Latest Opinons on The Punch

Positive discrimination is, if not dead, at least on life support with an overeager nurse reaching for the off switch.

Tokenism just doesn't work. Pic: Ross Michael

That’s according to a decent-sized survey out today that found two thirds of Australia’s bosses will not mandate that females be included in shortlists for senior management positions.

I reckon I wouldn’t be alone in turning a blind eye to that nurse, and wanting quotas put out of their misery. There are much better ways to achieve workplace diversity.

Latest 2 of 180 comments

 
  • Dr McKay says:

    05:28pm | 16/05/12

    You can also get throat cancer from the cervical virus.  I’m sure you can all figure out how. Read more »

  • PsychoHyena says:

    02:21pm | 16/05/12

    @Ads, it’s interesting, but the question gets asked to identify whether you may need additional support. If you answer yes they assume that you need assistance with everything because you’re aboriginal/torres strait islander, if you answer no they figure you’ll be fine, if you refuse to answer (you’re allowed to… Read more »

 

I am still in a state of shock. Delicious, indescribable shock. For the first time in my life, my beloved Manchester City FC are champions of England.


In the early hours of yesterday morning, the tiny window live streaming Foxtel on my iMac transported me 15,000km to Eastlands in Manchester to watch City’s biggest game since 1968, when we last clinched the league championship.

In the space of 95 agonising minutes the title was lost, won, lost again, lost almost irretrievably and then finally, somehow, incredibly won in the dying seconds with the very last kick of the season.

Latest 2 of 65 comments

 
  • D says:

    02:35pm | 16/05/12

    fairsfair - kind of, except City were never that successful. They had only won 2 titles before this in what, over 100 years. They had gone down divisions a decade or so ago, however. Imaginge Crowe bought souths, only there was no cap and he had by far the most… Read more »

  • D says:

    02:21pm | 16/05/12

    Not really, Tim. You’re missing the point. Did you see either of the games? The crowd reactions could tell you what was going on in the other game, and the tension was absolutely unbelievable - I wish I had been there, despite it not finishing the way I had hoped,… Read more »

 

It’s official. The climate change dialogue is getting loopier. Maybe the weirdness has been been brought on by heat-stroke.


Yesterday’s Daily Telegraph reported that Tim Flannery and the Climate Commissions’s Professor Lesley Hughes warned that mental illness and all kinds of other maladies would increase with a few extra hot days. For those of us who believe the consequences of climate change could be catastrophic on a global scale, these kinds of statements are trivial to the point of public nuisance. They are like prank calls to 000.

So here’s the real news. Scientists don’t actually believe heatwaves will send us all mad. They’re just saying stuff like this because they’re desperately fumbling for new ways to grab the public’s attention. How do I know this? Because Tim Flannery himself told me (and a small room of other people) pretty much exactly that this very weekend.

Latest 2 of 263 comments

 
  • Ted says:

    10:07am | 17/05/12

    It’s amazing how many alarmists don’t know that the amount of carbon dioxide in teh atmosphere is less than 400 parts per MILLION Read more »

  • Lisa Meredith says:

    02:05pm | 16/05/12

    Dear Kassandra, This is what you wrote, with my replies underneath: “It is the dire predictions of catastrophic future warming that is at issue.” I have written about this. Eg: -  And the predictions are only that: predictions. They are not actually proof, even though they do contribute to the… Read more »

 

One of the many enduring myths of Australian politics is that former prime minister John Howard defiantly imposed a goods and services tax on an unwilling populace despite promising that he would “never, ever” do such a thing.

Yes he can, but she still can't. Photo: Herald-Sun

He didn’t, of course. By the narrowest of margins, the people re-elected John Howard on a promise of introducing a GST.

He had a popular mandate to introduce the tax after he won a second term. He had ruled out the tax while in Opposition ahead of his 1996 win over Paul Keating, declaring the tax was “dead, buried” and would “never, ever” be introduced. He then changed his mind during his first term of office, and went on the now defunct Sunday program with Laurie Oakes to announce his new position, for which he would seek a mandate at the 1998 election.

Latest 2 of 88 comments

 
  • Peter#1 says:

    04:48am | 16/05/12

    @ Schnelly, Indeed, rational debate has been replaced with abuse , scaremongering and name calling. Sad really. If you don’t agree with something, you are instantly labelled either homophobic, a sceptic, or a denier. Read more »

  • Peter#1 says:

    04:37am | 16/05/12

    @ Doug What happened to Point three? I will agree with part of Point two “there is no way Labor can win an election” Read more »

 

Does Julia Gillard think the Australian people have the memory of a goldfish?

In the alternative Gillard reality we are apparently swimming about taking a fresh look at her Government with each lap of the bowl, oblivious to what we saw yesterday or the day before.

That is the only possible explanation for the bald-faced hypocrisy with which she is now championing a “Parliamentary Code of Conduct”.

Latest 2 of 214 comments

 
  • marley says:

    01:46pm | 16/05/12

    @DJ - well, you could be right on the Senate, in which case I’d say, yes, the good Senator should have been cross-benched for the duration (as I recall, it was a relatively short time between charges and sentencing).  But your other point, I disagree with entirely.  If there’s a… Read more »

  • DJ says:

    09:22am | 16/05/12

    Marley - you can always kick someone out of a party - Senator Colston was by the ALP and sat on the cross benches, you cant kick them out of the Senate same as house of Reps. Lamming and a couple of other LNP members were investigated by the AFP… Read more »

 

The worship of ‘working families’ is a bipartisan affair – all sides of politics fall over themselves to appeal to this valuable voting pool.  It’s enough to make the childless feel like drones, labouring to feed the reproducing queens.


First there was Prime Minister Julia Gillard’s cash splash for parents of schoolkids. Then, in his Budget reply speech, Opposition Leader Tony Abbott said: “My values are the product of an Australian life, a real life much like yours with Margie, raising three daughters in suburban Sydney, paying a mortgage, worrying about bills.”

Sorry, Mr Abbott, but that’s not a real life much like mine. Never mind living in suburban Sydney or having three daughters, even if I fell in love with a Margie I couldn’t marry her.

Latest 2 of 221 comments

 
  • Matt says:

    10:01am | 17/05/12

    In general I agree… but the school kid payout…why bother? why not just make public education free for Australian citizens and give all that extra cash to the schools? It stops the irresponsible “parent” blowing it on the pokies, booze, whatever else, and it guarantees an education for all of… Read more »

  • Derek says:

    05:31pm | 16/05/12

    @PTom: With such shocking english skills, I wonder what “unviersity degree” you could actually get…. Read more »

 

The other day I was watching ABC’s The Drum where Peter Singer was talking about the importance of giving to charitable causes to help alleviate global poverty. Good stuff from Singer, but out of nowhere comes a reference to Catholic Archbishop of Sydney Cardinal George Pell from one of the panelists.

And where did these hats end up?

Apparently Pell, at some point, had said that there is no genuine altruism, people only do good because it makes them feel good (well duh, I’ve heard that before). Anyway, next thing I know the inference is being made that Pell would rather have us walk around flagellating ourselves than giving to charitable causes.

There I am, watching the show, and I’m just baffled as to how went from generous giving to medieval self-mutilation at the behest of George Pell. Then it finally dawns on me, “Of course, this is the The Drum, the final credits can’t roll without at least one Catholic being bashed.” I should have known better.

Latest 2 of 77 comments

 
  • Dan says:

    05:36am | 16/05/12

    It is interesting that most of the posts are bashing the catholic church. The article stated that people within the church have done things totally unacceptable and worthy of condemnation and rightly so. However, the real point in this I believe is that no other group or institution in Australia… Read more »

  • Jason Todd says:

    11:20pm | 15/05/12

    ChrisL - I suspect henry is referring to Hitchens’ book - The missionary position, in which he addressess some of the criticisms that were levelled against Mother Teresa during her time. Henry, Teresa didn’t offer medical treatment either. In fact, there were many cases in which she specifically refused to… Read more »

 

During the lead-up to last week’s federal budget and the reporting that followed, the overwhelming focus was on whether Labor could deliver on the surplus promise it had pledged.

Unustrayan

The focus Australia has on keeping its books balanced is commendable, but there is another deficit we face. One that gets worse every year, and one that could create havoc in the economic budget if not attended to.

The environmental deficit. Last year’s State of the Environment report made the same point that it has made since its initial publication in 1996 - things are OK, but getting progressively worse.

Latest 2 of 21 comments

 
  • Mark/Fox says:

    05:18pm | 15/05/12

    Quality lifestle and a healthy enviroment are the victims of a growing population. Sustainable management will be attempted after its to late. Why we continue on this path of populate till we perish, who knows. We realy do not seem to care. Read more »

  • Ozymandias says:

    05:16pm | 15/05/12

    One of the major things that made me laugh during my University studies was the profoundly flawed assumption at the time that an economy is independant of an environment. The brutal fact of the matter is, if our environment is stuffed, then eventually our economy will be stuffed too. The… Read more »

 

One of the hottest debates at the Madrid tennis Masters tournament is over the colour, texture and feel of the clay beneath players’ feet.

Feet of clay. Picture: Getty

Rafael Nadal has had a bit of a blue with the blue clay, saying it’s “overly slippery”. Novak Djokovic has vowed to never play on the clay again. Sky News reports Djokovic said of organisers: “‘They can do what they like, I won’t be here next year if this clay stays.”

Serena Williams has labeled them “weenies”. But seriously. When was the last time you swam in an orange swimming pool? Played pool on a purple table? Served a volleyball on a blue beach?

It’s Tuesday. What’s on your mind?

Latest 2 of 133 comments

 
  • marley says:

    07:28pm | 15/05/12

    Lemme guess.  Some of these delivery guys might not have been native-born Aussies?  I’ve been in countries where the street numbers run from 1 to 70 on one side of the street, and back from 71 to 140 on the other side.  I’ve been to countries where house 11 is… Read more »

  • stephen says:

    07:22pm | 15/05/12

    Everything’s a blur at these concerts. Almost a waste of money, (bit like spending 150 bucks on beer at the pub, and pissing it out all night ... then going home alone.) Read more »

 

I graduated last Friday afternoon. Big ceremony in a great big new hall. Donned robes sporting my faculty’s blood-orange sash. And I got a little excited putting on one of those square hats.

Mr Thompson should go back to school. Picture: AP

Too excited. I chucked my hat up in the air a tad over-enthusiastically and smacked the guy behind me in the head trying to catch it. Whoops.

I’m sure Yahoo! shareholders are feeling the same way as that guy. The company’s new CEO, Scott Thompson, has resigned after it was exposed that he hadn’t attained a computer science degree at Stone Hill College as he had claimed. UPDATE 5:20pm: The Wall Street Journal is also reporting Mr Thompson was diagnosed with thyroid cancer before he resigned.

Latest 2 of 48 comments

 
  • John says:

    08:02pm | 16/05/12

    Congratulations Daniel ! ...but I was inspired to write by the cheerful , and understandable, naiveity of your piece. You will be in the not too distant future someone responsible for checking cv’s or writing references, and it is a very imperfect art. Resumes and references for adults are taken… Read more »

  • Bill says:

    10:27am | 16/05/12

    No doubting it’s hard work to get a degree. But there’s also a lot people out there who have worked just as hard in other ways - paid or unpaid - and who are extremely capable, yet can’t get a look in for a job which they could easily do,… Read more »

 

Facebook Recommendations

Read all about it

Punch live

Up to the minute Twitter chatter

Malcolm Farr

Sydney criminal barrister has advised Craig Thomson on phone cloning. Expect a mention in his Monday speech to Parly.. http://t.co/XC4FW8bq

Malcolm Farr

@michellegrattan Shorten has an ability to be aggressive and positive w/o being shrill. Not a skill all his cabinet colleagues share.

Daniel Piotrowski

@ACCAN_AU @ThePunchHQ thanks!

Daniel Piotrowski

RT @ACCAN_AU: Older consumers need digital literacy skills to combat cyber crime. Great artcile over at @ThePunchHQhttp://t.co/KAC1BG9e

Gentle jabs to the ribs

Real women like men who drink beer

Real women like men who drink beer

British comedian John Cleese calls them “beer fairies”.  It’s a euphemism for… Read more

198 comments

The story behind the picture

He wasn’t fat, he was just big boned and big whiskered

Tabby or not tabby? That is the question. Another key question in the wake of the tragic death of “Meow”… Read more

63 comments

Newsletter

Read all about it

Sign up to the free daily Punch newsletter