I loved this team and still do but, like most things we love at one time or another, it my broke heart.

We lost. Picture: Anthony Moran

Neville Wran was wrong when he said Balmain boys don’t cry: they cry a lot when you’re seven and the Tigers lose the Grand Final.

While writing this I’ve come to the spooky realisation that today is exactly the 20 year anniversary of that fateful afternoon on September 24 1989: Balmain Tigers vs Canberra Raiders NSW RL Grand Final.

This was a team made up of Rugby League legends the likes of which simply do not exist anymore.

Captained by Wayne “Junior” Pearce this team had a forward pack that didn’t so much attack as they did fly at you like a meteor storm that has no understanding of the damage it was going to cause some poor planet.

This included legendary hooker “Backdoor” Benny Elias, Steve “Blocker” Roach and Paul “Siro” Sironen.  Sironen would still work as a cop while playing football.

The backline had, as the cliché goes, had the perfect mix of youth and experience with New Zealand international Gary Freeman at halfback, one of the best full-backs ever to play in Garry Jack and a young, brash and heavily mulleted Tim Brasher.

Coming off a loss to Canterbury in the 1988 final, the Tigers in 89 had beaten minor premiers Souths and second place Penrith to get to the final: 89 had to be the year of the Tiger.

This was the same year my family moved to Canberra from Sydney and I had successfully lobbied to have my primary school’s end of term “Raiders’ Day” have its name changed to “Football Day”.

Wearing my Tigers jersey to school I pointed out that some kids were in fact Balmain fans: there was me, my brother, my sister and the silent kid in kindergarten who was more of an intense brooding type of Tigers fan.

At the beginning of that Sunday afternoon Balmain were looking unbeatable. They flew off to a 12-2 lead at half time, including an amazing try from Siro and a try saver from Jack. It was in the bag.

Canberra’s supercoach Tim Sheens (who later redeemed himself by coaching the Tigers to the 2005 premiership) put a rocket underneath the Raiders at half time, pointing out that they were in fact the better attacking team. 

With a their own superstars, including Mal Meninga and a young Ricky Stewart and Bradley Clyde, the Raiders attacked in the second half and the Tigers under Warren Ryan tried to defend rather than fighting back.

Ryan, one of the most respected coaches of his era, committed what would prove a shocking tactical error by taking both Sironen and Roach off thus making them ineligible to come on again in the event of extra time.

Why are Blocker and Siro on the bench? Cause Warren Ryan put them there

With Balmain being just 90 seconds away from their first Premiership in 20 years, Raiders winger John “chicka” Ferguson weaved through a pack of five Balmain defenders to force the game into extra time at 14 all* (corrected).

In the 20 minutes of extra time hooker Benny Elias tried for a field goal but hit the cross-bar - one of those strange horror moments in sport that seem to unfold in slow motion.

The Raiders managed to get one field goal (only after Elias charged one attempt down) and then with just a couple of minutes to go no-name replacement forward Steve Jackson scored a try by beating two tackles and pulling three Tigers over the line with him.

It was one of greatest moments in football history and the Tigers were on the wrong end of it.

This game is widely regarded as the best Grand Final ever, Tom Keneally was even inspired to write an account of it in “A Movie Script That Came To Life”.

None of this is much consolation to a crying seven year old though, who keeps asking his father the non-rhetorical question: “how did we lose?” 

The moment that buried Balmain,

Most commented

24 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • DG says:

      07:59am | 25/09/09

      As a raiders fan, I can unashamedly admit that the above article brought a tear to my eye. Not of pity for the tigers (however, they may deserve a degree of pity, nearly as much as their fans deserve to be pitied ), but of pride for the Mighty Green Machine - Those were the days.

      The brilliance didn’t end with Stewart, Meninga and Clyde. You’ve left out Daley, Walters (both Kevin and Steve), Lazarus… Need I go on?

      Shame our current team doesn’t have the skill or class of the glory days… But we’ll be back one day. Long live the Green Machine.

    • Tim says:

      08:51am | 25/09/09

      What Strength, What Power, What a Grand Final, What a Premiership.
      Too Bad for your Tigers Leo,
      the Raiders were ordained by God to win their first premiership in ‘89.
      Brings back memories of when the Raiders used to actually win games. Maybe next year.

    • wolf says:

      09:31am | 25/09/09

      I feel your pain Leo. I remember watching this as a kid and screaming at the tv in a mix of frustration and anger. I think this was the year that James Grant finished up one of the semis with a busted shoulder?
      What I am sure of is that this was pretty much the last year that the halfbacks fed the ball into the front row.  Since they now feed the ball into the second row I can confidently say there is no chance we’ll ever see a hooker as good as Benny again.

    • Chambo says:

      09:53am | 25/09/09

      Beautiful stuff Leo, but the league historian in me must point out that the final score was 19-14 in favour of the Raiders. It was never 18-all.

      And while I used to call this the greatest game of all time, looking at the video recently made me realise that it fades in comparison with modern day classics.

      For example, I wonder why the cliff-hanging 2003 grand final does not get more love. It had everything - two teams at the top of their game locked together until the dying minutes, a tiny number of penalties and stoppages, great tries, huge hits and possibly the greatest GF tackle of all time from Scotty Sattler that turned the result. The fact that i am a devout Panthers fan has nothing to do with my judgment on this matter…

      Maybe the 89 GF is so special because the Roosters are one of those teams that everyone loves to hate and most of us felt in 89 that it was the Tigers turn?

    • RT says:

      09:53am | 25/09/09

      You’re right, Leo, 20 years later and it still hurts. The 2005 premiership helped but did not wipe away the memories.

      There were many chances for the Tigers to wrap it up ithat day in 89. I remember Elias passing to Pearce only about 10 metres out from the Raiders’ line and about 10 minutes to go. Had Pearce taken the pass the defence probably would not have stopped him.  The pass was high and Pearce couldn’t catch it.

      Then Ferguson scored the equaliser.

      I’m also still dirty about the Tigers grand final the previous year, 1988 against the Canterbury Bulldogs. The Tiges looked hopeless to get there with only a few rounds of the season remaining. They’d have to win every match of seven to take the premiership. They were joined by English wizz Ellery Hanley, and with him, they won six in a row to make the GF. In the opening 10 minutes of the GF, Hanley was held from behind by the ‘dogs Andrew Farrar while Terry Lamb launched himself at his head with a forearm. Ellery was knocked into the 5th dimension and took no further part in the game.

      The ref looked the other way as this blatant and pre-planned foul was committed. No-one was marched.  With the Tigers demoralised by the turn of events, the ‘dogs went on to win the game.

      The ‘dogs powerful boss ‘Bullfrog’ Moore ensured there were no repercusssions and this blatant cheating was soon forgotten. The Tigers even inexplicably appointed Lamb as their coach some years later. They did no better with him than they did that day in 1988.

    • Tim says:

      10:06am | 25/09/09

      RT,
      don’t worry. Terry Lamb got some karma when big Mal smashed him in the ‘94 grand final.
      Ah Raiders memories.

    • Leo Shanahan

      Leo Shanahan says:

      11:35am | 25/09/09

      Thanks for the comments guys, they all help in the recovery process. @Chambo sorry about the mistake on the normal time score. Of course the Tigers never even got to 18 points. I my defence was seven in 89, you would’ve been about 54 (jokes).

    • Brendan says:

      12:20pm | 25/09/09

      As a Raider fan, I must give props to the Tigers that year.  They were a worthy opposition.  But the Raiders’ story that year was one for the history books .  As I recall the Green Machine was fouth placed at the end of the season due to some horrific injuries during the year.  They had to win something like the last 7-8 games back to back to make the Grand Final. 

      The Tigers were great, but the Raiders were legendary.

    • david whyte says:

      01:37pm | 25/09/09

      my wife still doesnt understand. but i cried all day. and yes, it still hurts.

    • PeterM says:

      01:54pm | 25/09/09

      Missed out the bit where the referee gave a penalty for “obstruction” against a Balmain forward because while holding the ball, he ran around an opponent.  Some of us thought that was the general idea of the game, but not this ref, who still tries to ignore the fact that Section 15 has a note saying “The player in possession of the ball cannot be guilty of obstruction”.  His book still says he was right, but he never explains why.

    • Paula says:

      02:48pm | 25/09/09

      As an Eels fan - I totally understand. This has brought back memories of the 2001 GF: Eels vs Newcastle…..

    • Nathan says:

      02:59pm | 25/09/09

      As a devout Roosters fan, my worst moment was when Scott Satler chased down Todd Byrne as he was sprinting away to score. Was there to see it happen live, in the pouring rain, and cannot forget how hollow I felt afterwards.

    • Mat says:

      04:28pm | 25/09/09

      Leo - I will NEVER get over that loss.  Tim Sheens I have forgiven because he got one back for us in 2005 but Wozza Ryan is still on my people to headbutt list!  I think I was 8 at the time and haven’t cried as much since

    • Duke says:

      04:53pm | 25/09/09

      Yes Peter M the obstruction call was the turning point, coming with a few minutes to go and the Tigers working towards half way.  Without the blatant referee error Ferguson would still be reliving his (and Ryan’s) glory year with the mighty jets.  Conveniently ignored by the holy city workstationers and their then team of high priced mercenaries.

    • Peter says:

      05:08pm | 25/09/09

      I was at that Grand final because I thought the sharks (minor premiers) would be there.  Balmain knocked them out the week before…9-2 if I rememeber correctly. I did cry then. Dogs played dirty in the final by Lamb taking out Ellery Hanley. Tigers never recovered from that.

    • tigermark says:

      05:08pm | 25/09/09

      thank-you Leo. you have seriously helped soothe the pain a little.  I was only 8 at the time and looking back now, I feel like an old fogie when I say things like “it’s just not the same anymore” and “those were the days”. another tissue please.

    • NQ says:

      11:53pm | 27/09/09

      Leo.  Tragic yes ... but move on.  At least you had 2005.  I am still in therapy over Benji’s pass and Bowman’s brain explosion.  We all have our sob stories to tell on the Leichhardt hill over 6-7 cans (especially if you are a Cows supporter ... the Tiger’s official ‘whipping’ boys).

    • Sam. says:

      12:30am | 28/09/09

      I feel sorry that your Grand Final at the age of seven wasn’t as good as mine, Leo.
      Mine was the 1997 Knights vs Manly win, still, for me, the best moment in my overpopulated sport-watching history. I’ll never forget the frenetic shouting of Ray Warren as Darren Albert crossed the line. I’ll never forget every person I was sitting with jumping off the couch simultaneously as we scored. I’ll never forget every single person in Newcastle becoming a football supporter for the next two weeks.
      It was an amazing time - my father and I religiously collected every newspaper cutting about the win… We wound up plastering an entire room with cuttings about the Grand Final.’

      What I think is particularly revealing in this article is the extent of the emotional attachment we have with our favoured sporting teams. It’s an amazing thing.

    • Tigerman says:

      01:10am | 28/09/09

      Ah had ignored - 20 years on -the date we Tigers were meant to have had with destiny.  A mighty Grand Final it was - shame about the result!
      And Peter M is correct one if the worst refereeing displays - that penalty was an error (to be nice),  It gave valuable free metres to Canberra at a critical time in the game .
      But what a team those Tigers were.
      As the saying goes:
      There are two types of people in the world - Those who are Tiger supporters and those who wish they were.

    • regina says:

      05:36pm | 28/09/09

      RT

      um .. i think a few corrections to your post are in order for the public record.

      ‘Hanley was ALLEGEDLY held from behind by the ‘dogs Andrew Farrar while Terry Lamb ALLEGEDLY launched himself at his head with a forearm ...

      The ref looked the other way as this ALLEGEDLY blatant and pre-planned foul was committed. “

      oh you’re welcome.

    • Emmanuel says:

      08:24pm | 03/10/09

      For a while I kept the post game article by Warren Ryan.  The biggest hype in the week before the game was about how great for the game it would be if Canberra won - it would spread the game if a team outside Sydney won.  Ryan said all this hype went to a subconscious level (for all but Tigers fans), even to the referee.

      When McGuire (Tigers in possession) ran into the offside Walters (Raiders),  Harrigan penalised McGuire.  To so penalise the attacking player had never happened before and has never happened since.  Wayne Pierce later said that Harrigan must have had some sort of brain snap and pointed the penalty the wrong way.  This fits in with Ryan’s explanation (na na na na).

      I tossed out Ryan’s article to help me get over it.  That has obviously worked.

    • Dave says:

      10:13pm | 14/10/09

      I was at the game, seats right on the half way line, eastern side of the stadium. I haven’t been able to bring myself to watch the replay in the 20 years since, but i’m positive Benny Elias hit the crossbar during regulation time while we were 6 points up.
      And i still remember having this uneasy feeling, even when leading 12-2 at half time, that Canberra were going to come home over the top of us.
      And what was with that Bill Harrigan decision against Bruce McGuire for using an offside Raiders marker as a shepherd???

    • cricketts says:

      04:36pm | 20/06/10

      brings back memories. i won a tigers jersy signed by the whole team of that yr and was a proud 7yyr old wearing it at the park on the day.
      what a shame it didnt go the other way. dosnt matter they still be the best team about…..GO THE TIGERS!!

    • Matt says:

      04:49pm | 17/09/10

      Just found this article & can say that it only brings back bad memories.  I was at Balmain Leagues that day & you could have heard a pin drop.  I was amongsy many Balmains boys that cried that day…

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Lucy Kippist

RT @HeatherSmithAU: Can living in another country change your life for the better? by @lucyjk on @newscomau f. moi http://t.co/E5Ma3kBut2

David Penberthy

@mooks83 sophisticated response. Think the kids parents saw it differently

David Penberthy

More class from 9's footy show, lampooning a baby that allegedly looks like Sterlo with a pic swiped from Facebook http://t.co/BGoYP6Pn68

Lucy Kippist

A story that's close to my heart - can living overseas change your life for the better? With thanks, @Alisa_reduxhttp://t.co/n6tksJstqs

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter