Someone I love very much is fat. Really fat. Technically, you’d say he’s morbidly obese, but “morbid” actually means “gruesome” or “being unduly interested in death”, which doesn’t apply to my friend at all. At least, I don’t think it does.

Reality bites. Photo: News.com.au

It’s hard to tell, because fat people don’t talk about being fat. Sure, they’re the first to dub themselves “chubster” or “jelly belly”, or “Sir Cumference” or “Lord of the Fries”. But it’s a tactic – much the same way gay people adopted “queer”, thereby cleverly disempowering the homophobes who tried to beat them with it.

It’s as if Roseanne Barr single-handedly silenced the plus-sized world when she said, “So you’re fat? Just be fat and shut up about it.” Well, she is wrong. (And not very funny. Much funnier is Dawn French, who says she’d have been a famous model had she been around when Rubens was painting. Kate Moss? She’d have been the paintbrush.)

Seriously, though, we need to talk about obesity. On a personal – not just policy – level. It’s all very well assembling taskforces and calling for bans on junk food ads, but if we’re not prepared to embrace it in a grassroots, one-on-one, “I love you, but I’m terrified you’re going to die” sort of way, we may as well succumb to death by burger.

If you’re fat, you’re going to look at my picture and think, what would she know? Fair enough. But I’m not wagging my finger, moaning about the blight on our health system and suggesting we put junk food in packaging decorated with images of clogged arteries. Talkback radio has that covered.

What I’m advocating is that we stop ignoring the elephant in the room. That, among families and friends, we acknowledge the battle and heartache that is obesity. Because I’d hazard a guess that the more you take your comfort from food, the less you take it from somewhere else.

A recent survey in the US revealed one in six women would rather be blind than fat. Another found that a third of women would trade at least a year of their lives to have the perfect body. Both are hideous sentiments, but also a measure of the slow, quiet desperation felt by those trapped by their girth.

New predictions that 83 per cent of Aussie men and 75 per cent of women will be overweight or obese by 2025 suggest that our strategies to stem the problem are failing. But new research also shows that our social networks have a huge bearing on obesity; if someone close to you becomes obese, your chances of joining them increase by up to 71 per cent, because people who socialise together tend to have similar eating and exercise habits.

It sounds simple, but what if we started talking? What if one woman said to her friends, “Let’s take champagne and go for a bushwalk to celebrate my birthday, rather than booking a restaurant.” What if the man I saw being innocently asked by his son why he was so fat actually bothered to answer him?

I once gathered 22 former Biggest Loser contestants for a photoshoot and saw first-hand the strength and freedom they’d gained by being open about their weight. They’d shed more than a tonne between them, but it was their shared stories (including a recipe for lettuce-wrapped burritos) that were inspiring. One modelled a bikini. “The last time I could fit into a bikini, I was four,” she told me, brushing away tears.

Talk of obesity doesn’t have to be patronising or preachy. Next time my fat friend jokes he’s in shape because “round is a shape”, I’ll probably still laugh. But I might gently ask if he’d ever like to be a rectangle.

Most commented

63 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • mahhrat says:

      06:26am | 19/06/11

      The biggest loser is making it worse, not better.  If it really inspired instead of allow the great unwashed to snigger at wobbly bellies like they will here, then you’d have similar shows for ppl quitting smoking or gambling, the other great modern Australian addictions.

    • Gregg says:

      07:45am | 19/06/11

      ” Next time my fat friend jokes he’s in shape because “round is a shape”, I’ll probably still laugh. But I might gently ask if he’d ever like to be a rectangle. ”
      You may have meant Angela, whether he would like to be surrounded by a rectangular form of a prism, one made of timber but I get your gist just as I had to look twice to make sure you had used someone and not something in
      ” Someone I love very much is fat. Really fat. “
      Having a larger frame, big bones and all, 13 lb. 4 oz. popping out of mum, I was always destined to be a bigger lad and a propensity to carry the extra pounds, family and friends saying you have the build to carry it etc. but you do tend to carry more as the years progress.
      Having been able to shed a few pounds, actually more than a few kilos on a few occasions, I reckon a lot of it is all in the mind, for me at least and the trend is again down for the moment, less time on the keyboard and being more active.
      You just have to want to do it! , and do it for yourself, no one else.

    • Melrusk says:

      10:14am | 19/06/11

      OOOOOOOOOOOOOOh big respect for your MUM wink

      I must say I agree with you Gregg.
      The power of ones emotions on how we see our selves physicaly never ceases to amaze me.
      On the other side however I did find being on the larger side was a pretty good Shite Filter.
      More power to you Gregg for recognising that.

    • Fiona says:

      10:17am | 19/06/11

      Actually birthweight doesn’t really paint the whole picture. I know a couple of young adults who were very low birthweight and both are tall, well built adults. Most 13lbers would have come from a woman with pregnancy induced diabetes, not all, but a lot. If your family is big that’s another thing.

    • Goldenfaber says:

      07:50am | 19/06/11

      So every womans magazine in the last fifty years has been full of diets and they just keep getting fatter. This article reminds me of Emma Thomson who wrote for the The Australian and who’s one and only article every week for a year was about being over weight and then at the end of the year wrote ” Why does everybody just talk about food’. She lacks the discipline and work ethic to write a researched article so cannot write about anything except her fat arse. You would not want to live with such a scatter brained self absorbed pile of immature waste of life. I work with some idiot woman who gets up at 4a.m. and starts exercising and has lost a lot of weight and now like all that mob is just a hyperactive drop kick who won’t talk about anything else.
      Just be fat and shut up about it you bloody head cases. People who talk about weight are just pigs so fuck off - you know that this will be the ten thousandth piece of crap article written about this topic this year in Australia and every head case woman will read it and add to her grief and dumbing down and no it will not help any of them. And yes i know Ms Stoopid was mainly talking about men but may i suggest that she is not one and we are sick of hearing woman talking about NOTHING else - i know men who are avoiding relationships because of this.

    • Gregg says:

      08:02am | 19/06/11

      @ Golden! big daddy,
      ” People who talk about weight are just pigs so fuck off - you know that this will be the ten thousandth piece of crap article written about this topic…................ “
      Wow there big boy, just don’t tuck into that stack of pancakes as well as the extra serves of bacon to lighten up your day.
      If anybody is stoopid or an idiot her, I reckon you’ll be close to getting the gold medal and I reckon you might just be jealous you cannot haul your own arse out of bed at 6 am, let alone 4 am.
      Get some balance into your life and you might not just be so abusive and critical of others.

    • BK says:

      08:08am | 19/06/11

      Women who obsess over their weight are just fishing for compliments anyway….and we are supposed to believe that their self-esteem is too low.

    • marley says:

      08:45am | 19/06/11

      Wow.  I hope that rant makes you feel better.  You may not need to work on your weight, pal, but you’d better do something about your anger.  That will cut your life short as sure as a few extra kilos will.

    • Spooner says:

      10:42am | 19/06/11

      Hilarious,very funny and sad,Im now going to eat a Mudcake

    • Sidhe says:

      02:39pm | 19/06/11

      OMG this is so true! Health nuts are boring and self absorbed as hell.

      It takes a huge amount of will power and time to drop just a couple of dress sizes, let alone from a very heavy weight. In fact from what I’ve seen, triggering and then milking Obsessiveness for all its worth is really the only way to lose a lot of weight. Hello Eating Disorders!

      If they want to die from being fat then the media should just let them! Stop making up Shame TV shows to make everybody else feel skinny and virtuous in comparison. Nobody’s perfect and I prefer the company of fat people to boney aggressive amphetamine addicts, boring health nuts, holier than thou vegetarians, anal retentive anorexic control freaks, useless stoners, neat freaks, liverish alcoholics, paranoid activists, sexually abusive footballers, ignorant boarish bogans, and fashion snobs, all of whom are happy to feel superior to anyone who wears a larger size than them.

      The problem is with people reacting to “fat” as if it were a sin and/or contagious. I have a dear friend who runs marathons but whose body does not show it. She is constantly being sneered at by people who are skinny but know nothing about health or her particular physiology that simply will not allow her to look anything but bulky no matter how healthy she is.

    • Jackie says:

      07:58am | 19/06/11

      Let us look at some of the messages we get thee days. How true is it, that we are eating ourselves to death, by being fat? ? People die of cancer , age 26, never fat! Obese people are potrayed as happy people! Look at Santa. the worriers and thinkers are potrayed as skinny and problem children. As a society we are constantly getting these differing ideas thown at us. Can we get some sensible logical ideas? Look at the new campaign by the govt, Swap it dont stop it. I think it is confusing even more people. Get some straight messages across, being obese is unhealthy. Period.

    • Luke says:

      08:41am | 19/06/11

      I am fat because food is my friend. I dont really have any friends, or family and food is my comfort. I know its a problem, and I know I need to change my behaviour, ive tried on many occassions, but its hard when for years you’ve used food as a substitute for your feelings, and to be honest its even harder when there is so much negativity aimed and condescending attitudes aimed at overweight people. It’s quite ironic that the constantly barrage of negatives aimed at fat people by the media and through snobby comments like “its easy you just eat less and exercise more” or “every time i go to kfc there’s always fatties scoffing down on food”, are actually fuelling the obesity epidemic more because those type of comments just make fat people feel even worse and they eat more. I am by no means blaming overeating on other people, but generally people are obese because psychologically they are using food as a way to control their emotive behaviour, so of course they will react to negative perceptions in a negative way.  If you really want to help with obesity or show support for a fat person, show some compassion, realise they are real people with real emotions, treat them the way you want to be treated. Just like you have your issues in your life that may force you to drink, gamble or take drugs, a fat person has their own issues with drives them to food. Oh and by the way, I went to the doctors for a full check up, blood tests etc 2 weeks ago and have been told im in perfect health, so dont assume all overweight people are unhealthy, lazy people. It’s like assuming every slim person is in pristine perfect health. I do want to lose weight though, and im trying. It’s hard though when you dont have any hope and the world just brings you down more and more.

    • Nicole says:

      09:54am | 19/06/11

      My personal favourite is when larger people are exercising in public and get mocked out of car windows, etc, for being fat. I mean, really? Where is the logic in that? Yes, let’s all make bigger people feel awful about their weight even when they’re actively trying to change it. /sarcasm

      I agree with you 100%, Luke. A little compassion can go a long way to helping someone break the trend.

    • Tron says:

      11:57am | 19/06/11

      Nicole, anytime i see a large person working out i think good on them, when i see them at maccas gorging i think you fat piece of shit

    • Speedo says:

      12:10pm | 19/06/11

      People will be nasty regardless whether you are exercising or not,,Do it for yourself! Go to any recreation centre at anytime of the day and people of all shapes and sizes are trying to be a little fitter,summon up the courage,jump in and have a swim

    • stephen says:

      12:43pm | 19/06/11

      (Labradors react negatively to a negative situation.)
      If you can discern that 2 negatives don’t equal a positive, then you are only a fool if you do not get professional help and improve your mental and physical being.

    • Elaine says:

      07:41pm | 19/06/11

      Good job Luke.

      Next time my friends snigger at a (perhaps not so in shape) person, I’ll ensure to slap and berate them.

      Best of luck in all your future endeavours.

    • Gregg says:

      08:49pm | 19/06/11

      @Luke,
      It is so easy to have food as a friend and I know all about that, even if it is for the occasional enjoyment of the mud cakes being on special and walking into Woolies, Coles etc. where there are stacks of them and the bakery close to the entrance surely doesn’t help.
      And it is never so easy to discipline yourself for a big change to habits but try little bites, literally as well to set yourself something of a plan, maybe start off with a weekly food plan and have little snacks throughout the day and there’s plenty of healthier options if you want to think about it.
      You might still find food can be a friend but not so much of it and then do some brainstorming on what you would like to do for just not food, be it reading, music or other hobbies, a good mix of some activity type ones being a good idea, even gardening to grow some easy stuff like strawberries, carrots and other fruits, all healthy.
      If you’re cooking for yourself, do things like stir fries but minimal oil and plenty of spices etc.
      Spice up your life in all respects and many people live relatively solitary lives, a dog a man’s best friend it is often said and you can meet heaps of people exercising a best friend and they’re full of compassion.
      And another approach is to think about what is the minimum food budget you can survive on healthily, set some targets and try and better them and then start thinking about all the good trips etc. you could make with what you save.

    • Lloyd says:

      08:55pm | 19/06/11

      Good luck mate.Be careful around here though there are people like therealdave and Sceptimus who lack compassion.Ignore them!

    • static says:

      07:21am | 20/06/11

      I reckon the first thing to do is throw away the bloody great UFO sized dinner plates that seem to be around today and get a much smaller one,or if you have a lot of money you can go to a trendy restaurant and watch as those huge white plates come out with a few bits of food on them

    • Matt says:

      04:46pm | 20/06/11

      Good luck with losing weight Luke, sounds like you want it.  Maybe next time at the doctors ask about some counselling sessions - I think you get 4 free sessions per year (or thereabouts), to help with emotive eating.  Again, good luck.

    • The Black Optimist says:

      09:35am | 19/06/11

      Luke, just change the word ‘friend’ to ‘enemy’ and find another reward.  I tried water and walked the walk and smelt the flowers and the frost in the air. Don’t give up.  If you’ve been given the fitness OK, take heart and keep it well by walking - good luck -  the best time of your life could be just around the corner.

    • Against the Man says:

      10:10am | 19/06/11

      Doesn’t Nicola Roxon find obesity highly amusing? Where is the plain packaging and no marketing for kids? I mean why stop at plain ciggie packs, obesity is either a good or bad thing, so which is it Roxon?

      Its is a health risk right?
      83% of men and 75% of women being obese is bad right?

      So where is the action Roxon? What are we paying you to do or not do as is the case?

      C’mon people, when your health minister is as dedicated and corrupt as Al Pacino’s Scarface, forget about finding a solution to the obesity epidemic. Just sit back and enjoy that heart attack!

      http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/alp-still-seeking-political-donations-from-tobacco-companies/story-fn59niix-1226077398148

    • Ashlee says:

      10:15am | 19/06/11

      I’m fat and I have a wonderful life.  So stop being so patronising with all your terrible puns.  Focus on health rather than vilification based on how people look.  I have skinny friends that get puffed climbing a few staircases. Health is the issue here, not size. Everyone should be encouraged to be healthy and that’s what policy should focus on instead of pointless government ads with obese balloons. Sure, there are some people who need help to live healthier lifestyles and get involved in activities. They may or may not be fat. But those Biggest Loser contestants you talked about were probably so darn happy because finally people stopped calling them names.  Perhaps it’s the constant stream of attacks rather than the weight that is the bigger problem that needs to be solved… it’s a problem that discourages many people from participating in sports and physical activity.

    • Pete says:

      11:43am | 19/06/11

      Ashlee you are right to claim health, not weight as the goal. Some people can be slightly overweight and OK, but in general, anyone classified as ‘fat’ might have a wonderful life, but statistically it’s going to be a shorter one. The correlation with overweight and reduced life expectancy is pretty much linear. Of course skinny people can be unhealthy: but that’s utterly irrelevant in a discussion on obesity, and sounds like self-justification to me, something I hear alot of from fat people.

    • BL says:

      12:07pm | 19/06/11

      @Pete
      Unhealthy and Skinny is entirely relevant to the situation, because often the argument is that “slim” people are fit and healthy, when in reality slim people generally take up habits other than overeating, such as smoking or drug abuse. While I think obesity is an issue and should be talked about, all I have been hearing lately is “fat bashing” of which nothing proactive will come out of, while when it comes to anorexia people are all supportive and loving, when in fact both obesity and anorexia are the symptoms of mental health and psychological issues.

      And also your comment that “statistically it’s going to be a shorter one” in relation to an overweight person’s life expectancy. Is this such a bad thing? In the coming decades we are going to have massive overpopulation issues, due to people wanting to “live forever”. I personally do not want to live beyond 60, and am quite happy dying younger knowing ive enjoyed life.  It’s going to be those that are intent of living until they are quite old that will be costing tax payers a hell of alot more than obesity.

    • stephen says:

      12:36pm | 19/06/11

      Size too.
      Fatties should pay double fares on buses, planes, and should keep off amusement park rides, lest it break, (and especially Luna Park’s scenic railway, lest it don’t make it up the hill.)
      Fat people eat too much, and if it weren’t so obcene, how come everybody takes offence when you watch them eat ?
      But that don’t mean we gotta feel sorry for then and save them by banning or curtailing fast-food shops.
      Lock up their cars, dismantle the elevator, triple the cost of the ferry,(too many fatties in the water will give us an idea of rising global sea-levels), and put some extra padding in the souls of their shoes, (i’d rather not, if you don’t mind, watch them waddle or roll.)
      And I certainly won’t patronize you if some kid cannot get a hospital-bed cause you’re there getting your tubes tied, (the one near your stomach).

    • marley says:

      02:14pm | 19/06/11

      Stephen, Stephen - you have just proven conclusively that it’s better to have a fat body than a fat head.

    • Sad Sad Reality says:

      10:48am | 20/06/11

      If you are overweight, you are not healthy. End of chat.

    • Ashlee says:

      10:20am | 19/06/11

      “Sure, they’re the first to dub themselves “chubster” or “jelly belly”, or “Sir Cumference” or “Lord of the Fries”. “

      Really?  Last I checked, it was usually other people who called fat people offensive names. At least that has always been my experience.  Maybe your “friend” plays along as a coping mechanism for all the constant taunting.

    • Anon says:

      11:06am | 19/06/11

      Just by the way, in the case of obesity “morbid” means a diseased state, disability or poor health due to obesity - as in, your weight is starting to adversely affect your health to the point where you can no longer function the way you use to, perhaps not being able to climb stairs or walk a certain distance.

    • Gladys says:

      11:34am | 19/06/11

      anon: i thought morbidly obese was when your BMI was at a certain level. It goes, Overweight, obese, morbidly obese super morbidly obese.

    • Kassandra says:

      12:18pm | 20/06/11

      Medically (that’s where the term comes from) morbid obesity means more than double the desirable weight for height, desirable weight being based on actuarial tables associated with morbidity’mortality risks, not on the latest BMI according to the weight police. Like elevated blood pressure and cholesterol, obesity is a risk factor not a disease in itself. Just keep in mind that although we may be fatter than ever, at least so we are told by the weight police, we are also taller, healthier and living longer than ever before.

    • Bella says:

      12:27pm | 19/06/11

      I figure that “fat” people (and why are they identified by their shape or size anyway?) feel that the only power over their own lives left in this fast developing control culture is over what they put in their mouth. 
      And I guess this goes for cigarettes too.
      I am convinced this is about saving on health costs for our “leaders” and nothing to do with your health…simply our government’s coffers !

    • Sosha says:

      12:37pm | 19/06/11

      Isn’t all this body shape and size nonsense about making a perfect state/State ?
      It’s not about being fat at all !  More and more I notice that narcissism takes hold and we don’t like looking at anything that is not perceived as “naice”.
      Maybe some bigger people just need a “barrier” between them and the rest of the world too, who could blame them ?
      My mother in law was as wide as she was tall, and lived healthily to the ripe old age of 98.  State of mind, not state of body !  Maybe just too much State !

    • stephen says:

      09:53pm | 19/06/11

      Why do you think it’s about the perfect state ?
      No-one’s mentioned the ‘group’.
      We are concerned about about health : emotional, physical and mental.
      If individuals are healthy, why is the ‘State” in danger ?
      Or are you so worried that, if neuroses becomes obsolete, no-one will take mediocrity seriously ?

    • Outraged says:

      12:50pm | 19/06/11

      Anglea, YOU need take responsibility for your industry glorifying obesity.

      Magazines like Marie Clare and Harpers have monthly articles about “Big Is Beautiful” and “Real Women Have Curves”. Fat chicks now get told they are just “curvy” or “sassy” and we support them with a “Go girl!”. I find alot of bigger girls are OVER confident and proud about their weight…and they heckle thinner (normal!) women as being “not real women” or “too thin”.

      I find the whole “Fat Acceptance” community just as warped as the “Pro Ana” crowd…both are promoting unhealthy body types.

    • Lucinda says:

      01:31pm | 19/06/11

      Love it how when fat people is the topic, the name calling starts. So many fattist people out there.

      I like being fat. I do. Weird but true.  I weigh, well I don’t know what I weigh really but last time I did I was 150kg or thereabouts, three years ago at my heaviest ever I was 170kg. Scary shit. And I only lost that 20kg so I could put socks on again without resorting to bbq tongs as an aid to dressing.

      I’m 5"4’, I’m 46, my blood pressure is 120/80. I don’t drink, my cholesterol is 3.2 , my bsl last time it was done a few weeks ago was 4.8. I’m disgustingly healthy on the inside - for now. My heart though is enlarged a little and my resting pulse sits around the 90-100 mark, which is BAD.

      I was a tubby kid but played a lot of sport, tennis, hockey, soccer. netball till I hurt my knee, indoor cricket, whatever was going. Rode my pushbike everywhere. I was a really active kid.

      My parents nagged me incessantly about losing weight, always, forever (and still do unfortunately) and withheld those naughty things like biscuits and cake etc. I had to steal food when I had a craving. I was always hungry. So, when I left school and started earning my own money, I ate everything in sight because I could and was still always hungry.  I worked out a couple of years ago that I ate to spite my parents. Pretty fucked hey?

      So, I steadily got bigger, never tried fad diets and being bigger never bothered me. I’ve never been single, or unemployed and could still get my legs behind my ears so to speak and I was having a lovely life, I still am.

      Being fat was no obstruction to anything so why be slimmer? It was only other people who wanted me skinny. And quite frankly skinny sounds scary. I’ve no doubt I would have been a terribly fickle and vain person (and a bit of a trollop) had I been slimmer, being a fatty has made me who I am today.

      But now that middle age has arrived, along with arthritis in the bits I damaged from all those sporting injuries in my teens and the worry that I’m a walking heart attack and that I could seriously cark it, things need to change. My dad has been diabetic for a few years too so there’s that risk also.

      Plus I found I don’t fit into cinema seats (that was quite an awkward moment) or any other sort of seat it seems. I’m sure they make them smaller now to save money, a bit like Cadbury’s making their 85gm bars 80gms. It’s inconvenient now for me to be a fatso. 

      I CAN lose size/weight, I’ve done it before. It’s easy, I just have to not eat and exercise for 10 hours a day.  I already walk daily, and swim daily in summer, so it really will be a struggle and perhaps down the track I will have to take the lapband option that has been offered by the quack but that is a last resort.

    • Anjuli says:

      02:00pm | 19/06/11

      I know of 4 people who have had stomach banding, 2 have been successful and lost 50 kilo each the other 2 not so. One is on bi-polar medication which doesn’t help but the downfall is the wine she drinks every night the other just likes her food has lost some but should have lost a lot more.It is very sad for these very overweight people ,there are a lot of things that can be done to get the extra kilos off but if they don’t have the will it won’t happen.I know , if I see an over weight person buying ice cream or doughnuts it is a great put off for me.

    • fish says:

      02:13pm | 19/06/11

      “What I’m advocating is that we stop ignoring the elephant in the room.”

      Was that an intentional pun?

    • Grant says:

      03:21pm | 19/06/11

      Ergh

      Grossing me out with their sweating and mouth breathing, pushing me off the seat on the bus, eating stuff with their mouths open.

      Don’t be ashamed by your repulsion.

      Your dislike is a proven scientific fact.  Your aversion and revulsion is a natural biological reaction designed to indicate that they are unhealthy and that you should not bread with them.

    • Rose says:

      04:19pm | 19/06/11

      I would prefer a fattie over an idiot who can’t even spell. FYI it’s “Breed”. Entirely different word to “Bread”.

    • baal says:

      05:00pm | 19/06/11

      Please Grant, how do you bread with a fat person? Also do you have a car or does you repulsion power you about? I say we should stop breeding with stupid bastards. I have a feeling there would be less comfort eating and depression in a world without bastards.

    • Grant says:

      10:32am | 20/06/11

      I apologise, I think I might have had food on the mind when I wrote ‘bread’ instead of ‘breed’.

    • Bitten says:

      03:40pm | 19/06/11

      Oh good, more Punch about absolutely nothing.

    • stephen says:

      09:04pm | 19/06/11

      No it’s about fat people and how our population explosion should not be pissing off Dick Smith, but personal girth.

    • Master race says:

      07:28pm | 19/06/11

      Heir Roxon ve are the master race and should get rid of fat people the smokers and drinkers . They are going to die from there habits and contribute nothing. The plan is working Australians are turning on each other and now they are guilt ridden wack on a big tax on smokes drinks sweets and soft drinks.
      Ban Apple computers as the kids and fatties might think it’s healthy make them put them in plain packaging .
      Heir Roxon you are not over weight it’s the camera that ads those extra 50 kgs and makes you looks a. bit Downey

    • VickiPS says:

      08:50pm | 19/06/11

      Oh for god’s sake, yet another “I’m only saying this for your own good” schtick.  Since you opened the door, may I make a fervent plea on behalf of my loved ones who suffer from uncontrollable flatulence?

      Look, if you’re serious about wanting to open dialogue about morbid obesity, can for f**k’s sake get past dressing up “eat less and exercise more” as though it were a magic gift just waiting to be unwrapped?  We KNOW all that.  What we’d like to have real dialogue about is why we morbidly obese people find it so difficult to do just that.  In my experience, that’s the point at which non-fat people stop hearing. 

      Punch, why don’t you do us all a favour and find a genuine expert in bariatric research and treatment to put all some facts before the readers, before opening yet another one-sided “dialogue”.

      PS.  Grant, that’s no way to talk about your mother.

    • PG says:

      02:48pm | 20/06/11

      “Look, if you’re serious about wanting to open dialogue about morbid obesity, can for f**k’s sake get past dressing up “eat less and exercise more” as though it were a magic gift just waiting to be unwrapped?  We KNOW all that.  What we’d like to have real dialogue about is why we morbidly obese people find it so difficult to do just that.  In my experience, that’s the point at which non-fat people stop hearing”

      Ok, some of us are listening. Why is it so hard to eat less and exercise more? I’m actually more interested in why you didn’t do something about it when you realised you were getting fat and before you got to be morbidly obese. It’s not like the health implications have only just become known. I’m an ex-smoker so I think I know some of the reasons but why don’t you tell us anyway.

    • Dave C says:

      09:23pm | 19/06/11

      I feel so so sorry for Obese people, they are addicted to bad behavior the same as a smoker, gambler or drug addict. The difference is they overdo what the rest of us do naturally and they need help.

      From what I can gather lap band surgery is the answer it ensures that an overweight or Obese person cant eat any more than a certain amount because they feel “full” Many people have changed their lives around as a result.

      The question is why isnt this surgery provided free or at least put on a medicare listing so anybody that needs it can get it. The cost of doing this would have to be greater than the cost of the taxpayers of diabetes and complications from it which is usual consequence of Obesity.

    • Lisa H. says:

      01:27am | 20/06/11

      Oh, Angela is going to remind her fat friend that he is fat.
      Do you think he doesn’t already know, Angela?

      I am a short, skinny woman who is desperately in love with my clinically obese husband, the father of my three kids, who must weight at least twice as much as me.

      Let me tell you: fat people are NOT all pie-eating slobs. I remain inspired by my husband’s restrain and self-discipline with food.

      One day, medical science will clarify what many already suspect: that genetics play a massive role in how fat you might get.

      The reality is, my husband is now the spitting image of his own father. He lives on fish and salad. He is very stressed from our 24/7 business and the extraordinary amounts of tax we must conjure for our esteemed government officials every month.

      But he is NOT a pig, he is NOT lazy or irresponsible or unintelligent or any of the other idiotic suppositions you may have about ‘fat’ people. One day, a greater genetic understanding will help us in our treatment of clinical obesity.

      In the mean time, guilt trips and hounding are unnecessary.

    • Emma says:

      07:40am | 20/06/11

      I honestly read the first 10 comments and couldn’t go any further my father weighed 180 kilos has high blood pressure and high cholesterol and was told he was going to die. He wasn’t big because he ate extra stacks of pancakes or whatever others posted he was a nurse so he would eat at odd times and the weight crept up Him. He was one of the first people to get a gastric band in Australia. He had his operation in 2004 and has lost 55 kilos he works out three times a week and has always eaten well. Obesity isn’t a joke and people who suffer shouldn’t be villanised because my childhood is full of memories of Jenny craig weight watchers protein shakes meal replacements you name it he tried it. And after his operation he could only eat liquids for months and when he did start eating solids he would be sick because his body couldn’t take it. I have watched my father struggle for 20 years with his weight. Next time someone like Angela tries to raise awareness that weight needs to be addressed don’t post comments about be fat and shut up try to imagine what it is like to look in the mirror and pray that the new duet or exercise routine may just work, or that some ignorant person won’t make them feel worthless today .

    • Chris says:

      11:20am | 20/06/11

      You dont get to 180 kilos by eating salads and steamed vegies.

      Your just putting up excuses for your father. I would be physically repulsed if my dad was that weight!! You sound more like an enabler than someone who truelly wants to see their parent get healthy again.

      I completely sympathise with those unfortunate people who have a MEDICAL CONDITION that makes it damn near impossible to keep their weight in check, i.e. thyroid problem. But for you lazy people out their who just find it to easy to eat a pie instead of a healthier option, i couldnt give to shits about you. You got yourself into your situation so dont come crying to the government for gastric band surgery because you are to lazy to work out on your own. And i certainly do not want my tax dollars to be spent on you!!!!!!!

      People constantly go on about how smokers have to live with their mistakes when they get lung cancer etc. Why not have the same attitude towards the people who eat themselves into death. YOU GET WHAT YOU DESERVE, stop making excuses

    • Melrusk says:

      12:54pm | 20/06/11

      Oh Chris you are correct ” YOU GET WHAT YOU DESERVE”

      So when Your Tax dollars are doubling at an exponential rate to treat the health/social effects of obese Australians, who had they been treated early would be off the public health burden before chronic illness sets in, you can remind your self how much cheaper prevention is than cure.
      Good luck too you,
      You Schmuck

    • Emma says:

      02:27pm | 20/06/11

      I have been trying to help my father for years this talking honestly that Angela is going on about i have been doing it for years. You want to hear real Irony Chris my father just got diagnosed as being in starvation mode, because he had too much fluid in his stomach from his lap band. He never stuffed his face with Pies!!!! People like you make me sick,. So you care about people with a medical condition, but weight gained from eating at all hours of the day and night, sleeping irregularly, thats unacceptable. What would have rather he done not become a nurse one less nurse in public hospitals who cares, you cannot understand the reasons behind how or why a person is the weight they are and claiming to care if it is due to a medical condition is IGNORANT!!!

    • Ian1 says:

      10:14am | 20/06/11

      One thing I can’t figure out, if an Armageddon style famine scenario afflicted our race, would only the obese survive?  Or would cannibalism thin them out?

    • OchreBunyip says:

      10:43am | 20/06/11

      Taking the time to eat well and to realise that regular meals of adult portions of food, not adolescent ones, combined with regular exercise, are the key to weight management. Food is advertised in large portions, it is a sign of affluence and indulgence; as a rare treat it is fine but every meal of every day and we see the effects. It is true there are eating disorders but not every fat person has such a disorder, some are simply ill-educated in adult nutrition. The fad diets that come out each week in women’s magazines are ridiculous and ineffective. Yes, I have been overweight but with the right advice from medical professionals I have corrected my own lack of knowledge.

    • mick says:

      11:19am | 20/06/11

      thats why i have a problem with curvy women being accepted as the new role models.

    • Jimmy says:

      11:40am | 20/06/11

      Its simple mathematics people! Energy out MUST exceed energy in.

      No amount of crash celebrity diets, miracle pills, ‘body sliming’ pants or Danoz Direct Ab-Swing Pros will shed any weight. Too many people these days only look for the easy way out, or make excuses for them themselves. While yes, a minority people have deeper emotional issues which may lead to overeating, the rest would rather hit KFC drive thru than prepare a wholesome healthy meal.

      Take some personal responsibility for yourself, put down the donut, turn off the TV and go for a run.

    • Lisa H. says:

      11:53pm | 20/06/11

      Gawd, these patronising comments are PRICELESS. My husband is a scientist. he knows all your silly ‘facts’. The reality is that science is stills silent on why some people gain a lot of weight on only a little food, and some people can eat six meals a day and find it hard to gain weight.

      Until the genetic influences on weight gain (among other aspects)  are fully understood, why don’t you keep your idiotic opinions to yourself.

      I would bet you a million dollars that my family eats more healthily than yours. I am vegetarian (although I’m skinny). My children are lean beans, they have meat two to three times a week (small serves). We never eat out (live in the country).

      My husband is classified as obese… he literally lives on fish and salad. For lunch (if he eats) he has tinned fish. For breakfast he might have one slice of toast, or usually just a cup of tea. Eating this way costs us a lot of money, but we care for him, and his health.

      I bet he is a more refined eater than you.

      And I bet you now turn around and say ‘Oh, well, it’s obvious… he has crashed his metabolism…’

      Your opinion means nothing,

    • Prince says:

      02:39pm | 20/06/11

      I love the morons who will block a shopping centre car park by double parking for 7-10 minutes just so they can get a parking spot 20 paces closer to the front door than they otherwise would have, that will then pay $15 to go for a casual visit to a gym

    • BJA says:

      02:45pm | 20/06/11

      Burn more calories than you eat and like magic you lose weight.

    • not fat says:

      06:03pm | 20/06/11

      what BJA said -  stop eating too much fatties exercise a bit and then you won’t be fat any more how fucking hard is that ?

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

: Bruce Springsteen: "I get roughed up crowdsurfing… people try to pull chunks out of me" http://t.co/jiHqt8agt9” it was him, @patricklion

Daniel Piotrowski

Ray Hadley fires back at Carlton. Great @candacesutton1 get: http://t.co/7fQzk4Xixh

Malcolm Farr

@Drag0nista Can't see it bring re l 'ship Cos lots of Ruddites don't back gay marriage (Joel, Bowen) and lot of Gillardians do.

Malcolm Farr

KRudd gives marriage equality folk hope, but odds still against it passing on June 6. http://t.co/QmQffMkSvH

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

The Punch is moving house

The Punch is moving house

Good morning Punchers. After four years of excellent fun and great conversation, this is the final post…

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

Will Pope Francis have the vision to tackle this?

I have had some close calls, one that involved what looked to me like an AK47 pointed my way, followed…

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

Advocating risk management is not “victim blaming”

In a world in which there are still people who subscribe to the vile notion that certain victims of sexual…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: Hasbro, go straight to gaol, do not pass go

Tim says:

They should update other things in the game too. Instead of a get out of jail free card, they should have a Dodgy Lawyer card that not only gets you out of jail straight away but also gives you a fat payout in compensation for daring to arrest you in the first place. Instead of getting a hotel when you… [read more]

From: A guide to summer festivals especially if you wouldn’t go

Kel says:

If you want a festival for older people or for families alike, get amongst the respectable punters at Bluesfest. A truly amazing festival experience to be had of ALL AGES. And all the young "festivalgoers" usually write themselves off on the first night, only to never hear from them again the rest of… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Superman needs saving

Superman needs saving

Can somebody please save Superman? He seems to be going through a bit of a crisis. Eighteen months ago,… Read more

28 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free News.com.au newsletter