” nowadays.
      No gnashing of teeth. Win, lose or draw, we are proud of our team.

    • James says:

      06:09am | 23/09/10

      Hook, line & sinker.
      —-
      I put it to you that the ‘hate’ towards collingwood is directly proportionate to the amount of fans that they have: with more fans there are more people to criticise and more occassions to do so.

      (I suggest that instead of having a sook towards ‘collingwood haters’ you have a go at your fellow fans about their disgraceful one sided support, that results in so many of them abusing collingwood players, and walking away when they are losing)

    • Don says:

      12:20pm | 23/09/10

      Can’t help but note that you don’t reveal whom you barrack for…
      The Pies didn’t play a final for 7 odd years and STILL had fans turning up in greater numbers than almost all other teams.
      And the fans leaving the stadium that you talk about are actually Essendon, Carlton, and even Geelong fans on Friday night just gone. Couldn’t stay to acknowledge the end of their era.
      I like to think of myself as a modern supporter. Respectful in defeat, humble in victory. But it’s people like you that make me want to dispense of that and - should we be fortunate enough to be victorious on Saturday - tell you where it’s at. Regardless of the result I will try to remain pragmatic and I hope the best side wins on the day.

    • Robbo says:

      09:55am | 24/09/10

      The deafening and nearly universally stated hatred of Collingwood is somewhat self fulfilling in that it elicits a siege mentality.  Chicken or the egg?

      I’m sure that there is some logic to it (James suggests something) but by far and away the majority of justifications given are irrational and hysteric.  In the end only serves to ‘poke the dog with a stick’.  Perhaps this is their true intent, having few other opportunities to feel superior elsewhere in their lives.  Collingwood, topping the ladder and (with a decent chance of) winning a premiership would severely injure this position.

      (James on your last point, like we’ve never heard fans of any team turn on their own when they are down.)

    • Max Vaunted says:

      06:22am | 23/09/10

      The two best things about Collingwood supporters are their desperate siege mentality and the massive chips on their shoulders. “Suck it up”, eh? “Pack of sooks”, eh? Are they taking it seriously, or what? That’s precisely what makes it all so interesting, and also why it’s always so attractive when they lose.

      Get a life Adam, no one hates you. You’re funny, that’s all.

    • Pork says:

      09:58am | 23/09/10

      Max Vaunted,
      Taunting the people that always lose and yet get taunted and ridiculed by all the others isn’t funny.  It is obnoxious.  It is rude.  It is bullying. It creates siege mentalities.
      We do take it seriously and you are right, what drives us berserk is jerks like you revving up the situation when you don’t really care and only turn up when your side is winning.
      Football isn’t a matter of life and death.  It is far more important than that.
      Like Adam says: Go and get stuffed.

    • Saint Septembermus says:

      06:30am | 23/09/10

      Why are you worried about the Saints mate,the premiership,s a cakewalk for the good old Collingwood. This is your problem,in the arrogance of the theme song,going the early crow is the cardinal sin in sport,all this does is inspire the opposition to rise above mere mortality and play the game of their life,so in a battle between sinners and saints,the footy gods will favour the beatified,but there is always next year, in your dreams.

    • tuccaboy says:

      07:10am | 23/09/10

      Maybe it’s not Collingwood they hate - maybe, just maybe, it’s Chairman Eddie Maguire who irritates people.

    • ILR says:

      01:19pm | 23/09/10

      You don’t mean the chairman of “Eddiewood” do you?!

    • Pork says:

      01:53pm | 23/09/10

      Tuccaboy, the Collingwood haters predate Eddie’s reign by quite a bit.
      ILR, Go and get stuffed.
      I note that you don’t say who you support.
      BTW I worked at the Nine Network while Eddie was still on the Footy Show.  When the doors closed and the public couldn’t see the celebrities could often act appallingly and treat staff like crap.  Happened all the time.
      My four experiences around Eddie in this situation found him to be a friendly and likeable guy, not at all a primadonna.  He was even nice to the Carlton supporters I worked with.
      I don’t care that he irritates you.  I don’t care that you don’t like him.  Our club has never run so well.
      So I reiterate, Go and get stuffed.

    • Dan says:

      08:57pm | 23/09/10

      You’re right Pork, my hatred for Collingwood does predate Eddie’s reign and I make no apologies for that. You don’t like that people hate Collingwood? Then barrack for another club.

      I barrack for Melbourne and I will continue to hate Collingwood, and the arrogant/“Born to win” mentality that many supporters have (news flash, you are not entitled to the premiership at all) as well as the fact that so many Collingwood supporters I have had the experience of encountering at the football have been abusive.

      Attacking Collingwood for losing may be bullying, may be rude and may be obnoxious, but it’s fun!

      St Kilda by one point!!!

    • TimB says:

      07:50am | 23/09/10

      Geeze. As a Western Sydney bred Rugby League fan I don’t follow AFL. But reading the various recent Punch articles about the upcoming AFL GF….

      If the “poor us” whining from Adam, and the “Born to Win” arrogance from Chongy is the typical attitude of Collingwood supporters….  then they deserve all the hate they get from the rest of the AFL crowd.

      Nothing like a little Schadenfreude to make the football enjoyable. Go St Kilda smile

    • Pork says:

      10:01am | 23/09/10

      Go and get stuffed.

    • ILR says:

      01:23pm | 23/09/10

      Oh, good comeback Pottsy!

    • Pork says:

      02:05pm | 23/09/10

      ILR, do you really think that TimB’s addition to this debate deserved anything more than “Go and get stuffed.”?!?!
      Which part?  The bit where he says he doesn’t follow the game, have a side or care about it?  Or the part where he professes to know what is “typical” of Collingwood supporters in spite of the above admission of total ignorance.
      Or maybe the “Born to win” analysis he somehow gets from T. Chongs comments that further underline that he has no idea what the hell he is talking about?
      Or should I engage him on the irony of him raising the very thing that galvanises all us ‘Pies supporters - the shameful joy of the Collingwood haters?
      I thought “why would I waste my time on such a moron.  I’ll take Adam’s advice and tell him to Go and get stuffed.”
      I reckon I was spot on in my chosen approach.
      But if you want I’ll engage you in an academic discussion on the banality and the lack of character that informs your attitude of hating Collingwood.  I am gainfully employed, have all my own teeth and a University education.
      Lets start by you telling us all just who you support and why they are so much better than The Collingwood Football Club.
      Alternatively you can go and get stuffed.

    • ILR says:

      04:27pm | 23/09/10

      Actually I did reply earlier but the moderator (a Collingwood supporter perhaps?) saw fit to not publish my response.  If the best you can come up with is “go and get stuffed” and “moron” I assume your University education must somewhat basic, or even incomplete.  And anyway, a university education means jacks**t.  It does not make one superior to anyone else as you rather untacitly imply in your previous diatribe.  Or has all the ribbing over the years about Collingwood supporters actually got to you?  But I begin to digress.  As per my unpublished reply, like other some contributors I don’t give, to use parlance you’ll understand, a rat’s a**e about the game.  Your assumption that all and sundry responding to this blog must “obviously” support an AFL side is laughable at best. Bottom line Porksy - show us your educational standard and aim to shoot the message, not the messenger, especially with lines like “go and get stuffed” and “moron”.  Furthermore answer me this.  If the AFL (or any other professional sport where someone is paid massive sums for harrassing a bit of pigskin) suddenly disappeared overnight would society be worse off?  Yes, I digress again.

    • TimB says:

      07:21pm | 23/09/10

      You know Pork Pie, I was ignoring this because I figured the touchy and unoriginal response rather confirmed my thoughts, no need for me to rub it in further. But you felt the need to try and explain yourself so…

      A couple of points:

      Don’t brag about your university education. I mean you apparently can’t see how the arrogant phrase “preordained Collingwood victory” can be construed as a “Born to win” mentality. And you seem to think my “Schadenfreude” comment is ironic, showing you don’t actually understand what irony is.
      So clearly your much touted education hasn’t done you any favours.

      Also your response doesn’t make you “spot on” it makes you a lemming, blindly following Adam’s lead. A little originality in your response would be nice.

      And my final piece of advice Pork Pie- Lighten up before you give yourself a stroke or something. You take things this team rivalry thing (one of the best parts of football) way too seriously and that’s the bloody point. If you can’t handle it, maybe you shouldn’t watch.

    • Alfred Deakin says:

      07:58am | 23/09/10

      St.Kilda have won one (1966) out of six (1913, 1965, 1966, 1971, 1997, 2009) Grand Finals. I barrack for the Saints but I don’t hate Collingwood, they are just another team.


      On “winning ugly” - everyone must remember how disappointed Swans fans were after they “won ugly” against West Coast in 2005 to break a 72 year Premiership drought!

    • Shifter says:

      12:12pm | 23/09/10

      Someone had to bring that up. Bloody umpires… when someone grabs a handful of jumper in a marking contest pay the damn free kick! Sampi was robbed!

      Where was I, oh yes… carn the saints! I for one can live without the smug arrogance of Collingwood fans (Joffa), players (Didak) and officials (Maguire).

    • Pork says:

      02:21pm | 23/09/10

      On this point, seriously go and have a look at the picture of the Barry mark.  Leaping Leo has his eyes closed.  Keneally is literally dragging Sampi down out of the contest and Robert-thomson is taking out Judd.
      Two clear free kicks, both of which should have been awarded, 25 metres out on a slight angle…  Robbery.
      Like Sammy Mitchell on Paul Chapman in the 2008 GF.

    • Swans Fan says:

      07:02pm | 23/09/10

      Swans never ‘won ugly’. In fact, West Coast, the follwing year ‘won ugly’. Swans deserved it - West Coast, some of their players play ‘ugly’.  And, yes, I can say we were robbed 06, I was there! How many of you were
      there? How many of West Coast players should have been tehre - not many. Judd, for his sake, was lucky to move to Carlton, and good on him for winning the Brownlow. The matches I have seen him in, he has played well. I wouldn’t mind if Swans stole him form Carlton when his contract is up.

      Also, Pork, are you on this point, what side are you supporting? I am not sure how to take your comment.

    • Dan says:

      08:02pm | 23/09/10

      Swas Fan, I watched the 2006 GF (why does it matter whether we were there or not?) and in no way were you robbed. WCE deserved to win fair and square and they played beautiful footy.

      “How many of West Coast players should have been tehre - not many.”

      Are you talking about drugs, because there is no evidence to suggest that any Eagle took performance enhancing drugs. You lost to a better team. Just accept it.

    • iansand says:

      08:19am | 23/09/10

      Just a Collingwood supporter with a ghost writer.  Nothing to see here.  Move along folks.

    • Jack Palm says:

      08:43am | 23/09/10

      My mob - the Dons,a fairly ordinary side - rolled St.Kilda twice during the 2010 season. Collingwood on the other hand thrashed Essendon twice. No contest - The Maggies by heaps.

    • Pete the footy fan... says:

      08:48am | 23/09/10

      Adam, no one gives a crap about Joffa being a welfare worker, he’s just another Collingwood toss-bag when he walks into the ground. Please God we see the now famous Eddie face again about 5:00 PM on Saturday arvo…you know the one Adam, the ‘we was robbed’, ‘we shoulda won’, ‘it’s not fair face’ that Eddie trotted out on Brownlow night…that’s partly why no one likes you blokes…the born to win mentality gives us the sh*ts.

    • bruce says:

      01:10pm | 23/09/10

      Well said Pete

    • Collingwood Dave says:

      09:12am | 23/09/10

      So Saint Septembermus it’s the arrogance in the theme song that upsets you? The fact that the SEVENTH line of the song mentions the word Premiership. What do you think of Geelong’s theme song claiming to be the “Greatest Team of All” in the SECOND line, or the Bomber’s theme song claiming to “win the Premiership Flag” in the SECOND line. Is it REALLY the theme song that bothers you, or is that just the p***weak excuse you’ve come up with to justify your hatred?

    • Luckycanuck says:

      09:26am | 23/09/10

      There is a theory that any sport was always best when you were 11 and the team you supported at that age is the team you will always be tribally bound to.  (For the record, the 1989 Stanley Cup Champion Calgary Flames are the best NHL team ever.  Way better than those damn whinging crybaby Oilers.)

      But I digress, I moved to Australia from Canada five years ago so that tribalism hasn’t rubbed off on me they way it has on many of you.  I’ve never quite understood why people seem to hate Collingwood so much.

      So I will be supporting the Pies this weekend.  I’ve enjoyed watching them play this year, and if nothing else, I enjoy people’s reactions when I tell them.  Apparently it would bother some people less if I was a serial killer or a convicted war criminal.

    • Graham S says:

      10:36am | 23/09/10

      Luckycanuck, you must have missed the great Montreal Canadiens of the late ‘50’s &The; Ice King, Gordie Howe’s Red Wings
      GO SAINTS

    • Tails says:

      09:29am | 23/09/10

      Saint Kilda have won three more wooden spoons than Collingwood has lost Grand Finals.

      Footy is a religion. Hating Collingwood and their supporters is religious vilification. Fact.

    • Hamish says:

      11:36am | 23/09/10

      Yeah and if you guys win on Saturday I think we’ll need to have an Inquisition…

    • Markus says:

      09:31am | 23/09/10

      People don’t hate Collingwood (Eddie Maguire excluded).
      Just that in terms of any team fanbase, they are by far the easiest to bait.
      Ridiculing Collingwood is fun, because you know that fans will bite 100% of the time.
      This article case in point.

    • Unfashionable Hawk says:

      11:51am | 23/09/10

      Spot on Markus. No one could seriously hate a team that has won the flag only two times in sixty odd years. Better fun than trolling!

    • Don says:

      12:29pm | 23/09/10

      Uhhhhh, that’d be because we have been down so much and kicked HARD. It is sad. Sad that people find so much amusement in making other unsuccessful people feel so awful. Think about it.

    • Terry says:

      09:50am | 23/09/10

      Well I hope it goes well for you on Saturday Adam. While not being completely versed on AFL history, I can empathise with your situation; the team I support in the NRL (The Sydney Roosters) has a similar maligned relationship with the other fans of the code.

      I like the “Us vs Them” mentaility anyway mate. Everyone else against you will only make your victory on Saturday so much sweeter.

    • John Glaister says:

      09:52am | 23/09/10

      My older brorther was a “Pies” supporter. I followed the “Dees”. He was Murray Wiedeman and I was Ron Barrassi in the back yard. Then Barrassi did the unforgiveable- he moved to Carleton. I cried, he laughed. I hate Collingwood-always have, always will. Go the Saints.
      String

    • Jan says:

      09:59am | 23/09/10

      It’s about time people gave up the petty attitudes and got on with watching and enjoying the game; it’s going to be a great one.  There are two of the best teams playing.  I have been a Collingwood supporter all my life and whatever the outcome they deserve respect for being in the finals, the same as St. Kilda.  I sincerely hope Leon Davis makes the team as he has worked tirelessly for the Club for years and really deserves a Premiership medal.
      Go Maggies!

    • iansand says:

      11:13am | 23/09/10

      There is no Grand Final that is not improved by hating one of the participants.

    • Joolz says:

      12:00pm | 23/09/10

      Lookie here, Pollyanna. Football is war with a ball. Australia is a peaceful nation because we put our tribal rivalries into our teams.

      I’m from Qld so I don’t really get into GFD, but I get it. It is love and hate, loyalty and support. It is marvelous. And I won’t have anyone water down the feud by saying vote teams are great.

      Garn the pies!

    • bullwinkle says:

      10:06am | 23/09/10

      See, my problem with this is that all of us non-Pies supporters don’t really need a reason to hate the Pies. We just do. End of story.

      Although I must admit that the line “Collingwood are shit and we hate you” has a certain je n’est sais pas. And a certain petulant boof headed president adds a bit to the level of hatred.

    • The White Knight says:

      10:25am | 23/09/10

      Where has this dislike for Collingwood F/C come from ?  maybe it’s a dislike of their feral supporters and not the club….......

    • Dan says:

      01:46pm | 23/09/10

      Exactly! :D I’m a Melbourne supporter, and Collingwood are our traditional rivals, however much of my hatred stems from encounters with Collingwood fans.

      Go Saints!!!!!

    • James says:

      10:25am | 23/09/10

      I love that people hate us. I find it amazing that people with absolutely no affiliation with a team can actually FEEL something for them…
      I sometimes wonder if supporters of perennial underdogs (Bulldogs, Freo, Nth Melbourne etc) ever feel offended that people out there actually list them as their ‘second-favourite’ team?
      I’d hate nothing more than to be that pitied.
      I’ll take hated with a passion any day!
      GO PIES!!!

    • Shane says:

      12:15pm | 23/09/10

      Perfect attitude, James.

      As a long suffering Dogs fan, nothing offends me more than being told we’re their second favourite team… usually because it’s accompanied by some slur about us never being a real threat! I would much rather bear the brunt of jealousy fueled hatred levelled at you any day…

      So, in a sign of solidarity, and respect of this years’ best performing team (by a country mile), I have one thing to say… GO PIES!!!!

    • A Dose of Reality says:

      10:26am | 23/09/10

      Let’s see…...... what’s to hate?

      1 - the fact that the wobbles get 18 home games a year at least (when you play at your home oval, in front of your home crowd it is a home game - regardless of who it is “nominated” to be an away game is when you travel).

      2 - the draw is rigged so that the wobbles opponents invariably have played an away game that has taken them to either Perth of the gabba the week before.

      3 - the fact that they are not forced to wear some silly “clash” jumper.

      4 - they complain that they play too many ‘away games” (see point 2)

      5 - They benefit from the Father-son” rule, unavailable to the Crows, port, west Coast nor to Fremantle.

      6 - The Draw is rigged so as to benefit the wobbles in the prime time spots (actively promoting them).

      7 - With some exceptions, the Draw is rigged so the wobbles usually get an extra day’s rest than their next opponent (and if the wobbles get a days lass rest - see point 2).

      8 - the draw is rigged so that the wobbles never get a shit spot (say, lunch time on mother’s day!)

      9 - how they actively try to imitate port adelaide (but just can’t win premierships)

      10 - the idiocy in stopping port from also wearing black and white (there are carlton, Geelong, North melb who all wear blue and white, why so precious - or is it simply because port, SANFL, is an older and more successful club).

      11 - the fact that the VaFL allows/facilitate points 11, 8, 7, 6, 5, 3, 2, 1.

      12 - the fact they think the rest of Australian Football is a “bunch of sooks” when in fact they are the club with the worst GF history in almost any league (work it out - 40 lost - this means that others were the winners).

      13 - they go on (and on and on…) about “tradition” and yet do not acknowledge the tradition of other clubs/competitions.

      Well that’s 5 minutes worth….. I’m bored…. and I haven’t even started on Eddie Sidchrome!!!!!

    • Kelly says:

      12:02pm | 23/09/10

      That seems like a completely fair, unbiased, realistic assessment of the situation… I assume your accusations of “rigging” are coming from a reliable source? Like the voices in your head? It’s OK… I completely believe they’re secret radio transmissions your fillings are picking up…

      And I really admire your ability to stretch three ill-informed, completely illogical, disturbingly paranoid theories into 13 “reasons”... Well done on that. Good to see the South Australian education system is turning out high-quality graduates.

      And you wonder why you’re branded as a “sook”... Idiot!

    • Dennis says:

      12:15pm | 23/09/10

      All of that rubbish about fixturing is a result of 15 other clubs requesting games against Collingwood at the MCG to maximise their home gate takings.

      You can’t have it both ways.

    • annewilo says:

      10:35am | 23/09/10

      Lovely story Adam.
      Bullwinkle, very well done on babblefish with the French quote.
      My story, a Collingwood die hard, week to week supporter, who was educated at the same school and year as Caroline Wilson. Our past history of grass roots football and the media perception that all Collingwood Supporters need Dentistry or police checks just make us true believers laugh. Think and say what you will, it will not hurt us.
      To use a religious analogy and that is what I believe football has taken a liking to in Melbourne, Jesus was mocked when he associated with the thieves and the downtroden. I’m not saying we are bigger than Jesus, like Lennon, but for us we believe in us and therefore we are great.
      All football clubs came from a basis of grass roots. We just spend our lives now trying to reject this concept because we are in the main the middle class norm.
      Why do we in Australia see the need to knock great achievers and achievement? Cannot people respect and admire great talent. No, they need to be followers mentality and go with the masses, chanting, I hate Collingwood because…....
      To the Collingwood team. I am so happy to you have given me a chance to see us in a Grand Final. I was not given too long when I was first diagnosed with my illness in 2008. But watching you take the field and triumph in adversity, keeps giving me hope for victory and happiness.

    • bullwinkle says:

      03:04pm | 23/09/10

      4 years of French at secondary school. I’m also word perfect on the
      French national anthem.

    • Cake Walker says:

      10:36am | 23/09/10

      Your comment: HaHa Ha you read the article
      and now you are reading the comments,
      then you will want to complain that there is too much media on Collingwood,
      forcing you to then comment ’ can’t bear to see Collingwood win, ...
      so Go Saints!’,
      even though your team isn’t good enough to be there
      as if any of us gave a rat’s tossbag that YOU hate Collingwood
      and still you wonder why the Pies army just get bigger and stronger.

      To all you Saints supporters, sorry that we have to beat you to win it.  You have been worthy for several seasons now.  But win it we will.  Nothing personal mind.

    • Gochuckawobbly says:

      11:19am | 23/09/10

      A bit too precious, Adam.
      The right attitude is that adopted by “Mighty Millwall from the Den”.
      “No-one likes us. We don’t care!”

    • The White Knight says:

      11:59am | 23/09/10

      Well if Collingwood get beaten on Saturday the Victorian Government had better have the police riot squad ready and on hand.

    • Lauren says:

      01:29pm | 23/09/10

      Saints fans would have to watch out - Brumby is a Pies supporter too.

    • Geoff says:

      04:01pm | 24/09/10

      Better get 2 riot sqauds if the win.

    • james may says:

      12:06pm | 23/09/10

      I’m a Hawks supporter but I find myself going for Collingwood on Saturday. I don’t know why but I want them to win. I usually can’t stand Collingwood winning games but I think they deserve it. They smashed the dirty Geelong and anyone who smashes Geelong deserves the cup (like Hawthorn in 2008).

    • fairsfair says:

      01:04pm | 23/09/10

      my biggest concern - the photo.

      Who tries to raise awareness for epilepsy with a large brighly coloured, shape shifting yellow sequin number?

      Seizure anyone?

    • Lauren says:

      01:24pm | 23/09/10

      Haters are gonna hate.

      I’m use to it, being both a ‘Pies and a Man. United supporter.

      And I prefer it that way. Nothing better than taking the train back to Essendon station after a good Anzac Day clash flogging like this year. smile

      Go ‘Pies.

    • Badger says:

      02:10pm | 23/09/10

      To me all Pies Supporters are Dungers from Dungersrville, I will rejoice with glee when they loose on Sat when the Mighty Saints Come Marching In by 1 point, that would rub it in for good for me.

    • ILR says:

      04:31pm | 23/09/10

      Double whammy - Collingwobblers AND Manure.  You really let the media tell you who to support don’t you.

      Now if you supported the mighty Scunners!

    • Geoff says:

      01:47pm | 23/09/10

      I am sure most Collingwood haters don’t actually know why they hate Collingwood.  They are mainly just a mindless bunch of twats wandering around bumping into each other wishing it is their team in the G.F.
      When it is all over, win lose or draw, these same mindless twats will be waiting in anticipation for their team to play the Pies next year, because that is the biggest crowd they are goinig to get all season.  Go Pies.

    • Ben Haslem says:

      02:23pm | 23/09/10

      Unless you followed Collingwood as a kid in the 70s, you have no idea. I approach Saturday afternoon with utter dread.

    • Brad Coward says:

      02:41pm | 23/09/10

      Collingwood….ugh !!!!!  My dislike for the football team has something to do with my passionate loathing of Eddie Mcguire.  Go the Saints this Saturday, but only because Brisbane and Hawthorne didn’t get there.

    • Matt says:

      03:04pm | 23/09/10

      A considered rebuttal from a pies fan is choosing not to stab someone!

    • Jason says:

      03:17pm | 23/09/10

      It’s like Apple Macs and iPhones.  I don’t mind the products but can’t stand the users.  Anyone who feels compelled to tell everyone else how good they are all the time just annoys.

    • Joolz says:

      06:38pm | 23/09/10

      Truth sucks, huh?

    • Shane From Melbourne says:

      03:31pm | 23/09/10

      Having all those Collingwood supporters in the MCG on Saturday will raise the average IQ of everywhere else in Victoria for the afternoon…...

    • Carrin G Bush says:

      04:22pm | 23/09/10

      Gee haven’t heard that one before.  How about a statewide density map of teeth?  The crime statistics of stolen cars in the carpark maybe?
      Seems like you could do with a raising of IQ out your way Shane
      oh yeah and some new material too.

    • Shane From Melbourne says:

      05:01pm | 23/09/10

      @Carrin- Why would I need new material? Everyone gets a lot of mileage out of anti-Collingwood jokes…..

    • Lewy says:

      03:56pm | 23/09/10

      People who cant understand the hatred of Collingwood really need to contact a proctologist for an urgent head removal procedure. This is a club who got there last star recruit by undermining the draft system, then Lord Farqwad (Eddie McGuire) patted himself on the back for ending the “rorts” interstate clubs got. They played a dirty brand of football in early 00’s and thought they were the ordained “Premiers” and the Lions were a pack of cheats. And thats just the score in the last decade.

      “The only thing better than winning a Grand Final is seeing Collingwood lose one” Leigh Matthews Coach of the 1990 Premiership Magpies.

      “I’m leaving Brisbane for a club with finals prspects” Nathan Ugly Duckling 1994

    • Adam Blencowe says:

      04:14pm | 23/09/10

      Haters.

      Collingwood deserves the flag for being the best team all year.

      Granted the Saints fared well without their best player for much of the year, look at the last time they played.

      While the Saints will be driven by last year’s defeat, the pies don’t lack motivation. I also consider myself a member of the stolen generation, Anthony Rocca definitely kicked a goal which was given a point late in the 2002 GF.

    • spinner says:

      04:38pm | 23/09/10

      come now dennis and you other poor suffering pies fans take note despite the cries of how you are misunderstood and hard done by this year pies played 4 games outside of victoria oh so so many, eddie everywhere was beside himself in grief, would have thought he would have enjoyed the extra frequent flyer points, the saints played 8 times outside victoria, twice to perth, twice to adelaide, once to brisbane and once to sydney, not even a whisper about horrid travel was it the AFL trying for a level playing field i wait for the year pies do play 8 games outside victoria but i wont hold my breath, however i will say carn the saints

    • Calm In Spinner says:

      06:00pm | 23/09/10

      What! no gig for the Saints at Manuka or Aurora. No wonder you’re cranky.

    • Geoff says:

      08:04am | 24/09/10

      And loving it.

    • spinner says:

      01:57pm | 24/09/10

      i think the comment was no complains from the saints or are you trying to prove that no matter how intelligent the pies fan is they still have a high level of stupid within ... taking today’s final parade into account the pies don’t even have enough respect to let the saints captain have his say   and people have no valid reason not to like pies supporters? think you blokes all need a bex and a good lie down as they say ABC anyone but collingwood

    • Geoff says:

      07:35pm | 24/09/10

      How dumb were the people that oraganised the speeches, what did they think was going to happen?  The two captains holding the cup up would have been sufficient.  By the way Spinner, before you start calling Pies fans stupid, you might like to clean up your spelling.

    • spinner says:

      09:05am | 25/09/10

      Geoff oh so now it’s the afl’s fault just letting you know mate your coffee is hot! talk about missing the point, guess they should have known feral pies fan’s wouldn’t have enough respect to let nick speak. must have been the occasion, yes ABC it is oh as for the spelling error? complains? if that is what you meant is not a spelling error but a typo used correctly it a sentence “Eddie Everywhere complains a lot when he feels the pies are hard done by.” the word i intended to use was complaints.

    • He was cranky after all says:

      03:44pm | 27/09/10

      Spinner….., mate…., not a sound strategy to slag off Pies supporters as stupid with a series of incoherent rants and selective analysis.  It is in fact you who misses the point, in both your original comment and subsequent responses. 
      2009 - 15 of 22 matches at their home ground and only one journey to Subiaco and one to the Gabba. Who? St Kilda no less.
      In recent years St Kilda have been taking home games interstate.  Sorry, my omission, I left out Gold Coast.  The poin is if you choose to play home games interstate don’t beef about how many you have to play!  (typo not a spelling error) Collingwood have an ever improving winning record interstate (85% in last 2 seasons) so how are they being advantaged?  It is noted that teams (not just Saints) won’t transfer any home games involving Collingwood due to the financial benefits of playing them at home.

      Yes we Magpies do have some stupid supporters! But we still love em anyway.  From reading your words here you can make no claim to be better than any of them.  You should be grateful that anybody gave that drivel the respect of a thoughtful response.

      p.s.  The explanation of the spelling issue is baffling.  Please have another go at it so my faith in humanity can be restored.

    • Horthy says:

      06:22pm | 23/09/10

      Aussie Rules? Great game!

      AFL? What a joke.

      Any competition, _any_ competition, whereby teams do not have an equal number of home and away games against every opposition is a joke. Seriously.

      As for the pies - meh.

    • Steph says:

      06:30pm | 23/09/10

      I’ve never really minded the Pies until a few weeks ago I saw vision of the players singing the song post-game and miming sleeping because it was “oh so boring to win again”.
      I didn’t see a repeat of it so I hope Eddie ripped them a new one but it was moment where I thought I would very disappointed if that was my team. I hope it’s good game on the weekend.

    • Dennis says:

      07:09pm | 23/09/10

      Erm, I’m very sure you’re thinking of a Geelong player earlier this year. Projection much?

    • Robbo says:

      08:45pm | 23/09/10

      Steph, the vision you might have seen is a replay from late May 2010 of James Kelly catching some ZZZ resting his head on the shoulder of G Ablett.  Bomber Thompson couldn’t say much because he has been caught (during different games); eating a salad roll and putting his feet up on the desk.  Cats fans were divided on the issue but most others thought it cocky if not disrespectful.

    • Swans Fan says:

      06:50pm | 23/09/10

      Interesting. What he says is true. But while I am a Swans fan, Collingwood deserve to win more than St. Kilda. I am expecting a thrashing of St. Kilda, and a reptition of last year.

    • A Dose of Reality says:

      09:36pm | 23/09/10

      Here’s a way to unite all you vics into supporting the ‘wobbles. 

      Imagine this Grand Final:

      ‘wobbles v Crows.

    • Pie with peas please says:

      09:38pm | 23/09/10

      Gimme a b, B! Gimme an o, O! Gimme a g, G! Gimme an a, A! Gimme an n, N! What does it spell? Collingwood supporter!

    • Bruce says:

      07:25am | 24/09/10

      While Eddie Everywhere is extremely irritating and the Pies are pampered year in year out through the fixtures, causes me to have some antipathy to Collonwood, when it comes to hate they rank very low down the list for me.

      Where I come from SK are known as the DEAF CHEATS and rank higher in hate than the Pies. Carltank rank even higher. But no club is more despicable than the West Coast Marketing Concept

      Gimme a toothless Pie supporter any day over pony tailed, white shoe wearing advertising exec with a coke habit

    • Sorrel says:

      03:12pm | 24/09/10

      Yeah, i wrote the ‘m.o’ for the event smile

      go saints
      <3 sorrel

    • Chris says:

      11:55pm | 24/09/10

      Sure, there’s that old Collingwood of Victoria Park days, that we love to hate, and deep down we do love them, in a hating kind of way. Its just a back-and-forth ribbing. Every club cops something.
      But then there’s the new Collingwood, the rich, sooky, spoilt brat right at the front of the crass commerce and TV-driven ‘new era’ of football.

      There’s the old club… and the new ‘franchise’.

      If only the ‘club’ people got the flag, I’d be right behind them. As it is, go Saints.

    • Dogs says:

      08:34am | 26/09/10

      Its typical that a pies fan refers to them as ‘an underdog’ one of the most successful clubs in the history of the game has a rough decade and he thinks they are an underdog!  Talk to the clubs with one premiership.  Talk to the clubs with the most wooden spoons, then you’re dealing with a perennial under-achieving underdog!

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

ToryShepherd

Does anyone, anywhere, have access to the audio of Isobel Redmond at the @ceda_news shindig?

tory_maguire

"If there was no Schapelle Corby there, in a Balinese prison, we'd still be doing it."...

tory_maguire

Bob Carr says releasing Indo kids convicted of people smuggling has nothing to do with Corby...

Anthony Sharwood

Off to @SkyNewsAust to explain on #sportsline why NSW will beat Qld. One reason is we're much less sooky about life. The other is...

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Schapelle has done her time

Schapelle has done her time

Schapelle Corby has served more than seven years in Kerobokan prison for attempting to import 4.2 kilos…

Who murdered the Arts degree?

Who murdered the Arts degree?

Have we murdered the liberal arts education? That was the final question on Monday night’s Q&A…

Australia, you have nothing to fear but fear itself

Australia, you have nothing to fear but fear itself

Hansonism’s back – and we’re not just talking about Pauline appearing as a sometime…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

242 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter