Update 2.35pm: The RBA has just announced it has raised the official cash rate by 0.25 a per centage point to 3.25 per cent.

The Rudd Government is yet to make a hard decision. But this won’t stop them leaving the heavy lifting to someone else - namely Glenn Stevens at the Reserve Bank.

Listen to Obi-Wan - an interest rate rise is a good thing

Whether the RBA decides to lift interest rates today or on Melbourne Cup day, this will be a hard decision. It will mean increased pressure on family budgets and small business.

For the more than 200,000 Australians who have bought their first home recently, it will their first Rudd rate rise, with more to follow.

It will also withdraw an important stimulus for the Australian economy, especially for our housing construction industry, following the wind back of the first home owners boost.

What amazes me is how the Rudd Government have been able to hypnotise so many into thinking that an increase in interest rates will be a good thing. It reminds of Obi-wan Kenobi’s Jeddi mind trick in the original Star Wars (I was nine at the time).

Sure, interest rates in Australia are low by domestic standards. But internationally, in the OECD, only Mexico, Iceland, Turkey and Poland have higher interest rates than ourselves. I’m don’t think this is the economic club we want to join.

Higher relative interest rates also inflate the value of the Aussie dollar, making our exports more expensive and damage our local tourism industry by making an overseas holiday much cheaper.

So why does the Rudd Government believe raising interest rates is such a fashionable idea? It’s not like it worked out so great last time they advocated this approach.

After they were elected in November 2007, they embarked on their first of many epic conflicts, the great war on inflation.

In pursuing this campaign they egged on the Reserve Bank with the Treasurer’s reckless talk of the inflation genie being out of the bottle. As a consequence rates were increased at the exact moment we needed them to ease. The same group think is now driving commentary on what should be done with interest rates today.

On that occasion, as now, the Rudd Government had a political strategy, not an economic strategy. After the election, talking up inflation was all about shamelessly trashing the economic reputation of the Howard Government. Today, their preference for higher interest rates is all about having an excuse to keep spending borrowed money and putting up signs outside schools, proclaiming their magnificence all the way until the next election.

There is an alternative. The Rudd Government can make a hard decision and pull back on their record spending. Their stimulus spending program is already behind schedule, with the bulk of the spending still ahead of us.

Sure, many people may like a new school hall, even if they didn’t ask for one. But if the choice is between that and paying higher interest rates (and it is, due to the relative strength of the Australian economy), then the response will be different. And that is the hard choice before the Rudd Government, to cut back on their record spending and ease the upward pressure on interest rates.

Lower interest rates will enable households to keep spending in our economy while keeping the cost of finance lower for small business, who are doing everything they can to keep people in work. It will also enable our exporters to be more competitive in an incredibly tough and price sensitive global marketplace. Building more school halls will not achieve these objectives.

The hard task for the Rudd Government is to get their spending under control. They must work through every line of expenditure, as the Coalition would if we were in Government today, and as we did to pay back $96 billion of Labor debt last time and return our budget to surplus.

Only the Government can identify these savings because, as a Government, only they have access all the information you need to make these decisions.

If they do this then Glenn Stevens and the RBA will have less pressure on them to raise interest rates and do the job the Rudd Government refuses to do.

So when interest rates rise and Kevin Rudd and Wayne Swan do their best Obi-Wan impersonation saying don’t look at us, we just run the country, you will know better. 

21 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Joe says:

      08:57am | 06/10/09

      You are so correct. Rudd has had a political strategy (read spin) for the economy but not a real strategy. And it is us home owners who suffer. Firstly to increase rates to try and trash the Howard legacy, not raise them again to account for their reckless spending.

    • Patrick says:

      09:36am | 06/10/09

      Again, when is the punch going to put *in their articles* that “The author of this article is a member of the “X” party and is a POLITICIAN WITH VESTED INTERESTS” in their articles authored by politicians.

      Scott Morrison has been peddling his intellectually dishonest crap about interest rates for awhile now, and people who are reading this and who do not click on the authors name to read his/her bio, and who do not know who Scott Morrison is,  need to be informed about his motivations, as with any other piece written by a politician

    • Grant says:

      09:48am | 06/10/09

      Seems poor Scott is not aware of who sets interest rates in our economy. And I thought this topic was done to death during the 2004 election campaign(And what a legacy was left!). My diagnosis is that Scott is suffering recurring occasional amnesia. Best read about interest rate policy & have a good lie down.

    • Peter Rechniewski says:

      10:03am | 06/10/09

      Either you think we should have an independent central bank or you don’t. Morrison must believe that we have an independent Reserve Bank in name only as it raises or lowers interest rates not in response to its reading of the broad economic data but to please the government. either that ot the Board memebers are all wimps and Labor party stooges. All the rest is smoke and hot air. And the evidence - he’s got a problem there.

    • WK says:

      10:03am | 06/10/09

      I for one want a rationalisation of interest rates to 4-4.5% by 2011.

    • pc says:

      10:08am | 06/10/09

      Mirror Mirror on the wall which politician is the most disingenuous liar of all?

      Malcolm Turnbull, Wilson Tuckey or Scott Morrison

      Mirror: Well todays prize has to go to scott.

      Thanks mirror, I thought so. There was a senate committee meeting with Glenn Stevens the governor of the RBA, Scott, you must have been watching star wars again. So what does the Governor of the RBA Glenn Stevens think,

      “So I think it is reasonable to conclude, against the benchmark of historical and interational experience, that Australia has done quite well on this occassion….” And interest rates will probably have to “Move off their currently low levels.” (Glenn Stevens Statement to Senate Economics References Committee 28 Sept 2008)

      But wait there’s more

      “Australia has avoided the large falls in housing prices….  (other countries have experienced).... This is a good thing…... Mortgage rates are low at present and as the bank has noted on a number of occassions, it is not reasonable to expect that interest rates will stay at the current low levels indefinitely.” (Anthony Richards RBA to CEDA on Sept 29, 2009)

      You can read more Scott at the RBA’s website. As a politician you should probably do this a bit more regularly.

      Its tough for the coalition at the moment. They had to send Steve Ciobo back to Lateline, last night, to explain their non position on climate change. Currently this non position is designed to make sure nothing happens before Copenhagen, this, the coalition hope will help to undermine negotiations at Copenhagen so nothing gets done. What a bunch of ar@eholes. And Steve Ciobo’s effort last night was nothing short of what we expect of a buffoon. Instead of risking looking as stupid as he did last time, this time Steve memorised all the answers to the questions he thought he would be asked. So he answered questions that Tony never asked. You give a bad name to buffoons everywhere steve.

    • Darren says:

      10:34am | 06/10/09

      I think may of the comments are being quite unfair to Scott Morrison - remember he is still trying to ingratiate himself to his party so they will let him join a local branch. Also he has used some great alliteration in this piece - Rudd rate rise - we all know the rest of the article is crap but you have to give him credit for well written crap

    • Shane From Melbourne says:

      10:37am | 06/10/09

      Too simplistic an article. Some of the factors affecting domestic interest rates are external- overseas lending rates, the state of oversea economies, demand for exports etc that the government has no control over. Some of the internal ones such as government expenditure, stimulus packages, first home buyers grant the governement has control over, others such as consumer sentiment, employer confidence, unemployment rates etc the government has no control over. I’m sure the Reserve Bank of Australia will take ALL factors into the determination upon interest rates.

      Shane’s Axiom on Governments and Interest Rates: When interest rates fall the government will claim credit, when interest rates rise, it must be some other factor.

    • Voxpop says:

      10:53am | 06/10/09

      Scott Morrison no doubt you’ve been patting yourself on the back over your recent success with The Punch *read high comment count* however that is only due to you rounding up the god squad on emotive moral issues.  Lets see if they bother coming to your defence on this.

    • Sloth says:

      11:39am | 06/10/09

      I, for one, love the idea that politicians can ‘egg on’ the RBA to raise rates. Would the Hon. Member for Cook concede, then, that if the Prime Minister and Treasurer were dangerously egging-on the RBA when they talked up inflation, that the Liberal party now has a deliberate policy of egging-on the RBA to raise rates in the face of national debt? I mean, every time any the Leader of the Opposition get air time he’s either squibbing it on the Coalition’s ETS policy, or complaining that all this government debt will cause a rate rise. Indeed, the Coalition’s debt truck claims that we’ll see around 300 billion dollars of debt; some 192 billion more than the latest figures from Westpac’s analysis. Surely this is the clearest example yet of politicians ‘dangerously talking up’ the level of state debt and ‘egging on’ the RBA to raise rates.

      It is nonsense, pure and simple. And once again the comments to this article demonstrate that the average punter is far more sophisticated and knowledgeable than polticians like the Member for Cook give them credit for.

      Mr Morrison, I’ll make the same plea to you that I find myself making to most politicians of all stripes. Could you please, please stop writing opinion pieces that assume your audience - that is us, your constituents - are mouth-breathing morons. We are not. The Australian people are far more sophisticated than you give us credit for. Please stop talking to us like we are idiots.

    • Paul says:

      11:53am | 06/10/09

      What was that about spin Scott?

    • proud aussie says:

      03:34pm | 06/10/09

      Well said Scott, now maybe those who believed the LIES of the Rudd team both before, during and after the last Federal Election, will now realize that Interest Rates go down, AND Interest Rates go up.  Funny how Kevin Rudd and his team always neglected to inform the Australian people that under the Howard Govt’s time in office,  there were 19 Interest Rate CUTS.  Kevin Rudd and his team always gave the impression that there were only Interest Rate rises during the Howard Govt’s time in office.

      How Australia misses the strong and skilled governance of the previous Govt.
      One has to feel sorry for all those people who have rushed to take up the first home buyers grants,  not taking into account that they will still have to pay back the loan PLUS deal with any Interest Rate rises in the future.

      Has Kevin Rudd created Australia’s own Sub Prime Crisis?

    • acker says:

      04:52pm | 06/10/09

      You forget to mention Scott

      That most of the low interest club after the disco have already cashed in their cab fare on last drinks and are either walking home or trying to train surf.

      Not only do we have enough money for a cab, we have have probably also got enough cash left for a hot dog or kebab as well

      Nice effort to spin away from the Royal Rumble like ETS Lib/Nat battle anyway wink

    • Damien says:

      05:28pm | 06/10/09

      Proud Aussie: Has Kevin Rudd created Australia’s own Sub Prime Crisis?

      Ha!

      12 years of debt fuelled wealth accumulation and you come up with that!

      Malcolm? Tony? Joe?

    • Smithy says:

      07:13pm | 07/10/09

      Proud Aussie, you are not the only one expressing concern regarding Rudd’s 1st home grant. I have read & heard many commentators indicating that Rudd & Swann have created an artificial bubble that will burst after the grants have ended, plus with rising interest rates & thus un -employment driving down house prices. The concept of our very own “sub-prime” crisis is on the not too distant horizon.

    • Sandy Campbell says:

      08:09pm | 07/10/09

      What about the retirees whose fixed income is at 50 year lows ?  Fixed term interest rates have fallen to an appalling 3.5% .  The lower the interest rates have gone, the less interest I receive for my hard earned money.!

    • Greg Atkinson says:

      03:59pm | 09/10/09

      I think the Opposition have got themselves in a tangle on interest rates. When they were in power their line was that the RBA was independent and we could not blame the Government when rates went higher because it was due to a strong economy blah blah….... Now they seem to be saying the Government can control rates and should lean on the RBA? I am not sure who looks after Liberal Party strategy, maybe it’s the same guy who screens the acts on Hey Hey?

      Anyway….I think the Coalition need a weekend away in the mountains, howl and the moon and sort themselves out.  Do we actually have an Opposition any more? See: http://www.shareswatch.com.au/blog/opinion/is-there-a-federal-opposition-in-australia/

    • Graeme Stedman says:

      08:35am | 30/01/10

      When a Government spends recklessly without any thought for the future people deserve what they voted for.
      Bring on high interest rates the Labor voters loose there houses creating opportunties for richer investors.
      This Federal Government will lead to the biggest transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich.
      Our AAA credit rating will be a thing of the past.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Daniel Piotrowski

What the hell are baby vegetables anyway? via @slatehttp://t.co/ALUgTRsv

Daniel Piotrowski

Federal government MP is going all kinds of crazy places to get Oz a UN Security Council seat. Next up: Gabon? http://t.co/i2mHmITH

Daniel Piotrowski

Sorry ex-premier, I'm not paying for your lunch. http://t.co/Kg0G8PBl

ToryShepherd

SA. It's the middle bottom bit. (PS I think I heard that phrase on @triplej, apologies for nicking!) http://t.co/YOhdLSlj

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

Deep down we’re all unionists, even the haters

Deep down we’re all unionists, even the haters

Bill Kelty made a memorable speech last week. Addressing the ACTU Congress Dinner in Sydney, the legendary…

Craig Thomson speaks. Meanwhile, in Australia…

Craig Thomson speaks. Meanwhile, in Australia…

Speaking of yourself in the third person is usually a sign that you’re suffering from delusions…

South Australia. It’s the middle bottom bit.

South Australia. It’s the middle bottom bit.

If South Australia had just arrived in the world, red and wrinkled and mewling, what would we call it?…

Gentle jabs to the ribs

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not… Read more

241 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter