I am concerned at the logic that because some jerks are treating Australia Day the way Liz Taylor treated the institution of marriage that we should get rid of the celebration altogether.

Should you lose points for eating this today?

The structures of our society are no better or worse because of actions of a few.  Trend is not established by a few data points.

Global warming is not off because of a cold snap in the UK. The monarchy is no more appropriate for Australia because Will seems like a great bloke. And our flag is no more or less appropriate because some people (mis)use it.

What Australia means - “brand Australia” - is the collective actions of 21 million people. 

To borrow from thinker Remo Giuffre: “The Community is the Brand”. 

If we don’t like the way we are seen, don’t change the bloody logo, change the way the community acts. 

If a large number of Australians are feel disenfranchised then let’s work to make them feel less pissed off and address why they need to express their frustrations and insecurities.

For a start we could put away the word “bogan”. Its use (but certainly not in its severity) is the exact equivalent of using the word nigger in the US.  It might be OK for those from a culture that has appropriated it, but not for those outside. Language works that way. (Btw, I have seen no evidence that so-called bogans have appropriated the word bogan. It is really just a gutter swipe at a socio-economic sub-class and no fair-minded person should need to do that.)

Australians throw the phrase around like they don’t care that it hurts some people.  Perhaps we don’t care.  Perhaps the chardonnay class (chardonnay is back by the way, now that sauv blanc is the new chardonnay) likes the thrill of being able to denigrate one subset of society and take the moral high ground at the same time.

The use of the phrase is providing an opportunity for Australia to tear itself apart by pitting bogan against non-bogan for the high moral high ground.  The fight between those who are Australian and those who are even more Australian.

Who is more “Australian”?

Is it the person who grew up in a low-income suburb, went to crowded, under-funded schools, was told constantly they were no good, saw the reward for sporting prowess placed over any intellectual pursuit, and knows that even if they save 20 per cent of their after tax income for the rest of their lives they will die with a mortgage representing 80 per cent of the value of their house?

Or is it the lucky person who was told they could amount to something, saw the evidence of it among others in their community, was encouraged at school, and had the physical security in their home life to pursue it?  

All I am trying to say is that if we continue to fight over the soul of Australia, there will surely be no winners.  I got to watch first hand the fight over what it meant to be American, and it was clear that only the fringes win in these battles. 

And in case my wife accuses me of laying into her homeland, I agree with her suggestion that we should just say “thanks” on Australia day.  We don’t need the American festival of turkey, but why not take one day a year to just say thank you to those Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians who came before us?

If we are going to get serious about this question of who represents Australia then you can’t manage what you don’t measure.  The only way to do it is develop a well audited system of “Australia Points” that citizens can monitor and know where they stand.

It starts with the test for citizenship.  Not only new immigrants, but a modified (bit simpler, please) version for standing Australians. The higher your marks, the more in your opening account.

Then all we have to do is work out which activities get you more points.  The more points you have the louder you can express your opinion and wear your Australian-ness with pride.

The only issue will be working out the system:

When it is 40 degrees in Sydney on a summer day and 48 in Penrith, do the people in Penrith get more Australia points than those who sit in the shade of leafy beach side suburbs? 

If I am constantly bullied at school, do I get Australia points per punch?

What if I eat cheap Chinese as my best meal of the week, do I get higher Australia points?

If I put zucchini on the bbq does it negate the Australia points of the marinated lamb on the other side of the BBQ? 

If I put zinc on my nose when I go to the beach do I get as many points if it is the invisible zinc?

If my thongs have a flag on them but are an American brand do they score as high the plain Billabong ones? (And is walking on the flag cool?)

Are there different points for the sauces I use? Tomato, BBQ, hot chilli, sweet chilli?

Should I drive slowly but accelerate fast from the lights or should I drive fast and accelerate slowly? Should I have a designated driver or abuse a cabbie?

And what of the fear that I will rack up heaps of these Australia points and just like frequent flier points never be able to use them when I want to?  

Given that a national “Australia points” system is as likely as a unified rail gauge, perhaps we should kick back today, say thanks to those who have made today possible, and work on what sort of Australia Day we want to have in 2020. 

12 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Liz says:

      08:00am | 27/01/10

      Good one.Maybe we’ve never been a tolerant nation…we seem to need tall poppies to cut down and small ones to stamp on.We’ve always had high expectations,you do that in a ‘can do’ society like ours.Let’s hope they extend to becoming a Republic soon.

    • the iconophile says:

      07:37am | 27/01/10

      Jeepers, what did you sprinkle on those zucchinis, Pete? Note to self. Sell Holmes a Court.

    • Faten says:

      08:06pm | 26/01/10

      I enjoyed your article. It’s annoying that people think they are more Australian than you because their parents were born and yours migrated here. It’s annoying because your not white that you must be born overseas, although clearly your accent says otherwise?  It’s annoying when people think your not Australian because you have a different religion! Its annoying people think their more Australian because they fly a flag, were a shirt, wear a thong (feet), paint their face in the Australian colours and then turn around and vilify someone because they think their ‘not Australian’. Yet If I turned around and asked the same ‘more Australian’ who was the first Prime Minister of Australia? What year did we enter World War I and II? What year did the first fleet arrive? What year did Captain Cook apparently discover Australia? What year was federation? How many years was John Howard Prime Minister of Australia? and finally bet half the population doesnt know this one, Why do we celebrate Australia day on the 26th of January?

    • nation of leeches says:

      07:37pm | 26/01/10

      Bogan is a nice word compared to the more accurate words that could be and should be used. I like this idea of points being awarded. How many do I get if I leave now and promise never to come back? It should be national hero status.
      Like I’d want to be any more Australian.

    • Firepower says:

      05:26pm | 26/01/10

      A zucchini threatened to kill me, but the police have a suspect and, fingers crossed, we might have an arrest before Sunday’s vote.

      BOGAN

    • Brad Coward says:

      04:38pm | 26/01/10

      I won’t put a vegetable on the barbie.  In fact, I won’t go near a barbie, especially if I’m holding a tinnie….or wearing a pair of thongs and my best pair of speedo’s.  Some leftie journo will call me a bogan or a redneck !

      What have I done with my takeaway latte and the sheet music for “The Internationale” ?

    • Glenn Beck says:

      04:35pm | 26/01/10

      Talk about hyperbole - bogan is equivalent to nigger? Do you really think bogan is tied to the history of oppression and subordination that a word like nigger has been? Uppercuts a plenty there.

      Glad to hear Australia is just another brand now as well. No wonder Aus Day has become so ugly and sloganeering, its just another corporate plaything. Pity the brand in question is Ed Hardy!

    • stephen says:

      01:47pm | 26/01/10

      Yes, bogan’s a dreadful word, but it looks so harmless on the page.
      It’s when its used in action - when its got life and thrown at someone - that’s when damage is done. (I’ve seen children walk away in tears at the word. It’s just not worth fighting for.)

    • S.L says:

      01:32pm | 26/01/10

      Pete an American Bogan is a Redneck not a Nigger.
      But in saying that you are spot on that no one is more Australian than another due to economic, social or geographical circumstances.
      Especially when you see the cost of say zucchinis compared to the stratospherical prices of lamb (must be to make up the advertising bill of Big Sam?) I’d go a zook on a barby anyday!
      P.S your footy teams crap!

    • Joe says:

      11:45am | 26/01/10

      Great article. It’s good to finally see a media commentator call for dissenting views to be addressed. And I’m glad you called out the hypocrites on their use of the word bogan. The same applies for redneck and hillbillies, etc. I disagree with your assessment of their severity. They are every bit as severe as the epithets for other races. The word nigger was used as a tool to silence blacks just the same as bogan is to whites.

    • sal says:

      10:31am | 26/01/10

      Um, ‘bogan’ is definitely not the “exact equivalent of using the word nigger in the US”. Bogan has no racial connotations.

    • nic says:

      09:59am | 26/01/10

      Well said Peter. This is one reason why I’m proud to support the Bunnies. There are some who have called the fans ‘toothless dole bludgers’. Yet, the club represents the average man, where we can unite under the same colours irrespective of where we live or what car we drive.

      Add some red to your green on the barbie, a great recipe!

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

RT @toplitigator: @farrm51 Very difficult to believe the excitment of 'Water Efficiency Labelling and Standards Scheme' website doesn't have ppl all over it.

Malcolm Farr

RT @toplitigator: @farrm51 As for the 'Intergovernmental Committee on Surveying and Mapping' website, just how do you contain your excitement?

Malcolm Farr

RT @lynlinking: @farrm51 Well the links should be posted on Twitter more, by people that care about the Government. Perhaps the MSM could help cheers lyn

Malcolm Farr

941 web sites and nothing to read. The rarely visited http://t.co/vPfJmesu sites. http://t.co/MhXMyvZv

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not…

Our Budget blade didn’t cut aid, it’s being paid in spades

Our Budget blade didn’t cut aid, it’s being paid in spades

Ten million children vaccinated. 2.5 million people with access to safe drinking water. And 30 million…

An insecure workforce makes for an insecure society

An insecure workforce makes for an insecure society

It’s usually best to avoid putting too many statistics in a post but reading the ACTU’s report…

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Real women like men who drink beer

Real women like men who drink beer

British comedian John Cleese calls them “beer fairies”.  It’s a euphemism for… Read more

198 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter