So here’s the news, if you can call it that. Ricky Ponting will no longer play One Day cricket, which we all knew, given he was dropped from the team yesterday. As Ponting himself effectively said this morning, the selectorial door is not a revolving one at his age.

The 2003 World Cup in South Africa. Ponting's finest hour.

Ponting will, however, continue to play Test cricket. So the Ponting landscape today is pretty much the same as it is yesterday, which made the 70 media at today’s presser, myself included, wonder why we had bothered to leave the office.

Notwithstanding the mild inconvenience of attending a cricketing equivalent of a Seinfeldian show about nothing, it’s worth reflecting on Ponting’s decision. And while we’re at it, let’s celebrate the 375 One Dayers Ponting racked up for Australia.

Ponting’s decision to keep playing Tests means he will now turn out in Tassie colours for the remainder of the Sheffield Shield season, in order for him to prepare himself for the three Test tour of the West Indies in March and April.

You can understand why he feels he deserves a chance, given he made over 500 runs in the India series, including a double century in his last Test in Perth.

Not many guys are dropped after a double ton. It happened to Jason Gillespie, but his freak double was made against the world’s weakest side. And as a bowler, he was rightly assessed on his ability to take wickets.

So Ponting has earned his spot. Assuming he make runs in the Windies, he then has a long layoff while the Australian One Day and T20 teams undergo a busy winter program which includes the World Twenty20 tournament. Ponting today said a stint in English country cricket is almost out of the equation.

In all likelihood, Ponting will front up in next summer’s twin three Test series, beginning in November, against South Africa and then Sri Lanka. If he goes well, then maybe, just maybe, he will make it to the 2013 Ashes. Asked today if he was seeking redemption, he answered: “Aren’t we all?”

Another thing professional sportsmen crave, though they never admit it publicly, is recognition. So let’s go through some of the highlights of Ponting’s One Day career.

In 375 games, he racked up 13,704 runs with 30 centuries at an average a tick over 42. Those are better numbers than Mark Waugh and Adam Gilchrist, who are the only other batsmen with a legitimate claim of Australia’s best One Day bat. You could probably throw in Michael Bevan as a candidate too, but while Bevan was a finisher, Ponting was the man who built innings.

This he did with incredible poise and skill for more than a decade and a half. The high point, as he admitted today, was the 2003 World Cup, an unbeaten campaign which preceded some incredible unbeaten streaks with Ponting at the helm of the One Day team. At one point, the team won more than 20 straight games.

Ponting instilled real hardness into the One Day team, so much so that you occasionally wondered why his captaincy was often so ineffectual in Tests. Captaincy issues aside, it is his batting he’ll be remembered for.

That match-winning 140 not out in the 2003 World Cup final was sheer class. There were classical cover drives galore, but the shot that totally made you gasp in awe was his signature shot – the pull shot.

The pull shot is both the easiest and the hardest shot to play in cricket. The easiest, because it is the natural swish across the body that every child plays instinctively before they learn the cultured art of the straight bat. And the hardest, because for one split second, the ball is coming straight at your face and all you have to defend it with is a cross bat.

The shot sums up Ponting’s career. When he is at his most vulnerable, he often pulls out his best cricket. He’s done that many times in all forms of the game and on balance, he more than deserves the chance to do it again in Tests.

For now.

If he so much as blinks, the selectors will be ruthless. Another Australian summer of Ponting is more than likely, but the Ashes are still a 50-50 bet at best. Really, it’s up to him.  As he said today: “I am my own best selector”.

Most commented

47 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • wolf says:

      11:55am | 21/02/12

      I’m struggling to see how Ponting will be at all competitive next summer without a stint in county cricket. It’s already a big ask for him to be competitive in the Windies with a seven week layoff from international cricket, never mind the seven month layoff by the time next summer rolls around.
      That assumes he makes runs in the Windies and remains a selection possibility.  This is all going to end in tears, when it could have ended gracefully after hitting a double ton in his last innings.  Can’t really feel sorry for him though as it’s all of his own making.

    • AFR says:

      12:41pm | 21/02/12

      Plus, once he commits to next summer, he will have to commit to the following one as well (2013/14) - as we have a fairly packed test schedule in 2013 with i think 3 tests against South Africa 3 against Sri Lanka, tour of India, then back to back Ashes series. If he won’t stick around for that long, then we should be preparing someone else (as long as it isn’t Shaun Marsh).

    • DaisyDuke says:

      12:05pm | 21/02/12

      So you managed to write an article about nothing?

      A more interesting story is why Sharwood had his profile pic on the punch updated?

    • TimR says:

      12:43pm | 21/02/12

      It’s for those other articles where he tries to pass him self off as something more than a sports journalist.

      Quit with the Punter bashing. After Clarke, he is the best test batsman in the country. He should not have been dropped from the one day side, rather they should have put him to bat at 6, after the Hussey’s. From that position he could tear a bowling team apart against the old ball.

    • Anthony Sharwood

      Anthony Sharwood says:

      12:51pm | 21/02/12

      Two reasons. “Cos” and “felt like it”. Other pic was done at a Chris Judd photo shoot in 2007. They needed a shiny head to Test the light for his! New pic is circa 2011. Back to work…

    • gobsmack says:

      12:59pm | 21/02/12

      The problem that Australia still has with its Test batting line up is the number 3 position.
      Traditionally, that spot is occupied by the best batsman in the side.

    • Gregg says:

      01:25pm | 21/02/12

      @Ant,
      Aah comeon now ant, that guy at the railway station was just too close to a cross between Bill Murray and you for comfort wasn’t he?
      What did the missus say when you put it to her re a new hairdo?

    • Jason says:

      03:32pm | 21/02/12

      His last 10 one day matches netted a return of 133 runs at an average of 13.3 and a strike rate of 63.6.  It was time for him to go from the one-dayers.  There’s no way that sort of form justifies even a drop down the order.

    • SM says:

      12:06pm | 21/02/12

      Ponting has been an out and out champion, the third best batsman I’ve ever seen live (Lara, Greg Chappell) but it’s time for him to depart the test arena as well.  A couple of good scores against the embarrassing Indian attack in the tests doesn’t take away from the fact that he just isn’t what he once was, and prior to those innings his previous test ton was in 2009 (I think).

      Kerry O’Keefe made an excellent point talking about Tendulkar on the radio the other day that I think applies to Ponting as well.  At his best, Tendulkar was the quintessential front foot driver, blasting balls between mid off and mid on.  Now he is a square of the wicket player at best, often resorting to playing behind the wicket, most notablty the streaky deflection over the top of slips shot.

      Whether it’s because they see it a split second later as they get older, or the feet don’t move like they once did, I’m not sure.  But to entertain the thought of him playing an Ashes series in 2013 is absurd.

    • Macca says:

      12:49pm | 21/02/12

      There’s a story that Warne, Mcgrath and Murali said that of Ponting, Tendulker, Dravid, Lara and Kallis, the bloke they would have preferred to bowl to was Lara.

      He was amazing at his best, but too many rough trots and you were always a chance at a wicket. He just doesn’t measure up to the others in that group above.

    • SM says:

      01:37pm | 21/02/12

      @Macca

      Sri Lankan spin great Muthiah Muralidaran does not rate even one Australian batsman among the top 10 opponents of his record-breaking career.

      Murali says it’s not a reflection on the quality of some of Australia’s recent greats, from the Waugh brothers through to Ricky Ponting and Michael Clarke, but more about the sheer quality of the likes of Brian Lara and sub-continental champions including Sachin Tendulkar and Mohammad Azharuddin, who are all in his top three.

      The 800-wicket Test champion says at times he had “no answer” to Lara’s brilliance.

      “Brian scored a double century against us at the Sinhaelese Sports Ground (in Colombo) once (in 2001-02),” he said. “I felt I’d been on top of him in the first two Tests in that series but in this game he played two amazing on drives through vacant mid-on. They were supreme shots. This day he won the battle. I tried to give him a single to get him off strike”

      MUTHIAH MURALIDARAN’S 10 TOP BATSMEN

      1. Brian Lara (WI)
      2. Mohammad Azharuddin (India)
      3. Sachin Tendulkar (India)
      4. Navjot Sidhu (India)
      5. Salim Malik (Pakistan)
      6. Inzamam-ul-Haq (Pakistan)
      7. Andy Flower (Zimbabwe)
      8. Graham Thorpe (England)
      9. Jon Crawley (England)
      10. Hansie Cronje (South Africa)

      http://www.backpagelead.com.au/cricket/2889-aussie-batsmen-not-in-my-top-10-murali

    • timbo says:

      02:12pm | 21/02/12

      @SM. Anyone who would put a player like Cronje ahead of the likes of Ponting clearly has issues with Australia’s treatment of him that he can’t get past as far as his objectivity is concerned.

    • jg says:

      02:21pm | 21/02/12

      SM,

      interestingly Murali averaged about 75 per wicket whenever he came to Australia. 

      His over all average against Australia was about 36 or so.

      Not great numbers really.

      Might say something about his choices?

      Whatever, he has a strange criteria.

    • gobsmack says:

      02:35pm | 21/02/12

      @SM
      Interesting that Muralidaran’s top ten includes at least 3 match fixers.

    • Mahhrat says:

      02:45pm | 21/02/12

      @SM:  The Man Who Had The Rules Changed gets no vote on something like that.

    • Jason says:

      03:37pm | 21/02/12

      He’s averaging over 56 from his last 15 digs in tests and I believe is our leading run scorer in the past 12 months.  I think that justifies keeping him, especially when there isn’t anyone else smashing down the door for his spot.  One-dayers he had to go.  Tests he needs to stay (at least until next summer).

    • SLF says:

      12:07pm | 21/02/12

      Fabulous player, best bat for Aus in the modern era.

      So why have Cricket Australia treated him pretty poorly over this? Whilst I fully agree Ponting deserves to be dropped on form and should have been dropped, why give him the captaincy for 2 games and then drop him?

      To me that indicates they saw a future for him, otherwise give Warner the captaincy. Now Warner must be wondering why the gave a dropped bloke a run at captaincy before him, the vice captain.

      A organise in brewery couldn’t up piss a.

    • SM says:

      01:30pm | 21/02/12

      Warner’s been on the scene for 5 minutes - with Clarke out injured for a game or 2, given his experience Ponting was the logical choice to stand in

    • Markus says:

      02:21pm | 21/02/12

      @SM, then Warner was a silly choice for Vice-Captain.

      The vice-captaincy role is to assist the captain, and be ready to cover the captaincy in the short-term should the need arise.
      International cricket is not the place to be given your captaincy training wheels.

    • MK says:

      03:09pm | 21/02/12

      You did not know Cricket Australia are a bunch of Idiots?

      are you new to Cricket?

      Either Hussey or even Binger would have been more than qualified to stand in as captain

    • Disco Stu says:

      12:34pm | 21/02/12

      Ponting and his Aussie bat are a bit like Charlton Heston. The only way you’ll get it off him is from his cold dead hand. Or kicking screaming. btw, hey Charlton, yoink!!

    • Macca says:

      12:46pm | 21/02/12

      Hussey’s ODI figures make Waugh and Gilchrist’s look rubbish. Ponting has always been dominate in the middle form of the game, but he’s certainly not the best ODI bat of his generation. Hussey or Bevan deserve that mantle.

      But today’s discussion should be about the amazing career of R. T. Ponting. We’ll do well to see another of his quality anytime soon

    • TChong says:

      01:03pm | 21/02/12

      agree macca.
      Hussey is superb, so is Clarkey
      Pontings up their with them, but its his Test career- very good tactical Captaincy,  sportsmanship at its best and outstanding batting, that puts him above Tubs and Waugh
      (and thats said with my NewSouth bias)

    • gobsmack says:

      02:37pm | 21/02/12

      Clarke is a good captain but too slow for ODI.

    • Ben says:

      03:25pm | 21/02/12

      Bevan wins, hands down. He was half the team in the late 90’s. I’ll always remember that game in 1996 when Bevan had to hit a boundary off the last ball against the West Indies for Australia to win. Second greatest ODI game ever (behind the 1999 semi final between AUS and SA).

    • MattyC says:

      12:58pm | 21/02/12

      Its sad that the last couple of knocks betrayed the quality bat that he was.

      IMHO that 140odd in the world cup final in South Africa was the best innings i have seen in ODI cricket.

      Good luck in your final test Ricky and thanks for the entertainment.

    • Martin says:

      01:38pm | 21/02/12

      Shame to see Ponting treated this way. I listened to that silly old wacker John Inverarity making the announcement. Frankly the first sacking should have been the entire group of selectors including Clarke. Never was there a more overated player than Clarke I am sorry to say. I notice that when Clarke goes through a form slump, that’s Ok apparently, but anyone else gets shafted.

      I would suggest immediate removal of Clarke and the selectors. This would result in a happy productive team. Instead we have this continual trail of dickhead decisions that are moral destroyers.

      I remember the Australian team of the 1970’s and early 80’s. No metrosexual twerps, they were tough tenacious players and the team didn’t change all that much so there was cohesion and mateship. Now we have a sporting team that is run like some sort of corporation with all the destructive politics thrown in for good measure.

      You only have to think back to even when Warne was playing. It wasn’t that long ago and the Australian team moral was high and they were world beaters. Now they are nothing more than dong beaters.

    • Ben says:

      03:30pm | 21/02/12

      Interesting then that the captain of that 1970’s-80’s team that you rate so highly (Ian Chappell) has nothing but praise for Clarke and the way he has conducted himself and his team since being made captain. John Inverarity, Andy Bichel and Michael Clarke are all very good inclusions on the selection panel. I think it is fairly self-evident that the Australian team is in a much better place mentally and in pure cricketing terms since they took over. It’s sad to see Punter go from ODI’s, but in the end it is the right decision for the Australian team.

    • Martin says:

      09:54am | 22/02/12

      @Ben, well there plenty that don’t. They won’t speak up though, because they’re afraid they’ll recieve the Katich treatment.

    • Jordan says:

      02:20pm | 21/02/12

      @Martin….is this the same Michael Clarke that is the highest scoring Australian captain on home soil…and the highest ever score at the SCG!!! Your a joke, Shane Warne has said on numerous occasions that he endorses Clarke at captain (he was saying this while ricky was still captain). Clarke had a form slump last summer, hes made up for it in spades this summer with great captaincy and aggressive batting. A captain that comes in for 3/37 then scores a triple century is definitely overrated…..another thing you clarke hater with all of his form slumps before this summer in tests he averaged 45 now his at 49.65…. if he keeps it up he could very well finish his career with a higher average than punter. Go back to your armchair, skull your beer and keep bagging clarkey coz he can get hotter women than you!!

    • gobsmack says:

      02:41pm | 21/02/12

      If Clarke is our best batsman, then he should be batting at No. 3.
      IMHO, there were 3 outstanding knocks this summer.  Warner’s centuries in Hobart and Perth were exceptional as they were made in conditions where everyone else struggled.  Ponting’s pair of 50s in Melbourne were made in tough conditions and proved to be the difference in that match.

    • Martin says:

      03:10pm | 21/02/12

      You’re a cranky little shit aren’t you. Sorry to say that was one of the worst Indian teams for a long, long time. Ponting also scored several centuries yet he is dropped. Easy for Clarke to win a series against those clowns.

      Let’s see how he goes when the competition is more serious overseas. As I said, Clarke is the most overated player. And it’s not only me saying it, a recent anonymous player poll identified Clarke as the most overated player.

      Gotta laugh at your little metrosexual tantrum, “coz he can get hotter women than you!!” Fair dinkum, easy to see what you spend most of your time thinking about. Stop playing pocket billiards and wake up to yourself.

      As for the triple century (I might remind you Ponting was there with him for most of it), well you’re only as good as your last innings, just ask Ponting.

      This is more about politics than talent.

      Just as a final point re captains- you mention Warne. The fact that Warne never captained Australia is full evidence of what a twisted bunch of wankers these selectors are. He tactically was a genius and never gets a go at the captaincy. Go figure.

      Yep you go play beach cricket with your twerp mates and talk crap to each other about Clarke and his ridiculous tattoos and bimbo hangers on. When the likes of Warne are overlooked and Clarke gets a geurnsey there is some terribly wrong.

    • SZF says:

      11:25am | 22/02/12

      Wow Gobsmack, just wow.

      You don’t rate the 10th(?) highest Test score EVER in the top 3 innings during the Indian series just because the wicket was a belter? It’s not like he came in with the side in trouble and proceeded to bat for two days or anything…

      Methinks your dislike of Clarke has coloured your perspective. I don’t particularly care for him either, but credit where credit’s due. It was a supreme knock.

    • Anna C says:

      02:47pm | 21/02/12

      Piss off Ricky, you’ve had your go. Now it’s time to give somebody else a shot.

    • Punter says:

      03:10pm | 21/02/12

      Charming!

    • Kelvin says:

      02:48pm | 21/02/12

      His media conference was a bit like calling the press together to tell them that the sun came up yesterday - but only if they asked. Oh and for good measure that it set last night.

      What a non-event. How precious is Cricket Australia and their players?

    • Michael says:

      02:50pm | 21/02/12

      Ponting is a living legend of Australian cricket, second only to ‘The Don’. Why people are so keen to get rid of him is beyond me. Let him play well into his 40’s if the desire and skill is evident. There is no need to dump a player of his stature from the test side simply because of age. He has proven that even at 37 he can return from a form slump, why could he not do the same at 42?

      Here’s to many more years from you Punter, a true class act.

    • Martin says:

      03:29pm | 21/02/12

      @Michael. I’m with you. However, unfortunately the politics of Cricket Australia dictate that the previous captain must be shitted on. The way Tubby Taylor was treated was an example, as was the snubbing of Warne.

      What a bunch of cats, it’s got nothing to do with ability, it’s all to do with brown nosing, image and sponsorship dollar.

    • CJ says:

      03:52pm | 21/02/12

      Nothing happened.
      Thank Christ you’ve written about it.

    • Typical Aussie says:

      04:07pm | 21/02/12

      You know what the only thing that shames me about Aussies ( and yes I am one )? One minute someone is a hero, and then we can’t wait to rip them down to nothing. Where is the respect? Europe glorifies a champion forever as a champion, let alone a once national captian. We just love successful people’s downfalls, showing what a bunch of miserable jealous sods we actually are…

    • Jordan says:

      04:58pm | 21/02/12

      @martin, mate i totally agree with you about warney, he shouldve been made captain over steve waugh and ricky ponting, but thats another arguement. your right australian cricket politics are messed up…nonetheless the team now is in far better shape under clarke and hes been leading from the front.
      @gobsmack im sick of hearing that the best batsman has to bat no. 3!! its nonsense whilst for a long time ponting was our best batsmen and no.3 have you not forgotten about steve waugh captaining from no. 5 very successful, bradman opened, tendulkdar has moved between 1 and 4 his whole career. clarke should bat 5 because hes our best player of spin bowling and its not worth having him see the new ball often, i think he could handle no.3 but 5 is his spot and it doesnt mean hes not a quality player for not batting there

    • Rich says:

      05:18pm | 21/02/12

      Lol @ ye who scoff at Ponting. I have been cursing his birth and calling for his axing since dec 2007 but frankly it’s a huge shame that he’s going. Sure, he’s not useful anymore… But all of this means that we’re going to spend a few years waiting for Usman Khawaja to score more than 20 runs in an innings, or Marsh’y struggle to break 2. It’s a horrible day, because we have no one really impressive to turn to anymore.

    • Waynevan says:

      08:20pm | 21/02/12

      The problem is announcing that Ponting will never play ODI’s again. Sounds like disciplenary action for something horrible he’s done (something we don’t know about perhaps?). Rather let’s just say he’s been dropped for poor form like anyone else may be, of course at 37 his chances of regaining that form are slimmer than for most, but wasn’t just a month ago he was slamming the Indians to all part of the SCG and Adelaide Oval?

    • redders says:

      08:50am | 22/02/12

      I notice that well known Bible basher Matty Hayden is horrified that poor old Punter got the chop. Hayden, like Ponting, is another example of “I’ll decide when it’s time to go” and another example of averaging a tad over 30 in his last 2 years of Test cricket. Remember up until the series against India Punter averaged about 20 in his last year of Test cricket. Why is it that cricketers are the only sportsmen who decide “when they go”. Do you reckon they’d carry Gary Ablett or Mal Meninga for 2 years? Don’t think so!

    • Fingers says:

      09:07am | 22/02/12

      “Not many guys are dropped after a double ton.” - Brad Hodge was dropped after making a double tonne against South Africa. Not sure what he did, but he really must have peed someone in the hierarchy off because he was one the best bats in the country for a decade and couldn’t get a proper gig. Probably could still cut in the One Dayas too.

    • Lapun says:

      09:18am | 22/02/12

      Ant, you did miss the one thing that did come out of the Ponting media meet.  The usual, but still inevitable arrogance of the man that has been ever present through the years.  To make the declaration that he would continue to play Tests, without even a mention of the proviso of him being first selected, I found incredible.  And if I was in the position of being a selector I would have taken this as a definite “up yours!”.  Ricky was good, not always reliable, but good.  I can’t see him in future meeting the criteria for selection in our Test team and I believe more than one of the selectors may be see him as a destablising influence and will be gunning for him as a result of yesterday.
      P.S.  You look better with a smile on your dial.

    • kellypeterson says:

      07:52pm | 22/02/12

      Wow! that must have ben an awesome chance to do so!
      I have looked at some of the
      custom essay writing
      options and considered the possibilities!

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter