WHEN mounting an argument sure to rub some people up the wrong way - such as, say, listing reasons to love the English on the first day of The Ashes - it can be useful to start by invoking supporting words of wisdom from a unifying, popular figure.

Step forward, Donald Rumsfeld.

The former US Defence Secretary - not exactly of Ghandi-esque stature in global public opinion - had a favourite phrase: that America would be vindicated in “the great sweep of human history”.

In the great sweep of sporting history, the English have been the objects of increasing ridicule. They deserve much of it, especially with their tragi-comic efforts in soccer and cricket during the 1990s. But with the 2009 Ashes series beginning this evening, Australian time, we’re sure to be in for weeks of tiresome jokes about whingeing Poms, underachievers, chokers, yob fans with beer bellies, along with general mirth at moments of English failure.

English people: So much to love about them

When Mitchell Johnson gets the ball in hand and eyes off Andrew Strauss in Cardiff before starting his run-up, it might be worth him - and Australians everywhere - pausing for a moment to reflect on England’s place in the great sweep of human history. For England, possibly more than any other nation, deserves respect.

[More Ashes: Luke Foley on English elitists | Phil Hillyard’s photo secrets]

And as one of the 10 reasons below argues, respecting England just might help Australia win The Ashes.

1. The English language

The platform for everything from epic American poetry to sledges about a batsman’s mother - where can you start in praise of this wonderful toolbox? Modern English, with roots in ancient Greek, Latin, Celtic and Scandinavian tongues and softened by the later influence of French, is the undisputed currency of global communication. Despite some of its complex rules it has managed to survive roughly in its current form for 500 years, since Shakespeare’s time, whilst always effortlessly accommodating new shizzle.

2. British comedy

No, it’s not just about Steve Harmison’s first ball in the last Ashes series. The best of English comedy, from Monty Python through The Young Ones to The Office, consistently pushes the boundaries while tackling social issues and is - most importantly - brilliantly funny.

3. The least worst brand of colonialism

Irish comedian Ardal O’Hanlon, best known for his role as Dougal in the TV series Father Ted, was asked once on British television why the English liked seeing the Irish doing well in sport but the warmth wasn’t returned. O’Hanlon responded it was probably something to do with the 800 years of oppression. Cue nervous laughter in the studio. Dead right, I thought.

Growing up in Ireland I thought hating the English was just something everybody did, like going to mass on Sunday. It’s unsurprising given what British authorities did in Northern Ireland, especially during the 1960s and 70s, including opening fire on the crowd during a civil rights march and introducing internment, a counter-terrorism tactic that made CIA rendition of suspected terrorists look civilised. People weren’t quietly spirited away the security forces thought they were up to something - they were just taken off the street and thrown in jail.

But taking enslavement, oppression and murder as the historical realities of all colonial enterprises, compare the outcomes countries the English commandeered to the fates of countries who received special attention from the French, Dutch, or Spanish. If you had to choose a country to be colonised by over the past 500 years, I’d argue you’d choose an army of cricket-playing imperialist tea-drinkers any day.

4. Good manners

Possibly the only good thing to come out of the persistent English social class structure is the sense that there are certain ways you should behave around people.

Ladette to Lady: See what an English person can do for you?

Etiquette and modesty were defining features of Victorian English society, but even modern Britain has its finishing schools, the inspiration for the recent hit television series Ladette to Lady. Now, while not everyone needs to know how to address the various ranks of the British aristocracy in the tent at a polo match, the Poms have exported useful social conventions. Like saying “please” and “thank you”.

5. The Beatles

Well, not just The Beatles, but them and the tradition they started of global stardom for musicians. Where would modern rock and pop be without the likes of the Rolling Stones, Led Zeppelin, or Eric Clapton? They didn’t just change music, but what it meant to be cool.

6. Great journalism

The term “Fleet Street” is often used as a reference to the cradle of great journalism, from the era when the offices of England’s great newspapers were all based there. English newspapers, in their rabidly competitive market, wrote the manual for much of what constitutes great journalism today, through crusading investigations like the thalidomide series by The Sunday Times in the 1970s to the extraordinary ongoing British MPs’ expenses scandal, led by The Daily Telegraph.

Its tabloid newspapers, like The Sun and the Daily Mail, broke new ground in popular, accessible reporting of news, entertainment and sport. The Sunday tabloids In the digital age, newspapers like The Times and The Guardian have extended their reach to global audiences, while another British brand, the taxpayer-funded BBC, is synonymous around the world with great reporting across television, radio, and the web.

7. The Premiership

Really, it's OK to enjoy it.

The best collection of players, scoring the most stunning goals, for a collection of the greatest teams, in a sporting competition with as proud a history as any. The names of stadiums like Anfield, Old Trafford and even White Hart Lane will make any the hair on a football tragic’s neck stand on end. Manchester Utd, Liverpool, Chelsea and Arsenal are teams recognised all over the world and followed by thousands of Australians.

8. Parliamentary democracy

Every now and then Australian politicians babble on about the Westminster system of government, as if it’s some sacred tradition that can’t be tampered with. It’s often used to refer to ministerial accountability, but in truth it’s an admission that the best way to make laws is the English way.

9. Literature

The English invented the novel - Daniel Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe is considered the first book-form fiction story. You can now enjoy one from the millions available while waiting for the rain to clear during any of the Tests.

10. English sport, including cricket

As a final reason to love the English, have a think back over some of their sporting achievements in recent years after more than 30 years of admirably consistent failure in major sporting events. England beat Australia in Sydney to win the Rugby World Cup in 2003 in one of the great championship performances. Then the cricketers took The Ashes back in England in 2005. And last year, at the Olympics, the British took home one more medal than the Australians - including 19 golds to Australia’s 14 - earning massive bragging rights for four years.

Underdog

For their occasional tears and complaining about games not going their way, I’ve come to think England have learned to take strength from being treated like underdogs. Perhaps they had to go through years of humiliation to discover it. But I’d be counting they won’t mind Australia being the favourites as this series gets underway.

Plus, they did invent the sport for which The Ashes are played.

I’ll be cheering them on.

43 comments

Show oldest | newest first

    • Eddie Keane says:

      08:47am | 08/07/09

      Paul Colgan’s view that the best colonial boot for the Irish people to live under in the the last 500 years was the British colonial boot doesn’t stand the historical test when one dispassionately examines the facts and these are : Successive British Administrations unsuccessfully tried to destroy Irish language and culture.Protestantism was imposed on the national psyche via Tithing.Social mobility was denied all Irish people and the Great Famine was an attempt at Genocide when 2 million died and 3 million emigrated.I haven’t even mentioned the countless rebellions and ruthless suppression methods used to quell same.
      Come on Paul - catch up on your reading and get a general history of Ireland to fill in the rather large gaps in your knowledge of British/Irish history.A selection of books by the famous historian Tim Pat Coogan should do and dispel your quaint ideas about British Colonialism and the Irish experience.

      Yours in Education,
      Eddie Keane

    • Matt H says:

      08:55am | 08/07/09

      To combine three of Colgo’s points - I’m reminded of the famous British editorial before the 1966 World Cup Final:

      “If perchance, on the morrow, Germany should beat us at our national game, let us take comfort in the fact that we have twice beaten them at theirs.”

    • Chris says:

      09:04am | 08/07/09

      Not to mention tea, cheese rolling, real ale, punk and a spanking from the school ma’am

    • Lord Nelson says:

      09:24am | 08/07/09

      My list
      1. Boarding schools that let escaping students run 10 miles before letting the school leopard out of its cage to track them down.
      2. Meat and three veg.
      3. Bangers and mash
      4. Mash and bangers
      5. Paul Colgan
      6. Sean Connery
      7. The Pogues
      8. Tom Jones
      9. Sunday Sport
      10. Paul Colgan

    • Greig says:

      09:37am | 08/07/09

      There’s also the small matter of English advances in science. Where would we be without Isaac Newton, Charles Darwin, Michael Faraday and Edward Jenner, to name a few?
      Their cricket team and supporters are still a load of toilet, though.

    • Makka says:

      09:39am | 08/07/09

      The thing I love most about the Poms is their history - endlessly entertaining. Kings being stabbed, decapitated, having red-hot pokers shoved up their nethers, having multiple wives beheaded, civil wars, peasant revolts, mass burnings for worshipping the wrong god - gotta love it. I defy anyone to read a book about England’s history and not be enormously entertained.

    • Dave says:

      10:37am | 08/07/09

      Tim Pat Coogan…1 person NOT to read if you’re looking for a fair and balanced account of Irish history!

    • Dave says:

      10:38am | 08/07/09

      English comedy???..you’re kidding..George and Mildred, Benny hill. It’s not exactly Seinfeld or the Simpsons. The English don’t really do irony.

    • John T says:

      10:52am | 08/07/09

      Not a bad list, Paul, but,  why, as you’re writing about cricket, only 10?
       
      What about “coming to terms with sporting defeats (after a few days of tabloid rage) ” to complete the 11?

    • Greig says:

      10:55am | 08/07/09

      Wait… what? You’re citing the Sun and the Daily Mail of examples of things that are good in the world? I mean I know your company owns the Sun, but there’s no need to blow that rusty trombone so loudly.
      And fair shake of the sauce bottle - the credit for the link between thalidomide and birth defects is due more to Australian William McBride, and German Widukin Lenz than some journo from the Sunday Times. You know, the guys that actually suspected and proved the link.

    • Alannis says:

      10:57am | 08/07/09

      Dave, are you being ironic?

    • Tony Hadley says:

      11:04am | 08/07/09

      and Spandau Ballet!

    • Chris says:

      11:12am | 08/07/09

      “The English don’t really do irony.”

      Who are you Dave, Alanis Morrisette?

    • Rob says:

      11:15am | 08/07/09

      Sorry Dave, there’s a lot more to English comedy than George and Mildred and Benny Hill. If you’ve not delved into some of them properly, then take a look at Only Fools and Horses, The Good Life, even Red Dwarf. Go back further and watch some episodes of The Two Ronnies or Morecambe and Wise. Then you’ll understand what English comedy is all about. Classic.
      My thoughts on “Please”, “Thank you” and their regrettable demise in everyday conversation would have to be saved for my next blog. I don’t have enough characters available here to subject you all to my thoughts on that

    • O says:

      11:20am | 08/07/09

      Nah!  Still not convinced, Paul.  For me, personally, the thing to love least about the English is that they invented cricket.  Of course, there are all the things they did to the Scots - not quite as bad as what they did to the Irish, although I’m sure some Scottish Nationalists would dispute that. I’m just glad the Ashes are in Cardiff, so only my late night viewing will be disrupted.  Lord Nelson, I fear for your life, lumping Sean Connery in a list of english favourites. He’ll be after you - kilt swaying and Claymore swinging. Be still my beating heart!  Tom Jones no doubt has a stash of ladies’ knickers he’ll be hurling at you for including him too. Paul, what will you do?

    • Gus says:

      11:33am | 08/07/09

      Eddie Keane, are you suggesting that the British deliberately introduced potato blight as an act of genocide against the Irish people? Don’t be ridiculous.
      Sounds like YOU need to read more widely. Sure, the British Govt. failed to act quickly and effectively to the famine but there was a massive outpouring of charity from the Britich people, from Queen Victoria down. There was also widespread popular criticism of the government in almost every newspaper.
      I wish my Irish brothers would a). stop blaming the British people for everything, and; b). stop whingeing about everything in the past.
      This anti-British rhetoric verges on racism.

    • Ozscot says:

      11:36am | 08/07/09

      Just to say that my name didn’t print right in my last post - it should be “Ozscot”, not “O”. Just thought I’d point that out as it makes my “Scottishness” clear. UK comedy is streaks ahead of American comedy. Give me Yes, (Prime) Minister, The Vicar of Dibley (my Aussie husband calls it “The Vicar of Drabble”), any Ronnie Barker show, etc over Seinfeld or The Simpsons any day.

    • Arnold Layne says:

      11:36am | 08/07/09

      Lord Nelson, you forgot Andy Murray!  grin

    • Steven says:

      11:40am | 08/07/09

      You forgot Oasis.

    • Greig says:

      12:04pm | 08/07/09

      Ozscot, I think you might have missed the subtle irony in Lord Nelson’s post. All those named would be considered eligible to play cricket for England, even Colgo (that is if he were familiar with the rule about staying within one’s crease while batting).

    • Adrian says:

      12:54pm | 08/07/09

      The best candidate for the first novel was Murasaki Shikibu’s “Tale of Genji” (1010). That’s 700 years before Crusoe. Take one off the list.

    • GJM says:

      12:55pm | 08/07/09

      Gus.. you are right.. stop living in the past people.. ie 1966 for one!  If I have to hear one more pom harp on about ‘66 as if it was the only world cup that mattered!  Oh and yes.. they also love to go on about world wars but seem to miss the point that if it wasn’t for the Americans they would all be speaking German.

      A great booke is Empire by Niall Ferguson which.. pretty fair read really saying the English did as much good as bad but I don’t think anyone could ever argue how their attempts to impose rule on Ireland could just be forgotten.

    • Richard the Great says:

      01:13pm | 08/07/09

      The Holy Roman Catholic Church established Tithing, not the Protestants.

      Have you been to Ireland ...have you.

      What a sad lot of tight fisted, mean spirited bastards….almost like South Africans…..give me Poms or Kiwii ‘s any day

    • Lord Nelson says:

      01:15pm | 08/07/09

      Re: Arnold Layne
      Andy Murray’s English? Surely not! He is to tennis what Bruce Lee was to spot welding.

    • Lachlan says:

      01:36pm | 08/07/09

      Colgo, not sure when Robinson Crusoe was written, but the first novel ever written is often attributed to an 11th century Japanese noblewoman, Murasaki Shikibu, who wrote The Tale of Genji.

    • Ozscot says:

      03:18pm | 08/07/09

      I hope I didn’t come across as your typical anti-English Scot, nor as an Aussie Pommy basher - Lord knows, I’m on the receiving end of enough of that myself. wink  I’m also very aware that the Scots were major players in Ireland (I come from South West Scotland) and pretty prominent in building the Empire. I was just trying to inject a bit of humour, knowing what a strong Scottish Nationalist Sean Connery is - would he be eligible, Greig? That is ironic, if he would.

    • Greig says:

      03:35pm | 08/07/09

      Ozscot,
      Mike Denness is a Scotsman who played test cricket for England. This was before Scotland had a national team, though. I rather suspect that if a Scot emerged who were good enough nowadays, the ECB would move heaven and earth to get three lions onto his shirt (given the number of Welshmen, Saffers, Zims and Australians who have played for England in recent years).
      If Mr Connery had been a cricket prodigy (far-fetched as that seems) he would certainly have been eligible for England selection, considering he’s older than Mr Denness.

    • Rodgy says:

      03:54pm | 08/07/09

      Lord Nelson !!
      Sean Connery is SCOTTISH and Tom Jones is WELSH !!!
      Not bloody English ..............

      Find 2 more for your list :o)

    • Peter Thornton says:

      04:33pm | 08/07/09

      Calling all Anglos! Here ‘over there’ or any bloody where:

      we do invent stuff. Discover, reveal and improve all manner of stuff too. Good stuff, practical stuff and bloody useful stuff. We then export it, usually to the highest bidder. We then import it back at their (premium) rate.

      Small price to pay for not being one of the Great Unwashed.

    • Bad Boy Bubby says:

      05:07pm | 08/07/09

      GJM
      And if it wasn’t for the British the Americans would be speaking French

    • Perthspurs says:

      05:10pm | 08/07/09

      “even White Hart Lane”...?

      It’s the home of football. It’s half the size of old trafford but makes twice the noise.

      Come on England!
      And come on you Spurs!

    • Barry says:

      06:33pm | 08/07/09

      No one can say the boys not clever - writes about the Brits - stirs the pot then goes o leave   LOVE the irony hahahahaha

    • Aussie Bob says:

      06:52pm | 08/07/09

      Oh Dear, Oh Dear, to all the Irish out there please stop whining about the famine etc etc etc, my Father was Irish he complained about the English all his life until he married one

    • Dan says:

      11:57pm | 08/07/09

      GJM, if anyone saved England during WWII it was the Russians, not the Americans.

    • Peter Thornton says:

      05:05am | 09/07/09

      In the past I’ve made scathing comments about the English, the Scots, the Irish & the Welsh by suggesting the lot of them are provincial hicks from inbred villages. I’m not denying it, but I’m also not so naive to believe there isn’t a bit of truth in what I’ve said. As I often say (and will continue to believe until sufficiently convinced otherwise): large population+small land mass+village society (must)= inbreeding. Anyone who thinks otherwise is an idiot.

    • Eric says:

      08:22am | 09/07/09

      The Americans saved both the British and the Russians.

    • Dave says:

      09:16am | 09/07/09

      The Americans turned up late to both World Wars and took all the credit. Then they blotted their copybook and went to Korea, Vietnam, armed the Afghans and went to war with Iraq because they mistook Sadam for Osama! Happy Days! Subscribing to the who is better than who and who is to blame for the past achieves nothing. Accept what you have now and look to the future. Besides, the list is loaded with irony.

    • Joan says:

      09:19am | 09/07/09

      Peter, your stirring arm must be aching! Actually, the large population is only in England and, being the island nations that they are, the in-breeding has been considerably diluted by Romans, Vikings, French, Spanish, Dutch, Belgian, etc blood over the centuries. Not forgetting more recently, West Indians, Pakistanis, Indians and no doubt, Australians.

    • Dave says:

      09:19am | 09/07/09

      Peter Thornton, you seem to know alot about inbreeding. How is Uncle Dad?

    • Mick says:

      10:32am | 09/07/09

      You left The Queen off the list… And the band too

    • sophie kennedy white says:

      07:27am | 10/07/09

      They sent us to Oztraylia and they stayed in Blighty!

    • SULLY says:

      02:59pm | 10/07/09

      Talking of inventing Cricket, the Barmy Army also invented the cricket song.
      Naked Comms in the UK launch a soundtrack to the forthcoming tour. You can hear it at:

      http://www.campaignlive.co.uk/news/917277/Naked-launches-Barmy-Army-single/

      Matt Jagger, the agency’s head of entertainment, has written, recorded and produced the single, called Hey, Hey, Ricky, which taunts Ricky Ponting, the Australia skipper, with a line in the chorus: We’re taking back the Ashes, they don’t belong to you.

      All good stuff, but it has some tough competition in Barmy Army favourites such as:

      The Aussies love the English, you might find it quite strange
      ‘Cos we sent them all down under, with only balls and chains
      And when they see the English, they always shout and scream
      But when they had the chance to vote they voted for the Queen!
      God save your gracious Queen
      Long live your noble Queen
      God save your Queen (you’re a convict)
      Send her victorious
      Happy and glorious
      Long to reign over you
      God save your Queen.

      All in the best possible taste.
      Let Battle commence!

    • Mike Bune says:

      08:18pm | 13/01/11

      What a difference eighteen months makes. Australia now has its first female Prime Minister and, what is more Welsh. Your East Coast is awash after torrential rain and costing lives. To cap it all a National Disaster, you did not even get a sniff of the ashes.
      Still, you still have one national sport that unites and uplifts you all - Pom Bashing. So, just to stir up those embers before they too turn to ash, I would like to wish you all the strength and courage to see yourselves through these troubling times. We know what it is like.

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Anthony Sharwood

One must absolutely read this as soon as is snootily possible (it's about the mad family sueing Geelong Grammar) http://t.co/YnWgqcfi

Malcolm Farr

Sydney criminal barrister has advised Craig Thomson on phone cloning. Expect a mention in his Monday speech to Parly.. http://t.co/XC4FW8bq

Malcolm Farr

@michellegrattan Shorten has an ability to be aggressive and positive w/o being shrill. Not a skill all his cabinet colleagues share.

Daniel Piotrowski

@ACCAN_AU @ThePunchHQ thanks!

Recent posts

The latest and greatest

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

They must pay for one’s bitter disappointments

A private school girl’s family is sueing her elite, extremely expensive private school for not…

Our Budget blade didn’t cut aid, it’s being paid in spades

Our Budget blade didn’t cut aid, it’s being paid in spades

Ten million children vaccinated. 2.5 million people with access to safe drinking water. And 30 million…

An insecure workforce makes for an insecure society

An insecure workforce makes for an insecure society

It’s usually best to avoid putting too many statistics in a post but reading the ACTU’s report…

Nosebleed Section

choice ringside rantings

From: The greatest ending to a football season ever?

Dave B says:

Congratulations & well deserved win! I've been a Utd supporter from 7 years of age, even stuck with them when they went down to the 2nd Div. However, despite the X-town rivalry & even as a devout MU fan, I can say that I truly admired the determination, courage & skill shown by the Blues - What a spectacle,… [read more]

From: Welfare for breeders is a bonus for everyone

Change Up! says:

I have no problem paying my taxes. As a single, childless person on a very decent income, I can afford it and not have my life severely altered. Plus I understand that my taxes paying for things like schools, childcare and infrastructure is ultimately a good thing. A better community is better for me… [read more]

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Real women like men who drink beer

Real women like men who drink beer

British comedian John Cleese calls them “beer fairies”.  It’s a euphemism for… Read more

198 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter