With the news that Cadel Evans had lost the yellow jersey on the Col de la Madeline stage of the Tour de France, Australians could be forgiven for thinking that this has been the most crash-prone edition of the Grande Boucle. Nursing a broken bone in his elbow from a crash two days before, Evans surrendered eight minutes to the leading riders.

The last place you want to be in the Tour de France. Photo: Getty Images

His crash followed the elimination of two other Australians, Adam Hansen, and Simon Gerrans, who had suffered a series of tumbles before a broken arm finally ended his tour hopes.

Frank Schleck, Vladimir Karpets and Christian Vande Velde have all ended their Tour on the bitumen, while the sprinters Robbie McEwen and Tyler Farrer survived high speed collisions to ride another day.

Even Lance Armstrong has suffered a series of falls in the nervous first week of the race, effectively ending his chance of a podium finish in his last Tour.

Crashes have been a part of the Tour from the outset.

Television coverage of the fast, steady pedaling of cycling’s elite as they charge through the scenic French countryside disguises the physical demands and danger of the event. Over the years, many riders have crashed, and, tragically, a few have died.

Racing at average speeds of 40 – 50 kph, within millimeters of each other to draft and conserve energy, the slightest mistake or miscalculation by a rider can be tragic. Add the unpredictability of wet roads, cobblestones, stray animals, exhausted riders and overenthusiastic spectators, there is a constant recipe for disaster.

As every weekend racer knows, even at the modest speed of 35 kph, a touch of wheels can leave you nursing grazed limbs or a broken collarbone in a split second. Young competitive cyclists are taught to ride through corners without braking, as a touch of the brakes in a tight peleton risks riders on the ground.

The dangers are magnified in the Tour, as 190 riders jostle through a tunnel of cheering fans up and down mountainsides, or along the fast, flat roads of France.

Overzealous spectators have been the cause of unfortunate crashes. “Look at that stupid, stupid man,” a television commentator yelled as a spectator took photos in the path of stage leader, Beppe Guerini, on the Alpe D’Huez in 1999. Luckily, Guerini was able to remount and win the stage after crashing into him.

Five years earlier, a gendarme stepped into the path of the riders to take a snap as they sprinted to the finish in Armentieres. He was hit by Wilfried Nielson and Laurant Jalabert, leaving the latter bloodied and shaken, his Tour over.

In 2003, Lance Amstrong’s handlebar snagged the musette bag of a spectator as he dueled with Iban Mayo and Jan Ullrich on the climb to Luz-Ardiden in the Pyrenees. Following the unwritten rule of cycling, Ulrich waited while Armstrong and Mayo picked themselves up from the road. Two year’s earlier, Armstrong had waited when Ullrich had crashed down a mountain side during the 2001 Tour.

The great Italian cyclist of the era, Gino Bartali, was assaulted by French fans as the Tour traversed the Pyrenees in 1950. After being knocked off his bike, Bartali led a walkout by the Italian team. Poetic justice reigned as a Swiss rider, Ferdi Kubler, eventually defeated the French in their own race.

Spectators are not immune from disaster. Last year a woman was killed when hit by a police motorbike in the entourage.

Animals have also been a cause for consternation in the peleton, as we witnessed again this year. In 2007, Markus Burghardt was felled by a stray canine. Sandy Casar, who won the Col de la Madeline stage this week, was brought down by a dog that year. But that wasn’t as bad as the fate which befell Napoleon Paoli, who collided with a donkey on a narrow descent in 1920. Paoli landed on the back of the frightened animal, which charged along the mountain for a kilometre before the Italian could get off and return to his bike! He was subsequently struck on the head by a rock, and had to withdraw from the Tour.

Lucien Petit-Breton, the 1908 winner, abandoned the race after hitting a cow in 1912. The year before, he collided with a drunken sailor in Boulogne.

Crashes have changed the outcome of the Tour. Who can forget the sickening sight when Joseba Beloki’s tyre skidded on the liquefied summer tarmac, burning the rubber from the rim? Lance Armstrong’s bike slid onto the grass as he narrowly avoided the Spaniard, forcing the Texan on a rough cross-country trip to rejoin the event the other side of the corner.  Armstrong went on to win the Tour. Beloki was not so lucky, breaking multiple bones, and never recovering to the form he once displayed.

Two decades earlier, another Spaniard, Luis Ocana, crashed on a slippery corner, only to have the Dutch rider, Joop Zoetemelk, smash into him, ending his chances. Ocana had been challenging the legendary Eddy Merckx for the overall lead at the time.

Two years later, Ocana crashed into a car blocking the road when chasing Merckx again. The Spaniard abandoned the race, leaving the ‘Cannibal’, as Merckx was known, to claim the third of his five Tour victories.

Wim van Est crashed down a ravine on the Col d’Aubisque twice when leading the 1951 Tour. Armstrong’s directeur sportiff, Johan Bruyneel, also survived a nasty spill over a roadside cliff when he was a competitor.

Tragically, riders have also died. The first was Francesco Cepeda, who, in 1935, misjudged his line through a hairpin bend and plunged into the gully below. Most recently, Olympic champion, Fabio Casartelli, was propelled headfirst into a granite block as he raced down the Portet d’Aspet pass. His death in 1995 resulted in helmets being made compulsory for Tour riders.

Drugs also have been involved. Roger Riviere later admitted that drugs he had been taking played a part in his back-breaking plunge into a ravine in the 1960 Tour. Seven years later, Tom Simpson, the first English-speaker to wear the maillot jaune, succumb to a cocktail of drugs as he dragged himself up Mont Ventoux in 50 degree heat.

The sprinters are often millimeters away from crashing in their wild, weaving charge to the finish line. This year’s race is no exception. One of the most spectacular finishes was in 1991, when the Tashkent star, Djamolidine Abdujaporov – known simply by most as Abdu – hit the safety barriers in the mad dash to the finish line on the Champs Elysees. Australian cycling fans recall the physical clash between Baden Cooke and Robbie McEwen in 2003 although they didn’t fall, and Robbie’s run-in with Stuart O’Grady on another occasion. In 2003, Rene Haselbacher finished a stage with his shorts almost torn-off after another nasty incident.

Bicycle racing is a magnificent sport and an enthralling spectacle. Sadly it can also be dangerous, as we have seen again this year.

16 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • delperro says:

      07:41am | 15/07/10

      Wow, Andrews. Awesome piece, and while I could never vote for you, I am now convinced we could have a conversation.
      My favourite for its tragedy was when Stuart O’Grady broke all those bones falling of the side of that Mountain a few years back.
      They look a bit mincy in their lyrca, but those guys are insane tough. Riding with broken collar bone is something you could have got Haneef to do to spill the beans on his “real” motivations.
      Sorry, nice piece.

    • Sherekahn says:

      12:30pm | 15/07/10

      Watching the Tour-de-France and motor bike racing is a health hazard for me.
      Although ‘they’ do say an occassional adrenaline rush is good for you.

    • Maxwell Silenciaga says:

      09:19am | 15/07/10

      Dear Kevin,
      Whilst I loathe your politics, your writing on cycling is tremendous.  We next await your analysis of Tony’s technique and the appropriateness of his choice in cycling wear.

    • Blaise says:

      10:09am | 15/07/10

      Interesting article Kevin - why don’t you and Tony have a cycling race?

    • Jack Thomas says:

      02:52pm | 15/07/10

      Interesting that the Latte Left would abhor anyone being treated badly for their dress or religion, yet happily smirk about Tony Abbot with comments about lycra…

      Let’s swap the word ‘lycra’ with hijab for instance, and see you snigger. Ey?

      Why is it so threatening to you that someone can be physically fit anyway? The morons who snigger about “lycra..” should also do the same to every swimmer down at the local pool training in Speedo’s surely, I mean just like cyclists should all train in jeans so should the average swimmer.

      Poor old Nicola Roxon sat munching on a donut sniggering about Tony Abbott riding the Pollies Challenge or whatever, when he was raising hundreds of thousands for charity as well. Err…another dumb idea from Labor’s spinners.

      While you are on Tony, Max, it is appropriate (ie. Pro) not to wear trade team gear, unless you are actually on that team.

      To be Pro, you should wear club or team gear you are part of, or failing that spend $500 per item on Assos or Rapha kit that has no sponsorship etc. on it.  Wearing a trade kit, rainbow or yellow jersey, etc. is so not Pro. You might as well follow Lance Armstrong…

    • Robert Smissen Rural SA says:

      04:21pm | 16/07/10

      Jack you forgot to mention the deafening silence from the loony left when photos of Bob Boofhead Hawke complete with man boobs is pictured in the paper. Could it be that they feel threatened by Tony’s strong family values, faithfulness to his wife & his fit masculine body as apposed to a serial womanizing booze artist.

    • Martin says:

      03:08pm | 15/07/10

      I live in your electorate. I voted greens last election (with a labour preference).

      Whilst it is nice to see someone on this website write an informed and researched article on cycling - I’ll still be voting Greens with a Labour preference in the coming election.

    • Nigel Catchlove says:

      10:36pm | 15/07/10

      Martin, you vote for them but don’t even know how to spell their name - that says so much.  Labor.

      Nice article Kevin.

    • Dick J says:

      06:40pm | 15/07/10

      I want to ride a bike to work. My 10yo boy loves riding his bike but can’t on the footpath as it is illegal and the road is just too dangerous .Whatsmore he appears to have talent and the build for it. Long, lean and strong.

      Three friends of mine were mad keen cyclists. Two have died in the last four years. One when a van driver opened his door as he rode past. The other run over by a semi trailer whilst riding a country road. The third friend is in plaster at the moment haveing undergone three operations to a compound fracture of her leg. She was hit on a roudabout . She has been on crutches for 9 months.

      I know it is probably a State matter but I see all these disused country railway lines in NSW. Canberra -Cooma, Tamworth - Moree etc. Wouldn’t’ they make good cycleways. Pour tar between the rails.

    • Catherine Andros says:

      09:00pm | 15/07/10

      Great article!!! Very interesting and insightful….it’s clear you have experience and extensive cycling knowledge.
      Perhaps during your next summer break you can join us ‘down under’ for a certain Australian UCI cycling event, and spare our ears from a certain not-so-knowledgeable commentator tongue laugh
      ....you have my vote on that!!!

    • Eugene says:

      09:18pm | 15/07/10

      Great to read an article written by someone who actually rides a bike! I know it was a brief history, but there were some other spectacular crashes. The difference between cycling fans and motor sports followers is that we wince when a crash occurs. Kevin, please take-up cycling journalism when you leave Parliament.

    • Jack says:

      10:59pm | 15/07/10

      Its a funny thing: People judge you by what the media says, but when i read your stuff, i get a very different impression. I recall your article about Cadel winning the world championship - very empathetic about a bloke who is often hard to like - even for cycling nuts like me. I am not really into politics - just stumbled across this site a while ago - and don’t connect to a lot of it, but I just wanted to say I appreciated your insights. I just looked at this tonight before watching an hour or so of the Tour coverage. I would love to watch every night till the end, but have to be up early for work. Still, the television coverage is very good. SBS should get you on for some expert comments.

    • Timmo says:

      09:04am | 17/07/10

      Why don’t the riders wear knee, and elbow guards to protect themselves should they fall off, now that would be a good idea, just like skateboarders and other sportspeople do.?. Might save a bit of pain and suffering.

    • stephen says:

      11:41am | 17/07/10

      Nice piece Mister Andrews, and I didn’t know you had so much free time ter write such a thing, and i gotta say, after the federal election, yer gonna have a lot more free time too.

      PS and i think there’s too many crashes cause the riders have those earpieces which diverts their attention.

    • Timmo says:

      04:09pm | 17/07/10

      If he’s bright enough to write that, then he’s bright enough to be in Government. A good article indeedy.

    • kimari says:

      07:27pm | 18/02/11

      yes it can be very dangerous. but it’s such a thrilling sport, accidents happen in every form of sport and entertainment. Great article, very well written.

      specialized

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

tory_maguire

"If there was no Schapelle Corby there, in a Balinese prison, we'd still be doing it."...

tory_maguire

Bob Carr says releasing Indo kids convicted of people smuggling has nothing to do with Corby...

Anthony Sharwood

Off to @SkyNewsAust to explain on #sportsline why NSW will beat Qld. One reason is we're much less sooky about life. The other is...

ToryShepherd

RT @AustProtParty: Depressed Leftie @ToryShepherd laments Aussie anti-immigration sentiment, says we're haters & intolerant redneck... http://t.co/DLssoRYP

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Who murdered the Arts degree?

Who murdered the Arts degree?

Have we murdered the liberal arts education? That was the final question on Monday night’s Q&A…

Australia, you have nothing to fear but fear itself

Australia, you have nothing to fear but fear itself

Hansonism’s back – and we’re not just talking about Pauline appearing as a sometime…

Wilkie is poking around on the wrong gambling issue

Wilkie is poking around on the wrong gambling issue

Andrew Wilkie has okayed a lame version of the government’s pokies legislation, which he yesterday…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

Michael S says:

"A teacher at Geelong Grammar had criticised her for using words that were too long, which had left her confused and had made her doubt her ability to write essays. She became ''quite distressed'' when her English marks began to fall." I can sympathise. My scholastic mentors conveyed to me a causal relationship… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

242 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter